Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Maman

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Maman [2012] FCAFC 13

Citation: Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Maman [2012] FCAFC 13
Appeal from: Maman v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] FMCA 426
Parties: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP v JIMMY MAMAN AND ANOR
File number: NSD 1051 of 2011
Judges: FLICK, FOSTER AND KATZMANN JJ
Date of judgment: 28 February 2012
Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – common law rules of procedural fairness – no disclosure of letter – relevant and significant – no continuing obligation of confidentiality

MIGRATION – Judicial review of Migration Review Tribunal decision — refusal of partner residence visa —domestic violence claim — procedural fairness —receipt by Department of prejudicial letter from sponsor — two opinions of independent expert that applicant was not a victim of domestic violence committed by sponsor — Tribunal considered itself bound by opinion — whether opinion formed in denial of procedural fairness — whether procedural fairness required letter or its substance to be disclosed to applicant — whether information in letter was “credible, relevant and significant”

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – notice of contention – need to “specify briefly” the grounds relied on

Legislation: Customs Act1901 (Cth)
Family Law Act1975 (Cth)
Migration Act1958 (Cth) ss 29, 30, 31, 65, 348, 349, 357A, 359, 359A, 440
Federal Court Rules O 52 r 22
Federal Court Rules2011 r 36.24
Migration Amendment Regulations 2007 (No 13) (Cth)
Migration Amendment Regulations 2009 (No 7) (Cth)
Migration Amendment Regulations 2009 (No 12) (Cth) reg. 6
Migration Regulations1994 (Cth) reg. 1.21, reg. 1.23, reg. 3.2, Schedule 2 clause 801.221
Co-Operation Act 1923 (NSW)
Cases cited:

Annetts v McCann (1990) 170 CLR 596, cited.
Ansell v Wells (1982) 63 FLR 127, considered.
Applicant VEAL of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2005] HCA 72, 225 CLR 88, considered.
Canterbury Building Society Ltd v Baker [1979] 2 NSWLR 265, considered.
Chu v Minister for Immigration, Local Government, and Ethnic Affairs (1993) 45 FCR 540, considered.
Commissioner of Police v Tanos (1958) 98 CLR 383, cited.
Executive Director of the Office of Liquor and Gaming Regulation v Cayneston Pty Ltd [2011] QCA 193, cited.
Hamblin v Duffy (No 2) (1981) 55 FLR 228, cited.
Jackson v Purton [2011] TASSC 28, cited.
Jadwan Pty Ltd v Secretary, Department of Health and Aged Care [2003] FCAFC 288, 145 FCR 1, considered.
Johns v Australian Securities Commission (1993) 178 CLR 408, considered.
Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550, considered.
Leghaei v Director General of Security [2005] FCA 1576, considered.
Leghaei v Director General of Security [2007] FCAFC 37, 97 ALD 516, considered.
Ma v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FCAFC 69, cited.
Maman v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] FMCA 426, reversing.
Marine Power Australia Pty Ltd v Comptroller-General of Customs (1989) 89 ALR 561, considered.
McVeigh v Willarra…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Maman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCAFC 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Maman involves an Israeli citizen, Jimmy Maman, who applied for a partner residence visa in Australia, sponsored by his Australian citizen wife, Ruth Seagull. The dispute centres on the refusal of Maman's visa application by the Migration Review Tribunal, which was affirmed by the Federal Magistrates Court. The Tribunal's decision was based on two independent expert opinions that Maman was not a victim of domestic violence, a criterion necessary for the visa grant under the Migration Regulations. The Tribunal considered itself bound by these opinions, leading Maman to appeal the decision to the Federal Court. The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Tribunal's consideration of the independent expert opinions without disclosing the prejudicial letter written by Seagull to the Department of Immigration constituted a breach of procedural fairness, and whether such information needed to be disclosed to Maman.

The Federal Court found that the Tribunal did indeed breach procedural fairness by failing to disclose the letter or its substance to Maman. The Court held that the information in the letter, which cast doubt on the genuineness of the marriage and alleged threats of violence by Maman, was credible, relevant, and significant. The Court reasoned that while the Tribunal was not obliged to accept the content of the letter as true, it should have at least informed Maman of its existence and the basis of the expert opinions. This failure denied Maman the opportunity to respond adequately to the allegations against him, thereby violating the principles of natural justice. Consequently, the Court concluded that the Tribunal's decision was flawed due to this procedural error.

The Court decided to dismiss Maman's appeal on the grounds of procedural fairness but noted the uncertainty regarding the Tribunal's authority to obtain its own independent opinion. To resolve this uncertainty and ensure the matter is determined according to law, the Court proposed setting aside the Tribunal's decision and remitting the matter to the Migration Review Tribunal for reconsideration. Pending any submissions from the parties on the appropriate form of orders, the Court directed that any party wishing to comment on the proposed orders must file a written submission by 6 March 2012, limited to two pages. The Court will then determine the final form of the orders based on the submissions received.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties are to file, on or before 6 March 2012, any submission as to the appropriateness of the proposed orders set out in paragraph [69], any such submission is to be of no more than two pages in length.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The argument, however, sought to be advanced by way of the Notice of Contention was apparently a contention that the independent expert formed an erroneous view as to what constitutes “domestic violence”. Given the facts set forth by the independent experts, it was understood that Mr Maman wished to contend that such facts did not amount to “domestic violence”. The merit of any such argument is unnecessary to resolve. CONCLUSIONS It follows that the appeal must be dismissed. A question necessarily arises, however, as to the form of orders to be made. Given the conclusions reached in respect of the denial of procedural fairness and the uncertainty that arises as to the power of the Tribunal to itself obtain its own independent “opinion”, it is tentatively considered that – in addition to dismissing the appeal – the decision of the delegate which was affirmed by the Tribunal should also be set aside and the matter be remitted to the Appellant to be determined according to law. For these reasons, subject to hearing further from the parties, the following orders would be the appropriate orders for the Court to make in the present case, namely orders that:1.The appeal is dismissed.2.Order 2 made by Federal Magistrate Raphael on 8 June 2011 is set aside. 3.The decision of the delegate as notified on 25 November 2009 is set aside.4.The First Respondent’s application as made on 15 May 2005 is remitted to the Appellant for determination in accordance with law.5.The Appellant is to pay the costs of the first respondent. Neither party suggested that the decision of the delegate should be set aside nor did the Court raise that possibility at the hearing of the appeal. It is considered that the parties should be given an opportunity to address that question, should any of them be of a mind to do so, before final orders are made. For this reason, the only order proposed at present is an order directing any party who wishes to make a submission as to the appropriateness of the proposed orders set out in [69] above file and serve by 6 March 2012 a written submission of no more than two (2) pages in length directed to the form of orders proposed. The Court will thereafter determine the form of the final orders on the papers. Jimmy Maman is an Israeli citizen, born in Morocco. He arrived in Australia on a tourist visa in December 2003. He later met Ruth Seagull, an Australian citizen born in Israel, whom he married on 15 May 2005. The same day, sponsored by Ms Seagull, he applied for a Partner (Temporary) (Class UK) Subclass 820 (Spouse) visa and a Partner (Residence) (Class BS) Subclass 801 (Spouse) visa. He was granted a temporary visa but the marriage broke down before his application for a residence visa was determined. Without his knowledge, on 3 March 2006 Ms Seagull wrote to the Department of Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (later renamed Immigration and Citizenship), notifying it that the relationship was over. In the letter Ms Seagull cast doubts on the genuineness of the relationship and reported that her husband had made violent threats against her. She concluded the letter with the statement:I am hoping [scil.] that this letter will not risk in any way the safety of me or my son as I am fearful from Jimmy and his future action in regard to this matter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Central to the resolution of both of the Grounds of Appeal is the question as to whether Ms Seagull’s letter should have been disclosed to the First Respondent during the course of the second independent expert preparing her report. Although attention was mainly focussed upon the second opinion which had been obtained, there is little reason to conclude that any different considerations apply to the first of the two opinions. THE MIGRATION ACT AND REGULATIONS – THE INDEPENDENT EXPERT The starting point for any consideration of a decision to grant or refuse a visa is to be found in the discretion conferred upon the Minister to do so if he is “satisfied” that “criteria … prescribed by this Act or the regulations have been satisfied”: Migration Act1958 (Cth) s 65(1)(a)(ii). The decision-making process in the present proceeding involved the delegate’s consideration of the request under cl. 801.221 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations. Clause 801.221 sets forth the “criteria to be satisfied at time of decision”. Relevantly cl. 801.221(6)(c) provided at the relevant time as follows:An applicant meets the requirements of this subclause if:…(c)either or both of the following circumstances applies:(i) either or both of the following :(A)the applicant;(B)…has suffered domestic violence committed by the sponsoring spouse;…The Migration Regulations, it should be noted, have also been amended from time to time. The form of reg. 1.23 of the Migration Regulations as it applied to Mr Maman’s application relevantly referred to “domestic violence”. Pursuant to amendments effected by the Migration Amendment Regulations 2007 (No 13), the phrase is now “family violence”. The Federal Magistrate, it should further be noted, erroneously referred to the regulations as amended. But nothing turns on that. The principles to be applied remain common to both. The regulations address a variety of different circumstances – including circumstances where an injunction has been granted under the Family Law Act1975 (Cth); where a court has made an order under a law of a State or Territory for the protection of the alleged victim from violence or where there has been a conviction for violence. The regulations prior to their amendment addressed in reg. 1.23(1A) what it then described as a “non-judicially determined claim of domestic violence”. Prior to the 2007 amendments, reg.1.23 addressed those circumstances in which a person contends that he has been the “victim” of “domestic violence” as follows:(1)For the purposes of these regulations: (a) a person (the alleged victim) is taken to have suffered domestic violence; and(b) another person (the alleged perpetrator) is taken to have committed domestic violence in relation to the alleged victim; if(c) on the application of the alleged victim, the court has granted an injunction under paragraph 114(1)(a), (b) or (c) of the Family Law Act 1975 against the alleged perpetrator; or (d) a court has made an order under a law of a State or Territory against the alleged perpetrator for the protection of the alleged victim from violence and, unless the alleged victim had, before 1 January 1998, claimed to Immigration to have suffered domestic violence committed by the alleged perpetrator, that order was made after the court had given the alleged perpetrator an opportunity to be heard, or otherwise to make submissions to the court, in relation to the matter; or(e) a court has convicted the alleged perpetrator of, or has recorded a finding of guilt against the alleged perpetrator in respect of, an offence of violence against the alleged victim, or(f) the Minister is satisfied, for paragraph (1B)(a), that the alleged victim has suffered relevant domestic violence; or(g) the Minister is required by subregulation (1C) to take as correct an opinion of an independent expert that the alleged victim has suffered relevant domestic violence.(1A)For these regulations, an application for a visa is taken to include a non-judicially determined claim of domestic violence if:(a) the applicant seeks to satisfy a prescribed criterion that the applicant, or another person mentioned in the criterion, has suffered domestic violence; and(b) either of the following circumstances exists:(i)the alleged victim and the alleged perpetrator have made a joint undertaking to a court in relation to proceedings in which an allegation is before the court that the alleged perpetrator has committed an act of violence against the alleged victim;(ii)for an alleged victim who is a person referred to in subregulation (2) ­– the alleged victim or another person on the alleged victim’s behalf has presented evidence in accordance with regulation 1.24 that:(A)the alleged victim has suffered relevant domestic violence; and(B)the alleged perpetrator has committed that relevant domestic violence.(1B) If an application for a visa includes a non-judicially determined claim of domestic violence, the Minister must consider whether the alleged victim has suffered relevant domestic violence (whichever of the circumstances mentioned in paragraph (1A)(b) exists) and:(a) if satisfied that the alleged victim has suffered relevant domestic violence –­ consider the application on that basis; or(b) if not satisfied that the alleged victim has suffered relevant domestic violence –­ seek the opinion of an independent expert about whether the alleged victim has suffered relevant domestic violence.(1C)The Minister must take an independent expert’s opinion on the matter mentioned in paragraph (1B)(b) to be correct for the purposes of deciding whether the alleged victim satisfied a prescribed criterion for a visa that requires the applicant for the visa, or another person mentioned in the criterion, to have suffered domestic violence.