Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Flight Centre Travel Group Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
KIEFEL, GAGELER, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER
COMMISSION  APPELLANT

AND

FLIGHT CENTRE TRAVEL GROUP LIMITED  RESPONDENT

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Flight Centre Travel Group Limited
[2016] HCA 49

14 December 2016
B15/2016

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed.

2.Set aside the order of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 31 July 2015, and in its place order that:

(a)the appeal be allowed in part;

(b)the respondent be granted leave to file its amended notice of cross-appeal dated 3 August 2016;

(c)the cross-appeal be allowed in part;

(d)the declaration made by Logan J on 28 March 2014 be varied as follows:

(i)in paragraph 1, omit the words "distribution and booking services for international passenger air travel" and replace them with the words "international airline tickets";

(ii)in each of paragraphs 1(a), (b), (c), (d), (e) and (f), omit the words "distribution and booking";

(iii)in each of paragraphs 1(a), (b) and (f), omit the words "the retail or distribution margin received by Flight Centre for its booking and distribution services would be maintained" and replace them with the words "the price Flight Centre charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be maintained, and that the price Singapore Airlines charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be fixed, controlled or maintained";

(iv)in each of paragraphs 1(c) and (d), omit the words "the retail or distribution margin received by Flight Centre for its booking and distribution services would be maintained" and replace them with the words "the price Flight Centre charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be maintained, and that the price Emirates charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be fixed, controlled or maintained"; and

(v)in paragraph 1(e), omit the words "the retail or distribution margin received by Flight Centre for its booking and distribution services would be maintained" and replace them with the words "the price Flight Centre charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be maintained, and that the price Malaysia Airlines charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be fixed, controlled or maintained"; and

(e)each party bear its own costs of the proceedings in the Full Court to date.

3.Remit the matter to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia for the determination of the appeal and cross-appeal insofar as they relate to penalty.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

J T Gleeson SC, Solicitor-General of the Commonwealth with M R Hodge and R C A Higgins (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

B W Walker SC with M I Borsky for the respondent (instructed by King & Wood Mallesons)

M H O'Bryan QC with N P De Young for the International Air Transport Association, as amicus curiae (instructed by Minter Ellison Lawyers)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Flight Cent... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] HCA 49
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) against Flight Centre Travel Group Ltd. The dispute concerned allegations that Flight Centre had contravened section 45 of the *Trade Practices Act 1974* (Cth) by proposing arrangements with three airlines – Emirates, Malaysia Airlines, and Singapore Airlines – with the purpose or effect of fixing, controlling, or maintaining the price of international airline tickets. The core of the ACCC's case was that Flight Centre, despite acting as an agent for these airlines, was also a competitor in the relevant market, and that its proposals to the airlines to prevent them from discounting their direct sales constituted price fixing that substantially lessened competition.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether Flight Centre, in its dealings with the airlines whose tickets it sold, was in competition with those airlines. This question was critical because the application of section 45 of the Act, particularly in conjunction with the deeming provision in section 45A, required Flight Centre to be characterised as a competitor to establish a contravention. The High Court also considered the appropriate definition of the relevant market for the purposes of assessing competition.

The High Court, in allowing the appeal in part, determined that the market should be defined as one for the supply of international airline tickets, rather than for the supply of carriage services or distribution and booking services. The Court reasoned that Flight Centre and the airlines were not in competition in relation to the supply of carriage services themselves, but rather in relation to the supply of contractual rights to those services, i.e., the tickets. The Court varied the declarations made by the primary judge to accurately reflect the findings regarding the price fixing of international airline tickets. The matter was remitted to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia for the determination of issues relating to penalty.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside the order of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 31 July 2015, and in its place order that:

(a) the appeal be allowed in part;

(b) the respondent be granted leave to file its amended notice of cross-appeal dated 3 August 2016;

(c) the cross-appeal be allowed in part;

(d) the declaration made by Logan J on 28 March 2014 be varied as follows:

(i) in paragraph 1, omit the words "distribution and booking services for international passenger air travel" and replace them with the words "international airline tickets";

(ii) in each of paragraphs 1(a), (b), (c), (d), (e) and (f), omit the words "distribution and booking";

(iii) in each of paragraphs 1(a), (b) and (f), omit the words "the retail or distribution margin received by Flight Centre for its booking and distribution services would be maintained" and replace them with the words "the price Flight Centre charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be maintained, and that the price Singapore Airlines charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be fixed, controlled or maintained";

(iv) in each of paragraphs 1(c) and (d), omit the words "the retail or distribution margin received by Flight Centre for its booking and distribution services would be maintained" and replace them with the words "the price Flight Centre charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be maintained, and that the price Emirates charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be fixed, controlled or maintained"; and

(v) in paragraph 1(e), omit the words "the retail or distribution margin received by Flight Centre for its booking and distribution services would be maintained" and replace them with the words "the price Flight Centre charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be maintained, and that the price Malaysia Airlines charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be fixed, controlled or maintained"; and

(e) each party bear its own costs of the proceedings in the Full Court to date.

3. Remit the matter to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia for the determination of the appeal and cross-appeal insofar as they relate to penalty.

Background

Background to the litigation

This appeal concerns a travel agent which, between August 2005 and May 2009, tried to persuade three airlines whose tickets it sold, under contractual arrangements with them, not to undercut it in their direct sales. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission ("ACCC") alleged that the agent was a competitor of the airlines in relevant markets and had contravened s 45 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ("the Act"), as it stood during the relevant time, by proposing an arrangement or understanding with a view to maintaining or controlling the price of air tickets supplied to consumers. The answer to the question whether the agent contravened the Act turns critically upon whether or not the agent was, in any relevant sense, in competition with the three airlines, which were its principals at the time it made the proposals. I would answer that question in the negative. In that respect I am in disagreement with the other members of the Court and I would dismiss the appeal.Procedural background Between August 2005 and May 2009, the period relevant to this appeal, Flight Centre Travel Group Ltd ("Flight Centre"), then called Flight Centre Ltd, conducted a travel agency business in Australia and overseas through a distribution network comprising shopfronts, call centres and the internet. It sold international passenger air travel services to consumers pursuant to a standard form Passenger Sales Agency Agreement ("PSAA") between itself and various carriers. The form of agreement had been prepared by the International Air Transport Association ("IATA"). Flight Centre also offered consumers travel advice about possible destinations and available flights on different airlines to those destinations. It received payment from customers for air travel booked through it and remitted the amounts less commission to the airlines. The airlines whose international passenger air travel services Flight Centre sold also sold directly to prospective passengers. In 2012, the ACCC commenced proceedings against Flight Centre, alleging that, between 19 August 2005 and 16 May 2009, it had contravened s 45(2)(a)(ii) of the Act. Flight Centre was said to have proposed to Emirates, Malaysia Airlines and Singapore Airlines an arrangement or understanding containing a provision which had the purpose and/or was likely to have the effect of fixing or controlling or maintaining prices for the supply of the services which it and they were selling. On the premise that Flight Centre, although their agent, was also in competition with those airlines, it was said that by operation of a deeming provision, s 45A(1) of the Act[1], the proposed arrangement or understanding had the purpose or would have or be likely to have the effect of substantially lessening competition and that by proposing it Flight Centre had contravened s 45. As appears from the provisions of ss 45 and 45A, the characterisation of Flight Centre as a competitor of the airlines, whose services it provided to its customers, was necessary in order to establish the contraventions alleged.[1]Repealed by item 21 of Sched 1 to the Trade Practices Amendment (Cartel Conduct and Other Measures) Act 2009 (Cth) with effect from 24 July 2009. Section 45A was superseded by Div 1 of Pt IV of the Act; subs (1) was in effect replaced by the purpose/effect condition in s 44ZZRD(2).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ (dissent) KIEFEL AND GAGELER JJ (dissent) NETTLE J
The outcome of the appeal does not turn on the precise dimensions of that market. The ACCC's persistence in describing it as a market for international passenger air travel services nevertheless tends to blur the product and functional dimensions of the market in a way which obscures the point that the supplies for which Flight Centre and the airlines competed were not supplies of carriage services but rather supplies of contractual rights to carriage services. The market is better identified as having been a market for the supply of contractual rights to international air carriage to customers or, in short, as a market for international airline tickets. Conclusion and orders The appeal should be allowed. The primary judge's declarations of contravention of s 45(2)(a)(ii) should stand, with adjustments to reflect the ACCC's success in establishing its secondary case as distinct from its primary case concerning satisfaction of the second condition of s 45A(1). In recognition of its failure to pursue that secondary case in the Full Court, the ACCC should not have its costs of the appeal to this Court and should not have its costs to date of the appeal to the Full Court. The following orders should be made:1. Appeal allowed. 2.Set aside the order of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 31 July 2015, and in its place order that: (a) the appeal be allowed in part; (b)the respondent be granted leave to file its amended notice of cross-appeal dated 3 August 2016; (c) the cross-appeal be allowed in part; (d)the declaration made by Logan J on 28 March 2014 be varied as follows: (i)in paragraph 1, omit the words "distribution and booking services for international passenger air travel" and replace them with the words "international airline tickets"; (ii)in each of paragraphs 1(a), (b), (c), (d), (e) and (f), omit the words "distribution and booking"; (iii)in each of paragraphs 1(a), (b) and (f), omit the words "the retail or distribution margin received by Flight Centre for its booking and distribution services would be maintained" and replace them with the words "the price Flight Centre charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be maintained, and that the price Singapore Airlines charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be fixed, controlled or maintained"; (iv)in each of paragraphs 1(c) and (d), omit the words "the retail or distribution margin received by Flight Centre for its booking and distribution services would be maintained" and replace them with the words "the price Flight Centre charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be maintained, and that the price Emirates charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be fixed, controlled or maintained"; and (v)in paragraph 1(e), omit the words "the retail or distribution margin received by Flight Centre for its booking and distribution services would be maintained" and replace them with the words "the price Flight Centre charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be maintained, and that the price Malaysia Airlines charged for its supply of international airline tickets would be fixed, controlled or maintained"; and (e)each party bear its own costs of the proceedings in the Full Court to date. 3.Remit the matter to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia for the determination of the appeal and cross-appeal insofar as they relate to penalty.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NETTLE J