AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL
Applications by Robe River Mining Co Pty Ltd and Hamersley Iron Pty Ltd [2013] ACompT 2
Citation: Applications by Robe River Mining Co Pty Ltd and Hamersley Iron Pty Ltd [2013] ACompT 2 Review from: Treasurer of the Commonwealth of Australia Parties: Robe River Mining Co Pty Ltd, North Mining Ltd, Pilbara Iron Pty Ltd, Rio Tinto Ltd, Mitsui Iron Ore Development Pty Ltd, Nippon Steel Australia Pty Ltd & Sumitomo Metal Australia Pty Ltd
Hamersley Iron Pty Ltd, Hamersley Iron-Yandi Pty Ltd, Robe River Mining Co Pty Ltd, North Mining Ltd, Pilbara Iron Pty Ltd, Rio Tinto Ltd, Mitsui Iron Ore Development Pty Ltd, Nippon Steel Australia Pty Ltd & Sumitomo Metal Australia Pty Ltd
File numbers: ACT 3 of 2008
ACT 4 of 2008Tribunal:
MANSFIELD J (PRESIDENT)
MR R SHOGREN (MEMBER)
MR R STEINWALL (MEMBER)Date of judgment: 8 February 2013 Catchwords: ACCESS TO SERVICES – review of Minister’s decisions to declare two services under s 44H of Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – where Minister had failed to consider proper test in applying criterion (b) in s 44H(4) – private profitability test – whether there was material which could satisfy the Tribunal about criterion (b) properly considered
ACCESS TO SERVICES – review of Minister’s decisions to declare two services under s 44H of Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – review being conducted after significant passage of time – extent of power of presiding member under s 44K(6) – whether in circumstances presiding member could request National Competition Council to secure experts reports through parties to review and provide them to Tribunal on issue not previously properly addressed – factors relevant to discretion of presiding member to exercise that power
ACCESS TO SERVICES – review of Minister’s decisions to declare two services under s 44H of Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – whether Tribunal has power to permit parties to adduce further evidence on review other than by presiding member exercising power under s 44K(6) – whether, if such power exists, it should be exercised in present circumstances where that would lead to a form of rehearing – discretionary factors considered
Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 29A, 44B, 44F, 44H, 44HA, 44K
Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law Act (No 2) 2010 (Cth)
Trade Practices Amendment (Infrastructure Access) Act 2010 (Cth)Cases cited: The Pilbara Infrastructure Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal (2012) 290 ALR 750 followed
Re Fortescue Metals Group Ltd (2010) 271 ALR 256 discussed
The Pilbara Infrastructure Pty Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal (2011) 193 FCR 57 discussed
Craig v South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 168 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Bhardwaj (2002) 209 CLR 597 cited
Collector of Customs (NSW) v Brian Lawler Automotive Pty Ltd (1979) 2 ALD 1 cited
Secretary, Department of Social Security v Alvaro (1994) 50 FCR 213 citedDate of hearing: 20 December 2012 Place: Adelaide (via video link to Melbourne) Category: Catchwords Number…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Applications by Robe River Mining Co Pty Ltd and Hamersley I... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] ACompT 2
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Tribunal included whether the Minister had correctly applied the private profitability test, and if there was material available that could satisfy the Tribunal that the test was properly considered. Additionally, the Tribunal examined the extent of its powers under section 44K(6) in reviewing decisions made after a significant passage of time, and whether it could request the National Competition Council to secure expert reports on issues not previously addressed. The Tribunal also considered whether it had the power to allow the parties to present further evidence, and if such a power should be exercised in the circumstances, despite the potential for a form of rehearing.
The Tribunal found that the Minister had indeed failed to consider the private profitability test correctly, as required by section 44H(4)(b). The Tribunal concluded that it had the discretion to request expert reports through the National Competition Council, and that doing so could be appropriate given the significant time elapsed since the Minister's decision. However, the Tribunal determined that it did not have the power to permit the parties to adduce further evidence beyond what the presiding member could request under section 44K(6), as this would amount to a rehearing, which was not permissible in the circumstances. The Tribunal's reasoning was based on the statutory framework, the nature of the review process, and the discretion afforded to the presiding member.
The Tribunal's final order was that the decisions of the Minister to declare the services as designated services be set aside, and the matter was remitted back to the Minister for reconsideration in light of the Tribunal's findings. The Tribunal also noted that, in the event the Minister did not properly consider the private profitability test upon reconsideration, the Tribunal would be open to further review of the Minister's decision.
Background
Background to the litigation
Subsequent to the Minister's decisions, Robe River Mining Co Pty Ltd and Hamersley Iron Pty Ltd sought a review of these decisions by a tribunal. The review was conducted some time after the original decisions were made. The tribunal had to determine whether there was sufficient material that could be presented to satisfy the tribunal that the private profitability test had been properly considered by the Minister. Additionally, the tribunal examined the extent of its own powers under section 44K(6) in the context of a review conducted after a significant passage of time. This included considering whether the presiding member of the tribunal could request the National Competition Council to secure expert reports through the parties involved, to review and provide them to the tribunal on the issue of whether criterion (b) had been properly addressed.
The matter initially came before the Minister who made decisions to declare two services under section 44H of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). Following these decisions, Robe River Mining Co Pty Ltd and Hamersley Iron Pty Ltd sought a review by a tribunal under section 44K of the Act. The tribunal was tasked with reviewing the Minister's decisions and determining whether the private profitability test had been properly considered. The review was conducted some time after the original decisions were made. Key procedural steps included the tribunal examining the extent of its powers under section 44K(6) and whether it could request the National Competition Council to secure expert reports through the parties to address the issue of whether criterion (b) had been properly considered.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether there was material which could satisfy the Tribunal about criterion (b) properly considered by the Minister.
2. Whether in the circumstances the presiding member could request the National Competition Council to secure experts' reports through the parties to review and provide them to the Tribunal on the issue not previously properly addressed.
3. Whether the Tribunal has the power to permit parties to adduce further evidence on review other than by the presiding member exercising the power under s 44K(6) and, if such power exists, whether it should be exercised in the present circumstances where that would lead to a form of rehearing.
Held
1. The court concluded that there was sufficient material to enable the Tribunal to properly consider whether the Minister had applied the private profitability test as required by criterion (b) in s 44H(4).
2. The court determined that the presiding member could exercise discretion to request the National Competition Council to secure experts' reports through the parties to review and provide them to the Tribunal on the issue not previously properly addressed. The decision was based on the unique circumstances of this case and the discretion available under s 44K(6).
3. The court found that the Tribunal had the power to permit parties to adduce further evidence on review, other than by the presiding member exercising the power under s 44K(6). However, the court held that this power should not be exercised in the present circumstances to avoid a form of rehearing.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining the first issue, which was whether there was material that could satisfy the Tribunal about criterion (b) properly considered by the Minister. The court held that, despite the Minister's failure to properly consider the private profitability test, there was sufficient material available for the Tribunal to properly assess the criterion. The court reviewed the evidence and found that the material was adequate for the Tribunal to make an informed decision.
In addressing the second issue, the court considered whether the presiding member could request the National Competition Council to secure experts' reports through the parties to review and provide them to the Tribunal on the issue not previously properly addressed. The court examined the discretion available under s 44K(6) and found that, given the significant passage of time since the original review and the unique circumstances of this case, it was appropriate for the presiding member to exercise that discretion. The court outlined the relevant factors that should be considered when exercising this discretion, including the need for expert input, the potential for unfairness, and the importance of finality in proceedings.
Finally, the court turned to the third issue, which was whether the Tribunal had the power to permit parties to adduce further evidence on review, other than by the presiding member exercising the power under s 44K(6). The court held that the Tribunal did have such power but concluded that it should not be exercised in the present circumstances to avoid a form of rehearing. The court set out the discretionary factors that should be considered when deciding whether to permit further evidence, including the potential for unfairness, the impact on the parties, and the overall interests of justice. The court emphasised the importance of maintaining the balance between fairness and finality in proceedings.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Tribunal has the power to permit parties to adduce further evidence on review, but this power should be exercised with caution, taking into account the discretionary factors outlined by the court. The court also confirmed that the presiding member has the discretion to request the National Competition Council to secure experts' reports in unique circumstances, such as when significant time has passed since the original review.