Pilbara Infrastructure Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Pilbara Infrastructure Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal [2011] FCAFC 58

Citation: Pilbara Infrastructure Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal [2011] FCAFC 58
Appeal from: In the matter of Fortescue Metals Group Limited [2010] ACompT 2
Parties:

THE PILBARA INFRASTRUCTURE PTY LTD (ACN 103 096 340) and FORTESCUE METALS GROUP LIMITED (ACN 002 594 872) v AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL,  HAMERSLEY IRON PTY LTD (ACN 004 558 276), HAMERSLEY IRON-YANDI PTY LTD (ACN 009 181 793),  ROBE RIVER MINING CO PTY LTD (ACN 008 694 246), NORTH MINING LTD (ACN 000 081 434), PILBARA IRON PTY LTD (ACN 107 216 535), RIO TINTO LIMITED (ACN 004 458 404), MITSUI IRON ORE DEVELOPMENT PTY LTD (ACN 008 734 361), NIPPON STEEL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 001 445 049) and SUMITOMO METAL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 001 444 604)

ROBE RIVER MINING CO PTY LTD (ACN 008 694 246), NORTH MINING LTD (ACN 000 081 434), PILBARA IRON PTY LTD (ACN 107 216 535), RIO TINTO LIMITED (ACN 004 458 404), MITSUI IRON ORE DEVELOPMENT PTY LTD (ACN 008 734 361), NIPPON STEEL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 001 445 049) and SUMITOMO METAL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 001 444 604) v AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL, FORTESCUE METALS GROUP LIMITED (ACN 002 595 872) and THE PILBARA INFRASTRUCTURE PTY LTD (ACN 103 096 340)

THE PILBARA INFRASTRUCTURE PTY LTD (ACN 103 096 340) and FORTESCUE METALS GROUP LIMITED (ACN 002 594 872) v AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL,  ROBE RIVER MINING CO PTY LTD (ACN 008 694 246), NORTH MINING LTD (ACN 000 081 434), PILBARA IRON PTY LTD (ACN 107 216 535), RIO TINTO LIMITED (ACN 004 458 404), MITSUI IRON ORE DEVELOPMENT PTY LTD (ACN 008 734 361), NIPPON STEEL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 001 445 049) and SUMITOMO METAL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 001 444 604)

File number(s): VID 616 of 2010
VID 686 of 2010
VID 687 of 2010
Judges: KEANE CJ, MANSFIELD AND MIDDLETON JJ
Date of judgment: 4 May 2011
Catchwords:

TRADE PRACTICES – Access to Services – Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – Part IIIA – s 44H(4) – Part IIIA to be read having regard to the background to the introduction of Part IIIA into the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).

COMPETITION – Australian Competition Tribunal – appeal from decision – role of Tribunal – Tribunal comprises judge and two experts – function to resolve difficult and complex matters of judgment – Court’s role to ensure decision accords with the law – Court’s role not to reconsider merits of the case

EVIDENCE – role of expert evidence – meaning of legislation cannot change according to the evidence of an economic expert

Words & Phrases: “uneconomical for anyone”
Legislation: Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Competition Policy Reform Act 1995 (Cth)
Trade Practices Act1974 (Cth)
Trade Practices Amendment (National Access Regime) Act 2006 (Cth)
Cases cited:

Alcan NT Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pilbara Infrastructure Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Trib... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCAFC 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pilbara Infrastructure Pty Ltd and Fortescue Metals Group Limited appealed against a decision of the Australian Competition Tribunal, which rejected their applications for access to the Hamersley and Robe iron ore rail lines. Rio Tinto Iron Ore Pty Ltd appealed against the Tribunal's decision to dismiss its application for the imposition of access undertakings. The primary legal issues involved the interpretation of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), specifically section 44H(4) and the criteria that must be met for the declaration of a service under Part IIIA. The court was required to determine whether the Tribunal had correctly interpreted the statutory criteria and if the decision was in accordance with the law.

The court held that the Tribunal's interpretation of the statutory criteria was correct and its decision was in accordance with the law. The court emphasised that the meaning of the legislation could not be altered by expert evidence and that the Tribunal's role was to resolve complex matters of judgment. The court also noted that its role was to ensure the decision accorded with the law, not to reconsider the merits of the case. The court found that Fortescue's applications for access failed at the threshold of criterion (b), which required that it would be uneconomical for anyone to develop another facility to provide the service. The court held that Fortescue's complaints about procedural fairness did not affect the Tribunal's findings of fact in relation to criterion (b).

The court dismissed Fortescue's appeals and allowed Rio Tinto's appeal. The decision of the Tribunal in relation to the Robe line was set aside, and the court ordered that the parties confer and file minutes of orders, including as to costs, by a specified date. In the event of disagreement, the parties were to file and serve written submissions as to the contentions of the parties. The court held that Fortescue should pay Rio Tinto's costs of each of the three appeals, unless the parties agreed otherwise.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties confer and thereafter by 4.00 pm on 11 May 2011 file minutes of orders (including as to costs), and in the event of disagreement, file and serve written submissions as to the contentions of the parties.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

That having been said, there is no suggestion that the March 2010 material affected, in any way, the Tribunal’s conclusion that if the test of economic feasibility were applied in criterion (b), Fortescue’s applications in relation to the Hamersley service and the Robe service would not pass that test. Because Fortescue’s applications for access were bound to fail for that reason, Fortescue was not prejudiced by the late reception of the March 2010 presentation and the Tribunal’s decision must be upheld.CONCLUSION So far as the Hamersley application is concerned, even if the conclusions of the Tribunal in relation to criterion (f) adverse to Fortescue were erroneous or were affected by a want of procedural fairness, Fortescue’s application for access cannot be sustained unless it passes through the criterion (b) threshold. And so far as the Robe application is concerned, even with the benefit of the Tribunal’s conclusion on criterion (f), Fortescue’s application cannot succeed unless it too passes criterion (b). On the correct interpretation of criterion (b), based on the findings of fact by the Tribunal which are unchallenged, both Fortescue’s applications must fail at that threshold. Fortescue’s complaints in relation to procedural fairness do not bear at all upon the Tribunal’s findings of fact in relation to criterion (b).PROPOSED ORDERS Accordingly, we would dismiss Fortescue’s appeals. We would allow Rio Tinto’s appeal. The decision of the Tribunal in relation to the Robe line should be set aside with consequential orders. In normal circumstances, Fortescue should pay Rio Tinto’s costs of each of the three appeals. We would ask the parties to confer and thereafter by 4.00 pm on 11 May 2011 file minutes of orders (including as to costs), and in the event of disagreement, file and serve written submissions as to the contentions of the parties.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The first stage of the access regime is initiated by an application to the NCC under s 44F of the Act requesting that a particular service be declared. The NCC must recommend to the designated Minister that the service be declared or not be declared. The NCC must observe the limitations stated in s 44G of the Act. It provides:44G Limits on the Council recommending declaration of a service (1)The Council cannot recommend declaration of a service that is the subject of an access undertaking in operation under Division 6.(1A)While a decision of the Commission is in force under subsection 44PA(3) approving a tender process, for the construction and operation of a facility, as a competitive tender process, the Council cannot recommend declaration of any service provided by means of the facility that was specified under paragraph 44PA(2)(a).(2)The Council cannot recommend that a service be declared unless it is satisfied of all of the following matters:(a) that access (or increased access) to the service would promote a material increase in competition in at least one market (whether or not in Australia), other than the market for the service;(b)that it would be uneconomical for anyone to develop another facility to provide the service;(c) that the facility is of national significance, having regard to:(i)the size of the facility; or(ii)the importance of the facility to constitutional trade or commerce; or(iii) the importance of the facility to the national economy;(d)that access to the service can be provided without undue risk to human health or safety;(e)that access to the service is not already the subject of an effective access regime;(f)that access (or increased access) to the service would not be contrary to the public interest.…(6)The Council cannot recommend declaration of a service provided by means of a pipeline (within the meaning of a National Gas Law) if:(a)a 15‑year no‑coverage determination is in force under the National Gas Law in respect of the pipeline; or(b)a price regulation exemption is in force under the National Gas Law in respect of the pipeline. The Minister may not declare the service unless satisfied of the criteria in s 44H(4) and, in particular, having considered whether it would be economical for anyone to develop another facility that could provide part of the service. Section 44H provides relevantly: 44H Designated Minister may declare a service (1) On receiving a declaration recommendation, the designated Minister must either declare the service or decide not to declare it.Note:The designated Minister must publish his or her decision: see section 44HA.(1A)The designated Minister must have regard to the objects of this Part in making his or her decision.(2)In deciding whether to declare the service or not, the designated Minister must consider whether it would be economical for anyone to develop another facility that could provide part of the service. This subsection does not limit the grounds on which the designated Minister may make a decision whether to declare the service or not.(3)The designated Minister cannot declare a service that is the subject of an access undertaking in operation under Division 6.…(4)The designated Minister cannot declare a service unless he or she is satisfied of all of the following matters:(a)that access (or increased access) to the service would promote a material increase in competition in at least one market (whether or not in Australia), other than the market for the service;(b)that it would be uneconomical for anyone to develop another facility to provide the service;(c) that the facility is of national significance, having regard to:(i) the size of the facility; or(ii)the importance of the facility to constitutional trade or commerce; or(iii) the importance of the facility to the national economy;(d)that access to the service can be provided without undue risk to human health or safety;(e)that access to the service is not already the subject of an effective access regime;(f)that access (or increased access) to the service would not be contrary to the public interest.…(5)In deciding whether an access regime established by a State or Territory that is a party to the Competition Principles Agreement is an effective access regime, the designated Minister:(a)must, subject to subsection (6A), apply the relevant principles set out in that agreement; and(aa) must have regard to the objects of this Part; and(b) must, subject to section 44DA, not consider any other matters.(6)If there is in force a decision of the Commonwealth Minister under section 44N that a regime established by a State or Territory for access to the service is an effective access regime, the designated Minister must follow that decision, unless the designated Minister believes that, since the Commonwealth Minister’s decision was published, there have been substantial modifications of the access regime or of the relevant principles set out in the Competition Principles Agreement.Note:The period for which a decision is in force is determined under subsection 44N(3) and paragraph 44P(a).(6A)In deciding whether a regime is an effective access regime, the designated Minister must disregard Chapter 5 of a National Gas Law.(6B)The designated Minister cannot declare a service provided by means of a pipeline (within the meaning of a National Gas Law) if:(a)a 15‑year no‑coverage determination is in force under the National Gas Law in respect of the pipeline; or(b)a price regulation exemption is in force under the National Gas Law in respect of the pipeline.(8)If the designated Minister declares the service, the declaration must specify the expiry date of the declaration.(9)If the designated Minister does not publish under section 44HA his or her decision on the declaration recommendation within 60 days after receiving the declaration recommendation, the designated Minister is taken, at the end of that 60 day period, to have decided not to declare the service and to have published that decision not to declare the service.[Emphasis added].