Police v Sullivan; Attorney-General (SA) v Sullivan

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Criminal: Application)

POLICE v SULLIVAN; ATTORNEY-GENERAL (SA) v SULLIVAN

[2018] SASC 11

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Hinton

9 February 2018

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - RELEVANT FACTORS  - NATURE AND CIRCUMSTANCES OF OFFENDER - INTELLECTUALLY HANDICAPPED OFFENDER

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - POST-CUSTODIAL ORDERS - OTHER TYPES OF POST-CUSTODIAL ORDERS

On 27 November 2017, Mr Sullivan was released from prison after serving sentences for sexual offences involving children. Upon his re-entering the community he was subject to an interim supervision order made under the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA) (the High Risk Offenders Act) in addition to obligations imposed by the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) (the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act). He failed to comply with the terms of the order and failed to meet his obligations under the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act.

Consequently, on 12 December 2017, Mr Sullivan was taken into custody pursuant to a warrant issued under s 15 of the High Risk Offenders Act. By Information laid on 13 December 2017, Mr Sullivan was charged with three counts of failing to comply with a reporting obligation relating to reportable contact with a child, contrary to s 44(1a) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act (counts 1-3), and three counts of failing to comply with reporting obligations, contrary to s 44(1) of the same Act (counts 4-6).

On 19 January 2018, he was interviewed by the Parole Board in relation to breaches of the interim supervision order. The Parole Board was satisfied that Mr Sullivan had breached the interim supervision order and directed that he be detained in custody pending attendance before this Court pursuant to s 17(1)(b)(ii) of the High Risk Offenders Act.

Because of the inter-relationship of these matters, Mr Sullivan appeared in the Supreme Court for three purposes:

• To determine whether a continuing detention order should be made against him under s 18 of the High Risk Offenders Act;

• To determine whether an extended supervision order should be made against him under s 7 of the High Risk Offenders Act; and

• For sentence on the offences he committed against the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act (on AMC-17-14780).

The charges arose out of, in effect, a self-report. Mr Sullivan suffers from an intellectual disability. He admitted breaching the interim supervision order and pleaded guilty to all charges. Subsequently he applied to withdraw his plea on count 4 and the prosecution applied to withdraw count 4.   

Held:

As to AMC-17-14780:

1.       Permission is granted to Mr Sullivan to withdraw his plea in relation to count 4.

2.       Permission is granted to the prosecution to withdraw count 4.

3. Convictions are imposed on each of counts 1, 2, 3, 5 and 6. Pursuant to section 18A of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 one penalty in relation to counts 1, 2, 3, 5 and 6 is imposed being a sentence of 54 days imprisonment commencing on 12 December 2017.

As to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Police v Sullivan; Attorney-General (SA) v Sullivan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASC 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Police v Sullivan; Attorney-General (SA) v Sullivan, the primary issue before the court was whether the defendant, Sullivan, should be subject to an extended supervision order under the High Risk Offenders Act. Sullivan had previously been convicted of child sex offences and had breached the conditions of an interim supervision order by failing to report certain contacts with children as required by the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate sentence for these breaches and whether an extended supervision order was warranted.

The legal issues centred on the interpretation and application of the High Risk Offenders Act and the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act. Specifically, the court had to consider the criteria for imposing an extended supervision order, the risk Sullivan posed to the community, and the need for assertive community support. The court also had to balance the interests of public safety with Sullivan's right to freedom and rehabilitation. Expert psychiatric evidence was central to the court's decision, particularly in assessing Sullivan's risk level and the effectiveness of potential rehabilitation programs.

The court found that Sullivan's history of offending, coupled with his failure to comply with supervision conditions, demonstrated a significant risk to the community, particularly children. The psychiatric evidence indicated that Sullivan's low intellectual capacity and difficulty in self-organisation necessitated strict supervision and support. The court concluded that an extended supervision order was necessary to manage this risk effectively. The order included specific conditions, such as prohibiting Sullivan from being in a domestic situation with underage children and requiring him to participate in a tailored sexual offender program at Owenia House.

The final orders included an extended supervision order for Sullivan, with specified conditions to manage his risk and facilitate his rehabilitation. Sullivan was also sentenced for the breaches of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act, with the sentences to be served concurrently with the extended supervision order. The court's decision underscored the importance of balancing public safety with the rehabilitative needs of offenders in cases involving high-risk individuals.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

I have received the following:·The affidavit of Fiona Yumi Williams-Mitchell, affirmed 6 September 2017, and the fourteen exhibits referred to therein. This affidavit was filed in support of the Attorney-General’s application for an extended supervision order. However, my understanding is that I may have regard to its content for all purposes.·A second affidavit of Fiona Yumi Williams-Mitchell, affirmed 28 September 2017, and the one exhibit referred to therein. I understand that, as with Ms Williams-Mitchell’s first affidavit, the content of this affidavit and exhibit can be used for all purposes. ·A report prepared by Dr C Raeside, a Consultant Forensic Psychiatrist with the South Australian Forensic Mental Health Service, dated 12 January 2018, prepared in compliance with the direction of this Court made under s 7(3) of the High Risk Offenders Act.·The affidavit of Colin John Mercer, sworn 31 January 2018. This affidavit explains how Mr Sullivan’s breach of the interim supervision order and conditions under the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act came to light and resulted in the Parole Board issuing a warrant under s 15 of the High Risk Offenders Act for Mr Sullivan’s arrest and detention.·The affidavit of Alyona Andreevna Haines, sworn 1 February 2018. This affidavit exhibits a report prepared by Dr C Raeside expressing an opinion as to whether Mr Sullivan was mentally competent to commit, and fit to be tried for, his 2011 offending. This report informs, in part, Dr Raeside’s 2018 report referred to above.·The affidavit of Peter Bikic, sworn 6 February 2018, and the two exhibits referred to therein. This affidavit sets out the background against which the offences under the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act were committed.·A Parole Board file containing records of proceedings and action taken by the Board since 12 December 2017 resulting in the exercise of the power contained in s 17(1)(b)(ii) of the High Risk Offenders Act. ·The Magistrates Court file AMC-17-14780 opened upon the police laying an Information charging Mr Sullivan with six counts of breaching reporting requirements under the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act. ·The affidavit of Paul Daniel Furst, affirmed 1 February 2018, detailing the therapeutic programs available at Owenia House. ·The affidavit of Matthew Edmond Boisseau, affirmed 6 February 2018. This affidavit annexes a letter from the Parole Board advising that it would not add any conditions under s 11 of the High Risk Offenders Act to those sought by the Attorney-General in his application for an extended supervision order unless there occurs a change in circumstances. Background Mr Sullivan was born on 12 November 1985. He was born whilst his mother was serving a sentence of imprisonment. Consequently he was separated from his mother and given to his grandmother. His grandmother, his aunts and uncles raised him. Mr Sullivan has described his grandmother as a “friendly old person that you can come along to. A proper mum – a real mum”. Welfare services never intervened in his care.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Accordingly, Dr Raeside was supportive of an extended supervision order being made in Mr Sullivan’s case. He recommended that Mr Sullivan be required to engage with the Owenia House sexual offender program, particularly adapted to his low intellectual capacity, and seek assistance from Disability SA. Dr Raeside was of the opinion that Mr Sullivan would find it difficult to engage voluntarily with Disability SA because of his low IQ and difficulty in organising himself. He repeated the opinion he expressed in 2011 that in Mr Sullivan’s case assertive community support would be necessary. Dr Raeside brought his report to a close recommending:Finally, although Mr Sullivan does not see himself as a sexual predator (in that he does not see that he represents a risk to children in general and somewhat different than others he might have associated with in custody), I would recommend that strict requirements be upheld in relation to him not being in a domestic situation in which there are underage children present, as well as the other various requirements that would be necessary as part of his ANCOR requirements.I do not believe Mr Sullivan requires any specific psychiatric treatment. He was previously on an antidepressant, but I found no evidence of any current depressive illness.The offences under the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act Because of the inter-relationship of the charges under the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act, the breach of the interim supervision order, and the question of whether to make an extended supervision order, with the consent of the parties, arrangements were made for the Magistrates’ Court file concerning the offences charged in the Information laid on 13 December 2017 to be transferred to this Court to be dealt with. Accordingly, for the purposes of sentencing Mr Sullivan for the offences committed against the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act as contained in the Information laid on 13 December 2017, I sat in the capacity of a Magistrate.[1][1] Judicial Administration (Auxiliary Appointments and Powers) Act 1988 (SA), s 5. The Information contains the following counts:1.Between the 27th day of November 2017 and the 12th day of December 2017 at HACKHAM WEST in the said State, being a registrable offender without reasonable excuse failed to comply with a reporting obligation relating to reportable contact with a child.Section 44(1a) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 20062.Between the 27th day of November 2017 and the 12th day of December 2017 at HACKHAM WEST in the said State, being a registrable offender without reasonable excuse failed to comply with a reporting obligation relating to reportable contact with a child.Section 44(1a) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 20063.Between the 27th day of November 2017 and the 12th day of December 2017 at HACKHAM WEST in the said State, being a registrable offender without reasonable excuse failed to comply with a reporting obligation relating to reportable contact with a child.Section 44(1a) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 20064.Between the 27th day of November 2017 and the 12th day of December 2017 at HACKHAM WEST in the said State, being a registrable offender without reasonable excuse failed to comply with his reporting obligations without reasonable excuse. (sic)Section 44(1) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 20065.Between the 27th day of November 2017 and the 12th day of December 2017 at HACKHAM WEST in the said State, being a registrable offender without reasonable excuse failed to comply with his reporting obligations without reasonable excuse. (sic)Section 44(1) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 20066.Between the 27th day of November 2017 and the 12th day of December 2017 at HACKHAM WEST in the said State, being a registrable offender without reasonable excuse failed to comply with his reporting obligations without reasonable excuse. (sic)Section 44(1) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006