FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
(DIVISION 2)
Homes v Australian Carers Pty Ltd (No 3) [2024] FedCFamC2G 128
File number(s): ADG 131 of 2022 Judgment of: JUDGE LUCEV Date of judgment: 19 February 2024 Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Application for leave to file a Further Amended Statement of Claim following partially successful no case to answer application – new claim for mental and emotional harm where no case to answer on previous claim for psychiatric injury – revised claims for quantum of money for overtime and allowances based on revised claim for classification of employee at a particular wage level – whether employee meets criteria for classification at particular wage level – consideration of overarching civil practice and procedure provisions – case management considerations – whether proposed amendments will cause delay and additional expense – effect of proposed amendments on efficient disposal of Court’s caseload and resolution of disputes and disposal of proceedings in a timely manner.
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Whether contravention of general protections – whether workplace rights in relation to alleged discrimination, bullying and harassment – whether mental and emotional harm – whether duties at classification level claimed – whether underpayment of overtime, on call and travel allowances.Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 545, 570
Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) s 190, 191, 192
Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth) r 7.01
Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) r 7.01(1)
Federal Magistrates Court Rules 2001 (Cth) r 7.01(1)
Cases cited: AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175; (2009) 83 ALJR 951; (2009) 258 ALR 14
Cai v Tiy Loy & Co Ltd (No 2) [2015] FCCA 2924
Clarke v Dixie Cummings Enterprises Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 987
Cleland v Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 222
COF17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FedCFamC2G 145; (2021) 365 FLR 1
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union & Others v Clarke [2008] FCAFC 143; (2008) 170 FCR 574; (2008) 176 IR 245
Dafallah v Fair Work Commission [2014] FCA 328; (2014) 242 IR 273; (2014) 225 FCR 559
Homes v Australian Carers Pty Ltd(No 2) [2023] FedCFamC2G 714
Homes v Australian Carers Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 711
Pietrobon v BMD Constructions Pty Ltd [2017] FCCA 1730
Reynolds v Harrier Group Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 930
Robinson v Pilbara Iron Company (Services) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] FedCFamC2G 593; (2023) 326 IR 132
SZGTE v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2006] HCATrans 639
SZGTE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2006] FCA 443
SZSRR v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 328
Division: Division 2 General Federal Law Number of paragraphs: 60 Date of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Homes v Australian Carers Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FedCFamC2G 128
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
ADG 131 of 2022
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)
BETWEEN:
CHARMAINE HOMES
Applicant
AND:
AUSTRALIAN CARERS PTY LTD
First Respondent
REGINALD MALCOLM VITNELL
Second Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
JUDGE LUCEV
DATE OF ORDER:
19 FEBRUARY 2024
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1. The Applicant’s application in a proceeding filed 25 August 2023 to file a Further Amended Statement of Claim be granted, save for the proposed amendments to paragraphs 30B, 39, 41, 42 (but only as to the underlined words and numbers “3 and/or Level 2”), 45.2 and 46.2.4
2. Costs, if any, reserved.
Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.
Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
JUDGE LUCEV
INTRODUCTION
1.
Before the Court is an application in a proceeding filed on 25 August 2023 by the applicant, Ms Homes, in which leave is sought to file and serve a Further Amended Statement of Claim (“Proposed FASOC”) in relation to her claims under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“FW Act”) against the respondents, Australian Carers Pty Ltd (“Australian Carers”) and Mr Vitnell respectively (collectively “Respondents”). The application in a proceeding was supported by an affidavit of the same date of Ms Homes solicitor, MyChi Duong, who also filed two further affidavits on 5 and 20 November 2023, those two affidavits being in response to two affidavits filed on 1 and 3 November 2023 by the Respondents’ solicitor, Corinne Leah Armanini.
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS
2.
Most of Ms Homes proposed amendments to the Proposed FASOC are not opposed by the Respondents, but some issues remain in dispute, namely whether leave to amend ought to be granted in respect of proposed claims for:
(a) mental and emotional harm;
(b) the classification level for Ms Homes duties; and
(c) underpayment of travel allowance and overtime (including on-call overtime).
LITIGATION HISTORY
3.
It is convenient to set out the litigation history at the outset of these Reasons for Judgment as it is a significant part of the context which informs matters for consideration in relation to the proposed amendments in the Proposed FASOC.
4.
The originating application was filed on 2 June 2022.
5.
At a directions hearing on 1 December 2022 the matter was listed for a two day hearing on 29 and 30 May 2023.
6.
On 5 May 2023 Ms Homes filed an Amended Statement of Claim (“ASOC”) pursuant to leave granted by the Court on 21 April 2023. The ASOC made significant amendments to the original Statement of Claim filed on 2 June 2022, and of particular relevance to the present application in a proceeding to file and serve the Proposed FASOC, the ASOC made claims that:
(a) Ms Homes was underpaid during on call shifts;
(b) Ms Homes duties were those of a Level 4 Social and Community Services Employee under the Social, Community, Home Care and Disability Services Industry Award 2010 (“Award”), and that she was entitled to be paid wages, overtime, statutory entitlements and allowances as a Level 4 employee under various clauses in the Award;
(c) Australian Carers failed to make payment of travel allowances pursuant to cl 20.5(a) (misdescribed as cl 20.7(a) in the ASOC) of the Award in respect of Ms Homes’ travel to clients using her own motor vehicle;
(d) Australian Carers failed to pay Ms Homes an on-call allowance under cl 20.11 of the Award;
(e) Australian Carers failed to pay Ms Homes on account of overtime during regular weekday work as required by cl 28.1(a)(ii) of the Award;
(f) Australian Carers failed to pay Ms Homes wages at overtime rates for duties performed when she was required to perform those duties whilst on-call after 5.00pm on Friday evenings and before 6.00am on the Monday mornings in contravention of cl 26 of the Award; and
(g) Australian Carers failed to make payment of annual leave loading of 17.5% as required by cl 31.3 of the Award.
7.
On 23 May 2023 Australian Carers filed an Amended Defence which denied liability in respect of most of the matters set out above.
8.
The matter was heard on 29 and 30 May 2023 as listed, and went into a third day on 31 May 2023, at which time Ms Homes closed her case. At hearing on 29 May 2023 Australian Carers made an oral application to strike out various of the amendments in the ASOC. That application in a proceeding was dismissed at the hearing. When Ms Homes closed her case on 31 May 2023, a no case to answer submission was made by the Respondents. Judgment on the no case to answer submission was reserved.
9.
On 1 August 2023 Ms Homes filed an application in a proceeding for discovery of certain documents. The application in a proceeding for discovery was dismissed in an ex tempore judgment delivered on 4 August 2023: Homes v Australian Carers Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 711 (“Homes (No 1)”).
10.
On 11 August 2023 judgment was published on the Respondents’ no case to answer application: Homes v Australian Carers Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] FedCFamC2G 714 (“Homes (No 2)”). In Homes (No 2) at [66] per Judge Lucev the Court concluded that the Respondents had no case to answer with respect to Ms Homes’ claims:
(a) that she had a workplace right to expect compliance with the discrimination and bullying provisions of the FW Act;
(b) that she had a workplace right to be afforded natural justice, or alternatively procedural fairness, in respect of any allegations against her;
(c) that she had a workplace right to work from home;
(d) that she had suffered a psychiatric injury;
(e) that her duties were those of a Level 4 Social and Community Services Employee under the Award, and that she was entitled to wages, overtime, statutory allowances, and allowances calculated at the rate of pay for a Level 4 employee under the Award; and
(f) for payment:
(i) of on-call allowance for six weekends as claimed;
(ii) for overtime whilst working on-call, other than on the weekends of 19-21 November 2021 and 3-5 December 2021; and
(iii) for overtime for the trip to Yorketown on the weekend of 19-21 November 2021.
11.
On 14 August 2023 Ms Homes filed an application in a proceeding which sought:
(a) leave to amend the ASOC to plead that Ms Homes duties were those of a Level 3, “alternatively” a Level 2, under the Award, and that she was entitled to wages, overtime, statutory allowances and allowances calculated at the rate of pay for a Level 3, alternatively a Level 2, employee under the Award; and
(b) the provision of certain specified documents referred to in affidavits filed on behalf of the Respondents.
12.
At a directions hearing on 15 August 2023 the Court made orders in relation to Ms Homes’ application in a proceeding filed 14 August 2023 that:
(a) by 10:00am on 16 August 2023 Ms Homes file and serve a further ASOC amending paragraph 41 of the amended statement of claim to plead the words and numbers “Level 3, alternatively Level 2” in lieu of the words and numbers “Level 4” therein, and to make any consequential amendments to amounts otherwise claimed pursuant to the Award, but otherwise dismissing the application in a proceeding;
(b) costs, if any, be reserved; and
(c) Reasons for Judgment in relation to orders 1 and 2 be delivered as part of the Reasons for Judgment in relation to the originating application, and any further ASOC if filed in accordance with order 1.
13.
The hearing of the matter was listed to resume for a further two days on 16 and 17 August 2023, but on 16 August 2023 Ms Homes’ instructing solicitor appeared on the resumption of the hearing and sought an adjournment on the basis of the illness of Counsel. It was also brought to the Court’s attention that the order of 15 August 2023 allowing for the filing by Ms Homes of a further ASOC amending paragraph 41 of the amended statement of claim to plead the words and numbers “Level 3, alternatively Level 2” in lieu of the words and numbers “Level 4” therein, and to make any consequential amendments to amounts otherwise claimed pursuant to the Award, had not been complied with. The Court granted an adjournment, and made orders that:
(a) the further hearing of the matter be adjourned to a date to be fixed;
(b) Ms Homes have liberty to apply on or before 25 August 2023 to file a further ASOC;
(c) in relation to the order for liberty to apply to file a further ASOC, the parties were to confer forthwith; and
(d) the costs, if any, of the adjourned hearing days on 16 and 17 August 2023, be reserved.
14.
On 25 August 2023 Ms Homes filed the present application in a proceeding seeking leave to file and serve the Proposed FASOC, which was heard by the Court on 21 November 2023.
15.
The matter is listed for a further two days of hearing on 7 and 8 March 2024.
LAW - LEAVE TO GRANT AMENDMENT
16.
In considering whether to grant leave to allow the amendments proposed in the Proposed FASOC the Court must have regard to the overarching civil practice and procedure obligations under s 190 of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) (“FCFCOA Act”), which provides as follows:
(1) The overarching purpose of the civil practice and procedure provisions is to facilitate the just resolution of disputes:
(a) according to law; and
(b) as quickly, inexpensively and efficiently as possible.
(2) Without limiting subsection (1), the overarching purpose includes the following objectives:
(a) the just determination of all proceedings before the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2);
(b) the efficient use of the judicial and administrative resources available for the purposes of the Court;
(c) the efficient disposal of the Court's overall caseload;
(d) the disposal of all proceedings in a timely manner;
(e) the resolution of disputes at a cost that is proportionate to the importance and complexity of the matters in dispute.
(3) The civil practice and procedure provisions must be interpreted and applied, and any power conferred or duty imposed by them (including the power to make Rules of Court) must be exercised or carried out, in the way that best promotes the overarching purpose.
(4) The civil practice and procedure provisions are the following, so far as they apply in relation to civil proceedings:
(a) the Rules of Court;
(b) any other provision made by or under this Act or any other Act with respect to the practice and procedure of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2).
17.
Section 190 of the FCFCOA Act, read with ss 191 and 192 thereof, sets out the overarching purpose of civil practice and procedure provisions which is to facilitate the just resolution of disputes according to law and as quickly, inexpensively and efficiently as possible. A number of relevant important objectives are included therein, including:
(a) the efficient use of the judicial and administrative resources of the Court;
(b) efficient disposal of the Court's overall caseload; and
(c) disposal of all proceedings in a timely manner and the just resolution of disputes at a cost that is proportionate to the importance and complexity of the matters in dispute.
18.
In COF17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FedCFamC2G 145; (2021) 365 FLR 1 at [21] per Judge Lucev the Court observed that:
In terms of the overarching purpose of the civil practice and procedure provisions in s 190 of the FCFCOA Act, the Court also notes that it relates to the “just resolution of disputes”. The use of the plural “disputes” as opposed to the singular “dispute” is important. That is because the use of the plural “disputes” allows the Court to give consideration to the possible impact of a proposed course of action on other matters pending before the Court, and not just the “dispute” the subject of the matter immediately before it for hearing. Thus the Court may have regard, as it traditionally would have: Sali v SPC Ltd & Anor (1993) 67 ALJR 841; (1993) 116 ALR 625; ALJR at 843-844 per Brennan, Deane and McHugh JJ and 849 per Toohey and Gaudron JJ; AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175; (2009) 83 ALJR 951; (2009) 258 ALR 14 at [95] per Gummow, Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ, to the possible effect on other litigants … [of the grant of the indulgence sought].
19.
The Court has power to amend a document pursuant to r 7.01 of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth) (“GFL Rules”), which provides that:
(1) At any stage in a proceeding, the Court or a Registrar may allow or direct a party to amend a document (other than an affidavit) in the way and on the conditions the Court or the Registrar thinks fit.
(2) Subject to rule 7.03, the Court or a Registrar may allow an amendment even if the effect would be to include a cause of action arising after the proceeding was started.
20.
Rule 7.01(1) of the GFL Rules (then r 7.01(1) of the
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In addition to consideration of the prospects of success of any proposed amendment: SZSRR at [47] per Gleeson J, considerations relevant to the exercise of the discretion to allow an amendment pursuant to what is now r 7.01 of the GFL Rules have been held to include:(a)the nature and importance of the amendment to an applicant, and if it is in the interests of justice to grant leave to amend an application;(b)whether the party seeking the amendment is acting in good faith and not unnecessarily delaying proceedings, and in particular if an explanation is to be given for any delay in making the amendment: AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175; (2009) 83 ALJR 951; (2009) 258 ALR 14 (“AON Risk”) at [102] per Gummow, Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ;(c)whether any injustice, with particular focus on the stage in which the proceedings are at, cannot be adequately compensated for; and(d)case management issues (with particular reference to AON Risk at [30] per French CJ and at [97]-[103] per Gummow, Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ).See Pietrobon v BMD Constructions Pty Ltd [2017] FCCA 1730; Cai v Tiy Loy & Co Ltd (No 2) [2015] FCCA 2924 at [27] per Judge Manousaridis; Robinson v Pilbara Iron Company (Services) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] FedCFamC2G 593; (2023) 326 IR 132 at [25] per Judge Lucev.CONSIDERATION OF THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS Alleged mental and emotional harm At [30B] of the Proposed FASOC Ms Homes alleges that she has been unable to secure long term or permanent employment, or “any employment at all”, following the cessation of her employment with Australian Carers on 18 January 2022. Proposed amendments to the particulars to the plea at [30B] of the Proposed FASOC are as follows:30B.1 The Applicant refers to the Injury she has suffered as pleaded below in paragraphs 39 to 39.5 inclusive therein and says the Injury has prevented her from working full time or at all. On or about 25 January 2022, the Applicant commenced employment with Enhanced Lifestyle (“Post termination Employment”) as a support co-ordinator;30B.2 During the Applicant's Post Termination Employment, she received professional psychological and counselling support for the mental and emotional harm pleaded below in paragraphs 39 to 39.5, which she suffered consequent on the Meeting;30B.3 On 25 July 2022 the Applicant was terminated from her Post Termination Employment following which on 30 July 2022 she commenced her own business. At [39] of the Proposed FASOC the proposed amendment seeks to substitute the words “mental and emotional harm” for the words “a psychiatric injury (“the injury”)”. Ms Homes thus now claims to have suffered mental and emotional harm because of alleged adverse action against her by the Respondents, that harm being “in the form of” helplessness and worthlessness; insomnia and tiredness; nervousness and restlessness; distress, hurt and humiliation; and depression and anxiety. These particulars of the “form of” the now alleged mental and emotional harm remain unchanged from the “form of” the previously alleged “psychiatric injury”.