Polites Investments Pty Ltd v Russell

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

POLITES INVESTMENTS PTY LTD v RUSSELL

[2022] SASC 9

Judgment of the Honourable Justice David  

PROCEDURE - STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS: JURISDICTION, POWERS AND GENERALLY - VEXATIOUS LITIGANTS, PROCEEDINGS AND RELATED MATTERS - VEXATIOUS LITIGANT

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY - SUMMARY DISPOSAL - SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR DEFENDANT OR RESPONDENT: STAY OR DISMISSAL OF PROCEEDINGS

Polites Investments Pty Ltd ('Polites Investments') made an application on 7 May 2020 seeking orders to the effect that the respondent, Mr Douglas Charles Russell, be declared a vexatious litigant pursuant to s 39 of the Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) (the 'Act').

On 21 August 2020, Mr Russell brought an action by way of Cross Claim against Polites Investments seeking $3 million compensation from Polites Investments on the basis of fraud, perjury, and false and misleading statements allegedly made to this Court. Polites Investments denies the allegations contained in the Cross Claim.

Held, per David JA, allowing the application, and summarily dismissing the Cross Claim.

1. The respondent, Mr Russell, has instituted vexatious proceedings, as defined in s 39(5)(b) of the Act, by persistently instituting proceedings without reasonable ground.

2. The respondent is prohibited from instituting further proceedings in any court of the State of South Australia against the applicant, Polites Investments, or any related body corporate, officer, agent, or advisor of the applicant without the permission of this Court pursuant to s 39(1)(a) of the Act.

3.      The Cross Claim is dismissed.

4. The respondent is to pay the applicant's costs of the s 39 application and the Cross Claim as taxed or agreed.

Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 39; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 296; Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) rr 1.3, 144.2, referred to.
Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd v Hallett Concrete Pty Ltd (2020) 137 SASR 117; Andrew Garrett Wines Resorts Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd [2007] SASC 173; Attorney-General v Kowalski [2014] SASC 1; Attorney-General for the State of South Australia v Henriette Piepkorn [2005] SASC 425; Brogden v Attorney-General [2001] NZCA 20; Mitsubishi Motors Australia Ltd v Kowalski [2005] SASC 154; Russell v Polites Investments Pty Ltd [2011] SADC 30; Russell v Polites Investments Pty Ltd (No 2) [2015] SADC 128; Russell v Polites Investments Pty Ltd [2015] SASC 181; Russell v Polites Investments Pty Ltd [2016] SASC 129; Russell v Polites Investments Pty Ltd [2020] SASCFC 11; Russell v Polites Princes Group of Companies [2009] SADC 73; WorkCover Corporation of South Australia v Moore-McQuillan [2016] SASC 191, considered.

POLITES INVESTMENTS PTY LTD v RUSSELL
[2022] SASC 9

Supreme Court:       Civil

  1. DAVID JA: By Summons dated 7 May 2020, the applicant, Polites Investments Pty Ltd (‘Polites Investments’), made an application seeking orders to the effect that the respondent, Mr Douglas Charles Russell, be declared a vexatious litigant. Polites Investments seeks a declaration that Mr Russell…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Polites Investments Pty Ltd v Russell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Polites Investments Pty Ltd brought an application against Mr Russell for the summary dismissal of a Cross Claim brought by Mr Russell against Polites Investments, its CEO, its Rental Manager, a former Senior Counsel, Bar Chambers, a Barrister, and a law firm. Mr Russell's Cross Claim sought $3,000,000 in compensation for, among other things, fraud and perjury. Polites Investments argued that the Cross Claim was vexatious and without reasonable prospect of success. The court was required to determine whether Mr Russell’s Cross Claim had a reasonable basis and if it should be summarily dismissed under Rule 144.2 of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA).

The court found that Mr Russell’s Cross Claim was vexatious, as it sought to re-litigate contentions and repeat unsubstantiated allegations of fraud and perjury. The court concluded that the Cross Claim did not disclose any proper cause of action. It found that there was no reasonable basis for the Cross Claim to proceed and that it was obvious that the claim could not succeed. The court emphasised the importance of not embarking on a "mini trial" and applying the principles articulated in Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd v Hallett Concrete Pty Ltd. The court dismissed the Cross Claim and found that Mr Russell had instituted vexatious proceedings. The court ordered that Mr Russell be prohibited from instituting further proceedings against Polites Investments and its related entities without the court's permission. Mr Russell was also ordered to pay the costs of the application and the Cross Claim.

ORDERS:
1. I declare that the respondent, Mr Russell, has instituted vexatious proceedings, as defined in s 39(5)(b) of the Act, by persistently instituting proceedings without reasonable ground.
2. I order that Mr Russell be prohibited from instituting further proceedings in any court of the State of South Australia against the applicant, Polites Investments, or any related body corporate, officer, agent, or advisor of the applicant without the permission of this Court pursuant to s 39(1)(a) of the Act.
3. I order that the Cross Claim is dismissed.
4. Mr Russell is to pay the applicant's costs of the s 39 application and the Cross Claim as taxed or agreed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held, per David JA, allowing the application, and summarily dismissing the Cross Claim:

1. I declare that the respondent, Mr Russell, has instituted vexatious proceedings, as defined in s 39(5)(b) of the Act, by persistently instituting proceedings without reasonable ground.

2. I order that Mr Russell be prohibited from instituting further proceedings in any court of the State of South Australia against the applicant, Polites Investments, or any related body corporate, officer, agent, or advisor of the applicant without the permission of this Court pursuant to s 39(1)(a) of the Act.

3. I order that the Cross Claim is dismissed.

4. Mr Russell is to pay the applicant's costs of the s 39 application and the Cross Claim as taxed or agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 21 August 2020, Mr Russell brought an action by way of Cross Claim against Polites Investments seeking $3,000,000 compensation from Polites Investments, its CEO, Mr George Polites, its Rental Manager, Mr Peter Murphy, Justice Livesey (Polites Investment’s former Senior Counsel), Bar Chambers, Mr Kym Ryder, and O’Loughlins Lawyers. Polites Investments denies the allegations contained in the Cross Claim.Background to the application From at least 1977 to 6 November 2019, Polites Investments was the registered proprietor of a property situated at 254 Hindley Street, Adelaide (the ‘Premises’). Between 10 June 1999 and 29 August 2000, Mr Russell leased the ground floor of the Premises from Polites Investments. On or about 29 August 2000, Mr Russell was evicted from the Premises for breaches of the lease, including a failure to pay rent. From 2000 to date, Mr Russell has issued numerous proceedings and appeals against Polites Investments, the history of which is set out below. Polites Investments submits that each of the following proceedings and the Cross Claim arise out of the same underlying factual situation — Mr Russell’s eviction from the Premises in August 2000.Magistrates Court Proceedings On 20 August 2000, Mr Russell initiated proceedings against Mr Con Polites of the Polites Group in the Magistrates Court of South Australia to stay his eviction from the Premises and/or seek relief against forfeiture (the ‘Magistrates Court Proceedings’). On 30 August 2000, the Magistrates Court Proceedings were heard by Senior Magistrate Gumpl. At that hearing, Mr Russell withdrew from the proceedings.[2][2] Copy of Record of AMCCI-00-11576 dated 30 August 2000.Personal Injury Action On 23 June 2003, Mr Russell issued proceedings against Polites Investments, Mr George Polites, and the Polities Group of Companies in the District Court of South Australia alleging personal injuries suffered during his tenancy at the Premises (the ‘Personal Injury Action’). In the Personal Injury Action, Mr Russell alleged that in October 1999, January 2000, and August 2000 he slipped while descending the stairs at the Premises and, on each occasion, injured his back. On 8 July 2009, after the close of the defendants’ case on the trial of that action, Judge Millsteed held there was no case to answer and dismissed the proceedings.[3] His Honour held that there was no evidence that the first defendant, the Polites Group, was a legal entity capable of being sued in its own name and that Mr Polites, in his capacity as director, was not liable for any tortious conduct of Polites Investments.[4] His Honour found that there was no case to answer on the following grounds:[5]·Polites Investments did not breach any duty of care owed to Mr Russell;·Mr Russell had failed to establish that the third fall was caused by the condition of the stairs; and·By reason of an exclusion clause in the lease, Polites Investments could not be held liable in any event.[3] Russell v Polites Princes Group of Companies [2009] SADC 73.[4] Russell v Polites Princes Group of Companies [2009] SADC 73 at [79]-[86].[5] Russell v Polites Princes Group of Companies [2009] SADC 73 at [101]-[109], [118], [120].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Rule 144.2 of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) establishes the circumstances in which summary judgment may be given:144.2—Summary judgment(1)The Court may, on application by a party, give summary judgment in favour of an applicant—(a)on a claim if there is no reasonable basis for defending the claim; (b)on a cause of action in a claim if there is no reasonable basis for defending the cause of action; or(c)on a separate issue that arises in a claim if there is no reasonable basis for contesting that issue.(2)The Court may, on application by a party, give summary judgment against an applicant—(a)on a claim if there is no reasonable basis for prosecuting the claim;(b)on a cause of action in a claim if there is no reasonable basis for prosecuting the cause of action; or (c)on a separate issue that arises in a claim if there is no reasonable basis for prosecuting the applicant’s contention on that issue.… In an application for the summary dismissal of a claim, the onus is on the applicant to establish that it is obvious that the claim cannot succeed. In Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd v Hallett Concrete Pty Ltd,[74] Doyle J summarised the principles to be applied in determining a claim summarily. His Honour said:[75]By way of summary of the approach articulated in Spencer v Commonwealth, it can be said that the power to determine a claim summarily should not be exercised lightly. Exercise of the power requires a practical assessment of whether the applicant has real, as opposed to merely fanciful, prospects of success. While the Court need not be satisfied that the claim is hopeless or bound to fail, nevertheless it must be cautious not to do a party injustice by summarily determining an action, particularly where there are disputed issues of fact or law or mixed fact and law, merely because the Court considers that the claim is unlikely to succeed. However, beyond these very general guidelines, the Court should focus upon the words used in the rules and avoid applying any judicial gloss.Related to the requirement that the Court undertake a “practical” assessment is the notion that the Court should not embark upon a “mini trial” of the claim. Rather, the claim should be assessed in a summary manner, while being cognisant of the incomplete nature of the evidence upon which the Court’s decision must be based. Adversarial argument may assist, and indeed may result in the emergence of a sufficiently clear answer to a complex issue that summary judgment is appropriate. On the other hand, the need for prolonged argument may be indicative of a reasonable basis for the claim.(citations omitted)[74] (2020) 137 SASR 117.[75] Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd v Hallett Concrete Pty Ltd (2020) 137 SASR 117 at [59]-[60]. Applying those principles to the Cross Claim, Mr Russell’s action seeks to re-litigate contentions and repeats general allegations of fraud and perjury that have been found to be scandalous and unsubstantiated. The matters raised by the Cross Claim do not disclose any proper cause of action. The claim is summarily dismissed. Orders

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.