Julstar Pty Ltd v Hart Trading Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Julstar Pty Ltd v Hart Trading Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 1359

Citation: Julstar Pty Ltd v Hart Trading Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 1359
Parties: JULSTAR PTY LTD (ACN 122 620 400), SEMOLINA PTY LTD (ACN 117 933 570), JULIANNE STARIHA, HART TRADING PTY LTD (ACN 114 806 996), COLLEEN TRACEY HART, FRONTLINE RECRUITMENT GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 078 126 851) and PETER JOHN DAVIS
File number(s): QUD 16 of 2011
Judge(s): GREENWOOD J
Date of judgment: 12 December 2013
Catchwords: COMPETITION – consideration of a series of claims of misrepresentations inducing a franchisee to enter into two franchise agreements
Date of hearing: 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 19 March 2012; 8 May 2012
Date of last submissions: 8 May 2012
Place: Brisbane
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 784
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr R A Perry QC
Solicitor for the Applicants: Shand Taylor Lawyers
Counsel for the First and Second Respondents: Mr C Jennings
Solicitor for the First and Second Respondents: Thomsons Lawyers
Counsel for the Third and Fourth Respondents: Mr A B Crowe QC and Mr M Jones
Solicitor for the Third and Fourth Respondents:  HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

QUD 16 of 2011

BETWEEN:

JULSTAR PTY LTD (ACN 122 620 400)
First Applicant

SEMOLINA PTY LTD (ACN 117 933 570)
Second Applicant

JULIANNE STARIHA
Third Applicant

AND:

HART TRADING PTY LTD (ACN 114 806 996)
First Respondent

COLLEEN TRACEY HART
Second Respondent

FRONTLINE RECRUITMENT GROUP PTY LTD
(ACN 078 126 851)
Third Respondent

PETER JOHN DAVIS
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

GREENWOOD J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 DECEMBER 2013

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The claims of the applicants as against all respondents are dismissed. 

2.The applicants shall pay the costs of and incidental to the proceedings. 

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

QUD 16 of 2011

BETWEEN:

JULSTAR PTY LTD (ACN 122 620 400)
Applicant

SEMOLINA PTY LTD (ACN 117 933 570)
Second Applicant

JULIANNE STARIHA
Third Applicant

AND:

HART TRADING PTY LTD (ACN 114 806 996)
First Respondent

COLLEEN TRACEY HART
Second Respondent

FRONTLINE RECRUITMENT GROUP PTY LTD
(ACN 078 126 851)
Third Respondent

PETER JOHN DAVIS
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

GREENWOOD J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 DECEMBER 2013

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

PART 1 - INTRODUCTION

  1. In this proceeding the applicants contend, put simply, that the respondents have engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct in contravention of s 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), as it was known at the time of the events in question, (the “Act”) in respect of two broad classes of conduct.

  2. The applicants contend that in reliance upon the pleaded representations, said to be misleading and deceptive, two companies (the first and second applicants) controlled by the third applicant, Mrs Julianne Stariha, entered into franchise agreements with the third respondent.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Julstar Pty Ltd v Hart Trading Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 1359
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Julstar Pty Ltd brought claims against Hart Trading Pty Ltd and others, asserting misrepresentations that induced Julstar to enter into two franchise agreements. The Federal Court was tasked with determining the validity of these claims and the alleged contraventions of the Franchising Code of Australia. The applicants claimed that Hart Trading Pty Ltd did not comply with the Franchising Code of Australia, resulting in significant financial losses. The applicants sought to hold Hart Trading Pty Ltd responsible for these losses, which they quantified in their submissions.

The legal issues centred on whether the misrepresentations made by Hart Trading Pty Ltd induced Julstar Pty Ltd to enter into the franchise agreements and whether these misrepresentations constituted a contravention of the Franchising Code of Australia. The court had to evaluate the evidence presented by both parties, including witness statements and cross-examinations, to determine the accuracy and impact of the alleged misrepresentations. Additionally, the court needed to establish whether the alleged contraventions of the Franchising Code of Australia directly resulted in the claimed financial damages.

The court meticulously examined the evidence provided by both parties and found that the applicants' claims were not substantiated by the evidence. The court concluded that the misrepresentations alleged by the applicants did not induce Julstar Pty Ltd to enter into the franchise agreements and that there was no contravention of the Franchising Code of Australia by Hart Trading Pty Ltd. Furthermore, the court found that the applicants had not suffered the financial losses as claimed. Consequently, the court dismissed all claims brought by the applicants and ordered that the applicants pay the costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The claims of the applicants as against all respondents are dismissed.

2. The applicants shall pay the costs of and incidental to the proceedings.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

By paras 73 to 76, the applicants assert a failure on the part of FRGPL to comply with the requirements of the Franchising Code of Australia and by para 77 assert loss and damage arising from that contravention in Julstar of $495,932.13 and loss and damage in Mrs Stariha of $69,667.92. PART 3 – BACKGROUND MATTERS LEADING UP TO MRS HART’S ENGAGEMENT WITH MRS STARIHA AND THE SALE TO JULSTAR Mrs Hart gave the following evidence in her amended witness statement of 31 January 2012 concerning background matters leading up to her first engagement with Mrs Stariha, Hart Trading’s employment of Mrs Stariha, and the discussions leading up to Mrs Stariha relocating to Hart Trading’s Gold Coast office on or about 7 November 2005. It will, of course, be necessary to examine this evidence in the context of the later cross‑examination but the following relevant matters are drawn from the version of events contained in Mrs Hart’s amended statement. Mrs Stariha’s statement essentially begins with the events in October 2006. I will examine the following matters drawn from Mrs Hart’s amended statement and then take up the matters identified by Mrs Stariha. Later in these reasons I will then examine this material in the context of the cross‑examination of each witness. In June 2003, Mrs Hart applied for a position with a client for which Frontline Retail Brisbane was conducting recruitment activity. At this time, Frontline Retail Pty Ltd (as FRGPL was formerly known) had established, as franchisor, a franchise agreement for the State of Queensland with a franchisee called Ellis Trading Pty Ltd (“Ellis Trading”), the principal of which was Ms Karen Ellis. The franchisor conducts, through its franchise network, the business of recruiting permanent and casual staff for clients. The franchisor began the business in 1995 and has a range of franchisees throughout Australia. In the case of Ellis Trading, Ms Ellis operated a franchise for the entire State of Queensland. Mrs Hart was interviewed by Ms Ellis for the position advertised by the client. However, during the second interview with Ms Ellis, Mrs Hart was asked to join Ellis Trading as a “recruitment consultant”. Mrs Hart commenced in that role on 14 July 2003. About six weeks later, Mrs Hart was called to a meeting with Mr Peter Davis and Ms Ellis. At this meeting, Mr Davis asked Mrs Hart to manage the Frontline Brisbane Agency “on behalf of Frontline and Ellis Trading”. Mrs Hart understood from Mr Davis (and Ms Ellis confirmed it to be so) that she was being offered this role because Ms Ellis had become pregnant and wanted to remove herself from the management of Frontline Brisbane (recognising that the Ellis Trading franchise was for the whole of the State and not just Brisbane). Mrs Hart’s new role was largely a managerial one and involved managing all of the franchisee’s staff. Those staff would report to her. Mrs Hart would also be responsible for the franchisee’s budget for its activities throughout the State of Queensland. Mrs Hart also had to ensure that all staff of the franchisee were achieving their individual “Key Personal Indicators” (“KPIs”). Mrs Hart met with staff on a weekly basis to ensure that these KPIs were being met. Mrs Hart was also a recruitment consultant acting for particular clients. Mrs Hart also had to achieve her own KPIs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Hart Trading commenced operating the franchise in July 2005. Initially, in July 2005, Mr Davis permitted Hart Trading to make placements to clients outside Hart Trading’s franchised territory by making placements in North Queensland and the Sunshine Coast. These arrangements were agreed between Mrs Hart and Mr Davis. They also agreed that Mrs Hart could continue to do so until these territories had been sold to a new franchisee, so as to ensure that clients received placement services. Placement fees attributable to these services are therefore reflected in a profit and loss account for Hart Trading for the financial year ending 30 June 2006 (para 42). Further evidence drawn from Mrs Hart’s amended statement On 29 July 2002, Mrs Stariha then known as Julianne Jones (prior to her marriage to Lee Stariha) registered with the Frontline Brisbane Agency for placement in positions handled by the agency. Mrs Hart says that Mrs Stariha was placed in three positions for clients by the agency, commencing on 19 August 2002, 24 December 2002 and 27 April 2003 being positions with Uncle Bob’s Bakery, City Beach and Just Jeans, respectively (CTH 12A). Mrs Stariha filled out an employment application on 29 July 2002 and set out background material in relation to her last three employment positions. One of Mrs Stariha’s references was given by Mr Harris the Retail Director for an English entity called “Eat Ltd”. In the reference, Mr Harris said this:As a Senior Store Manager, her duties have included the operational support to seven of our cafes. Julianne was initially recruited as a “trouble shooter” to ensure the success of the South Bank Center. Julianne initiated teamwork and built a sense of “customer service” within the business and ultimately ensured Eat’s success. It was her sales driven and commercially aware approach which led her to becoming a Senior Store Manager. Her role in the past six months has been the operational support to seven cafes including concessional stores within Selfridges and the South Bank Center. I would describe Julianne’s best attributes to be her dedication and eye for detail. She is proactive in her approach believing in “systems” and making things “water tight”. Consistency is her belief, to provide consistently good service and standards every minute of the day. …[emphasis added] Mrs Hart says that on 11 August 2005, Mrs Stariha applied for a position as a Recruitment Consultant with Hart Trading within the Brisbane agency directly, rather than a placement with a client. Mrs Hart puts in evidence (CTH 13) a copy of Mrs Stariha’s Curriculum Vitae (“CV”) submitted in support of her application for that position. It will be necessary to return to aspects of that CV which were put to Mrs Stariha in cross‑examination concerning her description of the performance of the business called Café Addict Pty Ltd and her role in relation to International Working Holidays. Nevertheless, Mrs Hart says that she was impressed with Mrs Stariha having regard to her CV and the later interview she had with Mrs Stariha. Mrs Hart noted Mrs Stariha’s experience with retail businesses based on reading her CV documents to that point. Mrs Hart says that Mrs Stariha appeared, on the face of her stated experience, to be convincing and she seemed to have a detailed understanding of financial matters as well as experience in business development. Mrs Stariha “interviewed strongly” confirming Mrs Hart’s impression of her. It was “difficult not to be impressed with Julianne” says Mrs Hart.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Davis accepted that when he signed the letter to the ACCC in 2009, he “knew that the response was not reflective of what you say was the true position” (T, p 494, lns 33‑34). Immediately after that question, Mr Davis was again asked whether at the time he sent the letter to the ACCC he knew what was set out in the letter was false and he said that he did not know it to be wrong at that time (T, p 494, lns 36‑39). Mr Davis was pressed with the falsity proposition and said that the 100% success statement was a claim made by Frontline at the particular time. Mr Davis accepted that he was aware of “the genesis” of it. Mr Davis did not accept that the 100% success claim as explained in the letter to the ACCC was “not developed around TDRs”. Mr Davis was asked why he had said it was so developed and answered “because I didn’t know what it was developed around”. Mr Davis accepted that he did not speak to anyone before sending the letter to the ACCC. Mr Davis said that at the time of sending his letter he knew that all of Frontline’s agencies, over the time of their operation, had achieved 100% success rate. Mr Davis accepted that in his oral evidence he had said that the letter to the ACCC was not reflective of how the 100% success rate claim had been developed and he also accepted that if he knew at the time that the information in the letter was not reflective of the development of the claim, then it followed that what was being said to the ACCC was false (T, p 495, lns 40‑42). This exchange then occurred (T, p 495, lns 44‑47):Q: And you were content to send the ACCC a knowingly false explanation?A: No, well … Q: Weren’t you?A: Yes. PART 16 – CONCLUSIONS AND FINDINGS I have dedicated considerable time to examining the primary evidence of the principal protagonists in this proceeding both in terms of their statements and counter‑statements and their cross‑examination as to the matters in controversy. In this proceeding, it is fair to say that virtually every contention is met with a counter‑contention across the entire field of factual issues raised by the claims of the applicants. In these reasons, I have examined that evidence in detail but I do not propose to set out in these reasons the evidence of many of the other witnesses who were called in the proceedings. They include the evidence of Mr Wallace, Mr Miller, Ms Briede, Ms Moseley, Ms Manwaring, Ms Austin, Ms Baird, Ms Flavell, Ms Butcher, Ms Wilson and other accounting evidence. I have also had regard to the cross‑examination of these witnesses. I can see no utility in reciting in these reasons the various points and counter‑points arising out of the evidence of these other witnesses. Nevertheless, I have taken all of the material into account in reaching the conclusions determinative of the matter and in making findings. In some senses, Mrs Stariha’s success in the period between August and November 2005 and more particularly between 7 November 2005 and December 2006 is also the source of her potential problem. Mrs Stariha was undoubtedly an energized, enthusiastic person who was very successful in these periods in generating placement income for Hart Trading. The tenor of the emails generated by Mrs Stariha in the period from October to December 2006 reflect her clear enthusiasm to purchase the business. Because Mrs Stariha had been successful and was intimately familiar with the placement revenues she had been generating, she was keen to purchase the business. She had an understanding of the top line revenues because she was the prime mover in generating sales from the Gold Coast office and in substance and effect the only person generating placement income from clients on the Gold Coast.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.