Attorney-General (SA) v Rigney Brown (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Criminal: Application)

ATTORNEY-GENERAL (SA) v RIGNEY BROWN (No 2)

[2024] SASC 8

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McIntyre  

19 January 2024

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS - DANGEROUS SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDER

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - POST-CUSTODIAL ORDERS - OTHER TYPES OF POST-CUSTODIAL ORDERS

On 31 October 2022, this Court made an extended supervision order with respect to the respondent pursuant to s 7(4) of the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA) (‘the Act’).

On 4 October 2023, the Parole Board satisfied itself that the respondent had breached three conditions of his extended supervision order in June, July and August of 2023. Pursuant to s 17(1)(b)(ii), the Parole Board directed that the respondent be detained in custody pending attendance before the Court for determination as to whether a continuing detention order should be made under s 18(2) of the Act.

The applicant seeks a continuing detention order until the end of July 2024 to enable the respondent to complete a Domestic Family Violence Intervention Program (‘DFVIP’) to be held at Mobilong between 19 February 2024 and 19 July 2024. 

Held:

1.      The respondent requires rehabilitation, support and treatment in order to reduce his risk to the      community. 

2.      The DFVIP is appropriate rehabilitation however, the applicant cannot guarantee that the     respondent will be able to attend the DFVIP at Mobilong.  The DFVIP is available to the respondent in the community.

3.      The breaches of the extended supervision order do not indicate a failure of the order to protect      the community.

4.      The application for a continuing detention order is dismissed.

Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA) ss 7, 17, 18, referred to.

Attorney-General (SA) v Rigney-Brown [2023] SASC 73., discussed.

Police v Sullivan; Attorney-General (SA) v Sullivan [2018] SASC 11; Attorney General (SA) v Drion [2002] SASC 120, considered.

ATTORNEY-GENERAL (SA) v RIGNEY BROWN (No 2)
[2024] SASC 8

Criminal: Application

  1. McINTYRE J: The respondent, David George Rigney-Brown, comes before the Court on a referral from the Parole Board under s 17(1)(b)(ii) of the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act2015 (SA) (‘the HRO Act’). The question for determination by the Court is whether the respondent should be subject to a continuing detention order (‘CDO’) pursuant to s 18(2) of the HRO Act.

    Background

  2. On 10 August 2020, the respondent was determined to be a high-risk offender and was placed on an Extended Supervision Order (‘ESO’) under s 7(4) of the HRO Act for a period of two years. On 31 October 2022, the Court made a second ESO for a further period of two years. The second ESO is due to expire on 30 October 2024.

  3. The ESOs were made on the basis that the respondent is a serious violent offender as a result of convictions for aggravated commit theft using force, aggravated attempted commit theft using force, assault, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney-General (SA) v Rigney Brown (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Attorney-General (SA) v Rigney Brown (No 2), the court addressed the matter of whether the respondent, who had breached the conditions of a second extended supervision order (ESO), should be detained in custody. The application for a community detention order (CDO) was based on the respondent's repeated failures to comply with the terms of the ESO, which included attending a domestic and family violence intervention program. The court was tasked with determining whether the respondent posed a significant risk to the community and, if so, whether he should be detained in custody to ensure his participation in a rehabilitation program.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the respondent posed an appreciable risk to the safety of the community and, if so, whether detention was necessary to mitigate that risk. The court considered various pieces of evidence, including affidavits from the respondent's NDIS worker, the Department for Correctional Services, and psychologists, as well as the Parole Board's findings. The evidence highlighted the respondent's history of violent offending, his lack of commitment to rehabilitation in the community, and the challenges he faced due to his disabilities.

The court found that the respondent presented a high risk of violent offending, based on his history and the expert reports. Despite the barriers to his rehabilitation, the court noted that the respondent had not fully engaged with the support systems available to him. The Parole Board had concluded that he could not be effectively managed in the community, leading to the recommendation for a CDO. The court balanced these findings with the substantial penalty the respondent had already faced for his breaches and his lack of motivation to comply with the ESOs. Ultimately, the court decided that the risk to the community warranted detention to ensure the respondent's participation in the required rehabilitation program, despite the uncertainties around his transfer to the appropriate institution.

The court ordered that the respondent be detained in custody to comply with the second ESO, with the aim of facilitating his participation in the domestic and family violence intervention program. This decision was made in the interest of public safety and to provide the respondent with the necessary support to address his violent offending behaviour.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As on the previous occasion, there is no dispute that the respondent breached the second ESO as outlined in the findings of the Parole Board on 4 October 2023. In saying that I note that the offences with which the respondent was charged following an incident on 11 August 2023 have been reduced to minor indictable offences and are contested. The respondent is now on simple bail for the offences of assault police and hinder police. He denies these charges but is prepared to plead guilty to resisting. Plainly the incident was not as serious as the material before the Parole Board suggested but nonetheless resulted in a breach of condition one of the ESO. Accordingly, the issues for determination are, again, whether he poses a risk to the safety of the community if not detained in custody and, if he does, whether he ought to be detained. Evidence A number of affidavits and documents have been tendered by the applicant in this matter as follows:·Affidavits of Emily Oriana Brown made on 27 November 2023 and 13 December 2023 (exhibit A1) and a further affidavit made on 17 January 2024 (exhibit A7); ·affidavit of Amanda Kate Pirone made on 19 December 2023 (exhibit A2) and an undated report from Ms Pirone (exhibit A3); ·letter from Matthew Pedler, Flinders Wellbeing Centre dated 15 December 2023 (exhibit A4);·affidavit of Rebekah Brand made on 10 January 2024 (exhibit A5); and ·affidavit of Jared Shane Frost made on 17 January 2024 (exhibit A6). In addition, Ms Pirone gave evidence on 21 December 2023. Ms Pirone is employed by the Department for Correctional Services (‘DCS’) as the Acting Clinical Supervisor in the Rehabilitation Programs Branch. In addition to providing an affidavit and report, she gave evidence concerning the DCS assessment of the respondent’s treatment needs and the rehabilitation options available to him in custody. The respondent was placed on the Aboriginal Men’s Family Violence Program (‘AMFVP’) whilst in custody in February 2023. This program terminated for “unforeseen operational issues” unconnected to the respondent after he had completed nine group sessions. Accordingly, it was proposed that the respondent attend the general Domestic Family Violence Intervention Program (‘DFVIP’). Ms Pirone explained that the programs are the same in terms of structure, format and content. The difference is that the AMFVP is conducted by an Aboriginal clinician and has more flexibility for cultural adaptations to suit the needs of the men in the program. The respondent was enrolled in the DFVIP in the community in May 2023 following the decision not to impose a CDO. He was offered a range of supports to facilitate his completion of the DFVIP and, in addition, had external support through the NDIS. Unfortunately, the respondent attended only three sessions and was subsequently terminated due to non-attendance. Ms Pirone indicated that there is no AMFVP offered in the community. The DFVIP is offered in the community on a rolling basis. The respondent could be offered a place in the program within 11 to 12 weeks. In the custodial setting, DCS will offer both AMFVP and the DFVIP. The DFVIP will be offered in Mobilong in February 2024 and the AMFVP will be offered at Cadell in March 2024. Ms Pirone was not able to guarantee that the respondent could be accommodated in those programs as there are a number of factors to be considered, including whether the respondent is deemed suitable to be relocated to those institutions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On the other hand, the respondent now has a good relationship with his NDIS worker. His NDIS provider is an indigenous organisation which will provide culturally appropriate support. The applicant has accommodation available to him in the community and the support offered by the NDIS program in addition to the support that will be provided under the ESO. He is engaging with drug and alcohol counselling through Aboriginal Sobriety Group and he has been speaking to the Flinders wellbeing psychologist. The ALRM prisoner care program will provide him with case management support in the community. He has significant NDIS funding which will provide him with support on his release. He may well receive further NDIS support if the recent application is successful. He has shown a willingness to engage with rehabilitation if provided with support. He has demonstrated no behavioural problems in custody since he was arrested in August. On any view, the support structure available to him this year is significantly better than last year. Finally, it was put that he has already sustained a substantial penalty for his breaches of failing to attend on one occasion, two positive drug tests and some alleged minor offending on 11 August 2023 and accordingly he is aware of the consequences should he not comply with the ESO. Consideration The respondent’s risk of violent offending was assessed as “high” at the time the first ESO was made. Due to his continual breaches of that ESO, nothing had occurred to reduce that risk by the time of the second ESO. The pattern under the second ESO has been the same. I am satisfied that the respondent presents an appreciable risk to the community based upon his history, the reports of Dr Raeside and Mr Balfour, and the material from the Parole Board and DCS. The question is then whether he ought to be detained in custody. The letter from the Parole Board dated 13 November 2023[6] details the shortcomings in the respondent’s compliance with the second ESO. Whilst there are a number of factors that affect his ability to comply with the orders as outlined in the May 2023 decision, he has shown no commitment to rehabilitation in the community. He has been resistant to supervision. The Parole Board has formed the view that he cannot be managed in the community and recommends a CDO because it provides, at least, a possibility that he can be engaged at some level with intervention. [6] EOB 3 of Exhibit A1 Affidavit of Emily Oriana Brown made on 27 November 2023. This is a finely balanced decision. This is the respondent’s fourth referral for a CDO. The referral was made on appropriate grounds. Whilst I accept that the respondent has significant barriers to rehabilitation as outlined in Mr Balfour’s report he has failed to recognise, and take advantage of, support that has been offered to him. It is challenging to determine how much of his non-compliance with the ESOs is the result of his disabilities and how much is due to a lack of motivation. On the other hand, the applicant asks the Court to impose an ESO which will see the respondent in custody for almost 12 months. The stated purpose is to enable the respondent to participate in the DFVIP, however there is no guarantee that he will in fact be able to do this. Whilst he has a guaranteed position in the DFVIP I cannot be assured that he will be permitted to transfer to Mobilong for the purpose of attending that program. This is unacceptable in circumstances where completion of that program is the main reason for the application. .