SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Criminal: Application)
ATTORNEY-GENERAL (SA) v RIGNEY-BROWN
[2023] SASC 73
Judgment of the Honourable Justice McIntyre
11 May 2023
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS - SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDER
CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - POST-CUSTODIAL ORDERS - OTHER TYPES OF POST-CUSTODIAL ORDERS
On 31 October 2022, this Court made an extended supervision order with respect to the respondent pursuant to s 7(4) of the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA) (the Act).
On 21 February 2023, the Parole Board satisfied itself that the respondent had breached three conditions of his extended supervision order on 10 November 2022. Pursuant to s 17(1)(b)(ii) of the Act, the Parole Board directed that the respondent be detained in custody pending attendance before the Court for determination as to whether a continuing detention order should be made under s 18(2) of the Act.
Held:
1. The referral for a continuing detention order be dismissed.
Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA) ss 7, 15, 17, 18, referred to.
Police v Sullivan; Attorney-General (SA) v Sullivan [2018] SASC 11, considered.
ATTORNEY-GENERAL (SA) v RIGNEY-BROWN
[2023] SASC 73Criminal: Application
McINTYRE J:
The respondent, David George Rigney-Brown, comes before the Court on a referral from the Parole Board under s 17(1)(b)(ii) of the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act2015 (SA) (the HRO Act). The question for determination by the Court is whether the respondent should be subject to a Continuing Detention Order (CDO) pursuant to s 18(2) of the HRO Act.
Background
On 10 August 2020, the respondent was determined to be a high risk offender and was placed on an Extended Supervision Order (ESO) under s 7(4) of the HRO Act for a period of two years. On 31 October 2022, the Court made a second ESO for a further period of two years. The second ESO is due to expire on 30 October 2024.
The ESOs were made on the basis that the respondent is a serious violent offender as a result of convictions for aggravated commit theft using force, aggravated attempted commit theft using force, assault, and aggravated assault.
The respondent breached the terms of the first ESO on a number of occasions resulting in him being remanded in custody on multiple occasions. The breaches found proven by the Parole Board are set out in attachment one of the written submissions of the applicant. He was convicted of eight criminal offences during the same period, none of which involved violence. These are set out in attachment two of the applicant’s written submissions. The respondent was referred to the Supreme Court on two occasions for consideration of a CDO during the term of the first ESO. On each occasion, the Court declined to make a CDO. On the second occasion this was due to the imminent expiry of the first ESO.
By report dated 1 September 2022, Dr Raeside, consultant…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney-General (SA) v Rigney-Brown and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] SASC 73
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the evidence provided by the applicant, including affidavits and expert reports, to assess the respondent's risk of reoffending. The evidence suggested that the respondent's antisocial personality disorder and other risk factors had not been mitigated by his time in custody. However, the court also considered the potential for rehabilitation in the community, particularly with the support of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The court found that while the respondent did pose a risk to the community, the conditions of the ESOs had effectively managed that risk so far. The breaches of the ESOs, while serious, did not involve violence against the community and were promptly addressed. The court concluded that the respondent's acceptance onto the NDIS and the potential for culturally appropriate assistance offered some hope for his rehabilitation in the community.
Ultimately, the court decided that the respondent did not need to be detained under a CDO to manage his risk to the community. The stringent conditions of the ESOs, along with the prospect of ongoing support and supervision, were deemed sufficient to protect the community. The court emphasised that the respondent would remain subject to these conditions and that any further breaches would likely result in another referral to the court. The decision reflects a balanced approach, recognising the respondent's history of offending while also considering the potential for rehabilitation and the effectiveness of community supervision.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
It is submitted that whilst the respondent committed other offences during the first ESO, he has not committed any violent offence since he was sentenced in 2016. The convictions set out in the attachment to the applicant’s written submissions are minor matters not involving violence. Accordingly, it is said that there is no evidence over the last six years of his life to bear out the assertion that he poses a continuing risk of violence to the community. It is contended that the evidence demonstrates that there are greater opportunities for rehabilitation in the community and that, unlike on previous occasions, the respondent will now have the assistance of an NDIS provider in relation to the various challenges he faces as identified by Mr Balfour. Finally, it was contended that the conditions of the ESO provide protection to the community in the sense that any breach of those conditions will see the respondent again arrested on a Parole Board warrant. Consideration The respondent’s risk of violent offending was assessed as “high” at the time the first ESO was made. Due to his continual breaches of that ESO, nothing had occurred to reduce that risk by the time of the second ESO. I am therefore satisfied that the respondent presents an appreciable risk to the community based upon his history, the reports of Dr Raeside and Mr Balfour, and the material from the Parole Board and DCS. However, I am not satisfied that detention is required to address that risk. The breaches that led to this application do not suggest any deterioration in his behaviour since the making of the second ESO. The breaches, whilst undoubtedly serious, did not involve offending against members of the community and were moreover dealt with promptly by the Parole Board and the Police. The respondent has not been convicted of any further violent offending since 2016. The matters for which he has been convicted since then could generally be described as property offences. He has not been convicted of any offences following the second ESO. The conditions of the first and second ESO have therefore been effective in protecting the community. I accept the applicant’s submission that the respondent’s compliance with the first and second ESO was very poor. He has shown no commitment to rehabilitation in the community and he has been resistant to supervision. However, Mr Balfour’s report provides some explanation for this. The evidence before me suggests cause for optimism that the respondent will respond more appropriately if released. Some of the barriers to rehabilitation and compliance with the conditions of the ESO identified by Mr Balfour will be ameliorated by the respondent’s acceptance onto the NDIS. This is likely to be enhanced if he is able to receive the culturally appropriate assistance outlined in Ms Liddy’s affidavit. The respondent will remain subject to the stringent conditions of the ESO. If the respondent continues to breach his conditions or fails to cooperate with rehabilitation, it is likely that he will find himself the subject of a further referral by the Parole Board. Having been in custody since 16 November 2022 for the current breaches, the respondent is well aware of the consequences of non-compliance.