Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Metcash Trading Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Metcash Trading Limited [2011] FCAFC 151

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Metcash Trading Limited [2011] FCAFC 151
Appeal from: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Metcash Trading Limited [2011] FCA 967
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v METCASH TRADING LIMITED ACN 000 031 569 and PICK N PAY RETAILERS (PTY) LTD
File number(s): NSD 1533 of 2011
Judges: FINN, BUCHANAN, YATES JJ
Date of judgment: 30 November 2011
Catchwords:

COMPETITION – merger – competition test – whether acquisition of shares in the capital of a body corporate would be likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition in a market – real chance test discussed

COMPETITION – counterfactual case – standard of proof – discussion of whether counterfactual case required to be established on balance of probabilities or on a real chance test – whether the primary judge erred in his evaluation of the counterfactual case as speculative

COMPETITION – market definition – hypothetical monopolist test – functional level – whether market properly defined as a wholesale market – whether market should be defined by reference to multiple functional levels

Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 50(1), 50(3)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140
Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd (2006) ATPR ¶42-123
Australian Gas Light Company v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2003) 137 FCR 317

Australian Telecommunications Commission v Krieg Enterprises Pty Ltd (1976) 27 FLR 400

Boral Besser Masonry Limited v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2003) 215 CLR 374

Bradshaw v McEwans Pty Ltd (1951) 217 ALR 1

Dandy Power Equipment Pty Ltd v Mercury Marine Pty Ltd (1982) 64 FLR 238
Global Sportsman Pty Ltd v Mirror Newspapers Pty Ltd (1984) 2 FCR 82

Howe v R (1980) 55 ALJR 5
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298
Lithgow City Council v Jackson (2011) 85 ALJR 1130; 281 ALR 223
Luxton v Vines (1952) 85 CLR 352
Momcilovic v R (2011) 85 ALJR 957; 280 ALR 221

Monroe Topple & Associates Pty Ltd v Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia (2002) 122 FCR 110
News Limited v Australian Rugby Football League Limited (1996) 64 FCR 410
Outboard Marine Australia Pty Ltd v Hecar Investments (No 6) Pty Ltd (1982) 66 FLR 120
Re Fortescue Metals Group Ltd (2010) 242 FLR 136
Re QIW Ltd (1995) 132 ALR 225
Re Queensland Co-operative Milling Association Ltd; Re Defiance Holdings Ltd (1976) 25 FLR 169
Seven Network Limited v News Limited [2007] FCA 1062
Seven Network Ltd v News Ltd (2009) 182 FCR 160

Sheen v Fields Pty Ltd (1984) 58 ALJR 93

Singapore Airlines Limited v Taprobane Tours WA Pty Ltd (1991) 33 FCR 158
Sydneywide Distributors Pty Ltd v Red Bull Australia Pty Ltd (2002) 55 IPR 354

Tillmanns Butcheries Pty Ltd v Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union (1978) 34 FLR 494

Tillmanns Butcheries Pty Ltd v Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Metcash Tra... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCAFC 151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (the Commission) appealed against a decision of the Federal Court of Australia, which dismissed the Commission’s application for injunctive relief concerning Metcash Trading Limited's (Metcash) acquisition of shares in Interfrank Group Holdings Pty Limited (Franklins). The Commission sought a declaration that Metcash's acquisition would likely substantially lessen competition in the Independent Wholesale Grocery Market, in breach of section 50(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (the Act). The central legal issues revolved around whether the primary judge correctly applied the competition test and the standard of proof required for establishing a counterfactual case. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the primary judge correctly defined the relevant market as a wholesale market and whether the market should be defined by reference to multiple functional levels.

The appeal court found that the primary judge did not err in rejecting the Commission's market definition and the counterfactual scenario. The court held that the primary judge's rejection of the market definition was entitled to deference, and the Commission had not demonstrated that the primary judge's findings were erroneous. Regarding the counterfactual case, the court determined that the primary judge did not err in applying the appropriate standard of proof, and even if the court had adopted the Commission's suggested approach, it would not have altered the outcome of the appeal. The primary judge had decisively rejected the Commission's scenario as speculative and unlikely, whether assessed on the balance of probabilities or a "real chance" test.

Consequently, the appeal was dismissed. The court also ordered that the appellant, the Commission, pay the respondents' costs. The final orders were to dismiss the appeal and for the appellant to pay the respondents’ costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant is to pay the respondents’ costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

On appeal, the Commission sought a declaration of contravention and stated that, if successful, it intended to commence divestiture proceedings. BACKGROUND In order to understand the Commission’s case and the primary judge’s rejection of it, it is necessary to have some appreciation of the chains of distribution of products that come to be supplied, in the defined territory, as grocery items to the consuming public. The primary judge was called upon to make an evaluative judgment about the product dimension of the market, taking into account the totality of the evidence before him. As I have said, his Honour’s finding was one to which he was entitled to come on that evidence. In my view the Commission has not demonstrated that the primary judge’s rejection of its market definition in this respect was an error, as opposed to simply a different conclusion on the evidence, on which reasonable minds could differ. The functional dimension of the market The Commission submitted that the primary judge erred in a number of respects when dealing with the functional dimension of the relevant market. These submissions reflected the substance of the Commission’s submissions at trial, which were to the following effect. The major supermarket chains operated as an uneven constraint on the pricing behaviour of independent retailers, many of whom exhibited a degree of relative pricing discretion. This meant that the major supermarket chains were not a close competitive constraint on the upstream activities of Metcash as a wholesaler. This was said to be reflected in the fact that Metcash itself exhibited a relative degree of pricing discretion. On the other hand, Metcash responded directly to the threat of Franklins as a wholesale supplier. This was illustrated by Metcash effectively cutting prices and locking in supply under Project Energise, and by taking retaliatory action under Project Ling Chi. These features showed that Franklins provided a greater constraint than the major supermarket chains on Metcash as a wholesaler. Accordingly, the correct framework to analyse the competitive effect of Metcash’s acquisition was a wholesale market, and the primary judge was in error in concluding otherwise. I turn now to consider the elements of the Commission’s case on appeal in this regard.Failure to consider functionally separate markets The Commission submitted that the primary judge failed to consider that functionally separate wholesale operations indicated a functionally separate wholesale market. It referred to the fact that Metcash was not vertically integrated (despite its contractual relationship with IGA suppliers) and supplied only independent retailers, many of whom did not operate under the IGA banner and therefore did not receive the range of ancillary services offered by Metcash to IGA retailers. In my view this submission cannot be sustained. It is plain that the primary judge did consider and take into account the existence and extent of transactions occurring at the wholesale level when dealing with this aspect of the Commission’s case. There was, however, a significant body of other evidence before the primary judge which served to show, on his Honour’s findings, that the true market behavioural constraints on Metcash came, to a great extent, from the major supermarket chains.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

If it is appropriate to apply that test at all, I agree with the approach taken by the trial judge. Moreover, in the circumstances of the present case, even adopting the full scope of the approach urged by the ACCC would not have changed my view about the outcome of the appeal. Even if I had been persuaded that the trial judge had erred in applying a requirement of proof on the balance of probabilities to the establishment of the facts constituting the so-called “counterfactual” (which I am not), testing the matter on the basis of whether it should have been concluded that there was a “real chance” of the outcome suggested by the ACCC would have made no difference. The trial judge decisively rejected that suggested outcome as involving any “real chance”. He said, plainly, that he had come to that view applying the “real chance” test to that issue, in case it was necessary to do so. Contrary to the submissions advanced for the ACCC the analysis which preceded that statement is not confined by the terms in which it is expressed to the application of a test on the balance of probabilities. The trial judge said repeatedly that it was unlikely that various elements of the scenario suggested by the ACCC would occur. It follows necessarily that he did not accept that it was likely that they would occur, whether as a “real chance” or otherwise, nor that the overall hypothesis had a “real chance” of recurring. Conclusion For the reasons I have given I agree that the appeal should be dismissed. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (the Commission) appeals from a judgment dismissing its application for injunctive relief in relation to the acquisition by Metcash Trading Limited (Metcash) of shares in Interfrank Group Holdings Pty Limited (Franklins) from Pick n Pay Retailers (Pty) Limited (Pick n Pay). On 1 July 2010 Metcash entered into an agreement with Pick n Pay to acquire all the issued shares in the capital of Franklins for $215 million. On 8 December 2010 the Commission commenced its proceeding in this Court seeking, in effect, to restrain the share acquisition from proceeding to completion. The Commission’s case was that the effect or likely effect of the share acquisition would be to substantially lessen competition in what it defined as the Independent Wholesale Grocery Market (the defined market), in contravention of s 50(1) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (the Act). This market was defined as a market in New South Wales and the Australian Capital Territory (the defined territory) in which: (a)the suppliers were Metcash, Franklins and SPAR Australia Limited (SPAR); (b)the acquirers were Independent Supermarket Retailers, as defined by the Commission; and(c)the products were a range of Wholesale Packaged Groceries, as defined by the Commission. I will return to describe aspects of the definition of this market. For present purposes it is sufficient to note that this market was one that was functionally delineated as a wholesale market.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established