Davids Holdings P/L v Coles Myer Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read
rP7 19ci~
JUDGMENT No. ........ ........ .. 1 ........ ..
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY 1
GENERAL DIVISION 1
No. OG 171 of 1991
BETWEEN:  DAVIDS HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED

Applicant

AND :  COLES MYER LIMITED
First Respondent
AND :  ALLAN BURGE

Second Respondent

AND :  ROSS DAVID CLARKE

Third Respondent

AND:  DEREK THOMAS CORNETT

Fourth Respondent

AND :  GEOFFREY JOHN MURPHY

Fifth Respondent

6'- b c M AND:  JAMES WILLIAM NOLAN

Sixth Respondent

ha/@j AND:  ANTONY EDWARD RANSON
Seventh Respondent
PND :  PETER WILSON

Eighth Respondent

D - : KEITH CHARLES WINNING

Ninth Respondent

AND :  KERRIE CLIFFORD WOOLACOTT

Tenth Respondent

AND :  GRAEME EDWARD BULLOCK

Eleventh Respondent

MINUTES OF ORDER

JUDGE MAKING ORDER:  Spender J.
DATE OF ORDER: 
30 April 1993  12 MAY 1993
WHERE MADE: 
Brisbane  FEDERAL COURT OF
28 days in which to replead.

WSTRALIA PRINCIPAL

THE COURT DIRECTS THAT:

The Reaistrar set the matter down for a directions hearing, the date, which is to be approximately six weeks from today, to be communicated to the parties within the next seven days.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.   The statement of claim be struck out.

2 .    The applicant in the principal proceedings be given

3.    The costs on each motion be the applicantst on those motions costs in the principal proceedings.

NOTE:  Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in
Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA ) DUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY 1

GENERAL DIVISION

1

No. OG 171 of 1991

BETWEEN:  DAVIDS HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED

Applicant

AND :  COLES MYER LIMITED

First Respondent

AND :  ALLAN BURGE
Second Respondent -
AND :  ROSS DAVID CLARKE
Third Respondent -
AND :  DEREK THOMAS CORNETT

Fourth Respondent

AND :  GEOFFREY JOHN MURPHY
Fifth Respondent -
AND :  JAMES WILLIAM NOLAN
Sixth Respondent -
AND :  ANTONY EDWARD RANSON

Seventh Respondent

AND :  PETER WILSON
Eighth Respondent -
AND :  KEITH C ~ E S WINNING

Ninth Respondent

AND:  KERRIE CLIFFORD WOOLACOT?

Tenth Respondent

AND :  GRAEME EDWARD BULLOCK

Eleventh Respondent

CORAM :  Spender J
PLACE :  Brisbane
m:  30 April 1993

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

As I indicated at the time of hearing this matter,

it is necessary for me to give my reasons on this application
orally, and, partly because of that circumstance, my reasons
will be tersely stated.

For the reasons which I will indicate, I propose to strike out the statement of claim but give liberty to replead within 28 days.

My conclusion in essence, is that while there are,

in my opinion, very real questions as to the existence of a cause of action under S. 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (the 'Actt), not so much on the basis of what is pleaded

the strike-out motion, this is not a case so clear that it
would be proper for the court, in the exercise of its summary
power under 0. 11 r. 16, to strike out that part of the claim.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Davids Holdings P/L v Coles Myer Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1993] FCA 287
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Davids Holdings Pty Limited brought a claim against Coles Myer Limited and various directors of QIW Retailers Limited, alleging breaches of fiduciary duty, conspiracy, and contravention of Section 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The defendants moved to strike out the statement of claim, arguing it disclosed no reasonable cause of action and was otherwise an abuse of process. The central issue was whether the pleadings adequately set out a cause of action under the Trade Practices Act and other common law claims.

The Court found that while there were significant deficiencies in the pleadings, the case was not so clear that the court could strike out the claim without giving the applicant an opportunity to replead. The pleadings failed to sufficiently allege an agreement between Coles Myer and the QIW directors, a necessary element for claims of breach of fiduciary duty and conspiracy. The claim under Section 46 also suffered from deficiencies in pleading the link between the alleged market power and the impugned conduct. However, the Court was reluctant to strike out the claims outright given the importance of not prematurely dismissing potential causes of action.

Accordingly, the Court struck out the statement of claim but granted Davids Holdings 28 days to replead, directing that the repleaded statement of claim address the deficiencies identified. The Court also ordered that the costs of the motions be the applicants' on those motions costs in the principal proceedings.

In summary, while the initial pleadings were deficient, the Court was willing to give the applicant an opportunity to replead to properly set out its claims, consistent with the principle that potential causes of action should not be prematurely dismissed. However, the deficiencies identified would need to be addressed in the repleaded statement of claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established