Julstar Pty Ltd v Hart Trading Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Julstar Pty Ltd v Hart Trading Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 151

Citation: Julstar Pty Ltd v Hart Trading Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 151
Appeal from: Julstar Pty Ltd v Hart Trading Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 1359
Parties: JULSTAR PTY LTD, SEMOLINA PTY LTD (ACN 117 935 570) and JULIANNE STARIHA v HART TRADING PTY LTD, COLLEEN TRACEY HART, FRONTLINE RECRUITMENT GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 078 126 851) and PETER JOHN DAVIS
File number: QUD 25 of 2014
Judges: DOWSETT, RARES AND LOGAN JJ
Date of judgment: 13 November 2014
Catchwords:

TRADE PRACTICES – EVIDENCE – whether misleading or deceptive representations made orally or by conduct in relation to purchase of franchise business – where purchaser of franchise operated business for significant time without complaint before alleging misrepresentations – proof of fact requires court to feel actual persuasion of its existence – where trial many years after making of alleged representations and conduct complained of

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – where significant delay between conclusion of trial and delivery of judgment – limitations of appellate courts in reviewing credibility findings by trial judge 

Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)
Trade Practices (Industry Codes – Franchising) Regulations 1998 (Cth)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Cases cited: Abalos v Australian Postal Commission (1990) 171 CLR 167 applied
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336 applied
Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Ltd (2004) 218 CLR 592 referred to
Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International Ltd (2000) 202 CLR 45 applied
Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2007) 162 FCR 466 referred to
Devries v Australian National Railways Commission (1993) 177 CLR 472 applied
Expectation Pty Ltd v PRD Realty Pty Ltd (2004) 140 FCR 17 applied
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118 applied
Haros v Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (2012) 287 ALR 507
Miller & Associates Insurance Broking Pty Ltd v BMW Australia Finance Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 357 applied
Parkdale Custom Built Furniture Pty Ltd v Puxu Pty Ltd (1982) 149 CLR 191 applied
Poulet Frais Pty Ltd v The Silver Fox Company Pty Ltd (2005) 220 ALR 211 referred to
Watson v Foxman (1995) 49 NSWLR 315 applied
Date of hearing: 19, 20, 21 May 2014
Place: Brisbane
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 126
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr RA Perry QC
Solicitor for the Appellants: Lynch Andrew Lawyers
Counsel for the First and Second Respondents: Mr C Jennings
Solicitor for the First and Second Respondents: Thomson Geer
Counsel for the Third and Fourth Respondents: Mr A Crowe QC with Mr M Jones
Solicitor for the Third and Fourth Respondents: HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

QUD 25 of 2014

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

JULSTAR PTY LTD
First Appellant

SEMOLINA PTY LTD (ACN 117 935 570)
Second Appellant

JULIANNE STARIHA
Third Appellant

AND:

HART TRADING PTY LTD
First…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Julstar Pty Ltd v Hart Trading Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCAFC 151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Julstar Pty Ltd brought an action against Hart Trading Pty Ltd in the Federal Court of Australia, alleging that Hart Trading made misleading and deceptive representations about the profitability and success of a franchise business before Julstar purchased it. The case concerned whether Hart Trading had made misrepresentations about the financial performance of the franchise business, leading Julstar to purchase the business at an overvalued price. The legal issues included whether the representations made were misleading or deceptive and whether there was a contravention of the Franchising Code of Conduct.

The primary judge found that there had been no misleading or deceptive conduct by Hart Trading. The judge reasoned that Julstar's purchaser, Mrs Stariha, had made no written complaints about the representations within a reasonable time after the purchase, which was odd given her later claims of being misled. The judge preferred the evidence of Hart Trading and Frontline's representatives over that of Mrs Stariha, noting that Mrs Stariha had actively pursued additional franchises shortly after the purchase without raising any concerns. Additionally, the judge found that the disclosure document provided to Mrs Stariha was materially accurate and not misleading. The appeal against this decision was dismissed, and Julstar was ordered to pay the respondents' costs.

The court's decision highlights the importance of timely complaints and the need for clear and convincing evidence in claims of misleading or deceptive conduct. The judge's preference for the testimony of Hart Trading and Frontline's representatives over that of Mrs Stariha influenced the outcome, emphasizing the need for contemporaneous documentation to support allegations of misleading conduct.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the respondents’ costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 23 January 2006, Mrs Knight emailed her curriculum vitae to Mrs Stariha that set out that she had worked between October and December 2004 for Frontline Retail at Southport on the Gold Coast. His Honour set the relevant position out at [492], including the following:“Reason for leavingA business decision was made to close the office and cover the Gold Coast region from Brisbane.” (emphasis added) On Mrs Stariha’s account, she enquired of Ms Knight whether she could make job placements for Billabong. Mrs Stariha gave evidence that Ms Knight told her that she had worked for Mrs Hart. Mrs Stariha denied having any knowledge, prior to early 2009, that Ms Ellis had been the previous proprietor. She said that, had she known beforehand that Ellis Trading had closed the Gold Coast office, she would not have caused Julstar to purchase the business from Hart Trading in the transaction in early December 2006 that is at the centre of these proceedings. Mrs Stariha said that, had she known that the previous Frontline franchisee had closed that office and it had been “a poor financial performer”, that information would have been inconsistent with what she claimed Mrs Hart and Mr Davis had each told her about the financial success experienced by Frontline franchisees. In September 2006, Mrs Hart and Mrs Stariha discussed the possibility that Mrs Stariha might purchase the Gold Coast business and operate a Frontline franchise there in her own right. In the event, Mrs Stariha caused Julstar to be her corporate vehicle for that purpose. On 5 or 6 October 2006, Mrs Stariha and Mrs Hart met and discussed the proposed transaction. Mrs Hart showed Mrs Stariha two accounting spreadsheets that were printouts headed “GC Agency”, one being for 2005/2006 and the other containing what appeared to be the year to date results for 2006/2007. There was a substantial factual dispute, for reasons that do not seem material, as to whether Mrs Hart left those two documents with Mrs Stariha. The documents showed that Hart Trading’s Gold Coast office, which Mrs Stariha ran but had no accounting responsibility for, had earned net profits for the eight or so months to 30 June 2006 of $58,216.51 and for the next period to early October 2006 of about $14,200. Mrs Hart said that she wanted $240,000 for the business, and that figure became the price. Importantly, on 13 October 2006, Mrs Hart sent an email to Mrs Stariha, copied to Mr Davis, that attached two spreadsheets, with figures updated and adjusted from those discussed at the meeting of 5 or 6 October 2006, after Mrs Hart’s bookkeeper had reviewed the earlier figures. The text of the email said:“Attached is the GC P&L for 05/06 & 06/07Also I’ve attached an Agency Forecast for your perusal – interesting to play with.Happy reading!” There was a dispute as to whether Mrs Stariha and Mrs Hart had another meeting or meetings to discuss matters around this time, but nothing turns on this. On 18 October 2006, one of Frontline’s employees, Ms Briede, emailed Mrs Stariha, copying in Mr Davis and Mrs Hart, with a non-disclosure agreement for her to complete so as to be able to be sent Frontline’s template perusal version of its franchise agreement that she was contemplating signing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The primary judge reasoned that, in the seven month period immediately following Julstar’s purchase of its Gold Coast franchise, first, Mrs Stariha made no written complaint to anyone about any of the matters on which she later relied as evidencing that she had been misled or deceived and, secondly, actively pursued acquiring from Frontline two hospitality franchises, initially, in Far North Queensland, and subsequently, on the Gold Coast, being the one Semolina purchased. As his Honour found:“As to the hospitality arrangements, the odd thing at the outset about the hospitality arrangement is that Mrs Stariha entered into the Frontline franchise and then quite quickly agitated strongly with Frontline and Mr Downer to take up a franchise for Far North Queensland. This does not seem to be the conduct of a person who is concerned about having been led into the operation of a business on the footing of misrepresentations about EBIT earnings and returns. Having failed to secure that territory, Mrs Stariha then took up a hospitality franchise, approximately seven months after trading in the retail franchise. Again, Mrs Stariha has embraced striking a new franchise arrangement, through Semolina, with some of the same group of individuals, so far as [Frontline] is concerned, that she had been dealing with in respect of which she says she was led into a retail franchise at an overvalue and one which was not ever profitable.” (emphasis added) Importantly, his Honour then found:“However, I am not satisfied that Mrs Stariha was led into taking up the hospitality franchise in the way she claims based on the representations she asserts. I do not accept that representations were made to her to the effect that no franchisee had failed or that the franchises were highly profitable. When it comes to a contest of evidence between Mrs Stariha and either Mr Downer or Mr Davis, I am satisfied that the version of events given by both Mr Davis and Mr Downer is to be preferred. I also find that the evidence of Mrs Hart is to be preferred to that of Mrs Stariha. I also find it odd that after a period in which Mrs Stariha had been operating the retail business and then the hospitality business, which might be regarded as an objectively reasonable period for a new operator to come to grips with the realisation that the businesses were not profitable in the way she imagined based upon “things” said to her, no complaint is made in emails or correspondence about those matters. By then, it may well have been too late to seek to set aside entry into those businesses but it is odd that Mrs Stariha was not propounding in writing her contentions about the conduct with Mrs Hart, Mr Davis and Mr Downer.” (emphasis added) His Honour found that, although Mrs Stariha strongly believed that she had received a Frontline disclosure document under the Franchising Code in October 2006, she was confused about that by the references to the non-disclosure agreement in documents created around that time. He found that Mrs Stariha only received the disclosure document on or about 24 November 2006 and that the version that she then received was materially accurate because at that time there were no extant proceedings against Frontline. Accordingly, his Honour found that there had been no contravention of the Franchising Code.