Vincent Nominees Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 86 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   VINCENT NOMINEES PTY LTD -v- WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2012] WASC 28

CORAM:   BEECH J

HEARD:   7­9 NOVEMBER 2011, 2 & 5 DECEMBER 2011

DELIVERED          :   2 FEBRUARY 2012

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2665 of 2008

BETWEEN:   VINCENT NOMINEES PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
First Defendant

THE BOARD OF VALUERS
Second Defendant

Catchwords:

Administrative law - Whether valuation by statutory board of valuers invalid on various grounds - Whether Wednesbury unreasonableness demonstrated

Contracts - Proper construction - Relevance of background matrix evidence

Town planning - Reservation of land for public purposes under Metropolitan Region Scheme - Compensation for injurious affection - Validity of payment of compensation - Whether amount of compensation must be determined by a third party or can be agreed by claimant and responsible authority - Whether agreement about compensation otherwise invalid

Statutory interpretation - Whether amount of compensation must be determined by a third party or can be agreed by claimant and responsible authority

Legislation:

Metropolitan Region Town Planning Scheme Act 1959 (WA), s 36, s 36C, s 37
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 171, s 173, s 177, s 180, s 187, s 188, s 190, s 191, s 192
Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA), s 11

Result:

Plaintiff's claim dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Dr J T Schoombee & Mr C McIntosh

First Defendant             :     Mr R M Mitchell SC & Ms M J Paterson

Second Defendant         :     No appearance

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Ilberys

First Defendant             :     State Solicitor for Western Australia

Second Defendant         :     No appearance

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Acorn Consolidated Pty Ltd v Hawkslade Investments Pty Ltd [1999] WASC 218; (1999) 21 WAR 425

Alpha Wealth Financial Services Pty Ltd v Frankland River Olive Company Ltd [2008] WASCA 119

Amcor Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining & Energy Union [2005] HCA 10; (2005) 222 CLR 241

Australian Broadcasting Commission v Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd [1973] HCA 36; (1973) 129 CLR 99

Bond Corporation Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2000] WASCA 257

Chemeq Ltd v Shepherd Investments International Ltd [2007] WASCA 117

CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd (1997) 187 CLR 384

Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of New South Wales [1982] HCA 24; (1982) 149 CLR 337

Ex Parte Re Bond Corporation Pty Ltd (Unreported, WASC, Library No 980186, 11 March 1998)

Genworth Financial Mortgage Insurance Pty Ltd v Hodder Rook & Associates Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 1043

Hodder Rook & Associates Pty Ltd v Genworth Financial Mortgage Insurance Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 279

International Air Transport Association v Ansett Australia Holdings Ltd [2008] HCA 3; (2008) 234 CLR 151

Kelly v The Queen [2004] HCA 12; (2004) 218 CLR 216

Maggbury Pty Ltd v Hafele Australia Pty Ltd [2001] HCA 70; (2001) 210 CLR 181

Mandurah Enterprises Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2007] WASC 43

Mandurah Enterprises Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vincent Nominees Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASC 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Vincent Nominees Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission, the plaintiff sought to challenge the validity of a compensation payment made to its predecessor in title by the defendant's predecessor, as well as to challenge the terms of a contract of sale between the parties. The key legal issues centered on the validity of the compensation payment and the interpretation of the contract of sale. The court had to determine whether the compensation payment was valid and if the contract terms correctly reflected the agreement between the parties.

The court held that the statutory scheme allowed the Metropolitan Region Planning Authority (MRPA) to agree on the amount of compensation with the claimant, and such an agreement did not need to be supported by a valuation from the Board of Valuers or a resolution of the affected value by the MRPA. The court also found that any agreement on the amount of compensation was valid and did not need to be executed under common seal or authorized by a resolution of the MRPA members. Furthermore, the court rejected the plaintiff's argument that the agreement was not a valid contract due to lack of consideration or intention to create legal relations.

As a result of these findings, the court concluded that the plaintiff had not established that the compensation payment was invalid. The court dismissed the plaintiff's claim and indicated that it would consider the issue of costs separately. The reasoning of the court was based on the proper construction of the statutory provisions and the contractual terms, emphasizing that any power of a statutory authority must be exercised in good faith and for a proper purpose.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts in outline The plaintiff bought lot 8 in May 1983 from Mrs Margaret Greenham. It has an area of 2.0917 ha. Earlier, in April 1981, a portion of 0.5391 ha of lot 8 had been reserved for 'Important Regional Roads' under the Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS). That reserve remained in place, although in 1999 the purpose of the reservation was changed to 'Primary Regional Road'. Before selling lot 8 to the plaintiff, Mrs Greenham gave notice, under the relevant legislation, to the Metropolitan Region Planning Authority (MRPA) of her intention to sell the property. There was then a series of steps taken by the MRPA and the Board of Valuers which I will describe later. (The MRPA is the predecessor to the WAPC). In June 1983, after lot 8 had been transferred to the plaintiff, Mrs Greenham claimed compensation from the MRPA for the injurious affection of lot 8 by the reservation. In August 1983, the MRPA paid $12,500 compensation to Mrs Greenham. The legal effect, if any, of that payment is in issue. There are also a number of issues about the steps taken and events leading to that payment. On 15 August 1993, the MRPA registered a caveat against lot 8, as contemplated in the legislation. The plaintiff did not become aware of the caveat until September 2006. At that time, the plaintiff had contracted to sell lot 8. The purchaser discovered the caveat after a title search and the contract fell over. The plaintiff wrote to the Minster for Planning, complaining about the caveat. A dispute arose between the parties. As I have said, the content of the dispute in itself is an issue. After the dispute arose, the parties negotiated a sale by the plaintiff to the WAPC of lot 8 as well as a neighbouring property, lot 7. In May 2008, the WAPC and the plaintiff entered a contract of sale of lots 7 and 8. There is no issue about the purchase of lot 7. The proper construction of the contract of sale is the first major issue in this action and will determine what the other issues are. The contract of sale The contract of sale is dated 29 May 2008 and is made between the plaintiff as seller and the WAPC as purchaser. In the contract the plaintiff is referred to as Nizich, which is the surname of the plaintiff's directors. The contract recitals include the following:B.The WAPC claims that -(a)In or around 1983 WAPC's predecessor The Metropolitan Region Planning Authority paid $12,500.00 compensation to Nizich's predecessor in title as compensation for injurious affection arising from a reservation in relation to part of Lot 8, which compensation entitlement arose upon the first sale of the property from Nizich's predecessor in title to Nizich following the reservation of the land under the Metropolitan Region Scheme ('MRS Reservation'), pursuant to section 36 of the former Metropolitan Region Town Planning Scheme Act 1959 (MRTPS Act).(b)At that time, the amount of compensation paid represented a quarter of the full market value of Lot 8 unaffected by the MRS Reservation. WAPC asserts that subsections 36(3) and (7) and section 36AA and section 37(5) of the MRTPS Act, now also re‑enacted as sections 171, 180 and 192 of the Planning and Development Act 2005, operate to support the position that the WAPC is entitled to reduce the unaffected value of Lot 8 by the proportion that the compensation it previously paid bore to the value of the land at the time the compensation was paid.C.Nizich disputes all the claims referred to in Recital B ('the Dispute').D.WAPC has offered $1,895,000.00 plus GST (if applicable) to purchase Lot 7 from Nizich and $1,406,250.00 plus GST (if applicable) to purchase Lot 8 from Nizich.E.The Parties agree that the offer for Lot 7 is full market value unaffected by the MRS Reservation and that there is no dispute or argument between the Parties in relation to the sale and purchase of Lot 7.F.In relation to Lot 8 the parties agree that the full market value unaffected by any MRS Reservation ('full market value') of Lot 8 is $1,875,000.00 plus GST. WAPC has discounted the full market value of Lot 8 by one-quarter of the full market value to reflect the proportionate value of the alleged compensation payment made to Nizich's predecessor in title.G.WAPC and Nizich have agreed to proceed with the settlement of the conveyance of Lot 7 and Lot 8 based on the purchase prices referred to in Recital D but without prejudice to and on the terms and conditions referred in this Contract including the assertion by Nizich of his entitlement with respect to the Dispute to be paid the additional one-quarter value of the full market value of Lot 8 after the transfer of Lot 8 to WAPC.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusion I would summarise my major conclusions as follows:(1)on a proper construction of the contract of sale, the plaintiff is entitled to the Additional Sum if and only if it establishes that the payment of $12,500 to Mrs Greenham was not a valid payment of compensation under s 36 of the MRTPS Act;(2)on a proper construction of the legislative scheme, it was open to a claimant and the MRPA to agree on the amount of compensation for injurious affection;(3)the validity of a payment for compensation, the amount of which is agreed, is not conditioned on:(a)the appointment of a person to determine the amount of the compensation;(b)that person or any person being satisfied of the matters set out in s 36(4);(c)an assessment by that person of the difference between the affected and unaffected values of the property;(d)a valid valuation of the unaffected value of the property by the Board of Valuers or a valid resolution of the affected value of the property by the MRPA; or(e)a legally enforceable contract between the claimant and the MRPA;(4)the plaintiff's attacks on the validity of the agreement about the amount of compensation fail;(5)as a consequence of the conclusions in (2) ‑ (4), the plaintiff's attacks on the Board of Valuers' unaffected value valuation and the MRPA's resolution of affected value would not, if successful, lead to the invalidity of the payment of compensation to Mrs Greenham;(6)in any event, those attacks fail; and(7)consequently, the plaintiff has not established that the payment of compensation to Mrs Greenham was invalid. It follows from these conclusions that the plaintiff's claim should be dismissed. I will hear from the parties on the question of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The plaintiff submits that the effect of the WAPC's construction, which permits the MRPA to agree the amount of compensation, is that there would be no limits or constraints on the freedom of the MRPA to agree any figure for compensation. I do not accept that submission. Apart from anything else, any power of a statutory authority must be exercised in good faith and for a proper purpose: see, for example, Thompson v Randwick Corporation (1950) 81 CLR 87, 105 ‑ 106. Section 36(2a) of the MRTPS Act stipulates how the price of land elected to be acquired under s 36(2) is to be determined 'if the [MRPA] and the owner ... are unable to agree as to the price to be paid for the land by the [MRPA]'. Thus that subsection specifically limits the application of the stipulated methodology to when the MRPA and owner have been unable to agree. Section 11(1) of the TPD Act does not contain corresponding language. In my opinion, that difference in language in two provisions in different Acts does not sustain the plaintiff's construction of s 11(1) of the TPD Act in the statutory context created by s 36 of the MRTPS Act. In summary, in my view, the language of the relevant provisions, the statutory scheme as a whole and the inconvenience that would result from the plaintiff's construction sustain the WAPC's construction. For these reasons, in my opinion:(1)on a proper construction of the statutory scheme, it was open to the MRPA to agree the amount of compensation with the claimant;(2)the payment of compensation to Mrs Greenham is not invalid on the ground that the amount of compensation was fixed by agreement between the MRPA and the claimant, and not fixed by a third party;(3)the payment of compensation to Mrs Greenham is not invalid on the ground that the amount of compensation did not comply with the requirements of s 36(6) of the MRTPS Act. A finding of non‑compliance with s 36(6) would not make the payment of compensation valid. I accept the WAPC's submission that, on a proper construction of the statutory scheme, the ability of the MRPA to agree the amount of compensation and then validly pay the amount so agreed is not conditioned on there being in existence (and before the MRPA) a valuation of the Board of Valuers of the unaffected value (valid or otherwise), or on the MRPA having given advice under s 36C(3), or on there being a resolution (valid or otherwise) of the affected value by the MRPA. The MRPA has power under s 36C(1) to waive the requirement for a selling owner to apply to the Board of Valuers for a valuation of unaffected value. In my view, that supports the construction I adopt. For these reasons, I reject the plaintiff's first major contention. I turn to the plaintiff's second contention - that any agreement between the MRPA and Mrs Greenham is invalid on various other grounds. The plaintiff's other attacks on any agreement In its reply dated 29 November 2011, the plaintiff attacks the validity of any agreement between the MRPA and Mrs Greenham on a number of grounds:(1)the MRPA had no statutory power to enter into any such agreement (reply par 4.1);(2)any agreement was incompatible with the proper discharge by the MRPA of its statutory functions in that its purpose or effect was to displace or circumvent the requirements of s 36(4) and s 36(6) of the MRTPS Act (reply par 4.6);(3)any agreement must be executed under common seal and could not be made by conduct (reply par 4.2 and par 4.4);(4)the agreement was not duly authorised by a resolution of the members of the MRPA (reply par 4.3); and(5)any agreement did not constitute a valid contract because it was not supported by consideration and because there was no intention to create legal relations (reply par 4.5).