Newton v Australian Postal Corporation (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Newton v Australian Postal Corporation (No 2) [2019] FCA 2192

File number: VID 876 of 2017
Judge: BROMBERG  J
Date of judgment: 23 December 2019
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“FW Act”), ss 340, 348 and 355 – where in reliance upon s 348 union representative alleged to have made threats to take action against employer with intent to coerce employer to engage in industrial activity, being removal of employee from position and cessation of a project (“project”) – where in reliance upon s 355 union representative also alleged to have made threats to take action against employer with intent to coerce employer not to allocate employee duties of his position – where employee removed from his position and duties by his employer and project cancelled – discussion as to what constitutes a “threat” for purposes of ss 348 and 355 of FW Act – discussion of meaning of “intent to coerce” in ss 348 and 355 – discussion of 361(1) of FW Act: presumption that action taken for a particular reason or intent unless proven otherwise – to which elements or ingredients of a cause of action under ss 348 and 355 is s 361(1) applicable – the pre-conditions to the engagement of s 361(1) – whether s 361(1) can apply to a threat – discussion of standard of proof necessary for contravention of FW Act – whether pleading admissions made by one party can be used against another party in a joint trial – whether threats, as alleged, made by union representative – whether applicant engaged s 361(1) by making requisite allegation regarding union representative’s intent – whether threat made with intent to coerce – discussion of pleadings deficiencies – whether applicant discharged his onus to establish use of unlawful, illegitimate or unconscionable means by union representative – whether employer and manager accessorily liable under s 550 of FW Act – adverse action – FW Act s 340: where alleged that employee removed from position for reasons that include that employee had a workplace right – applicable legal principles discussed – whether adverse actions (removal of employee from his position and exclusion of employee from work) taken including because of employee’s workplace right to a safe working environment

CONTRACTS – where employee contracted to be employed in specific position – where contract provided that employer may require employee to occupy alternative “suitable” position – where removed from contracted position – whether employer removing employee from contracted position without placing employee into a suitable alternative position was a breach of contract – discussion of meaning of suitable alternative position – whether suitable alternative position offered to employee – where direction that employee excluded from work pending medical clearance – whether direction in breach of contract 

DAMAGES – contractual claim: principles regarding damages for breach of contract – principles of causation –  whether loss should be characterised as a loss of chance or loss of bargain – whether…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Newton v Australian Postal Corporation (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 2192
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court was presented with a case brought by Michael Newton against the Australian Postal Corporation and the Communications, Electrical and Plumbing Union. Newton alleged that the Union representative, Metcher, made threats to coerce the Corporation into removing him from his position and cancelling a project. Newton further alleged that Metcher also threatened action to prevent the Corporation from assigning him duties. The case hinged on whether these threats constituted a contravention of sections 348 and 355 of the Fair Work Act 2009, and if the Corporation and the Union were liable for the actions of Metcher. Additionally, Newton claimed that his removal from his position and the cancellation of the project amounted to adverse action under section 340 of the Act. The court also needed to determine if the Corporation breached its contractual obligations by removing Newton from his position and excluding him from work.

The court examined the meaning of a "threat" and "intent to coerce" within the context of the Act, and considered the applicability of section 361(1) of the Act, which presumes action taken for a particular reason unless proven otherwise. The standard of proof necessary for a contravention of the Act was also debated, along with the admissibility of pleading admissions made by one party against another in a joint trial. The court assessed whether the threats, as alleged, were indeed made by Metcher, and if Newton sufficiently established the use of unlawful, illegitimate, or unconscionable means by the Union representative. Furthermore, the court deliberated on whether the Corporation and manager were accessorily liable under section 550 of the Act, and if the adverse actions taken were due to Newton's workplace right to a safe working environment.

In terms of contract law, the court considered whether removing Newton from his contracted position without providing a suitable alternative breached the employment contract. The meaning of a "suitable alternative position" and whether one was offered to Newton were also examined. The court assessed whether a direction excluding Newton from work pending medical clearance breached the contract.

Finally, the court discussed principles of damages for breach of contract, causation, loss of chance or loss of bargain, and remoteness of damage. The court considered whether intervening events broke the chain of causation, and if Newton's attempts to gain employment following termination involved a failure to mitigate loss. The court also determined if Newton was entitled to general damages.

The court found that Metcher's threats did not constitute a contravention of sections 348 and 355 of the Fair Work Act, and that Newton had not discharged his onus to establish the use of unlawful, illegitimate, or unconscionable means by the Union representative. The court also ruled that the Corporation and manager were not accessorily liable under section 550 of the Act, and that the adverse actions taken were not due to Newton's workplace right to a safe working environment.

In relation to the contract claims, the court held that removing Newton from his contracted position without placing him into a suitable alternative position was a breach of contract. However, it was determined that Newton was not entitled to general damages as he had failed to mitigate his loss. The court ordered the parties to file an outline of any witness evidence or a statement of agreed facts regarding Newton's earnings and employment circumstances post-November 2018, or a minute of the orders they proposed should be made. The proceeding was then listed for further hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On or before 24 January 2020, the applicant and the first respondent:

(i) file and serve an outline of any witness evidence dealing with the applicant’s earnings and employment circumstances post-November 2018 that the party seeks to rely upon; or in the alternative

(ii) file a statement of agreed facts dealing with those matters; or in the further alternative

(iii) should there be agreement on the quantum of damages and interest payable reflective of the findings made by the Court, file a minute of the orders those parties propose should be made.

2. Subject to any further order, the proceeding be listed for further hearing on a date to be fixed in the week of 3 February 2020.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Further in pleading Fahour’s reason for removing Michael Newton from his position as National Compensation Manager, the APC respondents say that during the course of the phone call on 5 February 2016, Metcher said to Fahour words to the effect that “[Michael Newton] had a personal zealotry to hurt injured workers the subject of Project Dove and that [Metcher] was angry with [Michael Newton]” and “that [Michael Newton] was the cause of problems that [Metcher] perceived with [APC’s] workers’ compensation function”. The pleadings of the APC respondents also state that during the phone call, Metcher expressed anger and volatility, including specifically towards Michael Newton.The Facts The only direct evidence of the conversation on 5 February 2016 between Fahour and Metcher was given by Fahour. Metcher was not called. At the time that he gave his evidence, Fahour was no longer employed by APC and was working as the Managing Director and CEO of a financial services company. Fahour first commenced employment with APC in February 2010 in the role of Managing Director and CEO. That was the role he held at the time of the conversation with Metcher. Before dealing with the conversation itself, there are some background matters that Fahour and others gave evidence about which provide a relevant context. APC utilised over 50,000 direct and indirect employees. It had, at the time, a 4 level management structure with about 10 people on an executive committee and a second layer of 30-40 managers at a management committee level. Walsh was at that level. There was a third level, the “senior leadership team” of about 200 managers, followed by a fourth level of some 1,000 managers. Michael Newton was at that fourth level. Whilst Fahour had regular contact with Walsh, he had no prior contact with or knowledge of Michael Newton before 5 February 2016. Fahour deposed that in late 2013/early 2014, APC began to develop a reform program (“APC reform program”) designed to save thousands of jobs and APC’s business from looming significant financial loss. The APC reform program was designed to transform APC from being a letter delivery company to a parcel delivery company. It was described by Fahour as the largest reform in APC’s history. The Commonwealth Parliament approved the APC reform program in late 2015 and the implementation of those reforms began in January 2016. Of the 30,000 or so employees directly employed by APC, Fahour deposed of his understanding that around 22,000 were members of the CEPU. The primary contact with the CEPU was through its National Secretary but contact on State-based issues occurred with other officials. In relation to New South Wales, where the largest number of employees of APC resided, the contact for him and APC was largely with Metcher. Fahour described his understanding of Metcher as someone who had a very long history in the CEPU. He said that what struck him most about Metcher when he met him was that he almost had an obsession with the everyday employee, those at the bottom of the income pile, for whom he felt a special connection. Fahour considered that he had very professional dealings throughout most of the time he interacted with Metcher until the APC reform program began, when Metcher seemed concerned about how management was going about the path of reform. He described Metcher as “cynical”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

These reasons are broadly divided into two sections – the first deals with the statutory claims made by Michael Newton (other than relating to the Garden leave decision) and the second deals with his contractual claims. Many of the facts are relevant, at least by way of background, to both the statutory and the contractual claims as well as the statutory claim made in respect of the Garden leave decision. Nevertheless, given the chronological order of the most significant events, it is convenient that I record those facts primarily of relevance to the statutory claims (other than the Garden leave decision) in the first section of these reasons and likewise deal with the facts of primary relevance to the remainder of the claims in the second section of these reasons. The overlapping relevance of many of the facts recorded should not, however, be overlooked. SECTIONS 348 AND 355 CLAIMS – REMOVAL DECISION AND CANCELLATION OF PROJECT DOVE Michael Newton alleges three separate contraventions of ss 348 and 355 of the FW Act by Metcher and the CEPU. What was communicated by Metcher to Fahour when they spoke by telephone on 5 February 2016 is critical to Michael Newton’s success on these claims. Michael Newton alleges that Metcher said that he would: (1)leak documents about “Project Dove” to the media and politicians;(2)arrange protest rallies about “Project Dove”;(3)take APC to the cleaners;(4)take serious industrial action; and (5)take legal actionunless Fahour cancelled Project Dove and removed Michael Newton from his role as National Compensation Manager. The contraventions of ss 348 and 355 of the FW Act are alleged on the basis that Metcher said to Fahour that, unless Fahour cancelled Project Dove and removed Michael Newton from his position as National Compensation Manager, Metcher would carry out the threatened actions detailed above. The alleged contraventions are said to be as follows:(1)A contravention of s 348 by reason of Metcher making threats to take action against APC with intent to coerce APC to engage in “industrial activity”, namely, complying with a lawful request (s 347(b)(iv)) or, alternatively, an unlawful request (s 347(e)) made by the CEPU to APC for Michael Newton to be removed from his position as National Compensation Manager.(2)A contravention of s 355 of the FW Act by reason of Metcher threatening to take action with intent to coerce APC not to allocate to Michael Newton the duties and responsibilities or not to designate Michael Newton as having the duties and responsibilities of the role of National Compensation Manager.(3)A contravention of s 348 of the FW Act by reason of Metcher making threats to take action against APC with intent to coerce APC to engage in “industrial activity”, namely, complying with a lawful request (s 347(b)(iv)) made by the CEPU to APC for Project Dove to be cancelled. Insofar as the CEPU is concerned, and in reliance on ss 363(1)(b) and 793(1)(a) of the FW Act, Michael Newton alleges that the actions of Metcher were the actions of the CEPU and that therefore the CEPU contravened ss 348 and 355 on each occasion that those provisions were contravened by Metcher. Insofar as APC and Fahour are concerned, and in reliance on s 550 of the FW Act, Michael Newton alleges that they were “involved in” each of Metcher’s contraventions set out above, such that they themselves are taken to have contravened those provisions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Fahour’s evidence was that he was sitting in his car on the afternoon of 5 February 2016, possibly in Sydney, when he participated in the call with Metcher. He was not sure who called whom and he did not know how long the call lasted. His evidence was that White and the proposed Leanne White Review, Project Dove, Michael Newton and the APC reform process were all discussed. Fahour deposed that the majority of the conversation was about “the workers’ compensation system”. He said that Metcher was obsessively concerned about what he perceived to be the injustice in relation to White. Fahour then said that towards the back end of the call the conversation turned to Project Dove and Michael Newton. Given the importance of the conversation it is best that the account given in chief by Fahour be set out largely in full. For ease of reference I have emphasised some elements I consider to be most significant:he – he raised once again – he said – and really he said, ‘You know, [Fahour], you know, you’ve gotten through the Parliament this reform program of yours and you’ve made all these promises about saving people’s jobs and it’s all about, you know, transferring them over and that’s what your intention – that you told them was, but here you are in the background working out how you’re going to hurt the most vulnerable of your employees and our members and those that are injured.’ And I said, ‘What are you talking about?’ He said, ‘Operation Dove.’ And I said – I said, ‘Is this a joke? What is Operation Dove?’ He said, ‘You know what it is.’ I said, ‘I have no clue. I haven’t heard what it is. You know, I – I tried to get hold of [Walsh] to find out and I have not been able to get an answer. So what are you talking about?’And what did he say?---Well, he said, ‘You’re – I’ve got some slides and it shows that you’re planning, through this operation, to fire 3000 or so people so that you can save a tonne of money and you think by saving that money, you’re going to save [APC] but you’re going to do it on the back of the most vulnerable, injured, hurt people in the company. These are the posties, the staff members.’ He – and – and he said some, you know, some words against me.Doing the best you can, what can you remember the words – about the words he used and what he said?---Well, when – when Mr Metcher is angry, his language can be quite vile and he was upset because he thought – he thought, and I might say completely wrongly, that I was somehow secretly plotting behind the scenes to – to – to fire the people that I have spent five years working on to help and support and to take care of. And he – he – he then said words to the effect, ‘You know, do you not have any morals? Do you have any values? How could you do this to these people? These are – these have given their heart and soul to the company and look what you’re doing to them’, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And then the first time, you know, he mentioned any other name – then he said – then the next person he went after was Catherine Walsh and he said, ‘I’ve worked with her for all these years and I can’t believe that she’s turning her back, as the head of HR, on these injured people.’And did he mention anyone else from [APC]?---He mentioned very much in passing – and he said something to the effect, ‘And your henchman,’ something – some word to that effect, ‘Michael Newton’s doing all your dirty work for you in this analysis that I’ve got here or in these spreadsheets that I’ve got here or these slides,’ or something to that effect.And did you say anything in response to that?---I said, ‘How can I have somebody doing my dirty work for me in the background when I don’t even know who he is?’ He said, ‘You know who he is. He’s done all this work for you.’ And I said, ‘I don’t.’ And then because he could see that I actually [sic] no answer, he then went back at that point to accusing [Walsh] and I of all sorts of accusations that, quite frankly, are a bit unfair and, well, that are wrong, but just not very nice. Again, what can you recall about the words he used in making any accusations?---He was just really, really angry that we were lying, that we were deceiving the Australian people about our true intention of how we were going to save [APC]. He thought that we were going to fire and hurt the livelihoods of all these injured people who were the most vulnerable. He – he was deeply and emotionally – beyond anything I’ve ever seen in my life felt that he was the last man standing to take care of these 3000 people. And I said to him, ‘[Metcher], I remind you these are my staff and I don’t need you to tell me this point. I will take care of my own people.’Can you recall anything else that he said during the call, anything else that you said to him?---I raised several times an opportunity to do this – this – the – a more thorough review about how we can do this, about how we can tackle the Workers’ Compensation review. And then, he said to me along the lines, you know, you –‘You’re about to launch this Operation Dove and I’m going to make sure that I expose you and all your staff for what you’re about to do.’ And I said to him, ‘I think you’re exaggerating, and there’s nothing going to occur about this because I don’t know anything about it.’ So he was very focused on – he thought there was something imminent that he had stumbled upon that we were about to do, and he couldn’t be further from the truth.