Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cascade Coal Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 87 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cascade Coal Pty Ltd (No 3) [2018] FCA 1019

(Revised on 15 August 2018)

File number: NSD 584 of 2015
Judge: FOSTER J
Date of judgment: 6 July 2018
Catchwords:

COMPETITION – cartel conduct – whether the corporate respondents made a contract or arrangement or arrived at an understanding containing a cartel provision in respect of the application process for exploration licences for coal in the Mt Penny and Glendon Brook areas of NSW – whether, in the circumstances, the corporate respondents were competitors or likely competitors – whether the corporate respondents had the proscribed anti-competitive purpose – whether any of the respondents gave effect to the alleged cartel provision

COMPETITION – contracts, arrangements or understandings that restrict dealings or affect competition – whether the corporate respondents made a contract or arrangement or arrived at an understanding containing an exclusionary provision – whether the provision was entered into for the purposes of preventing, restricting or limiting the supply or acquisition of specified services – whether any of the respondents gave effect to the alleged exclusionary provision

COMPETITION – joint venture defences – whether the alleged exclusionary provision is for the purposes of a joint venture – whether other elements of s 76C defence established – whether the alleged cartel provision was for the purposes of a joint venture – whether the elements of s 44ZZRP defence to the making of the alleged cartel provision were made out

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), ss 4A, 4D, 4F, 4J, 44ZZRB, 44ZZRC, 44ZZRD(1)(a)(ii), (1)(b), (3)(a)(iii), (3)(c), (4), (5), (7), (9) and (11), 44ZZRK, 44ZZRP, 45, 76C and 84(2)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 9

Mining Act 1992 (NSW), ss 13(4), 14, 120, 122, 133, 193, 363

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Trade Practices Amendment (Cartel Conduct and Other Measures) Act 2009 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011, r 30.21(1)(b)(i)

Cases cited:

ASX Operations Pty Ltd v Pont Data Australia Pty Ltd (No 1) (1990) 27 FCR 460

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Air New Zealand Ltd (2014) 319 ALR 388

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v IPM Operation and Maintenance Loy Yang Pty Ltd (2006) 157 FCR 162

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Leahy Petroleum Pty Ltd (2007) 160 FCR 321

Gibson Motor Sport Merchandise Pty Ltd v Forbes [2005] FCA 749

Norcast S.ár.L v Bradken Ltd (No 2) (2013) 219 FCR 14

South Sydney District Rugby League Football Club Ltd v News Ltd (2001) 111 FCR 456

United Dominions Corporation Limited v Brian Proprietary Limited (1985) 157 CLR 1

Visy Paper Pty Limited v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2003) 216 CLR 1

Date of hearing: 4–8, 11–14 and 26–28 April 2016
Date of last submissions: 25 April 2016
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Economic Regulator, Competition and Access
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 569
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr CA Moore SC, Mr M O’Meara, Mr RA Yezerski…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cascade Coa... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1019
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cascade Coal Pty Ltd (No 3) involved the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) suing Cascade Coal Pty Ltd and others over alleged anti-competitive conduct in the coal exploration licence application process in New South Wales. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The primary dispute centred around whether the respondents had made a contract, arrangement, or understanding containing a cartel provision, which would restrict competition in the coal exploration licence application process in the Mt Penny and Glendon Brook areas.

The key legal issues the court had to address included whether the respondents had entered into a contract, arrangement, or understanding containing a cartel provision, and if so, whether these provisions were intended to restrict competition. The court also had to determine if the respondents had the requisite anti-competitive purpose and whether any of them had given effect to the alleged cartel provision. Additionally, the court examined whether the alleged exclusionary provision was made for the purposes of a joint venture and if the defences under section 44ZZRP applied.

The court found that the respondents had indeed entered into a contract, arrangement, or understanding containing a cartel provision, which was aimed at restricting competition in the coal exploration licence application process. The court held that the respondents had the requisite anti-competitive purpose and that some of them had given effect to the alleged cartel provision. The court further ruled that the alleged exclusionary provision was not made for the purposes of a joint venture and that the defences under section 44ZZRP did not apply. The court concluded that the Application must be dismissed with costs, except for the second respondent who did not participate in the proceeding and the third respondent, Loyal Coal, whose settlement terms were yet to be disclosed.

The court ordered that the costs of the Application be borne by the first and fourth to eleventh respondents, with the specifics of the costs to be determined in a subsequent judgment. The court also noted that the terms of the settlement between the ACCC and Loyal Coal would be addressed when considering whether to give effect to that settlement.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to r 39.04 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (FCR) or, alternatively, pursuant to r 39.05(e) and (h) FCR, the Orders made by Foster J on 6 July 2018 be varied by deleting from Order 2 made on that day the word “second” so that Order 2 now reads:

2. The applicant pay the first and fourth to eleventh respondents’ costs of and incidental to the Application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

LOYAL COAL

[23]

A BRIEF OVERVIEW OF THE RELEVANT FACTS

[26]

THE ACCC’S CASE AND THE RESPONDENTS’ DEFENCES

[48]

THE RELEVANT FACTS

[83]

The Witnesses

[83]

The Primary Facts

[87]

Introduction

[87]

The Obeids’ Interest in Coal Ventures in the Bylong Valley – June and July 2008

[90]

Brook and his Introduction to the Obeids

[99]

Arrangements between Brook, Monaro and the Obeids

[105]

Obeid Interests and Associates Acquire Coggan Creek and Donola

[154]

The EOI Process for Mt Penny Commences

[166]

MMNL’s EOI for Mt Penny and Glendon Brook

[178]

The DPI Reopens the EOI Process

[190]

Negotiations between Cascade and the Obeids, Related Matters and Subsequent Events (20 May 2009 to May 2012)

[242]

The 31 May 2009 Meeting

[252]

The Meeting of 3 June 2009

[294]

The Meeting of 5 June 2009

[312]

The Yarrawa Deal Involving Coalworks

[389]

The 23 May 2009 Meeting

[395]

Additional Findings of Fact

[417]

THE RELEVANT STATUTORY PROVISIONS

[434]

CONSIDERATION

[455]

Attribution of the Main Actors’ Conduct

[455]

The Alleged Contract, Arrangement or Understanding

[464]

The Competition Issue

[492]

The Purpose Issue

[516]

The “Giving Effect” Issue

[527]

The Accessorial Liability of John McGuigan, James McGuigan, Poole, Moses Obeid and Paul Obeid

[529]

The Credit of Individual Witnesses

[531]

The Joint Venture Defences

[539]

Evidentiary Rulings

[568]

CONCLUSIONS

[569]

Background

Background to the litigation

At some future date, it will be necessary to conduct a hearing in order to determine whether the Court should approve and give effect to the settlement reached between the ACCC and Loyal Coal. A Brief Overview of the Relevant Facts In November 2007, Locaway, a company controlled by the Obeid family, completed the purchase of Cherrydale which is located at Bylong. Subsequently, over the next two years, the Obeid family, through companies and trusts controlled by the family, and, on occasion, in conjunction with associates of the family, also purchased two additional rural properties in the same area, Donola and Coggan Creek. These additional properties adjoined Cherrydale. The total sum outlaid on the three acquisitions was $7.75 million. In early July 2008, Moses Obeid, who is the eldest son of Eddie Obeid, met with Paul Gardner Brook (Brook), who was, at that time, Senior Vice President, Asia Special Situations Group, of Lehman Brothers (Lehman) in Sydney, xx xxxxxx xx xxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xx xxxxx xxxxxxxx xx x xxxx xxxxxx xxxxxx xx xxx xx xxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxxx Bylong is a few kilometres from Mt Penny. Cherrydale, Donola and Coggan Creek are centrally located in the Mt Penny coal exploration area which was one of the areas released by the NSW Government in September 2008 for the purposes of allowing exploration for coal to be undertaken there. When he met with Brook in early July 2008, Moses Obeid provided to Brook a list of those small to medium mining companies xxxxx xx xxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxx xx xxxxxxx xx xxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxx xxx xxx xx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xx. Xxx xxx xxxxxxx xxxxx xxx xx xxxx xxx xxx xxx xxxx xxx. One company on that list was Monaro Mining NL (MMNL), a company which, up to that time, had not been involved in mining coal. It had focussed on mining uranium. In August 2008, the NSW Department of Primary Industries (DPI), which was responsible for allocating and regulating ELs under the Mining Act, prepared an EOI Information Package (initial EOI information package) in respect of the NSW Government’s plan to release eleven areas of the State for the purpose of allowing exploration for coal in those areas and ultimately allowing mining for coal in those areas. After that package was prepared, the DPI sought and obtained the approval of the relevant Minister (at the time, Mr Ian Macdonald) to send the initial EOI information package to a number of specific mining companies together with an invitation to the recipients of that package to lodge EOIs in respect of ELs for one or more of the eleven coal release areas. This was the first external step taken in the process which, in substance, was a closed tender process. On 19 September 2008, an invitation to lodge an EOI in respect of all eleven coal release areas was sent to MMNL. At the same time, invitations were also sent to other companies. An initial EOI information package was sent with each EOI invitation. Cascade did not receive an initial invitation to lodge an EOI for any of those coal release areas.

Decision

Reasons for decision

At Transcript pp 96–98 (on day 2 of the hearing), I made a number of evidentiary rulings and indicated to the parties that I would provide reasons for those rulings at a later time. I intend to provide reasons for those rulings in a separate judgment.Conclusions For all of the above reasons, the Application must be dismissed with costs. Only the first and fourth to eleventh respondents should have the benefit of that costs order at the present time. The second respondent did not participate at all in the proceeding. For that reason, the second respondent is not entitled to its costs. The third respondent (Loyal Coal) settled the ACCC’s case against it upon terms yet to be disclosed. I will deal with the question of costs as between the ACCC and Loyal Coal in due course when I come to consider whether I should give effect to the terms of its settlement with the ACCC. There will be orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence and found that there was insufficient evidence to establish that the corporate respondents made a contract or arrangement or arrived at an understanding containing a cartel provision in respect of the application process for exploration licences for coal in the Mt Penny and Glendon Brook areas of NSW. The court found that the corporate respondents were competitors or likely competitors, and that they did not have the proscribed anti-competitive purpose. The court also found that none of the respondents gave effect to the alleged cartel provision.

The court found that there was no evidence to establish that the corporate respondents made a contract or arrangement or arrived at an understanding containing an exclusionary provision. The court found that the provision was not entered into for the purposes of preventing, restricting, or limiting the supply or acquisition of specified services. The court also found that none of the respondents gave effect to the alleged exclusionary provision.

The court found that the alleged exclusionary provision was not for the purposes of a joint venture. The court also found that other elements of s 76C defence were not established. The court found that the alleged cartel provision was not for the purposes of a joint venture, and that the elements of s 44ZZRP defence to the making of the alleged cartel provision were not made out.

The court relied on the evidence presented by the parties and the applicable statutory provisions. The court applied the relevant legal principles to the facts of the case and came to the conclusions set out above. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the ACCC did not establish the alleged anti-competitive conduct of the corporate respondents.