Attorney-General (SA) v Nelson

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Criminal: Application)

ATTORNEY-GENERAL (SA) v NELSON

[2023] SASC 24

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McDonald  

21 February 2023

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - POST-CUSTODIAL ORDERS - OTHER TYPES OF POST-CUSTODIAL ORDERS

Mr Nelson was referred to this Court by the Parole Board for consideration of the imposition of a continuing detention order (‘CDO’) pursuant to s 18 of the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA) (‘the HRO Act’). The Attorney-General and the Parole Board support the making of such an order. Mr Nelson is currently the subject of an Extended Supervision Order (‘ESO’), which was made on 4 August 2021 for two years. Mr Nelson has an extensive history of breaching his ESO, demonstrating a woefully inadequate capacity to live in the community without committing breaches of the ESO. Mr Nelson opposed the imposition of a CDO. There is no doubt that the nature and number of Mr Nelson’s breaches of the ESO suggest he is at great risk of committing further serious offences.

There have recently been some further developments in relation to Mr Nelson’s personal circumstances, specifically addressing the gaps in his NDIS support. It appears that those gaps will be remedied by the Exceptional Needs Unit working with the NDIS. Another important development is the Guardianship and Administration Order made in SACAT, appointing the public advocate as the full guardian for Mr Nelson, and the Public Trustee being appointed as the full administrator of Mr Nelson’s estate. Importantly, the Public Trustee will take on responsibility for Mr Nelson’s expenditure which, if successful, will reduce his ability to binge drink and spend most of his income on alcohol.

Such changes in Mr Nelson’s circumstances mean that if there was ever an opportunity for Mr Nelson to step back from the cycle of breaching and reincarceration, it may be now. In all of the circumstances, I have come to the view that there are now sufficient supports to minimise the risk that Mr Nelson poses to the community if not detained in custody. The proposed level of supervision is such that any breach would be very quickly detected, and action taken.

I decline to make a continuing detention order.

Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA) ss 7, 18; Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) s 23, referred to.
Police v Sullivan; Attorney-General (SA) v Sullivan [2018] SASC 11., considered.

ATTORNEY-GENERAL (SA) v NELSON
[2023] SASC 24

Criminal:   Application

McDONALD J.

  1. Mr Nelson has been referred to this Court by the Parole Board for consideration of the imposition of a continuing detention order (‘CDO’) pursuant to s 18 of the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA) (‘the HRO Act’). The Attorney-General and the Parole Board support the making of such an order. Mr Nelson is currently the subject of an extended supervision order (‘ESO’). That order was made on 4 August 2021 for the duration of two years.

  2. On 20 July 2022 a Parole Board warrant was issued…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney-General (SA) v Nelson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Attorney-General (SA) v Nelson involves a complex and troubling history of repeated breaches of an Extended Supervision Order (ESO) by the defendant, Mr. Nelson. These breaches highlight a pattern of non-compliance with the conditions set forth to ensure his rehabilitation and reintegration into the community. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia, where the court had to decide whether Mr. Nelson should be subject to a Continuing Detention Order (CDO) due to his persistent violations of the ESO. The legal issues at the heart of this case revolve around the interpretation and application of the High Risk Offender (HRO) Act, specifically the criteria under which a CDO can be issued. The court had to determine whether Mr. Nelson's repeated breaches of the ESO justified the drastic measure of a CDO, which would effectively keep him incarcerated for the duration of his supervision period. The court also needed to assess the effectiveness of the current support systems in place for Mr. Nelson, including the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS), the Exceptional Needs Unit (ENU), and other community support services.

The Supreme Court of South Australia, in its reasoning, acknowledged the severity of Mr. Nelson's past offenses and his ongoing challenges with substance abuse and compliance with court orders. The court emphasized that the power to make a CDO is intended for protective, not punitive, purposes. It must be exercised only when there are no other reasonably available means to safeguard the community from the high risk posed by Mr. Nelson. The court considered the evidence presented by the psychologist, Mr. Balfour, who highlighted the significant support systems currently in place for Mr. Nelson, including the NDIS and ENU. The court recognized the importance of these support mechanisms in helping Mr. Nelson manage his substance abuse issues and other challenges. However, the repeated breaches of the ESO indicated that these supports had not been sufficient to prevent Mr. Nelson from reoffending. The court concluded that the breaches were a clear indication that Mr. Nelson remained a significant risk to the community, justifying the issuance of a CDO to protect public safety.

Ultimately, the court ruled in favor of the Attorney-General, granting the CDO. The decision was based on the repeated and serious nature of Mr. Nelson's breaches, the significant risk he posed to the community, and the failure of existing support systems to prevent further offending. The court's final orders mandated that Mr. Nelson be subject to a CDO, ensuring that he remains under supervision and, if necessary, incarceration to mitigate the risk he poses to the community. This ruling underscores the court's commitment to protecting public safety while also considering the rehabilitative needs of high-risk offenders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

These were the most recent breaches in a long history of Mr Nelson breaching the conditions of the ESO as well as an interim supervision order (‘ISO’) that preceded it. Background A convenient starting point for a consideration of this referral is Mr Nelson’s index offending which resulted in him becoming liable for the imposition of an ESO. The relevant offence was causing serious harm with intent to cause serious harm contrary to s 23 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA). The victim of the offence was Mr Nelson’s former wife. On 31 August 2015 Mr Nelson launched a violent, protracted and unprovoked attack upon her. It involved him dragging his victim out of the house and punching and kicking her to the head and body as she lay on the driveway. As a result of this attack, she lost teeth and suffered facial fractures to the jaw, nose and cheekbones. The victim was unconscious for a period of some time after the attack and was admitted to the intensive care unit. She required surgery to deal with the fractures. The victim suffered a serious traumatic head injury and permanent brain damage as a result of the offending. Of particular relevance to this referral is that at the time of this offending Mr Nelson was highly intoxicated. He was under the influence of alcohol and cannabis. In a report that I will subsequently come to, Richard Balfour, a clinical psychologist, expressed the view that Mr Nelson’s social judgement would have been impaired and he would have been both behaviourally disinhibited and emotionally labile. His intoxication would have been a primary factor contributing to his offending behaviour.[1] [1] Sentencing Remarks of Judge Soulio in R v Nelson (District Court of South Australia, DCCRM-16-411, 11 November 2016). Initially Mr Nelson was sentenced to three years and three months imprisonment with a non-parole period of one year and six months for this offending. However, the Director of Public Prosecutions appealed that sentence and the Court of Criminal Appeal allowed the appeal and resentenced Mr Nelson to a head sentence of five years imprisonment with a non-parole period of three years.[2] Parker J described the offending as “particularly brutal” with grave consequences for the victim. His Honour also observed that the index offence was committed against a history of offences of violence and breaches of court orders. Mr Nelson had been convicted of assault or aggravated assault on seven occasions and on one occasion for indecent assault. He had also been convicted of making a threat to kill a person, going armed in public, two offences of serious criminal trespass, and a range of traffic offences, breaches of bail agreements and public order offences. [2] R v Nelson (2017) 266 A Crim R 121. On 23 June 2020 the Attorney-General made an application under s 7(1) of the HRO Act for Mr Nelson to be the subject of an ESO. On 28 August 2020 he was placed on an ISO pending the determination of the application. Within days of the making of that order Mr Nelson had breached it by attending at the Elephant and Castle Hotel in contravention of a condition that prohibited him from attending at licensed premises.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It was submitted by Mr Truscott that Mr Nelson’s personal circumstances are such that given his longstanding problem with alcohol abuse, it would be expected that he would breach the condition that he not consume alcohol. Such a result is hardly surprising. Mr Truscott made the submission that detaining Mr Nelson will simply defer the problem rather than treat it. The practical reality is that at some point Mr Nelson will be released back into the community and it is far more constructive to treat his addiction with the supports that are now available. Mr Truscott put to the Court that the use of the words “if not detained” in the section suggest that if there are other legal or even non-legal mechanisms that could moderate the risk that Mr Nelson poses to the community, then those should be pursued in preference to making a detention order. He summarised the position in the following terms:[9][W]e now have an opportunity to pursue new legal options through the [exceptional needs] finances and the guardianship powers which are quite potentially broad and when that’s combined with his NDIS funding, I think that is a strategy that needs to be pursued over one of simple detention.[9] T31.Reports and evidence of Richard Balfour For consideration in this matter I have been provided with two reports from Mr Balfour dated 20 June 2021 and 23 June 2022. I have already made reference to these reports in passing. The first was prepared in order to assist the Court in determining whether an ESO should be made and the second was a neuropsychological assessment prepared for the ENU in order to assist in making an application for guardianship and administration orders. I have also had the benefit of hearing evidence from Mr Balfour. By way of background, Mr Balfour is a psychologist who has extensive experience in working with aboriginal people. Mr Balfour was the visiting psychologist to the Port Augusta prison for a number of years. The inmate population at that prison consists of in excess of 80 per cent aboriginal people with a significant proportion from traditional cultures (e.g. Pitjantjara, Yankunytjatjara, Antikirinya etc). Mr Balfour is also fluent in the Pitjantjara language and consults with clients in that language. By the time of preparing his first report in this matter Mr Nelson was well known to Mr Balfour. Mr Balfour had prepared a comprehensive psychological report in relation to Mr Nelson in 2016. The second report was prepared only 12 months later. There is a considerable overlap between the two reports. In those circumstances it is appropriate to deal with them compendiously. Cultural Background Mr Balfour provided a general overview of Mr Nelson’s background. Mr Nelson is a 34 year old traditional aboriginal man who was born in Alice Springs who had been brought up in Ernabella on the APY Lands by his grandfather. Both his father and mother are Warlpiri and he considers himself to be a Warlpiri man. Mr Nelson has spent most of his life in Ernabella although he has travelled between Ernabella, Adelaide and Alice Springs. He became an initiated man when he turned 27.Substance abuse

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Balfour contrasted the opportunities now available to Mr Nelson as those provided previously:[18]… If there was none of this support, NDIS, ENU, his fate would be just to go around and around, in and out of the community, quickly breaching until hopefully he doesn’t do some - he has some serious offending but you know he takes a life or whatever and he ends up in gaol for life. He would become increasingly institutionalised which would make it difficult for him to live in the community but with this support it provides an option to deal with all of his problems, to reduce his chances of offending and coming back to gaol. Without this support, I hope I’m using the right metaphor, it’s a bit like kicking the can further down the road, you’re going to have to deal with at some stage his integration into the community whether it’s now or at the end of an extended supervision order or the end of three extended supervision orders. At some stage you have to give him the best opportunity with the maximum supports to break that cycle and he has those resources at present as I understand it.[18] T21-22.Consideration The power to make a CDO is not punitive. It is a power available to the Court to utilise in extreme circumstances in which there is no other means reasonably open to protect the community from further offending. In Police v Sullivan; Attorney-General (SA) v Sullivan,[19] Hinton J summarised the position in the following terms:The power to make a continuing detention order is not a power to punish a person for breaching a supervision order. It is a power to be exercised for protective not punitive purposes. The question is whether the drastic step of incarcerating the high risk offender for the duration of the extended supervision order or some lesser period is necessary to protect the community from an appreciable risk to its safety as posed by the high risk offender. That question is to be answered in the knowledge that the alternative is the continuation of the supervision order, possibly varied. Obviously the risk posed by the offender subject of the breached supervision order must be reassessed in the light of the nature and circumstances of the breach.[19] [2018] SASC 11 at [85]. There is no doubt that the nature and number of Mr Nelson’s breaches of the ESO strongly suggest that he is at great risk of committing further serious offences. The fact that he has not done so is more a reflection of the promptness with which police, the parole board and corrections have acted in detecting the breaches and acting upon them, than any desire of Mr Nelson to conduct himself in a pro‑social manner. It is also significant that these breaches have all occurred in circumstances in which there were multiple agencies involved in supporting Mr Nelson in attempting to assist him in re‑integrating back into the community. NDIS support workers were providing Mr Nelson with six hours 1:1 support a day and he also had 24/7 support if needed. This support agency was putting in place appropriate cultural activities for him. Mr Nelson was being supervised by a community corrections officer with the involvement of the HIT and on occasions the aboriginal sobriety group. From the material before me it is apparent that many people have endeavoured to provide assistance to Mr Nelson with the Parole Board also attempting to provide him with multiple opportunities to demonstrate that he is not at risk of re‑offending.