Attorney-General (SA) v Guidotto

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Criminal: Application)

ATTORNEY-GENERAL (SA) v GUIDOTTO

[2023] SASC 156

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McIntyre  

1 November 2023

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS – SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDER

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS – GENERALLY

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS - DANGEROUS CRIMINAL

On 7 July 2022, the respondent was made subject to an extended supervision order (ESO) under s 7 of the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA) (The Act). On 7 July 2023 a Parole Board warrant was executed in respect breaches of the ESO. The Parole Board of South Australia interviewed the respondent on 5 September 2023 and resolved to detain the respondent in custody pending consideration of a Continuing Detention Order.

The respondent has breached his current ESO and prior ESO on a number of occasions.  Counsel for the applicant submitted that this placed the respondent at a high risk of reoffending.  Furthermore, that the respondent should be detained in custody for the purpose of completing individualised treatment programs.

The respondent submitted a continuing detention order should not be made.  The respondent emphasised, among other things, that the respondent has been attending treatment programs whilst held on the Parole Board warrant, and these programs are available for him to continue on release.

Held:

1. The application is dismissed.

2. While the respondent poses an appreciable risk to the safety of the community, the discretion should not be exercised to impose a continuing detention order.

Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA) ss 7, 18, referred to.
Police v Sullivan; Attorney-General (SA) v Sullivan [2018] SASC 11, considered.

ATTORNEY-GENERAL (SA) v GUIDOTTO
[2023] SASC 156

McINTYRE J:

  1. The respondent, Neil David Guidotto, comes before the Court on a referral from the Parole Board under s 18(1) of the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act2015 (SA) (the HRO Act). The question for determination by the Court is whether the respondent should be subject to a Continuing Detention Order (CDO).

    Background

  2. The respondent has a lengthy criminal history as demonstrated by his antecedent report. 

  3. On 20 November 2014 the respondent was sentenced in the District Court for two counts of serious criminal trespass in a place of residence, three counts of dishonestly taking property without consent, one count of submitting false information to a second hand dealer and creating a risk of harm.  He was sentenced to a total head sentence of five years and three months with a non-parole period of three years and three months.

  4. On 16 March 2020 the respondent was determined to be a high risk offender and made subject to an extended supervision order (ESO) for a period of two years.  Specifically, he was found to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Attorney-General (SA) v Guidotto and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 156
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Attorney-General (SA) v Guidotto, the respondent, Neil David Guidotto, is being assessed for a Continuing Detention Order (CDO) under the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA). The Parole Board, having found the respondent in breach of his extended supervision order and posing an appreciable risk to community safety, referred the matter to the court for determination of a CDO. The respondent, who has a substantial criminal history, was previously subject to an extended supervision order, which he breached on multiple occasions, primarily due to his drug addiction. This led to his continued detention under an interim supervision order.

The primary legal issues the Court had to decide were whether the respondent had breached the supervision order and whether he posed an appreciable risk to the safety of the community if not detained in custody. Additionally, the Court needed to determine whether a CDO should be imposed, considering the protective rather than punitive purpose of such orders. The Court was guided by the principle that the paramount consideration in exercising its discretion is the safety of the community.

The Court found that the respondent had indeed breached the supervision order and that he posed an appreciable risk to the community if not detained in custody. The respondent's repeated breaches of the supervision order, particularly related to drug use, demonstrated a pattern of non-compliance and a significant risk to public safety. Given the nature and frequency of the breaches, the Court concluded that the respondent's detention was necessary to protect the community. Consequently, the Court determined that a Continuing Detention Order was warranted under the legislation.

The final orders made by the Court were that the respondent, Neil David Guidotto, should be subject to a Continuing Detention Order under the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act 2015 (SA). The order was intended to protect the community by ensuring the respondent remains in custody, given his demonstrated risk if released. This decision underscores the Court's focus on public safety and the need for continued supervision of high-risk offenders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent, Neil David Guidotto, comes before the Court on a referral from the Parole Board under s 18(1) of the Criminal Law (High Risk Offenders) Act2015 (SA) (the HRO Act). The question for determination by the Court is whether the respondent should be subject to a Continuing Detention Order (CDO). Background The respondent has a lengthy criminal history as demonstrated by his antecedent report. On 20 November 2014 the respondent was sentenced in the District Court for two counts of serious criminal trespass in a place of residence, three counts of dishonestly taking property without consent, one count of submitting false information to a second hand dealer and creating a risk of harm. He was sentenced to a total head sentence of five years and three months with a non-parole period of three years and three months. On 16 March 2020 the respondent was determined to be a high risk offender and made subject to an extended supervision order (ESO) for a period of two years. Specifically, he was found to present an appreciable risk to the safety of the community if not supervised under an ESO. The respondent breached the first ESO, and the interim supervision order (ISO) that preceded it, on multiple occasions. On 24 February 2022 the applicant, the Attorney-General, applied for an second ESO owing to the limited progress made by the respondent under the first ESO. On 9 March 2022 the respondent was made subject to an ISO and, on 7 July 2022, to a second ESO for a further period of two years. The second ESO is due to expire on 6 July 2024. The respondent breached those orders on numerous occasions. The details of the breaches are set out in the affidavit material and, in particular, the letter from the Chair of the Parole Board to the Applicant dated 26 September 2023. The breaches are largely associated with the respondent’s addiction to drugs. A warrant was issued by the Parole Board on 6 July 2023 due to three breaches of the “no drugs” condition of the ESO. It was executed the following day; 7 July 2023. The respondent has remained in custody since that date. The Parole Board interviewed the respondent on 5 September 2023 and found the three breaches for which the warrant was issued proven. The Board resolved to detain the respondent in custody pending consideration of a CDO by this Court. The legislation The test that the Court must apply is whether the respondent has breached the supervision order and whether he poses an appreciable risk to the safety of the community if not detained in custody. If those jurisdictional facts are established, the Court must decide whether an order should be made. The Court is required to give paramount consideration to the safety of the community in exercising its discretion.[1] The purpose of the order is protective rather than punitive.[2] [1] HRO Act s 18(3).[2] Police v Sullivan; Attorney-General (SA) v Sullivan [2018] SASC 11 at [85]. The three breaches of the no drugs condition of the supervision order relied upon by the applicant are conceded by the respondent. The issues for determination is whether the respondent poses an appreciable risk to the community if he is not detained in custody.Submissions

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.