Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v Roberts

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Military Rehabilitation & Compensation Commission v Roberts
[2007] FCA 1

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – Commonwealth employees’ entitlement to compensation – employment related injury, disability or disease – arising out of employment – meaning of s 6(1)(a) of Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

DEFENCE AND WAR – defence forces – compensation for injuries and other civil actions

Held:   the respondent’s injury arose out of her employment by virtue of the ‘but for’ test mandated by s 6(1)(a) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

‘Injury arising out of employee’s employment’  

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) s 4, s 6(1)(a)

Bull v Attorney-General (NSW) (1913) 17 CLR 370 followed
Esso v Commissioner of Taxation (1998) 83 FCR 511 followed
Kennedy v Telstra Corporation (1995) 61 FCR 160 discussed

Roncevich v Repatriation Commission (2005) 222 CLR 115 distinguished and applied
Schmid v Comcare (2004) 77 ALD 782 discussed

MILITARY REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION COMMISSION v MICHELLE ROBERTS
ACD 1 OF 2006

MADGWICK J
8 JANUARY 2007
SYDNEY (HEARD IN CANBERRA)

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

ACD 1 OF 2006

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED BY A SENIOR MEMBER

BETWEEN:

MILITARY REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

MICHELLE ROBERTS
Respondent

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 JANUARY 2007

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY (HEARD IN CANBERRA))

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed with costs.

THE COURT ORDERS, BY CONSENT, THAT:

2.Pursuant to Order 3 rule 3, Order 52 rule 15 be varied to extend the time for filing an application to appeal to 29 January 2007.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

ACD 1 OF 2006

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED BY A SENIOR MEMBER

BETWEEN:

MILITARY REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

MICHELLE ROBERTS
Respondent

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE:

8 JANUARY 2007

PLACE:

SYDNEY (HEARD IN CANBERRA)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

HIS HONOUR:

  1. On 15 December 2006 I delivered judgment in the matter, dismissing the application with costs.  I now provide reasons for that decision.

  2. This is an appeal from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) setting aside a decision of the applicant. In lieu of that decision, the Tribunal determined that pursuant to s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (‘the Act’), the respondent, Ms Roberts, was entitled to compensation in respect of post-traumatic stress disorder suffered in May 2000. That Tribunal decision was based on and applied an earlier decision of the Tribunal holding that an assault suffered by the respondent in May 2000 was an injury which arose out of her employment by the Royal Australian Air Force (‘RAAF’).

  3. This case concerns the meaning of the expression ‘arising out of … the employee’s employment’ in the definition of ‘injury’ in s 4 of the Act, the construction and operation of s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v Robert... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v Roberts, the Federal Court was asked to determine the meaning of the expression 'arising out of … the employee's employment' in the definition of 'injury' in s 4 of the Act, the construction and operation of s 6(1)(a) of the Act, and the sufficiency of the Tribunal's reasons for decision. Ms Roberts, who was enlisted in the RAAF, alleged that she was indecently assaulted by a colleague while she was living on base. She subsequently suffered a psychiatric condition and was medically discharged from the RAAF. The Tribunal found that the alleged assault had taken place, and the sole question for the Tribunal was whether the assault was an injury 'arising out of, or in the course of' the respondent's employment within the meaning of the Act.

The Court held that the respondent pointed to the decision of Cowdroy J in Coward v Military Compensation and Rehabilitation Service [2006] FCA 840, in which his Honour took an expansive view of the scope of military service in the context of living in barracks. The Court found that the requirement asserted by the applicant that the employee must show some elevation of the risk of the injury sustained, which elevation must result from the employment, was mistaken. Instead, it is enough that there can be shown, as a matter of common sense, some substantial link or connection with the employment which is causal and not merely temporal. The Court also found that s 6(1)(a) compelled the rejection of the applicant's case. The Court dismissed the application with costs and varied the time for filing an application to appeal to 29 January 2007.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed with costs.

THE COURT ORDERS, BY CONSENT, THAT:

2. Pursuant to Order 3 rule 3, Order 52 rule 15 be varied to extend the time for filing an application to appeal to 29 January 2007.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns the meaning of the expression ‘arising out of … the employee’s employment’ in the definition of ‘injury’ in s 4 of the Act, the construction and operation of s 6(1)(a) of the Act, and the sufficiency of the Tribunal’s reasons for decision.BACKGROUND Ms Roberts enlisted in the RAAF in 1997 at the age of 27. In 2000, she was a Leading Aircraft Woman working as a signals operator at the Defence Signals Directorate at Russell, Canberra. She had been officially permitted, although she was not required, to live ‘on base’, and was free to exercise her discretion as to her living arrangements. At the time of the events in question, she lived at the RAAF base known as RAAF Fairbairn in rented and subsidised accommodation provided by her employer. On 13 May 2000 the respondent was rostered ‘off duty’. During the evening she attended an informal social function at the Airmen’s Club at RAAF Fairbairn. The people attending the function were wearing civilian clothes and brought their own alcohol to the function. The respondent had some drinks at the function, and left to retire to bed at approximately 11 pm. At approximately 2.30 am on 14 May 2000 the Tribunal found that a man had entered her room uninvited through an open window in her quarters. The intruder indecently assaulted her but later left her room after she demanded that he do so. The respondent had recognised the man as one of her colleagues who lived in the same accommodation block, but in his own quarters across the hall. The respondent reported the incident to military police who conducted an investigation. The man in question was charged with military offences contrary to the Defence Force Discipline Act 1982 (Cth), but was later found not guilty. Ms Roberts suffered from a psychiatric condition as a consequence of the incident in her room and was medically discharged from the RAAF on 28 March 2003. However, she has now resumed full time employment and no longer suffers from that condition.The relevant Tribunal decision An agreed statement of facts was provided by the parties to the Tribunal. It said:‘1. The applicant was born on 12 October 1970.2.The applicant enlisted in the Royal Australian Air Force (“the RAAF”) on 16 November 1997.3.In the year 2000 the applicant was a Leading Aircraft Woman working as a signals operator at the Defence Signals Directorate at Russell, Canberra.4.The applicant was living at RAAF Fairbairn in rented accommodation.5.The applicant was not required to live on base and was free to exercise her discretion as to her living arrangements. 6.On 13 May 2000 the applicant was rostered “off duty”.7.On the evening of 13 May 2000 the applicant attended an informal social function at the Airman’s Club RAAF Fairbairn.8.The people attending the function were wearing civilian clothes and brought their own alcohol to the function.9.The applicant drank beer at the function and left to retire to bed at approximately 11 pm.10.At approximately 2.30 am on 14 May 2000 the applicant alleges a male person entered her room uninvited through an open window in her condominium.11.The applicant alleges the person indecently sexually assaulted her by touching her breasts and genital area.12.The male person later left her room after the applicant asked him to leave.13.The applicant recognised the male person as one of her colleagues who lived in the same accommodation block as the applicant but in his own condominium across the hall.14.The applicant reported the incident to the military police who conducted an investigation.15.The male person was charged with offences contrary to the Defence Force Discipline Act 1982 (“the DFDA”).16.On 11 May 2001 the male person was found not guilty of the charges of “act of indecent without consent” and “assault on superior” contrary to section 61 and subsection 25(1) of the DFDA.17.The applicant suffered from a psychiatric condition as a consequence of the incident described above.18.On 28 March 2003 the applicant was medically discharged from the RAAF.19.The applicant has now resumed full time employment and no longer suffers from a psychiatric condition.’

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MADGWICK J
Ms Roberts suffered from a psychiatric condition as a consequence of the incident in her room and was medically discharged from the RAAF on 28 March 2003. However, she has now resumed full time employment and no longer suffers from that condition.The relevant Tribunal decision An agreed statement of facts was provided by the parties to the Tribunal. It said:‘1. The applicant was born on 12 October 1970.2.The applicant enlisted in the Royal Australian Air Force (“the RAAF”) on 16 November 1997.3.In the year 2000 the applicant was a Leading Aircraft Woman working as a signals operator at the Defence Signals Directorate at Russell, Canberra.4.The applicant was living at RAAF Fairbairn in rented accommodation.5.The applicant was not required to live on base and was free to exercise her discretion as to her living arrangements. 6.On 13 May 2000 the applicant was rostered “off duty”.7.On the evening of 13 May 2000 the applicant attended an informal social function at the Airman’s Club RAAF Fairbairn.8.The people attending the function were wearing civilian clothes and brought their own alcohol to the function.9.The applicant drank beer at the function and left to retire to bed at approximately 11 pm.10.At approximately 2.30 am on 14 May 2000 the applicant alleges a male person entered her room uninvited through an open window in her condominium.11.The applicant alleges the person indecently sexually assaulted her by touching her breasts and genital area.12.The male person later left her room after the applicant asked him to leave.13.The applicant recognised the male person as one of her colleagues who lived in the same accommodation block as the applicant but in his own condominium across the hall.14.The applicant reported the incident to the military police who conducted an investigation.15.The male person was charged with offences contrary to the Defence Force Discipline Act 1982 (“the DFDA”).16.On 11 May 2001 the male person was found not guilty of the charges of “act of indecent without consent” and “assault on superior” contrary to section 61 and subsection 25(1) of the DFDA.17.The applicant suffered from a psychiatric condition as a consequence of the incident described above.18.On 28 March 2003 the applicant was medically discharged from the RAAF.19.The applicant has now resumed full time employment and no longer suffers from a psychiatric condition.’ Senior Member J W Constance found that the alleged assault had in fact taken place. The Member also noted that the respondent had lived at RAAF Fairbairn under a ‘Living In Policy’ which had been issued pursuant to s 9A of the Defence Act 1903 (Cth). The Tribunal Member found that at the time of the assault, the respondent was not required to ‘live in’, but had been granted permission to do so, and that this arrangement was to her financial advantage. The Commission had agreed that the assault fell within the concept of an ‘injury’ (other than a disease) for the purposes of the Act, on the basis that her psychiatric condition constituted a ‘mental injury’ within the meaning of par (b) of the definition of ‘injury’ in s 4 of the Act. The sole question for the Tribunal was whether the assault was an injury ‘arising out of, or in the course of’ the respondent’s employment within the meaning of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MADGWICK J

The respondent pointed, after the close of submissions, to the decision of Cowdroy J in Coward v Military Compensation and Rehabilitation Service [2006] FCA 840 in which, in obiter dicta, his Honour took an expansive view of the scope of military service in the context of living in barracks.CONSIDERATIONQuestion of law It is a question of law whether there is any evidence sufficient to find that a statutory test of the kind here in question has been complied with. This is not a case of ordinary words with a plain meaning but of a compound statutory concept employing what have become terms of legal art, or something close to them: Roncevich at 123. The revised questions of law are adequate to engage the Court’s jurisdiction. Had my conclusion been different, I would have reformulated them a little before answering them.‘Arising out of …’ Counsel for the applicant ably made a respectable argument as to the meaning of the phrase ‘injury … arising out of … the employee’s employment’. In the view I take it is neither necessary nor desirable that I resolve that question to finality. I am however inclined, on a tentative basis, to think that the requirement asserted by the applicant that the employee must show some elevation of the risk of the injury sustained, which elevation must result from the employment, is mistaken and that it is enough that there can be shown, as a matter of common sense, some substantial link or connection with the employment which is causal and not merely temporal. Among other things, some of the matters regarded by the High Court in Roncevich as relevant to the ‘arising out of … test’ were not, it would seem, of any notable relevance to a restricted view of causation, such as that urged by the applicant, but were relevant to the less restrictive view I am inclined to favour. Questions might, however, possibly arise as to whether the test so stated could, as a matter of law, be satisfied by the matters to which the Senior Member referred. Roncevich is, as the applicants argued, clearly distinguishable on the facts of the present case. The ‘in the course of the employment’ test was not available in that case. It might be thought that its facts would readily fit within such a conception. Such a factor may well assist to provide evidence also of a causal, as well as a temporal link. It must be acknowledged that, on the scant known facts, this case would, if it fits at all within the meaning of ‘arising out of ….’, without its s 6(1)(a) extension, sit at the very margins of the concept. It is unnecessary to proceed further down that track because, in my view, for the reasons I give below, s 6(1)(a) compels the rejection of the applicant’s case. It is undesirable to do so because many potentially relevant facts appear not to have been elucidated, for example: How long was Ms Roberts’ posting in Canberra? To what extent was there any real advantage to the military in having her quartered where she was? What was the extent of any encouragement by the RAAF for her to live on the Base as distinct from elsewhere? Had her assailant become drunk at the Base ‘Club’? Was the ‘Club’ organised by the Air Force? Were personnel smiled on, as in Roncevich, for drinking heartily or even more than that? Was the assailant, on that account, affected by liquor? Did disinhibition by liquor account for his behaviour? Was the respondent, on account of a RAAF-tolerated drinking culture, so affected? If so, did the influence of alcohol lead to any lack of care by her as to providing, unwittingly, the opportunity for her assailant to intrude upon her by leaving her window open on a May night in Canberra? Was she, at the time, subject to military discipline? Why was the matter solely investigated in a military context without calling in the civilian police? The answers to questions like these may have assisted one party or the other notwithstanding that, apparently, they were not forensically elucidated by either party for the Tribunal’s benefit. Section 6(1)(a)