Robinson v Pilbara Iron Company (Services) Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Robinson v Pilbara Iron Company (Services) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] FedCFamC2G 593

File number: PEG 8 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment: 12 July 2023
Catchwords:

FAIR WORK –– Employer’s fair treatment system policy – whether a benefit – whether an entitlement under employment contract – whether a safety net contractual entitlement

EMPLOYMENT – termination of employment contract – whether employment contract can be resuscitated or terminated twice – whether variation of employment contract or new contract

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to amend defence – factors for consideration – prejudice – case management – delay – use of judicial and administrative court resources – whether amendments arguable – whether amendments in the interests of justice

WORDS AND PHRASES – “safety net contractual entitlement” – “benefit” – “entitlement”

Legislation:

Constitution (Cth) Ch III

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 542, 570

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) s 190

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth) rr 7.01, 18.02

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) r 7.01

Federal Magistrates Court Rules 2001 (Cth) r 7.01

Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 29

Cases cited:

AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175; (2009) 83 ALJR 951; (2009) 258 ALR 14

Birrell v Australian National Airlines Commission (1984) 5 FCR 447; (1984) 9 IR 101

Boston Commercial Services Pty Ltd v GE Capital Finance Australasia Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1352; (2007) 236 ALR 720; (2006) 70 IPR 146

BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Shire of Hastings (1977) 180 CLR 266; (1977) 52 ALJR 20; (1977) 45 LGRA 62, (1977) 16 ALR 363

Cai v Tiy Loy & Co Ltd (No 2) [2015] FCCA 2924

COF17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FedCFamC2G 145; (2021) 365 FLR 1

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 1; (2022) 96 ALJR 89; (2022) 312 IR 1; (2022) 398 ALR 404

Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of South Australia Inc [2002] HCA 8; (2002) 209 CLR 95; (2002) 76 ALJR 465; (2002) 112 IR 56; (2002) 187 ALR 92; (2002) 51 AILR 4-596

Frederick v South Australia [2006] SASC 165; (2006) 94 SASR 545; (2006) 152 IR 182

Gallagher v BHP Billiton Nickel West Pty Ltd [2016] FCCA 3367

Giltrap v Czeschka [2022] FedCFamC2G 715

Hodgson v Amcor Ltd [2012] VSC 94; (2012) 264 FLR 1; (2012) 64 AILR 250-033

Julstar Pty Ltd v Hart Trading Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 108

Matthews v Cool Or Cosy Pty Ltd [2004] WASCA 114; (2004) 136 IR 156

McGough v Minister for Finance [2021] FCCA 290

MCL Pty Ltd v The Agency Group Australia Ltd (No 3) [2021]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robinson v Pilbara Iron Company (Services) Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 593
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Robinson v Pilbara Iron Company (Services) Pty Ltd (No 2), the Court was tasked with determining the legal implications of a Fair Treatment System (FTS) Policy implemented by Pilbara Iron Company (PIC) on the employment terms of Mr Robinson, who was employed as a Production Superintendent. The dispute arose following Mr Robinson's termination of employment, which he challenged on the basis that the FTS Policy constituted part of his contract of employment and thus, should have been adhered to by PIC.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the FTS Policy, which provided a structured process for employees to appeal decisions affecting them, conferred any contractual obligations on PIC that would entitle Mr Robinson to benefits under the policy during his employment. Mr Robinson argued that the requirement to comply with PIC's policies, including the FTS Policy, imbued it with contractual status, and therefore, PIC should have followed the policy in terminating his employment.

The Court, however, found that the obligations imposed on employees to comply with PIC's policies, including the FTS Policy, were enforceable not by the policies themselves but by the employees' implied duty to comply with PIC's lawful and reasonable directions. Moreover, the Court observed that PIC retained the unilateral discretion to vary the benefits provided by the FTS Policy, which indicated that the benefits were discretionary and not guaranteed by any contractual promise. Consequently, the FTS Policy did not confer any contractual obligations on PIC that would have protected Mr Robinson's employment under the terms of the policy.

In light of the Court's findings, it concluded that the FTS Policy did not confer any contractual benefits on Mr Robinson that would have altered the terms of his employment or the process of his termination. The Court further ordered an extension of time for certain procedural matters, granted PIC leave to amend its Defence, and declared that clause 3.5 of the FTS Policy constituted a benefit to Mr Robinson, albeit without conferring any contractual status on the policy itself. The Court decided there would be no order as to costs and scheduled a further hearing to determine any additional orders, including the potential dismissal of Mr Robinson's originating application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Court has also had the benefit of reading, and having regard to, the transcript of the proceedings on the hearing of the Preliminary Question on 16 February 2023STATEMENT OF AGREED FACTS The Statement of Agreed Facts is as follows:1.[Mr Robinson] was employed by [PIC] in the role of Production Superintendent pursuant to:a)a letter of offer dated 1 April 2011 (annexed to the affidavit of John Dasey dated 24 September 2020 as “JD1” [the Dasey Affidavit]);b)a contract of employment executed on 14 April 2011 (annexed to the Dasey Affidavit as “JD2”) (the Employment Contract).2.During the course of [Mr Robinson’s] shift on 15 October 2020, [PIC] stood down [Mr Robinson] on full pay in order to investigate allegations of misconduct made against [Mr Robinson]. The standing down of [Mr Robinson] was subsequently confirmed by letter dated 16 October 2020 (the Stand Down Letter) (annexed hereto as “AD1”).3.On 2 November 2020, [PIC] issued [Mr Robinson] with a letter of termination of his Employment (Termination Letter). The Termination Letter stated that the termination of [Mr Robinson’s] employment was “effective 2 November 2020”, and “effective immediately” (annexed to the Dasey Affidavit as “JD3”).4.On 9 November 2020, [Mr Robinson] initiated a Fair Treatment System review of the decision to terminate his employment under [PIC’s] Fair Treatment System Policy (FTS Policy) (annexed to the Dasey Affidavit as “JD4” by submitting a Fair System Treatment notification form (annexed hereto as “AD 2”).5.On 1 December 2020, [PIC] issued [Mr Robinson] with a further letter amending the Termination Letter. The further letter was dated 2 November 2020 (annexed to the Dasey Affidavit as JD5).6.[Mr Robinson] was paid by [PIC] from 15 October 2020 until 2 December 2020. Thereafter, [PIC] paid [Mr Robinson] in lieu of notice of termination.7.The Agreed Documents are:a.The annexures to the Affidavit of Elizabeth Moran dated 19 July 2021, which is taken to be filed in support of the Respondent in these proceedings pursuant to the Orders of Judge Lucev dated 8 September 2020 (the Orders);b.The annexures to the Affidavit of John Dasey dated 24 September 2021 which is taken to be filed in support of [Mr Robinson] in these proceedings pursuant to the Orders;c.The additional Agreed Document annexed to this Statement of Agreed Facts as “AD1-AD2”. For the purposes of these Reasons for Judgment the Court has adopted the definitions of “Employment Contract”, “Stand Down Letter”, “Termination Letter”, “FTS Policy” and “Orders” as they appear in the Statement of Agreed Facts.AGREED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE The agreed documentary evidence is set out or referred to hereunder.Employment Contract In a letter of offer dated 1 April 2011 from PIC to Mr Robinson (an offer accepted by Mr Robinson on 14 April 2011) it was said that:The terms and conditions of your employment are recorded in the attached Schedule of Remuneration, Benefits and Employment Conditions.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the purposes of these Reasons for Judgment the Court has adopted the definitions of “Employment Contract”, “Stand Down Letter”, “Termination Letter”, “FTS Policy” and “Orders” as they appear in the Statement of Agreed Facts.AGREED DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE The agreed documentary evidence is set out or referred to hereunder.Employment Contract In a letter of offer dated 1 April 2011 from PIC to Mr Robinson (an offer accepted by Mr Robinson on 14 April 2011) it was said that:The terms and conditions of your employment are recorded in the attached Schedule of Remuneration, Benefits and Employment Conditions. This Schedule of Remuneration, Benefits and Employment Conditions is the “Employment Contract” as defined in the Statement of Agreed Facts. The Employment Contract is organised under several major headings: “Remuneration”, “Leave”, “Employee Benefits”, “Employment Conditions”, “Policies, procedures and standards”, “Information management” and “Termination of Employment”. Each major heading has several sub-headings, and under the major heading “Policies, procedures and standards” the following relevant sub-headings and text appears (emphasis added):­Policies and Procedures In addition to the terms and conditions outlined in this contract, you are required to comply with all reasonable directions by the Company and policies, procedures and standards that apply to your employment. Such policies include (but are not limited to) the Company’s Code of Conduct and The Way We Work.You must familiarise yourself with Company policies, procedures and standards. The Company retains the discretion to vary the policies, procedures and standards.Failure to comply with Company policies, procedures and standards could result in disciplinary action, which may include termination of your employment.The benefits provided to you under our policies are discretionary in nature and do not form part of your contract of employment.Details of our policies, procedures and standards are available from Human Resources or on the Company intranet.Fair Treatment The company currently operates a Fair Treatment System which can be accessed if you believe that a decision has been made which unfairly affects you in your role and cannot be resolved through consultation with your leader. When using the Fair Treatment System you are required to follow the process set out in the Fair Treatment System.Stand Down Letter The Stand Down Letter is as follows:Dear Dave,Stand Down from Role – Pending InvestigationWe confirm that you have been stood down on full pay, effective 15 October 2020.An investigation is being conducted into a physical altercation at Mesa A that is alleged to have occurred on 21 July 2020. We will endeavour to resolve this matter as soon as reasonably practicable. Whilst you are stood down you are required to take all necessary measures to ensure that you are fit and available to return to work or to attend meetings as and when directed during your normal work time.You have been provided with the contact number of our Employee Assistance Programme (EAP) provider BSS (1800 30 30 90). We encourage you and your family to use this service if required during this time. Should you need to contact us whilst you are stood down please call me on [mobile number of Phil Scott], or Skye Mitchell from Human Resources on [mobile number of Skye Mitchell].Sincerely,Phil ScottManager Mine OperationsRio Tinto Iron OreTermination Letter

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Robinson also contended that the fact that he was required to comply with PIC policies and procedures gave contractual status to the FTS Policy, but as the Court has already observed at [44(c) and(d)] above:(a)the articulated obligations on employees which PIC may enforce, are not enforceable under the policies, including the FTS Policy, themselves, but by force of each employee’s implied duty to comply with PIC’s lawful and reasonable directions: Wittenberg at [77]-[79] per Buchanan J, and nothing about that scheme warrants this Court implying a contractual obligation upon PIC to comply with the FTS Policy; and(b)PIC has a unilateral discretion to vary any of the benefits provided by the FTS Policy, and the benefits are therefore wholly discretionary at the behest of PIC, which is the antithesis of the existence of a contractual promise by PIC to provide the benefits in the FTS Policy for the duration of the Employment Contract, or at all: Wittenberg at [112] per Buchanan J, and [336] per McKerracher J (agreeing in part with Buchanan J).CONCLUSION For the reasons set out above there will be:(a)an order that in relation to the Court’s orders of 6 January 2023 time be extended as follows: (i)in order 1(a) to 9 January 2023;(ii)in order 1(b): (A)to 24 January 2023 for filing an outline of submissions; and(B)to 14 February 2023 for filing a list of authorities;(b)an order that pursuant to r 7.01 of the GFL Rules that leave be granted to PIC to amend its Defence in terms of the Proposed Amended Defence, that is in terms of the Amended Defence annexed as Exhibit TK1 to the Klaasen Affidavit (“Amended Defence”);(c)a declaration that cl 3.5 of the FTS Policy constitutes a benefit to Mr Robinson; and(d)an order that the Preliminary Question be answered as follows: “No, insofar as any provision thereof confers a benefit upon Mr Robinson”. Further, there will be an order that there be no order as to costs: FW Act, s 570(2). The Court will provide the parties with a brief opportunity to read these Reasons for Judgment before determining whether an order for dismissal of the originating application, or some other orders, ought to be made. For that purpose there will be a further order that the matter be adjourned to 2.00pm on 14 July 2023.