Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Boral Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Boral Ltd [1999]
FCA 1318

TRADE AND COMMERCE – restrictive trade practices – misuse of market power – concrete masonry manufacturer – selling below avoidable cost of production – offering to buy plant of competitor – increasing capacity – market definition – whether market for concrete masonry or for walling and paving products – substitutability of other products – whether substantial degree of market power – barriers to entry – relevance of financial resources – whether taking advantage of market power – predatory pricing – whether intention to recoup supra-competitive profits – whether proscribed purpose

WORDS AND PHRASES – “market” “substantial degree of power” “take advantage of power”  “predatory pricing” “avoidable cost”

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 4E, 4F, 46

Re Queensland Co-operative Milling Association Ltd (1976) 25 FLR 169 applied
Queensland Wire Industries Pty Ltd v BHP Co Ltd (1989) 167 CLR 177 applied
Arnotts Ltd v Trade Practices Commission (1990) 24 FCR 313 applied
United Brands v European Communities Commission [1978] 1 CMLR 429 applied
Eastern Express Pty Ltd v General Newspapers Ltd (1992) 35 FCR 43 applied
National Australia Bank Limited v Boral Gerrard Strapping System Pty Ltd (1992) ATPR 41-196 followed
Cargill, Inc v Monfort of Colorado, Inc 479 US 104 (1986) applied
Indiana Grocery Inc v Super-Value Stores 684 F Supp 566 (1988) applied
Barry Wright Corporation v ITT Grinnell Corporation 724 F 2d 227 (1983) applied
Eastern ExpressPty Ltd v General Newspapers Ltd (1991) ATPR 41-128 applied
Trade Practices Commission v The Gillette Company (1993) 45 FCR 366 applied
Adams v Cape Industries Plc [1991] 1 All ER 929 applied
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 applied

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v BORAL LIMITED & ANOR

NO. V 79 of 1998

HEEREY J
22 SEPTEMBER 1999
MELBOURNE

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 79 of 1998

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

BORAL LIMITED (ACN 000 051 696)
First Respondent

BORAL BESSER MASONRY LIMITED (ACN 000 223 718)
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

HEEREY J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 SEPTEMBER 1999

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The application is dismissed.

2.        The question of costs is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

 VG 79 of 1998

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

BORAL LIMITED (ACN 000 051 696)
First Respondent

BORAL BESSER MASONRY LIMITED (ACN 000 223 718)
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

HEEREY J

DATE:

22 SEPTEMBER 1999

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

CONTENTS

Page

I         INTRODUCTION........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ 1

1.          The issues  1

2.          Relevant TPA provisions  2

II        PARTICIPANTS AND CUSTOMERS........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ........ ....... 3

1.          BBM  3

2.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Boral Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] FCA 1318
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought an action against Boral Ltd, specifically its subsidiary BBM, in relation to alleged anti-competitive behaviour in the concrete masonry products market. The dispute centred on whether BBM had engaged in price undercutting below its variable costs, in violation of the Trade Practices Act. The Federal Court was tasked with determining the legal issues arising from the ACCC's claims.

The primary legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the Trade Practices Act and whether BBM's pricing strategies constituted price undercutting below variable costs. The court needed to assess whether BBM’s pricing policies, which often saw prices set below variable costs, violated the Act. Additionally, the court had to determine the relevant market for concrete masonry products to assess the competitive dynamics and substitutability of products within that market.

The court found that while BBM’s prices were below variable costs for significant periods, there was no evidence to suggest that BBM management was aware or believed their pricing practices contravened the Trade Practices Act. The analysis of the market showed that concrete masonry products constituted a competitive market with potential for substitution between products and suppliers. The court concluded that BBM’s pricing strategies, while sometimes below variable costs, did not amount to a breach of the Act. Therefore, the application by the ACCC was dismissed.

The court adjourned the question of costs to a later date, pending further determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The question of costs is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There was very sensible cooperation between the parties and their accounting experts. The Commission accepted, for the purposes of this case, the respondents’ figures and methodology. As a consequence, the following findings can be made:(i)The monthly sales revenue from sales of all concrete masonry products by BBM exceeded the variable costs of manufacture and supply for all months during the relevant period (April 1994 – October 1996) except for May, July, August, September and December 1994, January and November 1995 and October 1996.(ii)The total sales revenue exceeded variable costs of manufacture and supply by about $1.3 million and by the following amounts in the following respective years:1993-4 - $732,2201994-5- $124,4131995-6- $373,0861996-7- $770,4204. Graphic evidence of BBM revenue and costs Some of the evidence provided in graphic form can be summarised as follows. Again for the sake of clarity I will mention only 15.01 block. Figures are approximate only, based on the appearance of the graphs. (i) Sales revenue and variable costs for 15.01 block. From April 1994 both sales and costs plunged together from a high $25,000 to a low $8,000 in June. Then there was a sharp rise to August by which time costs ($30,000) had outpaced revenue ($25,000). Then there was a more gradual fall off until February 1995 with costs consistently above revenue, although the gap was narrowing. From a low of $10,000 both costs and revenue rose in unison to a peak of $53,000 in May 1995. Then a jagged decline to December 1995 (costs $18,000, sales $15,000) with costs always slightly above sales. Finally there was a jagged rise with costs and sales almost identical concluding at $35,000 in October 1996. (ii) Sales revenue and variable cost per unit for 15.01 block. At April 1994 price and cost were both on 80 cents. Price then fell to above 75 cents the following month while cost remained at 80 cents. Price rose to meet cost at July 1994. Thereafter cost rose to 86 cents and remained at that level until July 1996 when it rose by about 2 cents. From August 1994 to May 1996 price was always below cost, with the one exception of June 1995 when they coincided. The difference was as much as 18 cents in October 1994. From April 1996 price was mostly above cost. (iii) Total BBM sales revenue and variable costs. In April 1994 revenue $480,000 was above costs $440,000. Thereafter sales rose to $760,000 (November 1994), dropped to $460,000 (February 1995), rose jaggedly to $850,000 (December 1995), fell sharply then rose to $800,000 in (October 1996). For roughly about three-quarters of this period sales were either equal to or above costs. (iv) BBM and Pioneer monthly unit prices for 15.01 block. For almost all the period BBM was below Pioneer by margins of the order of 10 to 20 cents. However in the period April to July 1994 Pioneer won contracts for Western Metro TAFE, Dandenong Shopping Centre Car Park and Melbourne Exhibition Centre with prices well below BBM’s average monthly unit selling price. Likewise with Flagstaff Gardens in February 1996 Pioneer’s price was again below BBM’s average, although the difference was not so great.

Decision

Reasons for decision

HEEREY J
Relevant to the pricing policy of BBM was the importance it attached to winning major jobs. Its executives took the view that such sales were important so as to keep production volumes up and recover fixed costs. This was seen as the best way to increase market share. Mr Randerson said:“At any one time during 1995 and 1996, there were probably no more than six or seven major building projects under construction in the Melbourne area but they would collectively account for the bulk of the available volume. Therefore, to protect the market share and production volumes of the business during this period, it was important for BBM Victoria to be supplying several of these projects, at any time.”6. Conclusion on pricing In strict terms of price against avoidable cost, the latter exceeded the former for important parts of BBM’s product range for a significant part of the relevant period. Moreover, since competent businessmen are usually aware of their costs I infer that BBM management knew that prices were below variable costs for much of the time. However, there is no ground for thinking that they believed or suspected that their pricing might contravene the TPA. VII THE RELEVANT MARKET1. Market definition Section 4E requires the Court to have regard to goods that are “substitutable for, or otherwise competitive with” goods in the posited market. In Re Queensland Co-operative Milling Association Ltd (1976) 25 FLR 169 at 190 the Trade Practices Tribunal gave an exposition which has been consistently adopted by the High Court and this Court in subsequent cases. The Tribunal said:“Before giving our reasons we should explain our understanding of the market concept, and of the relationship between ‘markets’ and ‘sub-markets’. We take the concept of a market to be basically a very simple idea. A market is the area of close competition between firms or, putting it a little differently, the field of rivalry between them. (If there is no close competition there is of course a monopolistic market.) Within the bounds of a market there is substitution – substitution between one product and another, and between one source of supply and another, in response to changing prices. So a market is the field of actual and potential transactions between buyers and sellers amongst whom there can be strong substitution, at least in the long run, if given a sufficient price incentive. Let us suppose that the price of one supplier goes up. Then on the demand side buyers may switch their patronage from this firm’s product to another, or from this geographic source of supply to another. As well, on the supply side, sellers can adjust their production plans, substituting one product for another in their output mix, or substituting one geographic source of supply for another. Whether such substitution is feasible or likely depends ultimately on customer attitudes, technology, distance, and cost and price incentives.It is the possibilities of such substitution which set the limits upon a firm’s ability to ‘give less and charge more’. Accordingly, in determining the outer boundaries of the market we ask a quite simple but fundamental question: if the firm were to ‘give less and charge more’ would there be, to put the matter colloquially, much of a reaction? And if so, from whom? In the language of economics the question is this: From which products and which activities could we expect a relatively high demand or supply response to price change, i.e. a relatively high cross-elasticity of demand or cross-elasticity of supply?”2. Concrete masonry products or walling and paving products?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HEEREY J

BBM was keen to win this project because the site was near the Deer Park production facility. Mr Vella thought it would be embarrassing to have a building constructed from a competitor’s product right on their doorstep. BBM quoted prices to three competing builders including 88 cents for 15.01. The building contract was awarded to Frank Cambria. In July Mr Vella arranged a meeting with Mr Cambria because he had heard rumours that prices quoted for the project by Pioneer were substantially less than BBM’s. Mr Cambria confirmed that this was so. At the meeting Mr Vella agreed to match the prices quoted by Pioneer. Mr Cambria shook hands on that and BBM was appointed supplier. BBM supplied 15.01 at an average price of 71 cents. 27. Rocla closes all Victorian masonry operations Aug 1995 In 1994 Rocla assessed the Melbourne market for concrete masonry products. There appeared to be substantial overcapacity. Any one of the three major manufacturers i.e. Pioneer, BBM or Rocla, could have supplied the total amount for concrete masonry products with their existing plants operating on three shifts, seven days per week. Production overcapacity led to low prices. Rocla decided at the end of 1994 to concentrate on its product strengths which were faced bricks for domestic housing and coloured paving products. These were value added products selling at the upper end of the retail market and so offered greater profit margins compared with grey concrete block. This strategy worked for a while but in the first six months of 1995 demand in the housing market declined substantially. Rocla decided to close down in Victoria because it considered operation at profitable levels was unlikely. It was thought that the business would lose more money the longer it remained operating in Victoria. 28. Men’s Prison Laverton Sept 1995 BBM submitted a quote to the builder John Holland on 20 September. John Holland had not yet engaged a blocklayer. The price for 15.01 was 88 cents. About a year later BBM was asked to submit quotes to the tendering blocklayers. The price for some blocklayers for 15.01 was 92 cents and for others a dollar, depending on which had the better relationship with BBM. On 20 September 1996 Mr Simon Pethica of Bradys contacted Mr Vella and told him that Pioneer was quoting about five to ten cents for 10.01 less than BBM, even though it was manufacturing at Clayton and transporting to Laverton. He also said that C&M were quoting slightly lower in respect of some products than BBM (10.01 70 cents v 72 cents) and higher in others (15.01 94 cents v 92 cents). Nevertheless BBM won the job. Their relationship with Bradys was good and in Mr Vella’s assessment Brady was generally prepared to pay a bit more for BBM customer service and reliability. Also the $1000 per month rebate to Bradys initially as part of the Casino project was still being paid. The net price paid by Bradys was slightly lower than the invoice price.29. Kraft Leitchville Oct 1995 This was a plant near Albury. On 11 October BBM quoted to five tendering builders. The only price offered was 88 cents for 15.83. Pioneer won the job.30. Smorgons Laverton Oct 1995