Sammut v AVM Holdings Pty Ltd [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   SAMMUT -v- AVM HOLDINGS PTY LTD [No 2] [2012] WASC 27

CORAM:   COMMISSIONER SLEIGHT

HEARD:   28 NOVEMBER 2011

DELIVERED          :   30 JANUARY 2012

FILE NO/S:   GDA 4 of 2011

BETWEEN:   KAY JOAN SAMMUT

ANTHONY SAMMUT
Appellants

AND

AVM HOLDINGS PTY LTD
First Respondent

ANTONIO VIOLA
Second Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :DR B DE VILLIERS (MEMBER)

Citation  :SAMMUT and AVM HOLDINGS PTY LTD [2011] WASAT 32

File No  :CC 785 of 2010

Catchwords:

Appeal from State Administrative Tribunal - Reference to Tribunal on a question arising under a lease - Alleged breach of lease for non-permitted use and illegal activities - Admissibility of statements and conclusions reached by local authority and regulatory body - Whether any error is an error on a question of law - Whether any decision would have or might have been different - Turns on its own facts

Legislation:

Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 16(1)
Food Act 2008 (WA), s 22
Metropolitan Water Supply, Sewerage & Drainage By-laws 1981 (WA)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 105

Result:

Appeal dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellants:     Mr C S Williams

First Respondent           :     In person

Second Respondent       :     In person

Solicitors:

Appellants:     Solomon Brothers

First Respondent           :     In person

Second Respondent       :     In person

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond [1990] HCA 33; (1990) 170 CLR 321

Australian Postal Commission v Hayes (1989) 87 ALR 283

Comcare v Etheridge (2006) 149 FCR 522

Helton v Allen(1940) 63 CLR 691

Kostas v HIA Insurance Services Pty Ltd t/as Home Owners Warranty (2010) 241 CLR 390

Mickelberg v The Director of the Perth Mint [1986] WAR 365

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko‑Wallsend Ltd [1986] HCA 40; (1986) 162 CLR 24

Paridis v Settlement Agents Supervisory Board [2007] WASCA 97; (2007) 33 WAR 361

R v War Pensions Entitlement Appeal Tribunal; Ex parte Bott (1933) 50 CLR 228

Ramsay v Australian Postal Corporation [2005] FCA 640; (2005) 147 FCR 39

Re Pochi and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 36 FLR 482

Roberts v The State of Western Australia [2005] WASCA 37

Rodriguez v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2002] FCA 30

Secretary to the Department of Premier and Cabinet v Hulls (1999) 3 VR 331

Waterford v The Commonwealth (1987) 163 CLR 54

  1. COMMISSIONER SLEIGHT:  This is an appeal from a determination of Dr De Villiers, a member of the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) in respect of a retail shop lease.

  2. The appellants, Mr and Mrs Sammut, are the owners of premises situated at 306 Odin Drive, Stirling (the premises). The first‑named respondent, AVM Holdings Pty Ltd (AVM) occupied the premises pursuant to an assignment of lease dated 1 September 2006 (the assignment of lease).  The lease was dated 4 May 2001 (the lease).  The second‑named respondent, Mr Antonio Viola, provided a guarantee…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sammut v AVM Holdings Pty Ltd [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASC 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sammut v AVM Holdings Pty Ltd [No 2], the State Administrative Tribunal was asked to determine whether the premises in dispute were being used for the permitted use as specified in the lease, namely as a delicatessen. The Tribunal was also asked to consider whether there was a breach of the lease due to non-permitted use and illegal activities. This appeal arose from the Tribunal's earlier decision, and the primary focus was on the admissibility of statements and conclusions reached by the local authority and regulatory body, as well as whether any error in the Tribunal's decision was an error on a question of law.

The legal issues that the court had to address included the interpretation of the lease, the classification of the premises' primary use, and the admissibility of evidence from the City of Stirling and other regulatory bodies. The court had to determine whether the evidence provided by the City and the regulatory bodies was admissible and whether the Tribunal's reliance on this evidence led to an error of law. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the Tribunal's decision was based on an error of fact or law and whether the outcome would have been different if the court had reached a different conclusion on the facts.

The court found that the Tribunal did not err in law by relying on the evidence from the City of Stirling and other regulatory bodies. The court held that the evidence provided by the City was well-informed and reflective of information gathered over an extended period, and therefore, it was appropriate for the Tribunal to consider this evidence. The court also found that the Tribunal's conclusion that the premises were being used as a delicatessen was not an error of fact or law. The court accepted that the difference between a delicatessen and a lunch bar or sandwich bar may be one of degree, and it was not possible to draw a definitive line or exact distinction when an operation ceased to be a delicatessen and became a lunch bar.

The court concluded that there was no breach of the lease, as the premises were predominantly operated as a delicatessen, as provided for by the lease and the local government planning scheme. The court held that the Tribunal's decision was correct and that there was no error of law. The appeal was therefore dismissed. The court did not make any further orders beyond dismissing the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr De Villiers in his decision stated as follows:Is there a breach of the lease in that the premises is not being used for the permitted use namely the operation of a delicatessen?The answer to this question is 'no' ­ there is not a breach of the lease, since the Tribunal finds that the premises is predominantly operated as a delicatessen as provided for by the lease and the local government planning scheme [12].The reasons for this finding are as follows:a)The Tribunal concurs with the legal representative of the applicants, Mr Carmody, when he says the question whether the premises is being used as a delicatessen or a lunch bar is a factual question which can only be addressed by taking into account all of the actual activities on the premises. The Tribunal also agrees that the difference between a delicatessen and a lunch bar or sandwich bar may be one of degree, with a grey area in‑between. It is not possible to draw a definitive line or exact distinction when an operation ceases to be a delicatessen and becomes a lunch bar, especially not in the absence of a definition in the lease by what is meant by a delicatessen and no reference in the lease to a lunch bar or a definition thereof. All information about the activities that occur on the premises must therefore be taken into account to form a view of what is the predominant activity and what are possible ancillary activities. It is especially in the absence of a definition of 'delicatessen' in the lease that the Tribunal must rely on the general evidence and information provided to it, communications from the City of Stirling (City), as well as its own observations during the site inspection.The Macquarie Concise Dictionary (Third Edition) defines 'delicatessen' as follows:'A shop selling cooked or prepared goods ready for serving; usually having a noticeable proportion of continental or exotic items.'It must be noted that, other than the evidence of Ms Sammut and the contentions of Mr Carmody, there is no evidence before the Tribunal of any expert provided by the applicants.When all the information before the Tribunal is taken into account, the Tribunal is satisfied that the proper characterisation of the predominant use of the premises is consistent with the lease, namely, a delicatessen. The items on display in the photographs, and the stock visible during the site inspection and in the inventory of all products on the premises, are clearly of the kind that would fall within the description of a delicatessen, and most certainly offer a much wider range of products than would be expected of a lunch bar. While the provision of some prepared food and sandwiches for lunch or for immediate consumption may be part of the range of products offered by the respondent, such sandwiches and prepared food are incidental to its general profile as a delicatessen. Both objectively and subjectively speaking, one could not possibly conclude that the list of items on the inventory, the photographs provided and the range of items visible during the inspection, were indicative of a lunch bar.b)... ... If the applicants had called an expert to assess the content of the shop, its inventory and the nature of the activities, and such an expert had found that the premises was not being used in accordance with what is generally understood to be a delicatessen, their contentions may have been on firmer ground.In the absence of an expert assessment of the activities, the Tribunal is guided for its conclusion by the inventory, observations by inspectors of the City and the Water Corporation, the photographs tendered and observations made by the Tribunal during the site inspection.After taking into account all of such information, the Tribunal concurs with the assessment of the City's Mr Neil Duffin in his letter of 18 August 2010 when he says that 'the City is satisfied that any food preparation (included limited cooking activities) is incidental to the approved use of the premises as a delicatessen and is entirely consistent with the medium risk rating assigned to the premises'.The Tribunal must stress that it does not seem as if Mr Duffin had come to this conclusion, as was suggested by Mr Carmody, based solely on information given to him by Ms Viola. On the contrary, the evidence is that the City had on various occasions inspected the premises and that its views were very well informed and reflective of information gathered over an extended period. Ms Sammut also acknowledged that she had brought complaints to the City and officials of the City had investigated the complaint. The inspectors of the City therefore seemed to have a very good and intimate knowledge of the entire business operation and were not merely relying on the information provided to them by Ms Viola. The City's understanding of the entire operation is evidenced by Mr Duffin saying as follows in his letter, namely, that 'all food handling operations carried out on the premises have been fully considered' by the City … ' (Tribunal emphasis).Although Mr Duffin was not called to give evidence, the Tribunal can take into account his assessment and, on the basis of the lack of other expert evidence, concurs with his categorisation, since it is consistent with the other evidence and information provided to the Tribunal as well as the observations made by the Tribunal during the site inspection....g)The Tribunal notes the contention of the applicants that the commercial activities in the delicatessen have shifted from 'take‑home' products to immediate consumption products. The applicants did not offer any expert assessment of stock to substantiate their contention. Mr Carmody referred in this regard to the milk and cold drink container sizes to show that clients are, in effect, encouraged to consume what they buy on the spot. According to Mr Carmody, this is indicative of a lunch bar rather than a delicatessen. The Tribunal does not accept this contention. First of all, it is not supported by any evidence or assessment by an expert of the stock profile of a delicatessen. ......i)The Tribunal accepts that the assessment of the City cannot, in itself, determine the questions. However, the Tribunal had the benefit of a site inspection as well as the evidence of the photographs, inventory and the evidence of Ms Sammut and Ms Viola. If all of this is taken into account, the Tribunal reaches the same conclusion as the City [13]. (original emphasis)