Mandurah Enterprises Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
GUMMOW, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ

MANDURAH ENTERPRISES PTY LTD & ORS  APPELLANTS

AND

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION                   RESPONDENT

Mandurah Enterprises Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission
[2010] HCA 2
3 February 2010
P15/2009

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed in part.

2.Declare that:

(a)the taking order of 5 August 2003 made under s 177 of the Land Administration Act 1997 (WA) relating to:

(i)Lot 7 on Plan 8565, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1936 Folio 292 ("lot 7");

(ii)Lot 8 on Plan 8565, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1936 Folio 291 ("lot 8");

(iii) Lot 30 on Diagram 74229, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1838 Folio 943 ("lot 30"); and

(iv) Lot 49 on Plan 17900, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1957 Folio 286,

was invalid so far as it purported to apply to those portions of lots 7 and 8 zoned urban under the Peel Region Scheme and that portion of lot 30 zoned industrial under the Peel Region Scheme; and

(b)the interests of the appellants in those portions of lots 7 and 8 zoned urban under the Peel Region Scheme and in that portion of lot 30 zoned industrial under the Peel Region Scheme were not extinguished pursuant to s 179(b) of the Land Administration Act 1997 (WA) following registration of the taking order under s 179.

3.Set aside orders 1, 3, 4 and 5 of the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Western Australia made on 17 October 2008, save for so much of orders 1, 3 and 4 as allow the appeal in respect of the zoned portion of lot 30, and in lieu thereof order that:

(a)the appeal be allowed in respect of the zoned portions of lots 7 and 8; and

(b)the orders of the primary judge made on 23 February 2007 be set aside.

4. Respondent to pay one half of the appellants' costs in this Court, and one half of the appellants' costs in the Court of Appeal and at first instance.

5. The application for declaratory and other relief otherwise be referred back to the primary judge for determination in accordance with these reasons and orders.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Western Australia

Representation

R I Viner QC with L E Rowley for the appellants (instructed by Deacons Lawyers)

R M Mitchell SC with C S Bydder for the respondent (instructed by State Solicitor for Western Australia)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ.   This appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Western Australia ("the Court of Appeal") concerns the validity of a taking order which effected the compulsory acquisition of four lots of land,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mandurah Enterprises Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning C... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] HCA 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal concerning the compulsory acquisition of parts of several lots of land by the Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC). The dispute arose because portions of these lots, initially reserved under a town planning scheme for primary regional roads, were subsequently acquired for railway and primary regional road purposes. The landowners, Mandurah Enterprises Pty Ltd and others, challenged the validity of the acquisition, arguing that land reserved for one purpose could not be acquired for another, and questioning the validity of the acquisition under both the *Town Planning and Development Act 1928* (WA) and the *Land Administration Act 1997* (WA).

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the WAPC's compulsory acquisition of the whole lots was valid, particularly where portions were acquired for public works and other portions were acquired to avoid statutory obligations related to access, and whether the acquisition could be severed to uphold the valid parts while invalidating the invalid parts. Specifically, the court had to determine if the acquisition of land to avoid the obligation to construct railway crossings was incidental to the purpose of a public work, and if a single taking order could effect both valid and invalid acquisitions.

The High Court reasoned that the *Land Administration Act 1997* (WA) permitted the compulsory acquisition of land for the purposes of a public work. While the initial reservation of parts of the lots for regional roads was valid, the subsequent acquisition of the entirety of certain lots for railway and road purposes was partially invalid. The court found that the acquisition of the portions of lots zoned urban or industrial was invalid, as these acquisitions were not for the purposes of a public work. However, the acquisition of the portions of the lots reserved for regional roads and the entirety of Lot 49 were considered valid. The court noted that the common law principle of severance could potentially apply to distinguish between valid and invalid acquisitions within the same taking order, but ultimately found it unnecessary to definitively rule on severance given the specific relief granted.

The High Court allowed the appeal in part, declaring that the taking order of 5 August 2003 was invalid concerning the portions of Lots 7, 8, and 30 that were zoned urban or industrial under the Peel Region Scheme. Consequently, the interests of the appellants in these specific portions were not extinguished. The court set aside certain orders of the Court of Appeal and the primary judge, substituting them with declarations and referring the matter back to the primary judge for further determination. The respondent was ordered to pay half of the appellants' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed in part.

2. Declare that:

(a) the taking order of 5 August 2003 made under s 177 of the Land Administration Act 1997 (WA) relating to:

(i) Lot 7 on Plan 8565, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1936 Folio 292 ("lot 7");

(ii) Lot 8 on Plan 8565, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1936 Folio 291 ("lot 8");

(iii) Lot 30 on Diagram 74229, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1838 Folio 943 ("lot 30"); and

(iv) Lot 49 on Plan 17900, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1957 Folio 286,

was invalid so far as it purported to apply to those portions of lots 7 and 8 zoned urban under the Peel Region Scheme and that portion of lot 30 zoned industrial under the Peel Region Scheme; and

(b) the interests of the appellants in those portions of lots 7 and 8 zoned urban under the Peel Region Scheme and in that portion of lot 30 zoned industrial under the Peel Region Scheme were not extinguished pursuant to s 179(b) of the Land Administration Act 1997 (WA) following registration of the taking order under s 179.

3. Set aside orders 1, 3, 4 and 5 of the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Western Australia made on 17 October 2008, save for so much of orders 1, 3 and 4 as allow the appeal in respect of the zoned portion of lot 30, and in lieu thereof order that:

(a) the appeal be allowed in respect of the zoned portions of lots 7 and 8; and

(b) the orders of the primary judge made on 23 February 2007 be set aside.

4. Respondent to pay one half of the appellants' costs in this Court, and one half of the appellants' costs in the Court of Appeal and at first instance.

5. The application for declaratory and other relief otherwise be referred back to the primary judge for determination in accordance with these reasons and orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ HAYNE J
Estates Development Co Pty Ltd v State of Western Australia[29] supports the proposition that the challenged acquisitions by the taking order do not have to be considered in globo and that suggests that the common law principle of severance might be applied in the context of compulsory acquisition of land, at least in respect of different lots. Some of the difficulties in the application of the common law principle of severance have been pointed out in SST Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Rieson[30]. However, it is unnecessary to make any final determination on the issue of severance because relief applicable to the findings set out above in these reasons renders severance otiose. [29](1952) 87 CLR 126 at 142 per Dixon CJ, Webb and Kitto JJ; [1952] HCA 42; see also Thames Water Authority v Elmbridge Borough Council [1983] QB 570 at 577‑581 per Dunn LJ, 583-585 per Dillon LJ, 585-586 per Stephenson LJ.[30](2006) 225 CLR 516 at 530 [43] per Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Heydon and Crennan JJ; [2006] HCA 31.Conclusions The taking order of 5 August 2003 is valid in respect of the reserved portions of lots 7, 8 and 30 and the whole of lot 49. It is invalid in respect of the zoned portions of lots 7, 8 and 30. This result constitutes substantial but partial success for the appellants as the WAPC's submissions have succeeded in respect of the reserved portions of lots 7, 8 and 30 and the whole of lot 49. Whilst lot 30 has been restored to the ownership of the second appellants, all rights were reserved by the parties, and declaratory relief is sought by the appellants in respect of all four lots.Orders The orders made by the Court of Appeal on 17 October 2008, save for so much of orders 1, 3 and 4 as allow the appeal in respect of that portion of lot 30 on Diagram 74229 zoned "Industrial" under the Peel Region Scheme, and save for order 2, be set aside and in lieu thereof it should be ordered that the orders of the primary judge made on 23 February 2007 be set aside, and that the appeal be allowed in respect of the zoned portions of lots 7 and 8. Declarations should be made in the following terms:1.The taking order of 5 August 2003 made under s 177 of the Land Administration Act 1997 (WA) relating to:(i)Lot 7 on Plan 8565, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1936 Folio 292 ("lot 7"); and (ii)Lot 8 on Plan 8565, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1936 Folio 291 ("lot 8"); and(iii)Lot 30 on Diagram 74229, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1838 Folio 943 ("lot 30"); and (iv)Lot 49 on Plan 17900, being the whole of the land contained in Certificate of Title Volume 1957 Folio 286,was invalid so far as it purported to apply to those portions of lots 7 and 8 zoned urban under the Peel Region Scheme and that portion of lot 30 zoned industrial under the Peel Region Scheme.2.The interests of the appellants in those portions of lots 7 and 8 zoned urban under the Peel Region Scheme and in that portion of lot 30 zoned industrial under the Peel Region Scheme were not extinguished pursuant to s 179(b) of the Land Administration Act 1997 (WA) following registration of the taking order under s 179.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ, HAYNE J