Russell v Polites Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

RUSSELL v POLITES INVESTMENTS P/L

[2016] SASC 129

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Stanley

17 August 2016

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY - SUMMARY DISPOSAL - SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR DEFENDANT OR RESPONDENT: STAY OR DISMISSAL OF PROCEEDINGS

PROCEDURE - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - DISCOVERY OF DOCUMENTS - GENERALLY

The court has before it four interlocutory applications.  There are three applications by the appellant, Mr Russell. The first and second applications are mirror images of each other brought in separate actions instituting appeals from judgments of the District Court.  They seek an extension of time for the provision of appeal books for appeals brought against judgments of the District Court dismissing claims by the appellant against the respondent for damages for personal injury and for breach of lease.  In the third application the appellant seeks orders in the nature of discovery in the appeal from the dismissal of his claim for damages for personal injury. 

The respondent brings its own interlocutory application.  It seeks an order that the appellant’s notice of appeal be summarily dismissed or, in the alternative, struck out, together with an application for costs.

Held:

1.  The appellant has not put forward any arguable ground of appeal nor any reason why an extension of time should be granted or why permission to appeal should be granted.  The appeal is well out of time and without merit.  It is clear beyond argument that the appeal against the judgment of Peek J of 12 November 2015 must fail (at [44]).

2.  Dismiss the appellant’s notice of appeal filed on 19 January 2016 (at [53]).

3.  It is unnecessary to consider an extension of time for providing the appeal books in the actions SCCIV-15-934 and SCCIV-10-1293 (at [53]).

4.  Dismiss the application for discovery from Mr Murphy, Mr Polites, Mr Ryder, Mr Vormelker and Mr Sekhon (at [53]).

Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 117(2)(e), r 136, r 232, r 288, 290(1)(c), r 295(1)(h), r 296(2); Supreme Court Civil Supplementary Rules 2014 (SA) r 240(1)(b); Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) r 60, referred to.
Slinko v Guardianship and Administration Tribunal [2006] 2 Qd R 279, discussed.
Landmark Operations Ltd v J Tiver Nominees Pty Ltd & Ors [2009] SASC 273; Purins v Alpine Constructions Pty Ltd [2008] SASC 11; Morgan v WorkCover Corporation [2013] SASC 47; Slinko v Guardianship and Administration Tribunal [2006] 2 Qd R 279; B Q and H M Doe Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank [1999] SASC 124; Rajski v Bainton (1990) 22 NSWLR 125; Buying Systems (Australia) Pty Ltd v Tien Mah Litho Printing Co (PTE) Ltd (1986) 5 NSWLR 317; Spurway v Police [2011] SASC 177; Duke Group v Arthur Young (No. 2) (1991) 4 ACSR 355; Russell v Polites Investments Pty Ltd [2015] SASC 181; Spencer v Commonwealth (2010) 241 CLR 118; O’Brien…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Russell v Polites Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 129
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Russell v Polites Investments Pty Ltd, the appellant sought to appeal against judgments from the District Court that dismissed claims for damages for personal injury and breach of lease. The respondent applied for the appellant's notice of appeal to be summarily dismissed or, in the alternative, struck out, and sought costs. The appellant had previously attempted to appeal against similar judgments, but those appeals were dismissed by Peek J on the basis that the prospects of success were extremely low or negligible. The appellant’s current application also related to discovery of documents and interrogatories, seeking information from various parties involved in the proceedings.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the appellant's notice of appeal should be dismissed or struck out, and whether the discovery sought by the appellant was relevant and necessary for the appeal. The court had to consider whether the appellant's appeal was likely to succeed, and whether the discovery sought was relevant to the issues on appeal. The court also had to determine whether the appellant had acted appropriately in seeking the discovery of documents and interrogatories from the respondent.

The court found that the appellant's notice of appeal should be dismissed as the prospects of success were extremely low or negligible. The court noted that the appeal was significantly out of time and that the appellant had previously attempted to appeal similar judgments which were dismissed. The court also found that the discovery sought by the appellant was not relevant to the issues on the appeals and that the appellant had not adequately explained its relevance. The court dismissed the application for discovery and struck out the appellant's notice of appeal. The court ordered that the parties would be heard regarding the costs of all four applications.

In summary, the court dismissed the appellant's notice of appeal, found the discovery sought was irrelevant, and ordered the parties to be heard regarding costs. The dismissal of the appeal and the striking out of the notice of appeal reflect the court's view that the prospects of success were extremely low, and the discovery sought did not pertain to the relevant issues.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent brings its own interlocutory application. It seeks an order that the appellant’s notice of appeal be summarily dismissed or, in the alternative, struck out, together with an application for costs. Background to the applications In order to explain the disposition of these applications it is convenient to start with a recent judgment of this Court. On 12 November 2015 Peek J dismissed an application by the appellant for the setting down of appeals to the Full Court from the judgments in the District Court dismissing the appellant’s claims for damages for personal injury and breach of lease. Those notices of appeal had lapsed by operation of 6SCR 296(2). Peek J dismissed the application on the basis he was satisfied that the making of the order sought was not necessary for the proper conduct of the proceeding or otherwise was not in the interests of justice. He did so on the basis that he was satisfied that the prospects of success on either appeal would be extremely low or negligible. It is necessary that I explain something of the history to those appeals. In June 2003 the appellant brought proceedings in the District Court against the respondent, the Polites Princes Group of Companies, Polites Investment Pty Ltd and Mr George C Polites, claiming damages for person injury he allegedly suffered as a result of falling down stairs in premises leased from the respondent in 2000. On 8 July 2009, after the close of the appellant’s case on the trial of that action, a Judge of the District Court, Judge Millsteed, held that there was no case to answer and dismissed the proceedings. The judge held that on the facts, while a duty of care arose on the part of the respondent to the appellant, it had not breached its duty, and in any event, the appellant failed on the issue of causation, and finally, the judge found that any liability was excluded by the terms of the lease. In February 2007 the appellant took action in the District Court against the respondent, claiming damages for losses allegedly suffered as a result of a breach of lease alleged to have occurred in 2000. That action was statute barred. On 9 July 2009 a Master of the District Court ordered the appellant provide security for costs in that action by 14 August 2009. The appellant failed to pay the monies ordered by way of security into court. Subsequently in January 2010 the respondent applied for the dismissal of the action and the appellant filed an application that he be permitted to proceed with the action without having to comply with the order for security. Those applications were heard by a different Master of the District Court. On 31 May 2010 the master dismissed the appellant’s application, dismissed his action for want of prosecution, made an award of costs in favour of the respondent and ordered an allocatur in relation to those costs. On 21 September 2010 the appellant filed a notice of appeal in the Supreme Court in action 1293 of 2010 from the judgment of Judge Millsteed dismissing his claim for damages for personal injury. The appeal was some 13 months out of time.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Discovery is also sought from Mr Ryder, who is or was a solicitor for the respondent, of a receipt from the Registry for the photocopying of the two appeal books that his firm did not receive from the appellant. If such a document exists, I accept it is within the possession of the respondent, being within the control of the respondent. However, it is unclear to me how it is said to be directly relevant to an issue on the appeals. The appellant failed to explain its relevance. Discovery is also sought from Mr Sekhon, who is or was a solicitor for the respondent, to confirm an affidavit that he did confirm to Master Rice on 15 April 2006 that he said to the Court that he and Polites had received the medical evidence book. This is not a proper application for discovery. It does not seek disclosure of a document. It is also irrelevant to any issue that arises on the appeals which do not concern medical evidence. Conclusion In the circumstances I would make the following orders:1.It is unnecessary to consider an extension of time for providing the appeal books in the actions SCCIV-15-934 and SCCIV-10-1293.2.I would dismiss the application for discovery from Mr Murphy, Mr Polites, Mr Ryder, Mr Vormelker and Mr Sekhon.3.I would dismiss the appellant’s notice of appeal filed on 19 January 2016. I would hear the parties as to costs of all four applications.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the issue of whether the appellant's notice of appeal should be summarily dismissed or struck out due to the prospects of success being extremely low or negligible. The respondent sought an order for this based on a previous judgment by Peek J, who dismissed the appellant's application for setting down appeals from the judgments in the District Court. Peek J had dismissed the application on the basis that the prospects of success on either appeal would be extremely low or negligible. The appellant's history in the case was marked by failures, including the dismissal of his claims for damages for personal injury and breach of lease, and his inability to comply with an order for security for costs, leading to the dismissal of his action for want of prosecution. The court acknowledged the precedent set by Peek J and found the appellant's prospects of success to be extremely low or negligible, aligning with the previous judgment.

The court then turned to the issue of whether an order for costs should be granted to the respondent in relation to the interlocutory applications. The respondent's application for costs was considered in light of the appellant's unsuccessful attempts to appeal the District Court's judgments. The court determined that the costs should be borne by the appellant, reflecting the futility of the appellant's appeals and the respondent's need to defend against meritless claims. This decision was consistent with the principles that costs should follow the event, and that a party who pursues a vexatious or unmeritorious claim should bear the costs incurred by the other party in defending it.

Next, the court considered the issue of whether the respondent was required to provide discovery of documents from Mr Murphy, Mr Polites, Mr Ryder, Mr Vormelker, and Mr Sekhon, and if such discovery was relevant to the issues on appeal. The court found that the discovery requests were not properly framed and that the documents sought were not directly relevant to the issues on appeal. The appellant had failed to explain the relevance of the documents to the appeals, which did not concern medical evidence. The court dismissed the application for discovery, emphasizing that the discovery process should be limited to documents that are pertinent to the issues at hand.

Finally, the court addressed the issue of whether an extension of time should be granted for providing the appeal books in the actions SCCIV-15-934 and SCCIV-10-1293. The court noted that the appellant had filed a notice of appeal that was 13 months out of time, which indicated a lack of diligence. Given the appellant's history of untimeliness and the low prospects of success on appeal, the court deemed it unnecessary to consider an extension of time for providing the appeal books.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an appeal with extremely low or negligible prospects of success may be summarily dismissed or struck out, and the costs of interlocutory applications may be awarded to the respondent if the claims are found to be vexatious or unmeritorious. The court also clarified that discovery should be limited to relevant documents, and extensions of time may not be granted where there has been a history of untimeliness and lack of diligence.