Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v P T Garuda Indonesia Ltd [2016] FCAFC 42

Appeal from: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Air New Zealand Limited (2014) 319 ALR 388; [2014] FCA 1157
File numbers: NSD 1330 of 2014
NSD 1331 of 2014
Judges: DOWSETT, YATES AND EDELMAN JJ
Date of judgment: 21 March 2016
Catchwords:

TRADE PRACTICES – price fixing – meaning of a market “in Australia” – whether markets for airborne cargo out of Hong Kong, Singapore and Indonesia to ports in Australia were markets “in Australia” within s 4E of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – whether inconsistency exists between Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and Air Navigation Act 1920 (Cth)

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act (1901) (Cth) s 15B

Air Navigation Act 1920 (Cth) ss 12, 12(2), 13, 13(b), 22(1)

Air Navigation Amendment Regulations 2000(No 3) (Cth)

Air Navigation Regulations 1947 (Cth) reg 106A, 258

Commerce Act 1986 (NZ) ss 3(1), 3(1A)

Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act 1901 (Cth) s 109

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)

Competition Policy Reform Act 1995 (Cth)

Crown Suits Act 1898 (WA) ss 33, 37

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 63(2)

Extradition Act 1988 (Cth)

Federal Aviation Act of 1958, 49 USC 1301 (1958)

Industrial Relations Act 1996 (NSW) s 84(1)

Limitation of Actions Act 1958 (VIC) s 5(6)

Police Act 1990 (NSW) s 80(3)

Sherman Antitrust Act 15 USC (1890)

Trade Practices (Misuse of Trans–Tasman Market Power) Act 1990 (Cth)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 2, 4, 4(1), 4E, 45, 45(2), 45(3), 45(2)(a)(ii), 45(2)(b)(ii), 45A, 45A(1), 46, 50(1), 51, 51(1), 51(1A), 51(1C), 51(1C)(a), 76, 77, 77(1), 77(2), 82, 82(1), 82(2), 88, 88(1)(c)-(e); Pt IV

Trade Practices Amendment Act 1977 (Cth)

Trade Practices Bill 1974 (Cth)

Agreement between the Government of the Commonwealth of Australia and the Government of the Republic of Indonesia for Air Services Between and Beyond their Respective Territories. 7 March 1969. Australia–Indonesia. [1969] ATS 4 Arts 2, 6, 6(2), 6(3), 6(4)

Consolidated Version of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. 13 December 2007. European Union. 2008 O.J. C 115/47 Art 102

Convention on International Civil Aviation. Signed 7 December 1944. 15 UNTS 295 (entered into force 4 April 1947) (Chicago Convention)

Trans–Atlantic Conference Agreement [1959–1962] O.J. Spec. Ed. 87

Treaty Establishing the European Community (Consolidated Version), Rome Treaty. 25 March 1957. European Union Art 82

Treaty of Lisbon Amending the Treaty on European Union and the Treaty Establishing the European Community. Signed 13 December 2007. European Union. 2006 O.J. C 321 E/37 (entered into force 1 December 2009)

Cases cited:

Application by Services Sydney Pty Ltd [2005] ACompT 7; (2005) 227 ALR 140

Associated Minerals Consolidated Ltd v Wyong Shire Council [1975] AC 538

Atlantic Container Line AB v Commission (TAA) [2005] 4 CMLR 20

Atlantic Container Line AB v European Commission [2002] All ER (EC) 684

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Air New Zealand…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v PT Garuda I... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCAFC 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd, the central issue was whether the markets for airborne cargo from Hong Kong, Singapore, and Indonesia to ports in Australia constituted markets "in Australia" under section 4E of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) alleged that Garuda Indonesia and other airlines engaged in price-fixing agreements, which violated the Act. The parties debated the interpretation of "a market in Australia" and whether the Trade Practices Act conflicted with the Air Navigation Act 1920 (Cth). The court needed to determine whether the alleged anti-competitive conduct occurred within Australian territory or if it was sufficient that the effects of such conduct were felt in Australia.

The court examined the legislative history and purpose of section 4E, concluding that the term "market" was intended to be interpreted flexibly to align with the purposes of the Trade Practices Act. It was noted that the Swanson Committee had emphasised the need for flexibility in defining markets due to the variable factors influencing market boundaries, such as price, product substitutability, and distance from supply. The court further found that focusing on the port of origin, where the alleged price-fixing occurred, was appropriate in assessing the impact on competition. The court held that the markets for airborne cargo from the specified origins to Australian ports were not markets "in Australia" as they did not directly involve Australian territory.

Consequently, the court ruled in favour of PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd, finding that the alleged anti-competitive conduct did not occur within a market "in Australia" as defined by section 4E of the Trade Practices Act. The court ordered that the parties submit a minute of proposed orders by 24 March 2016 to formalise the decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 24 March 2016, the parties file a minute of proposed orders to give effect to these reasons.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

One significant area of authority which is not considered below is the body of antitrust decisions from the United States. The primary Judge held that United States authorities were not of any assistance because there is a substantial difference in the “effects doctrine” under the Sherman Antitrust Act 15 USC (1890), a doctrine which was developed as early as the decision of Learned Hand J in United States v Aluminum Co of America 8 F 2d 416 (2d Cir 1945). The Commission did not challenge this. Neither at trial nor on this appeal did the Commission submit that the appropriate approach to whether a market was “in Australia” was to test whether the relevant effect of anti‑competitive conduct was felt in Australia. The parties all avoided any reference to, or discussion of, the copious United States authority on this issue. That authority is, however, not uniform: Brown GW, “Relevant Geographic Market Delineation: The Interchangeability of Standards in Cases arising under Section 2 of the Sherman Act and Section 7 of the Clayton Act” (1979) Duke Law Journal 1152.(1) Legislative background Section 4E provides:For the purposes of this Act, unless the contrary intention appears, market means a market in Australia and, when used in relation to any goods or services, includes a market for those goods or services and other goods or services that are substitutable for, or otherwise competitive with, the first-mentioned goods or services. When the Trade Practices Act was first enacted, the term “market” was defined in s 4 as follows:“market” means a market in Australia. According to the explanatory memorandum which accompanied the draft Bill at [87]:The extent to which the legislation will operate extra‑territorially is indicated in clause 5. The definition of market in clause 4 is also relevant in this regard. The Trade Practices Amendment Act 1977 (Cth) repealed that definition and inserted s 4E in its present form, save that the words, “unless the contrary intention appears”, were not present. Those words were inserted by the Trade Practices (Misuse of Trans–Tasman Market Power) Act 1990 (Cth) to allow for the existence of trans‑Tasman markets. At [4] of the explanatory memorandum which accompanied the 1977 Bill, it was said that:A “market” for goods and services has been defined to include substitutable or competitive goods or services … .In the second reading speech, the Hon John Howard MP, as he then was, referred to an earlier Bill introduced in 1976. It had lapsed when Parliament was prorogued: see Commonwealth, Parliamentary Debates, House of Representatives, 8 December 1976, 1476 (John Howard). In the second reading speech in connection with the 1976 bill, Mr Howard referred to a committee report, saying that the bill would implement some of its recommendations. The report in question was the Swanson Report: see Trade Practice Act Review Committee, Report to the Minister for Business and Consumer Affairs (Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra, 1976). Concerning the meaning of the term “competition”, the committee adopted the language used by the Trade Practices Tribunal in QCMA. The committee said:4.20The concept of market involves the performance of a function in relation to a product, being goods or services, within a geographical area. Markets within the chain of distribution, from manufacturing to wholesaling and retailing, depend upon factors internal to the industry concerned, and distinction may in particular cases be blurred or non–existent. Product and geographic markets, on the other hand, depend upon factors extraneous to the industry. Their boundaries are determined by the relationship between such factors as price, product substitutability, desired use and distance from supply, to name some. Because of the variable nature of such factors, the boundaries of product and geographic markets are necessarily flexible.4.21The Committee considers that no advantage would be gained by attempting to define exhaustively the term ‘market’. No definition could produce a formula capable of certainty, having regard to the variable nature of the factors discussed in the paragraph above. Importantly also, the Committee has regard to the fact that persons involved with particular cases wish the matters in dispute to be judged on the particular facts, as they may present them, and not by artificial rules designed to achieve what we would suggest is an illusory certainty.4.22There is, however, one aspect of the definition of ‘market’ about which we consider the Act should give useful legislative guidance; namely, in relation to product substitution. The Committee therefore recommends that the Act should require that, in the determination of a ‘market’ for particular purposes, regard shall be had to substitute products, being products which have a reasonable interchangeability of use and which have high cross‑elasticity of demand, i.e. where a small decrease in the price of a particular product would cause a significant quantum of demand for a similar product to switch to the product in question.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

We have set out the history of the definition of the word “market” in order to demonstrate that the enactment in 1977 of s 4E was not intended to change the meaning of the term “a market in Australia”, save to the extent that the amendment may have extended the concept of “market” by the addition of the inclusory provision which requires that regard be had to substitute products as one of the factors to be considered in the flexible assessment of the factors comprising a market. In other words, the amendment seems to have been intended to extend the range of goods or services to be taken into account in the market identification exercise.(2) The flexibility of the concept of a “market in Australia” and purposive considerations The reference to a “market” in s 4E is to an abstract concept, not to a physical place. In one sense the description is a metaphor. It conjures an image of a “marketplace” involving a single location where buyers and sellers meet. But the legislation is plainly not limited to this narrow conception which developed well before the era of global commerce in which the Trade Practices Act was enacted. Moreover, the history of s 4E, and its purpose, manifest Parliament’s intention that the section be interpreted flexibly and in light of the purposes of the Trade Practices Act. The Swanson Committee recognised the flexibility of the boundaries of product and geographic dimensions of a market due to the variable nature of factors such as price, product substitutability, desired use and distance from supply ([4.20]). One reason why the evaluative exercise contemplated by the Swanson Committee was intended to be flexible is that the Committee was conscious of the dangers of definitions that are too wide or too narrow. At [4.19] the Committee said:If the market is too widely defined it may be that the requisite effect upon competition cannot ever be shown, to the detriment of those seeking relief from a restrictive agreement or practice. Alternatively, if the market is too narrowly defined it may result in hardship to and unnecessary limitations upon business actions … . Air NZ submitted ([26]) that defining a market too widely would have the result that the requisite effect upon competition would never be shown, citing French, Spender and O’Loughlin JJ agreeing in Singapore Airlines Limited v Taprobane Tours WA Pty Ltd [1991] FCA 808 [167]; (1991) 104 ALR 633, 642. This can be accepted. But, equally, the narrower the approach that is taken to whether a market is “in Australia”, the less likely it will be that any effect on competition, no matter how significant to Australians, would fall within ss 45 and 45A. The primary Judge found that the understandings were arrived at in meetings held, or through conduct occurring, at the port of origin, whether that was in Hong Kong, Singapore or Indonesia. None of the price-fixing conduct occurred in Australia. It was appropriate for the primary Judge to focus attention, firstly, on the port of origin because this was the place where the impugned conduct occurred. As Allsop J observed in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd [2006] ATPR 42-123; [2006] FCA 826 at [437]:… Market definition is to be approached by beginning with the problem at hand and asking what market identification best assists the assessment of the conduct and its asserted anti-competitive attributes…