Nigam v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Nigam v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 106

File number: NSD 1658 of 2016
Judge: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 15 February 2017
Catchwords:

MIGRATION – Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 501CA –
cancellation of visa – whether Administrative Appeals Tribunal erred in the exercise of discretion by taking into account the “principle that persons who commit serious crimes should expect to forfeit the privilege of remaining in Australia” as a legal principle -  whether Tribunal was required to make a “determination” as to where the best interests of the applicant’s child lay in the sense of making a positive finding – whether the Tribunal failed to have proper regard to the extent to which the applicant would play a positive role in his minor child’s life

COSTS – extent to which costs are recoverable against legally aided person in Federal Court – whether s 47, Legal Aid Commission Act 1979 (NSW) limiting liability for costs is applied by s 79 Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) as a surrogate Commonwealth law – whether decision in Woodlands v Permanent Trustee Co Ltd (1996) 68 FCR 213 overruled

Legislation:

Constitution s 109

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 43

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 79

Legal Aid Commission Act 1979 (NSW) ss 42, 47, 57

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 4, 13, 14, 29, 45, 501, 65, 499, 501CA

Cases cited:

AZAFQ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 105

Commissioner of the Australian Capital Territory Revenue v Alphaone Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 576

Jones v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1995) 63 FCR 32

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton [2016] FCAFC 11

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liange [1996] HCA 6

Paerau v Minister for immigration [2014] FCAFC 28

SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2006] HCA 53

SZTMD v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 150

Tesic v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1465

Tupkovic v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 73

Wilson v Alexander [2003] FCAFC 272

Woodlands v Permanent Trustee Co Ltd (1996) 68 FCR 213

Date of hearing: 8 December 2016, 9 February 2017
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 94
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr L Karp
Solicitor for the Applicant: Kinslor Prince Lawyers
Counsel for the First Respondent: Ms R Francois
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Sparke Helmore
Counsel for the Second Respondent: The Second Respondent filed a submitting appearance save as to costs
Table of Corrections
 23 February 2017 The catchwords have been amended

ORDERS

NSD 1658 of 2016
BETWEEN:

ANISH NIGAM

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

PERRY J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 FEBRUARY 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is dismissed.

2.The applicant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nigam v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 106
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the applicant, a citizen of India, challenged the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to refuse his visa application. The Tribunal had dismissed his application for judicial review of the decision of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to cancel his visa on the basis that he did not pass the character test. The applicant’s visa was cancelled on the basis that he had a substantial criminal record, and it was not in the best interests of his daughter for the visa not to be cancelled. The applicant argued that the Tribunal had erred in law in failing to make a positive finding as to the best interests of his daughter, and in failing to have proper regard to the positive role he could play in his daughter’s life.

The Court considered the extent to which the Tribunal was required to make a determination as to the best interests of the applicant’s daughter. The Court held that the Tribunal was not required to make a positive finding as to the best interests of the child. Rather, it was sufficient for the Tribunal to conclude that it was not satisfied that it was in the best interests of the child for the visa to not be cancelled. The Court also held that the Tribunal had not failed to have proper regard to the extent to which the applicant would play a positive role in his daughter’s life, as it had considered the matter in the context of whether the Optimal Conditions would be met, and was not satisfied that they would be met.

The Court dismissed the applicant’s appeal and ordered that the applicant pay the first respondent’s costs as agreed or assessed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The applicant is to pay the first respondent’s costs as agreed or assessed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Finally, Paragraph 12 identifies in a non-exhaustive manner, other considerations which must be taken into account where relevant including impact on family members and international non-refoulement obligations. 3. BACKGROUND3.1 The applicant’s background and application for the visa The applicant is a citizen of India. He arrived in Australia in September 1996 on a student visa. That visa expired in November 2000. After that time, the applicant remained in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen until 2 August 2004. On 2 August 2004, the applicant applied for a Partner (Temporary) (Class UK) visa, which was sponsored by his then de facto partner, Ms B. He was granted a bridging visa until the determination of his visa application. In July 2005, Ms B gave birth to their daughter. At the time of the Tribunal hearing, the applicant’s and Ms B’s daughter was 11 years old. Ms B is her daughter’s primary carer and maintains full parental custody. The daughter has a disability manifesting itself in severe behavioural problems and requires extensive consideration and care.3.2 The applicant’s offending and imprisonment In May 2007, the applicant was convicted of aggravated armed robbery, robbery in company, aggravated break and enter, and engaging in money laundering. He pleaded guilty to all charges. The offences in question were committed by the applicant in 2004 and 2005. Those offences were summarised by the Tribunal as follows:Offences committed in May 2004(a) On 24 May 2004, Mr Nigam and his co-offenders were involved in the robbery of the proprietor of a grocery store. The offenders broke into the home of the victim where he was physically restrained and threatened with violence. The statement of agreed facts noted that the role of Mr Nigam was to "wait outside the premises and keep a 'lookout'. The offenders stole keys to the victim's business premises and two watches. The victim was restrained while one or more of the offenders travelled to and stole cash from his business. Mr Nigam was the driver of the vehicle used to break and enter the victim's business.(b) On 25 and 27 May 2004, Mr Nigam engaged in conduct amounting to money laundering, namely the electronic transfer of money which was the proceeds of crime and the purchase of a motor vehicle with the proceeds of crime.Offence committed on 10 January 2005(c) On 10 January 2005, Mr Nigam and two co-offenders were involved in an aggravated robbery. The victim was a joint owner of a fruit store. He was attacked by the offenders as he approached his motor vehicle. He was punched numerous times in the head, restrained with cable ties and then forced into the back seat of his vehicle, which was then driven away by one of the co-offenders. The victim was physically assaulted and restrained again as he tried to escape. The victim was then punched in the head numerous times until he surrendered the keys to his store. The statement of agreed facts went on the say, "the victim was told "I know where you live, I'll get your family." The statement of agreed facts also noted that during the robbery, Mr Nigam's role was to "wait nearby where he acted as a 'lookout' for police. He was in a position to assist his co-offenders if required."

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant has been in immigration detention since 27 May 2016.3.4 The Tribunal’s decision The Tribunal dismissed the application for review on 18 August 2016. I note that, subject to exceptions not presently relevant, s 500(1)(b) of the Act provides that the Tribunal may review decisions of a delegate of the Minister made pursuant to s 501. In its written statement of reasons, the Tribunal noted that, as the applicant was sentenced to 10 and a half years in prison with a non-parole period of seven and a half years, he had a “substantial criminal record” as defined in s 501(7) of the Act. Consequently, the applicant did not pass the character test by virtue of s 501(6) of the Act. This was conceded by the applicant (Tribunal’s reasons at [16]). The issue before the Tribunal was therefore whether the discretion in s 501(1) of the Act should be exercised to refuse to grant the applicant a visa (Tribunal’s reasons at [10] and [17]). The Tribunal dealt with each primary criterion in Direction No. 65 in turn. The Tribunal was satisfied that the decision to refuse Mr Nigam’s visa is the correct and preferable decision. In reaching that view, the Tribunal had regard to the following considerations. (1)The applicant’s offending was objectively serious. In this regard, the Tribunal rejected the applicant’s argument that his offending was less serious because he was not directly involved in the violent aspects of the crimes for which he was convicted (at [27]-[31]). (2)During the course of the hearing, the applicant attempted to minimise his responsibility and involvement in one of the charges the applicant incurred whilst incarcerated by claiming it was a misunderstanding (at [34]), and the Tribunal was not satisfied the applicant fully accepted responsibility for his past conduct (at [43]).(3)While there was a low risk that the applicant would reoffend, even that low risk posed a significant risk of substantial harm to the Australian community (at [48]).(4)The Tribunal was not satisfied that it is in the best interests of the applicant’s daughter that his visa not be refused (at [50]-[80]).(5)With respect to paragraph 11.3 of Direction No. 65, the applicant has not met the expectation that as a non-citizen he will obey the laws of this country. He spent a substantial time in prison and on parole, and committed the serious offences earlier referred to. That consideration weighs against a decision that the applicant’s visa not be refused (at [81]-[86]).(6)The Tribunal did not consider that there were any other considerations of material relevance to the present case. Besides his daughter, the applicant has no other family members in Australia (at [87]). The findings summarised at (4) and (5) above are in issue on the application for judicial review.4. CONSIDERATION4.1 Grounds 1 and 2: Best interests of the applicant’s daughter4.1.1The Tribunal’s reasons With respect to the conclusion reached regarding the best interests of the child, the Tribunal’s reasons were as follows. (1)The applicant’s daughter has significant special needs resulting in among other things severe behavioural difficulties (at [52]). The Tribunal considered that “[t]he evidence is very clear that Mr Nigam’s daughter requires stability and routine. Any change to her daily activities and patterns causes her great distress.” (at [53]). (2)The Tribunal found that it was plain, that her mother, Ms B, loves and cares for her daughter very much (at [56]). The Tribunal also accepted that caring for a child with special needs is challenging, that Ms B may need to seek help from others at times and occasionally respite care, and that she feels that she would be assisted by the applicant’s more active participation in their daughter’s upbringing. However, the Tribunal found that “[s]he has coped without [Mr Nigam] and alone for a significant period of time and I have no doubt that she can continue to do so”(Tribunal reasons at [58]). (3)A registered psychologist gave evidence that Mr Nigam’s daughter needs as much support as possible and ideally a direct parental relationship. She opined that “…it is in the child’s best interest for Mr Nigam to remain in Australia, if a number of optimal conditions transpired (‘the Optimal Conditions’)” (emphasis in the original). Ten Optimal Conditions were identified, relating to the extent, constancy and nature of contact between Mr Nigam and his daughter (at [59]). (4)In finding at [60] of its reasons that on balance it was not satisfied that the Optimal Conditions are likely to materialise, the Tribunal looked at a number of factors. These included the extent of contact that Mr Nigam had had with his daughter, acknowledging positive increases in that contact since his incarceration (increased phone contact and a successful home visit), and that he had recently provided increased financial support for his daughter in excess of his required child support payments. While Mr Nigam also gave evidence that he intends to move closer to his daughter and increase his custodial care and/or visitations, the Tribunal found that “[t]his, however is currently hypothetical and, as he says, dependent on finances. There is no clear plan at present for Mr Nigam to move closer to [Ms B] and his daughter, nor for them to move closer to Mr Nigam.” (at [67]). The Tribunal also took into account that:(a)despite Mr Nigam’s evidence that he wished and intended to be involved in his daughter’s schooling and to help her with her learning difficulties, he had not taken steps to contact her teachers;(b)“[i]t is plain that at the time that he committed the offence [in January 2005], he gave little, if any, consideration to the well-being of his family…” (at [70]);(c)despite Mr Nigam’s best intentions, “his role as a positive parental figure is largely untested. He has spent the majority of her life either incarcerated, on parole or detained. How he would respond to the daily challenges of fatherhood is mostly unknown.” (at [73]);(d)the applicant’s history of abusive (not physical) conduct towards the mother is also concerning (at [74]); (e)any future criminal or other serious misconduct, whether directly or indirectly involving the mother and his daughter, could have a serious negative impact on his daughter’s stability, routine and well-being (at [75]);(f)whilst Mr Nigam’s daughter may have some difficulties at school, there is no evidence upon which the Tribunal could be satisfied that her difficulties or behaviour will worsen without Mr Nigam’s direct parental involvement (at [76]);(g)the Tribunal did not accept Mr Nigam’s evidence that contacting his daughter from India would be very difficult, finding that his claims are mostly unfounded and unsupported by evidence (at [77]);(h)nor was there any evidence that could support the applicant’s contention that he may not be able to support his daughter financially due to difficulties in finding work in India (at [78]). (5)The Tribunal concluded on this factor that:79. On balance, I am not satisfied it is in the best interests of Mr Nigam’s daughter that his visa not be refused. 80. This consideration weighs against a decision that Mr Nigam’s visa not be refused.4.1.2Preliminary matters

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The findings summarised at (4) and (5) above are in issue on the application for judicial review.4. CONSIDERATION4.1 Grounds 1 and 2: Best interests of the applicant’s daughter4.1.1The Tribunal’s reasons With respect to the conclusion reached regarding the best interests of the child, the Tribunal’s reasons were as follows. (1)The applicant’s daughter has significant special needs resulting in among other things severe behavioural difficulties (at [52]). The Tribunal considered that “[t]he evidence is very clear that Mr Nigam’s daughter requires stability and routine. Any change to her daily activities and patterns causes her great distress.” (at [53]). (2)The Tribunal found that it was plain, that her mother, Ms B, loves and cares for her daughter very much (at [56]). The Tribunal also accepted that caring for a child with special needs is challenging, that Ms B may need to seek help from others at times and occasionally respite care, and that she feels that she would be assisted by the applicant’s more active participation in their daughter’s upbringing. However, the Tribunal found that “[s]he has coped without [Mr Nigam] and alone for a significant period of time and I have no doubt that she can continue to do so”(Tribunal reasons at [58]). (3)A registered psychologist gave evidence that Mr Nigam’s daughter needs as much support as possible and ideally a direct parental relationship. She opined that “…it is in the child’s best interest for Mr Nigam to remain in Australia, if a number of optimal conditions transpired (‘the Optimal Conditions’)” (emphasis in the original). Ten Optimal Conditions were identified, relating to the extent, constancy and nature of contact between Mr Nigam and his daughter (at [59]). (4)In finding at [60] of its reasons that on balance it was not satisfied that the Optimal Conditions are likely to materialise, the Tribunal looked at a number of factors. These included the extent of contact that Mr Nigam had had with his daughter, acknowledging positive increases in that contact since his incarceration (increased phone contact and a successful home visit), and that he had recently provided increased financial support for his daughter in excess of his required child support payments. While Mr Nigam also gave evidence that he intends to move closer to his daughter and increase his custodial care and/or visitations, the Tribunal found that “[t]his, however is currently hypothetical and, as he says, dependent on finances. There is no clear plan at present for Mr Nigam to move closer to [Ms B] and his daughter, nor for them to move closer to Mr Nigam.” (at [67]). The Tribunal also took into account that:(a)despite Mr Nigam’s evidence that he wished and intended to be involved in his daughter’s schooling and to help her with her learning difficulties, he had not taken steps to contact her teachers;(b)“[i]t is plain that at the time that he committed the offence [in January 2005], he gave little, if any, consideration to the well-being of his family…” (at [70]);(c)despite Mr Nigam’s best intentions, “his role as a positive parental figure is largely untested. He has spent the majority of her life either incarcerated, on parole or detained. How he would respond to the daily challenges of fatherhood is mostly unknown.” (at [73]);(d)the applicant’s history of abusive (not physical) conduct towards the mother is also concerning (at [74]); (e)any future criminal or other serious misconduct, whether directly or indirectly involving the mother and his daughter, could have a serious negative impact on his daughter’s stability, routine and well-being (at [75]);(f)whilst Mr Nigam’s daughter may have some difficulties at school, there is no evidence upon which the Tribunal could be satisfied that her difficulties or behaviour will worsen without Mr Nigam’s direct parental involvement (at [76]);(g)the Tribunal did not accept Mr Nigam’s evidence that contacting his daughter from India would be very difficult, finding that his claims are mostly unfounded and unsupported by evidence (at [77]);(h)nor was there any evidence that could support the applicant’s contention that he may not be able to support his daughter financially due to difficulties in finding work in India (at [78]). (5)The Tribunal concluded on this factor that:79. On balance, I am not satisfied it is in the best interests of Mr Nigam’s daughter that his visa not be refused. 80. This consideration weighs against a decision that Mr Nigam’s visa not be refused.4.1.2Preliminary matters