Windbox Pty Ltd v JACT Pastoral Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

CITATION:Windbox Pty Ltd v JACT Pastoral Pty Ltd & Ors [2022] NTCA 2

PARTIES:WINDBOX PTY LTD

(ACN 007 419 641)

v

JACT PASTORAL PTY LTD

and

LESLIE, Zebb Raymond

and

ROWBOTTOM, Kylie Danielle

TITLE OF COURT:  COURT OF APPEAL OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  CIVIL APPEAL from the SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:AP 5 of 2020 (21840850)

DELIVERED:  1 March 2022

HEARING DATES:  20, 21 and 22 October 2020

JUDGMENT OF:  Grant CJ, Kelly and Barr JJ

CATCHWORDS:

APPEALS – Challenge to findings of fact – Assessment of credibility

Whether the trial judge’s findings “glaringly improbable” and “contrary to compelling inferences – Whether trial judge’s findings on credibility inconsistent with facts “incontrovertibly established by the evidence” – No error in trial judge’s findings of credibility – Appeal dismissed.

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118, Halikos Hospitality Pty Ltd & Ors v INPEX Operations Australia Pty Ltd [2020] NTCA 4, State Rail Authority of New South Wales v Earthline Constructions Pty Ltd (In Liq) (1999) 160 ALR 588, referred to.

CORPORATIONS – Directors and officers – Whether “officer”

Whether trial judge erred in finding Station Manager not an “officer” within the meaning of s 9 of the Corporations Act – Station Manager engaged in day-to-day tasks of running the station – Station Manager not involved in the company’s management in the sense of policy formation and significant decision-making – Station Manager not involved in the management of Windbox as a “corporation” and was not a “decision maker” of Windbox – Appeal dismissed.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 9, s 181

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Citigroup Global Markets Australia Pty Ltd [No 4] (2007) 160 FCR 35, Australian Securities and Investments Commission v King (2020) 376 ALR 1, Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Vines (2005) 55 ACSR 617, Commissioner for Corporate Affairs v Bracht [1989] VR 821, Grimaldi v Chameleon Mining NL [No 2] (2012) 200 FCR 296, referred to.

CORPORATIONS – Directors and officers – Director’s duties – Duty not to use position as director or officer improperly

Whether trial judge erred in finding no breach of duty on the basis Station Manager not using powers or discharging duties as a contractor – Trial judge found Station Manager did not make improper use of position to gain an advantage for himself – No duty as Station Manager to assist in appellant’s application for renewal of grazing licences – No evidence of misuse of confidential information – No error disclosed – Appeal dismissed.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 182, s 183

CIVIL PROCEDURE – Pleadings – Amendment – Late application for amendment

Whether trial judge erred in failing to allow amendment to plead breach of fiduciary duty – No irrelevant consideration taken into account – No basis to question trial judge’s determination that amendment would require fresh factual and legal enquiries – Not shown that in exercise of discretion trial judge acted upon any wrong principle, failed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Windbox Pty Ltd v JACT Pastoral Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NTCA 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Windbox Pty Ltd v JACT Pastoral Pty Ltd, Windbox Pty Ltd, the appellant, challenged the findings of the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory, which dismissed its action against JACT Pastoral Pty Ltd, the first respondent, and others. The dispute arose from the appellant's continued occupation of land under expired grazing licences and the subsequent negotiations for their renewal. The appellant claimed that the trial judge's findings were erroneous and contrary to the evidence, particularly in relation to the credibility of witnesses and the characterisation of Mr Leslie as an officer of Windbox.

The court was required to decide whether the trial judge's findings of fact, particularly those relating to the credibility of witnesses, were erroneous. The appellant argued that the trial judge's findings were "glaringly improbable" and inconsistent with facts established by the evidence. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether Mr Leslie was an officer of Windbox and if he contravened sections 181, 182, and 183 of the Corporations Act. The appellant contended that Mr Leslie was in breach of these obligations due to his position as an officer.

The court dismissed the appeal, affirming that no error was found in the trial judge's assessment of credibility. The judge's findings that Mr Leslie and Ms Rowbottom were credible, and Mr Dodd was not, were consistent with the evidence presented. The court held that the trial judge did not err in concluding that Mr Leslie did not contravene sections 181, 182, and 183 of the Corporations Act. The findings that Mr Leslie was not an officer of Windbox were also upheld. The court found no basis to overturn the trial judge's conclusions on these matters.

The appeal was dismissed, and the orders of the Supreme Court were affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal against a judgment of the Supreme Court given on 13 May 2020 dismissing the appellant’s action, giving judgment for the first, second and third respondents and giving liberty to the first, second and third respondents to apply to enforce the appellant’s undertaking as to damages – and also the order for costs.Background The appellant, Windbox Pty Ltd (“Windbox”), conducted a cattle business on land owned by the Daguragu Aboriginal Land Trust, under grazing licences (“the Grazing Licences”) over three areas of land known as McDonald’s Yard, Berta Warta and Northern Paddocks (collectively called “Kalkarindji Station”). The Grazing Licences expired on various dates in 2010 and 2011. However, Windbox continued in occupation of the land under holding over provisions and continued to pay the licence fees. Windbox also operated an abattoir and butcher’s shop in the Kalkarindji township (“the Kalkarindji Meatworks”). At the time relevant to these proceedings, the shareholders of Windbox were Mr Dodd (85%) and Mr Vagg (15%). Mr Dodd and Mr Vagg were directors. Mr Vagg was purportedly removed as a director by Mr Dodd (without Mr Vagg's knowledge) on 6 February 2018.[1] The second respondent, Mr Zebb Leslie, was engaged by Windbox to manage Kalkarindji Station and the Kalkarindji Meatworks. He was also a licensed meat inspector, a position that the Kalkarindji Meatworks was required to have for the business to operate. In addition to managing Kalkarindji Station, Mr Leslie operated his own helicopter mustering business with the consent of Windbox. The third respondent, Ms Rowbottom, is Mr Leslie’s partner. They lived together on Kalkarindji Station with their four children. Ms Rowbottom also worked for Windbox, first as a meat worker and also doing gardening, cooking and liaising with Windbox’s bookkeeper in Melbourne about the station books and other office work. Windbox was in negotiation with the Central Land Council (“CLC”) for the renewal of the Grazing Licences over a number of years. The directors of Windbox were insisting that they needed a ten year licence with two ten year options. The traditional owners were only prepared to grant a five year licence with one five year option. Mr Leslie performed some tasks in relation to those negotiations at the request of Mr Vagg, and to a lesser extent, Mr Dodd. A dispute arose between Mr Dodd and Mr Leslie and Ms Rowbottom. Mr Leslie wanted to be reimbursed for equipment of his that he had brought onto Kalkarindji Station and which had been used for Windbox’s business, and he and Ms Rowbottom wanted to be allocated some shares in Windbox in return for their efforts. Mr Leslie said he had been promised a 10% shareholding in the company back in 2015, but in 2017 Mr Dodd was offering him a 2% shareholding “in recognition of past effort and in compensation for those items you have purchased that are used on Kalkarindji” and a further 8% at 1% per year over eight years contingent upon his achieving a specified weaner rate. Discussions followed which were not successful, culminating in a meeting in Melbourne on 3 January 2018 at which there was no resolution satisfactory to Mr Leslie and Ms Rowbottom.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant also asserted in written submissions that the trial judge made other adverse credit findings in relation to Mr Dodd that were unnecessary for his findings of fact.[42] However, none have been identified; and it has not been explained how this might have led to appellable error. Similarly, the appellant asserts that the trial judge made certain findings in relation to the reliability of the evidence of the new station manager, Mr Cann, including that his evidence was “tainted” by the “powerful influence of Mr Dodd”.[43] The appellant submits that those findings were not open to the trial judge in the absence of a finding that Mr Cann had given deliberately false evidence – which his Honour carefully did not make.[44] There are many reasons apart from the telling of deliberate lies why a witness’s evidence may be found to be unreliable. The appellant has not shown any reason for overturning the judge’s findings in relation to Mr Cann. In any event, as the respondent pointed out, there were no contemporaneous documents which supported the serious misconduct allegations belatedly levelled against Mr Leslie by Mr Cann.[45]Conclusions in relation to the Fox v Percy challenge No error has been shown in the trial judge’s findings of credibility that were favourable to Mr Leslie and Ms Rowbottom and unfavourable to Mr Dodd,[46] or in relation to the credit findings generally. Grounds 3 and 7: Whether Mr Leslie was an “officer” of Windbox and whether he contravened ss 181, 182 and 183 of the Corporations Act Sections 181, 182 and 183 of the Corporations Act provide, relevantly, as follows:Section 181:(1) A director or other officer of a corporation must exercise their powers and discharge their duties:(a)in good faith in the best interests of the corporation; and(b)for a proper purpose.Section 182:(1) A director, secretary, other officer or employee of a corporation must not improperly use their position(a)gain an advantage for themselves or someone else; or(b)cause detriment to the corporation.Section 183:(1) A person who obtains information because they are, or have been, a director or other officer or employee of a corporation must not improperly use the information to:(a)gain an advantage for themselves or someone else; or(b)cause detriment to the corporation.Note 1: This duty continues after the person stops being an officer or employee of the corporation. Ground 7 contends that the trial judge erred in his findings[47] and his conclusion that Mr Leslie did not contravene the obligations imposed by ss 181, 182 and 183 of the Corporations Act. The appellant’s contention at trial that Mr Leslie was in breach of the obligations imposed by s 181 of the Corporations Act was contingent on his characterisation as an “officer” of Windbox. Ground 3 contends that the trial judge was in error in finding that Mr Leslie was not an “officer” of Windbox at the relevant times (ie in the period to 31 January 2018 when he was an employee of Windbox, and in the period after 31 January 2018 when he was a contractor). Ground 3: was Mr Leslie an “officer” of Windbox?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.