Boral Besser Masonry Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ,
GAUDRON, McHUGH, GUMMOW, KIRBY, HAYNE AND CALLINAN JJ

BORAL BESSER MASONRY LIMITED
(now Boral Masonry Ltd)   APPELLANT

AND

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND
CONSUMER COMMISSION   RESPONDENT

Boral Besser Masonry Limited (now Boral Masonry Ltd) v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

[2003] HCA 5

7 February 2003
M1/2002

ORDER

1.   Appeal allowed with costs.

2.   Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court dated 27 February 2001, and in place thereof order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation:

A C Archibald QC with C M Maxwell QC and I B Stewart for the appellant (instructed by Blake Dawson Waldron)

N J Young QC with D Shavin QC, M J Crennan SC and P M Tate for the respondent (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GLEESON CJ AND CALLINAN J. This appeal concerns the application of s 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ("the Act") to the conduct of the appellant in relation to the supply of concrete masonry products ("CMP") in Melbourne between April 1994 and October 1996. The central issues are whether the appellant had a substantial degree of power in a market, and whether it took advantage of that power in contravention of s 46.

  2. Section 46 provides, so far as is relevant:

    "(1)A corporation that has a substantial degree of power in a market shall not take advantage of that power for the purpose of:

    (a)eliminating or substantially damaging a competitor of the corporation or of a body corporate that is related to the corporation in that or any other market;

    (b)preventing the entry of a person into that or any other market; or

    (c)deterring or preventing a person from engaging in competitive conduct in that or any other market.

    …

    (3)In determining for the purposes of this section the degree of power that a body corporate or bodies corporate has or have in a market, the Court shall have regard to the extent to which the conduct of the body corporate or of any of those bodies corporate in that market is constrained by the conduct of:

    (a)competitors, or potential competitors, of the body corporate or of any of those bodies corporate in that market; or

    (b)persons to whom or from whom the body corporate or any of those bodies corporate supplies or acquires goods or services in that market.

    (4)In this section:

    (a)a reference to power is a reference to market power;

    (b)a reference to a market is a reference to a market for goods or services; and

    (c)a reference to power in relation to, or to conduct in, a market is a reference to power, or to conduct, in that market either as a supplier or as an acquirer of goods or services in that market."

  3. The provisions of ss 4E…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Boral Besser Masonry Ltd v Australian Competition and Consum... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] HCA 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal concerning alleged breaches of section 46 of the *Trade Practices Act 1974* (Cth) by Boral Besser Masonry Limited (BBM). The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) alleged that BBM had misused its substantial degree of market power in the concrete masonry products market. The primary judge had found that BBM engaged in anti-competitive conduct with proscribed purposes, and the Full Court of the Federal Court had upheld this finding, concluding that BBM had breached section 46.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether BBM possessed a substantial degree of market power in the concrete masonry products market and whether it took advantage of that power for a proscribed purpose, specifically to deter or prevent competition or eliminate a competitor. This involved an analysis of market definition, the substitutability of products, BBM's market share, barriers to entry, and its pricing behaviour, including whether it engaged in predatory pricing to recoup losses and consolidate its market power.

A majority of the High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Full Court. The majority's reasoning, though not fully detailed in the provided text, appears to have concluded that BBM did not possess the requisite degree of market power or did not take advantage of it in the manner proscribed by section 46. In contrast, the dissenting judgment argued that the evidence supported the findings of the Full Court, highlighting BBM's express purpose of deterring entry and eliminating competitors, its reduction of market players, and its consolidation of market power through short-term pricing sacrifices for long-term economic gain, which it considered precisely the type of conduct section 46 forbids.

The High Court allowed the appeal with costs and set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court, dismissing the ACCC's appeal to that Court with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court dated 27 February 2001, and in place thereof order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Boral Besser Masonry Ltd (BBM) was a major player in the Australian market for concrete masonry products. These products, such as bricks, pavers, and blocks, are used extensively in construction. BBM's business involved manufacturing and supplying these products to a variety of customers, including builders, architects, and the retail sector. The company held a significant market share, which afforded it substantial economic power within the industry.

The dispute arose from BBM's pricing strategies which other competitors and the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) argued were anti-competitive and predatory. Specifically, BBM was accused of engaging in predatory pricing practices, which involved setting prices below cost to drive competitors out of the market and subsequently raising prices. This conduct was alleged to have been undertaken with the purpose of deterring entry by potential competitors and eliminating existing ones. The ACCC argued that BBM's actions were in breach of Section 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), which prohibits corporations from engaging in anti-competitive conduct, including the misuse of market power.

The primary judge found that BBM had indeed engaged in the proscribed conduct, had the requisite substantial degree of market power, and acted with the purpose of damaging competitors. The Full Court of the Federal Court overturned this decision, concluding that BBM did not have the requisite degree of market power. This appeal to the High Court was brought to challenge the Full Court's decision, with the ACCC arguing that the appellate court had erred in its assessment of BBM's market power and its purpose in engaging in the alleged anti-competitive conduct.

Boral Besser Masonry Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission originated as an appeal from a decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia, which had set aside a judgment of the primary judge, Justice Merkel. The matter concerns allegations of anti-competitive conduct by Boral Besser Masonry Ltd (now Boral Masonry Ltd) in the concrete masonry products market. The proceedings were initiated by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) under section 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), which prohibits corporations from engaging in anti-competitive conduct, such as taking advantage of substantial market power for a proscribed purpose. The primary judge, Justice Merkel, found that Boral Besser Masonry Ltd had indeed engaged in such conduct, imposing penalties accordingly. Boral Besser Masonry Ltd appealed the primary judge's decision to the Full Court, which allowed the appeal and set aside the penalties imposed, concluding that Boral Besser Masonry Ltd did not possess the requisite degree of market power. The ACCC then appealed the Full Court's decision to the High Court, arguing that the Full Court erred in its interpretation of market power and its application to the facts of the case. The High Court's decision to allow the appeal and set aside the Full Court's orders indicates a review of the legal and economic principles applied in determining market power and the conduct of Boral Besser Masonry Ltd.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GLEESON CJ CALLINAN J
This was anti-competitive conduct. It was engaged in by a corporation. That corporation was clearly a big player in the particular market. It had a substantial degree of economic power in that market. It deliberately set out to act as it did. In doing so, it took advantage of its substantial power. As the primary judge found, at the time BBM had one or more of the purposes proscribed by s 46 of the Act. As the Full Court found, in acting as it did, BBM was in breach of s 46.Conclusion and orders When all the peripheral facts and sophisticated legal and economic analysis in this appeal are stripped away, what is the outcome that now follows from the approach of the majority of this Court? The conclusion unanimously reached by three appellate judges in the Full Court of the Federal Court is set aside. The impugned "big" player, as its own records disclosed and the primary judge found, had the express purpose of deterring entry and eliminating certain competitors from the market, in part as a response to their earlier price-undercutting that had endangered a relatively placid market. By inference, the corporation was concerned that more such uncongenial competition would otherwise ensue. Its conduct reduced the number of market players effectively to three. The corporation's purpose was fulfilled to that extent. With the number of rivals reduced and the appellant's market share correspondingly increased, its market power was further consolidated. Short-term pricing sacrifices were made for long-term economic rewards. Inevitably, these would come at a probable cost to consumers. This is precisely the type of market conduct that s 46 of the Act forbids. Despite that, the corporation is now absolved because, it is said, it did not possess, and take advantage of, the requisite degree of power in the relevant market. Respectfully, I regard that conclusion as contrary to the reasonable inferences arising from the evidence. No error on the part of the Full Court is shown. I therefore dissent. The appeal against the judgment of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia should be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GLEESON CJ, CALLINAN J

In Boral Besser Masonry Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, the court carefully examined whether Boral Besser Masonry Ltd (BBM) had a substantial degree of market power in the concrete masonry products market. The court found that BBM indeed held a significant position in the market, which was characterised by a relatively small number of large firms. This finding was based on BBM's substantial market share, its financial strength, and its ability to influence market prices. The court relied on economic principles and empirical data to assess market power, concluding that BBM's position allowed it to engage in practices that could affect competitors and consumer welfare.

The court also considered whether the market for concrete masonry products should include close substitutes. It determined that the market should be defined broadly to encompass products that could be used interchangeably by consumers. This expansive market definition was supported by evidence showing that consumers viewed certain products as viable alternatives. By defining the market in this manner, the court ensured that the analysis of market power and competitive practices was comprehensive and realistic.

In examining the barriers to entry in the concrete masonry products market, the court found that these barriers were largely created by the practices and policies of incumbent firms, including BBM. The court concluded that high capital requirements, economies of scale, and regulatory hurdles significantly impeded new entrants. BBM's actions, such as increasing supply capacity and setting prices below cost, were seen as strategic moves to fortify these barriers. This reinforced BBM's market dominance and discouraged potential competitors.

The court thoroughly investigated whether BBM engaged in predatory pricing with the purpose of deterring entry and eliminating competitors. It found that BBM had deliberately set prices below cost to drive out competitors, which aligned with the purpose proscribed by section 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). This conclusion was supported by BBM's documented intentions and the economic consequences of its pricing strategy. The court highlighted that BBM's actions were not merely competitive but were part of a broader plan to consolidate its market power.

In assessing whether BBM's conduct contravened the legislative purpose of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), the court underscored the importance of preventing anti-competitive practices that harm consumers. The court found that BBM's predatory pricing and efforts to eliminate competitors were precisely the types of conduct the Act was designed to prevent. By reducing competition and potentially raising prices in the long term, BBM's actions were deemed to contravene the Act's purpose of protecting consumer interests and maintaining competitive markets.

Finally, the court addressed whether the economic conditions of the market and BBM's purpose of damaging a competitor were relevant to the determination under section 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The court held that both factors were pertinent. The economic conditions illustrated the competitive landscape and the potential impact of BBM's actions on market dynamics. BBM's specific intent to harm competitors further evidenced its anti-competitive purpose. Together, these considerations supported the conclusion that BBM's conduct was in breach of the Act. The court's analysis provided a clear and binding legal principle for future cases: corporations with substantial market power must not engage in predatory practices aimed at eliminating competition, as such conduct undermines the Act's objectives.