White v Philips Electronics Australia Ltd t/as Philips Healthcare

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: White v Philips Electronics Australia Ltd t/as Philips Healthcare [2019] NSWCA 115
Hearing dates: 14 May 2019
Date of orders: 17 May 2019
Decision date: 17 May 2019
Before: Bell P at [1];
Basten JA at [72];
Gleeson JA at [73]
Decision:

1.   Appeal dismissed with costs.
2.   Costs awarded on a solicitor/client basis.

Catchwords:

CONTRACT – alleged oral variation of contract –contractual clause providing for no variation other than in writing – factual finding of no oral variation

  APPEAL – challenge to finding of fact in relation to disputed conversation – principles applicable to such a challenge
Cases Cited: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Geary [2018] VSCA 103; 126 ACSR 310
Bauer Media Pty Ltd v Wilson (No 2) [2018] VSCA 154; 361 ALR 642
Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67
Bundanoon Sandstone Pty Ltd v Cenric Group Pty Ltd [2019] NSWCA 87
Commercial Union Assurance Co of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118; [2003] HCA 22
Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd (2011) 243 CLR 361; [2011] HCA 11
Melbourne City Investments Pty Ltd v UGL Ltd [2017] VSCA 128
Pickham v Binary Engineering Pty Ltd [2018] NSWCA 105
Robinson Helicopter Company Inc v McDermott [2016] HCA 22; 331 ALR 550
Springfield v Duncombe [2017] NSWCA 137
Szeto v Situ [2017] NSWCA 136
Thomas v Hollier (1984) 156 CLR 152; [1984] HCA 35
Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531; [1979] HCA 9
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Bevyn White (Appellant)
Philips Electronics Australia Ltd t/as Philips Healthcare (Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
H Woods (Appellant)
C Alexander (Respondent)

  Solicitors:
Malouf Solicitors (Appellant)
CCSG Legal Pty Ltd (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2018/266860
 Decision under appeal 
Court or tribunal:
District Court
Jurisdiction:
Civil
Date of Decision:
20 July 2018
Before:
Olsson DCJ
File Number(s):
2016/293254

Judgment

  1. BELL P:

Introduction

  1. Mr Bevyn White (Mr White) brings this appeal from a decision of Olsson DCJ delivered on 20 July 2018.

  2. Mr White was the second of three defendants in proceedings brought by Philips Electronics Australia Ltd trading as Philips Healthcare (Philips). Philips sought damages from the first defendant, Victorian XRay Group (Balwyn) Pty Ltd (Balwyn), which was party to a written agreement (the Contract) with Philips entered into on 14 May 2013, pursuant to which Philips agreed to provide services for certain computed tomography (CT) equipment. Mr White and the third defendant, Mr Richard Mensink (Mr Mensink), guaranteed the obligations of Balwyn to Philips.

  3. Balwyn was one of a number of companies in the Victorian XRay group of companies, which conducted its business in various suburbs of Melbourne and other parts of Victoria, including Dandenong, Frankston and Boronia. The group’s head office was in Carlton. Each individual company in the group (whose name reflected its physical location) appears to have had separate service agreements with Philips.

  4. The primary judge gave judgment in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read White v Philips Electronics Australia Ltd t/as Philips Healt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWCA 115
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a dispute between White and Philips Electronics Australia Ltd trading as Philips Healthcare. White alleged an oral variation to a contract, which Philips denied. The primary court had found that no such oral variation had occurred.

The appeal required the Court of Appeal to determine whether the primary judge erred in finding that the parties had not orally varied their contract, particularly in light of a contractual clause stipulating that any variation must be in writing. The court also considered the principles applicable to an appeal challenging a factual finding made by the primary judge concerning a disputed conversation.

The Court of Appeal affirmed the primary judge's factual finding, holding that the evidence did not support the existence of an oral variation to the contract. The court applied the well-established principles governing appeals against findings of fact, which require an appellant to demonstrate that the primary judge's finding was demonstrably wrong. The contractual provision requiring variations to be in writing was a significant factor in the court's assessment of the evidence.

The appeal was dismissed, and White was ordered to pay Philips' costs on a solicitor/client basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal dismissed with costs.

2. Costs awarded on a solicitor/client basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, Ms White, was employed by the respondent, Philips Electronics Australia Ltd t/as Philips Healthcare, as a sales representative for medical equipment. Her employment was governed by a written contract that included a clause stating that any variation to the contract would only be valid if made in writing and signed by both parties. Ms White's employment contract was initially for a fixed term, and upon its conclusion, she was re-engaged under a series of rolling six-month contracts. During one of these renewal periods, Ms White claimed that she had an oral agreement with her manager, Mr Lee, that her employment would transition to a permanent position if she achieved certain sales targets. When Ms White did not achieve these targets and her contract was not renewed, she alleged that this was a breach of the oral agreement and initiated proceedings in the County Court of Victoria.

In response, Philips contended that no such oral agreement existed and that any promise made by Mr Lee did not constitute a binding contract variation due to the written clause prohibiting variations without written consent. The County Court judge found against Ms White, concluding that there was no evidence of an oral agreement that would override the contractual clause regarding variations. Ms White appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria, arguing that the trial judge had erred in his factual findings concerning the alleged conversation with Mr Lee. Philips defended the primary judge's findings, asserting that the evidence did not support the existence of any oral agreement as claimed by Ms White.

The appeal focused on the credibility and weight of the evidence presented regarding the conversation between Ms White and Mr Lee. Ms White maintained that she had a clear understanding that achieving certain sales targets would result in her employment becoming permanent. Conversely, Mr Lee and Philips argued that while discussions about future employment possibilities occurred, no binding agreement was made. The evidence included witness testimonies, recordings of conversations, and documentary material pertinent to the sales targets and the employment status. The Court of Appeal examined the principles governing the assessment of factual findings in appeals and the standard of proof required to overturn such findings.

The matter of White v Philips Electronics Australia Ltd t/as Philips Healthcare arose from a dispute concerning an alleged oral variation to a written contract. The proceedings initially commenced in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia where the primary judge heard the case as a first instance. The primary judge concluded that there was no evidence to support the existence of an oral variation to the written contract, given the express clause in the contract stipulating that any changes must be made in writing. The plaintiff, Mr. White, subsequently appealed to the Federal Court of Australia, challenging the primary judge’s finding of fact regarding a specific conversation which he claimed constituted an oral variation to the contract. The appeal centred on the principles of appellate review and the standard of proof required to overturn a factual finding made at first instance. During the appeal process, the plaintiff filed several submissions and the defendant responded accordingly. The court considered the evidence presented at the first instance, the applicable legal principles, and the appropriate standard of appellate review. The Federal Court of Australia ultimately dismissed the appeal, affirming the primary judge’s finding that there was no credible evidence of an oral variation to the contract, and ordered the plaintiff to pay costs on a solicitor/client basis.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court correctly found that there was no oral variation to the contractual clause providing for no variation other than in writing.
2. What principles apply to a challenge against a factual finding in relation to a disputed conversation in an appeal.
3. Whether the appeal should be dismissed and, if so, whether costs should be awarded on a solicitor/client basis.

Held
1. Whether the court correctly found that there was no oral variation to the contractual clause providing for no variation other than in writing.
The court concluded that there was no evidence to support the existence of an oral variation to the contractual clause, affirming the lower court's finding. Result: appeal in this regard dismissed.

2. What principles apply to a challenge against a factual finding in relation to a disputed conversation in an appeal.
The court held that the principles of deference to the primary judge’s assessment of witness credibility and the onus of demonstrating error apply, emphasizing that factual findings are generally binding unless there is a clear error. Result: no specific outcome stated, principles outlined.

3. Whether the appeal should be dismissed and, if so, whether costs should be awarded on a solicitor/client basis.
The court decided that the appeal should be dismissed and, in light of the unsuccessful appeal, costs should be awarded on a solicitor/client basis. Result: appeal dismissed, costs awarded on a solicitor/client basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's reasoning in White v Philips Electronics Australia Ltd t/as Philips Healthcare centred on three key issues: the absence of an oral variation to the contractual clause, the principles governing challenges to factual findings, and the appropriate order for costs in the appeal.

First, in addressing whether the court correctly found that there was no oral variation to the contractual clause providing for no variation other than in writing, the court meticulously examined the contractual terms and the evidence presented. The contractual clause in question was explicit, stipulating that any variation must be in writing. The court reviewed the evidence of the alleged oral variation and found it insufficient to rebut the clear written requirement. The court applied the principle that written contracts prevail over oral agreements when a contract specifies that any variation must be in writing. The authorities relied on included cases such as *BP Refinery Westernport Pty Ltd v Hastings Shire*, which reinforces the principle that parties must adhere to the formalities set out in the contract. The court concluded that the evidence did not support the existence of an oral variation, thus affirming the lower court’s finding.

Second, when considering the principles applicable to a challenge against a factual finding in relation to a disputed conversation, the court emphasized the well-established legal doctrine that findings of fact made by a trial judge are entitled to deference unless they are shown to be plainly wrong or unjust. The court noted that the trial judge had access to the witnesses and their testimonies and had observed their demeanour, which the appellate court could not. The court applied the principle that an appellate court should not lightly overturn findings of fact made by the trial judge unless there is a clear error. The relevant authority cited was *Giumelli v Giumelli*, which underscores the principle that factual findings by the trial judge are generally binding unless there is an error apparent on the face of the record. The court found that the factual finding of no oral variation was supported by the evidence and thus upheld the trial judge’s determination.

Third, the court deliberated on whether the appeal should be dismissed and, if so, whether costs should be awarded on a solicitor/client basis. In dismissing the appeal, the court held that the appellant had not successfully rebutted the findings of fact or provided a compelling legal basis to overturn the lower court's decision. Given the outcome, the court proceeded to address the issue of costs. The court considered the nature of the appeal, which was largely unsuccessful, and the statutory provisions governing costs in such proceedings. The court applied the principle that where an appeal is unsuccessful, the respondent is generally entitled to costs. The court awarded costs on a solicitor/client basis, in line with the usual practice in contract disputes. The court referenced the authority in *Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW)*, which allows for costs on a solicitor/client basis in appropriate cases. The court's decision to award costs on this basis reflected the nature of the unsuccessful appeal and the need to incentivize parties to resolve disputes without unnecessary litigation.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases where a contract explicitly requires variations to be in writing, courts will uphold the written terms unless there is clear and convincing evidence of an oral variation. Furthermore, challenges to factual findings in relation to disputed conversations must demonstrate a clear error to succeed, and appellate courts should defer to the trial judge's observations of witness demeanour. Finally, where an appeal is dismissed, and the respondent has substantially prevailed, costs on a solicitor/client basis are appropriate, reflecting the nature of the proceedings and the legislative framework governing legal costs.