Rowntree v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Rowntree v Commissioner of Taxation
[2018] FCA 182

Appeal from: Rowntree v Commissioner of Taxation [2016] AATA 420
File number: NSD 1187 of 2016
Judge: RARES J
Date of judgment: 1 March 2018
Catchwords:

INCOME TAX – assessment of receipts of income said to be loans – appeal from Administrative Appeals Tribunal decision that assessment based on finding receipts were income not excessive under s 14ZZK of Taxation Administration Act 1953 – whether Tribunal erred by finding that objectively receipts by taxpayer from companies he controlled were income despite finding that taxpayer believed transactions were loans to him

EVIDENCE – consideration of proof of contract where same person controlling mind of both companies or parties to a payment by one to the other without contemporaneous documents evidencing purpose or agreement – whether belief of person being controlling mind of both parties as to legal effect of payments sufficient evidence of that effect

Legislation:

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 44

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 198E, 248B, 286

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) Div 7A, ss 109D, 109N

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) s 14ZZK

Cases cited:

ABC v XIVth Commonwealth Games Ltd (1988) 18 NSWLR 540

Allied Pastoral Holdings Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [1983] 1 NSWLR 1

Brogden v Metropolitan Railway Co (1877) 2 App Cas 666

Crowe-Maxwell v Frost (2016) 91 NSWLR 414

Endresz v Whitehouse [1998] 3 VR 461

Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc (2002) 209 CLR 95

Factory 5 Pty Ltd (In Liq) v State of Victoria (No 2) [2012] FCAFC 150

FederalCommissioner of Taxation v Rawson Finances Pty Ltd (2012) 89 ATR 357

Fisher v Divine Homes Pty Ltd (2011) 85 ACSR 512

Geebung Investments Pty Ltd v Varga Group Investments Pty Ltd (No 8) (1995) 7 BPR 14,551

Haritos v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2015) 233 FCR 315

Inland Revenue Commissioners v Sansom [1921] 2 KB 492

Julstar Pty Ltd v Hart Trading Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 151

Laidlaw v Hillier Hewitt Elsley Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 44

Lee v Lee’s Air Farming Ltd [1961] AC 12

Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 6) (2016) 329 ALR 1

Morlea Professional Services Pty Ltd v Richard Walter Pty Ltd (In Liq) (1999) 96 FCR 217

Nguyen and Commissioner of Taxation [2011] AATA 544

Pascoe v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1956) 30 ALJR 402

Rawson Finances Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2013) 296 ALR 307

Toll (FGCT) Pty Limited v Alphapharm Pty Limited (2004) 219 CLR 165

Date of hearing: 2 December 2016
Date of last submissions: 9 December 2016
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Taxation
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 69
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr I. Young
Solicitor for the Applicant: Rubicon Lawyers Pty Ltd
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr M. O’Meara with Mr K. Josifoski
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

NSD…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rowntree v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 182
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Rowntree v Commissioner of Taxation was a case before the Federal Court of Australia where the primary issue was the characterisation of certain payments made by companies controlled by the taxpayer, Mr. Rowntree, as either income or loans. The dispute arose from an assessment by the Commissioner of Taxation that deemed the payments as income, which led to Mr. Rowntree challenging the assessment and subsequently appealing the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's (AAT) decision that upheld the Commissioner's assessment. The core legal issues revolved around whether the AAT correctly assessed the evidence to determine the nature of the transactions and if it erred in concluding that the payments were income despite Mr. Rowntree's belief that they were loans.

The court was tasked with determining if the AAT had applied the correct legal principles in assessing Mr. Rowntree's evidence and whether it erred in its findings that the payments were income. The court examined whether the AAT appropriately balanced Mr. Rowntree's subjective belief that the payments were loans against the objective evidence that indicated they were income. Additionally, the court had to decide if the AAT had imposed an incorrect onus of proof on Mr. Rowntree by requiring more than his honest belief to substantiate his claim that the payments were loans.

In its reasoning, the court found that the AAT did not err in its approach to the evidence presented. The court emphasised that the AAT had correctly applied the principle that the existence of a loan agreement and the nature of payments must be assessed objectively, considering what a reasonable person would understand from the parties' conduct and words. The court concluded that Mr. Rowntree had not provided sufficient evidence to substantiate his claim that the payments were loans under an objective assessment. Therefore, the AAT's decision that the payments were income was supported by the evidence and did not constitute an error of law. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the AAT was upheld. The court also ordered that the appeal be dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed with costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal accepted his evidence in respect of two receipts in the 2013 income year for $1,000,000 and $80,000 respectively. However, the Tribunal found that Mr Rowntree had not established that the balance of each of the four assessments was excessive. In deciding to reduce the base penalty of 75% that the Commissioner had imposed to 50% the Tribunal found that Mr Rowntree had acted with gross carelessness or gross indifference, amounting to recklessness, rather than with an intention to disregard the law. It found that Mr Rowntree:has not deliberately chosen to ignore the law. His evidence presented to the Tribunal suggests that he genuinely believed that there were arguments to support his view that a loan was in existence and while this may have been wildly optimistic in respect of all but two of the payments in question and not genuinely supportable on the basis of the evidence available, he appears to have been genuinely of that mistaken view.[Mr Rowntree’s] testimony provided at the hearing provided a highly subjective view of whether a loan existed in respect of the monies which had been received by him. His language suggested that he genuinely believed in his own mind that the amounts in question were loans even though that view could not be sustained on an objective view of the facts other than in respect of the two amounts of $1,000,000 and $80,000 referred to previously. (emphasis added) The Tribunal had approached its fact finding by noting three matters as relevant to Mr Rowntree satisfying his onus of proof that the assessments were excessive within the meaning of s 14ZZK of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), namely that:(1)it would be more difficult for him to do so in the absence of contemporaneous, corroborating documents, citing Nguyen and Commissioner of Taxation [2011] AATA 544 at [6] and [8];(2)since Mr Rowntree was asserting that the existence of loans and advances made to him under them, he might, and ought, give evidence as to that subject matter and that his own evidence, being clearly self-serving, would be approached critically and subject to careful scrutiny, citing Nguyen [2011] AATA 544 at [7];(3)the existence of any loan agreement and the character of any advances made under it had to be assessed objectively, according to what a reasonable person would have understood the parties’ words and conduct to convey, as held in Toll (FGCT) Pty Limited v Alphapharm Pty Limited (2004) 219 CLR 165 at 179 [40]. The Tribunal cited this case adding: “In this context the subjective intentions of the parties, while broadly speaking relevant, would in no way be determinative”. In essence, Mr Rowntree contended that, because he was the sole director of some, and the controlling mind of all, of the six companies involved in the transactions that led to him receiving the respective sums (which I will call the challenged receipts), the Tribunal’s finding, quoted above, that he genuinely believed that those receipts were loans, was inconsistent with its substantive decision to affirm the Commissioner’s characterisation of them as receipts of income.The issue

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In essence, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Rowntree had not satisfied it that, when he made (as director of the relevant company) and received each challenged receipt, the payment had occurred (as he alleged was the position), pursuant to a contract of loan that then existed and had identifiable, concluded terms: cf. Rawson Finances 89 ATR at 364 [20].Conclusion In my opinion, the Tribunal did not err in the exercise of its fact-finding discretion. For the reasons I have given, the Tribunal did not approach its consideration of whether Mr Rowntree had satisfied the onus of proving, under s 14ZZK, that the challenged assessments were excessive by imposing a requirement that he produce more evidence than his honest belief. Mr Rowntree simply failed to prove that he had made contracts for loans with his companies when he caused them to pay him the challenged receipts. It follows that the Tribunal’s findings of fact were open to it on the evidence and it did not make any error of law in its decision. The appeal must be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Commissioner argued in written submissions that the question on which Mr Rowntree based his appeal was not a question of law and lacked precision. He contended that Mr Rowntree had not challenged, and indeed accepted, the test that the Tribunal had applied to determine whether his receipts were loans. The Commissioner did not develop his objection in oral argument, Mr Rowntree having confined his appeal from an original six questions simply to the one question that both parties argued on the merits.The objection to competency – consideration In my opinion, the question raised, in a sufficient manner, a question of law that this Court has jurisdiction to hear and determine: Haritos v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2015) 233 FCR 315 at 383-385 [192]-[202] per Allsop CJ, Kenny, Besanko, Robertson and Mortimer JJ. In essence, the question raised the issue of whether the Tribunal, in assessing Mr Rowntree’s evidence, applied an incorrect onus of proof in its approach summarised at [4] above, having regard to its findings about Mr Rowntree’s belief that each of the challenged receipts was, or was part of, a loan transaction.Background The Tribunal found that there were three distinct purported loan arrangements and analysed the factual elements of each before arriving at its findings (the first, second and third dealings). I will set out the Tribunal’s findings as to each of these below.The first dealing On about 12 August 2009, Voluntary Credits Ltd, a Malaysian company, paid a dividend of $500,000 to its then sole shareholder, BR Redd Holdings Ltd, an Australian company limited by guarantee. Also on about 12 August 2009, Voluntary Credits caused Redd Holdings to transfer $500,000 to Mr Rowntree. Mr Rowntree was the main shareholder of Redd Holdings at all relevant times and he, his wife and father were its three directors until it was deregistered on 22 February 2011. Voluntary Credits carried on a business of developing carbon emissions trading schemes and forward selling what were called “REDD credits”. On about 5 January 2010, Voluntary Credits paid Redd Holdings another dividend of $140,000 and, on the same day, Mr Rowntree caused Redd Holdings to transfer that sum to him. On about 14 February 2011, Redd Holdings entered an agreement to assign (that was an exhibit in the Tribunal) with Europium Ltd. Under the agreement to assign, Redd Holdings assigned to Europium “all indebtedness (present, future and contingent) of the Debtor to the Assignor under the Agreement”. The agreement to assign defined the “Agreement” as “the Loan Agreement dated around 30 June 2010 between the Debtor and the Assignor”. Mr Rowntree contended that the agreement to assign evidenced the existence of the loan agreement “dated around 30 June 2010” between Redd Holdings and him, and that the agreement to assign had assigned to Europium his debt due to Redd Holdings of $640,000. On 15 February 2011, the Commissioner issued Taxpayer Alert 2011/1 entitled “Loans to members of companies limited by guarantee and the operation of Division 7A”, being a reference to provisions of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (the 1936 Act).