Habib v Nationwide News Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read
Reported Decision: 76 NSWLR 299

New South Wales


Court of Appeal


CITATION: Habib v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2010] NSWCA 34
HEARING DATE(S): 22 May 2009
 
JUDGMENT DATE: 

16 March 2010
JUDGMENT OF: Hodgson JA at 1; Tobias JA at 1; McColl JA at 1
DECISION: 1. Appeal allowed with costs. 2. Set aside the judgment and orders of McClellan CJ at CL made on 7 March 2008. 3. In lieu thereof, judgment for the appellant. 4. Respondent to pay the appellant’s costs of the trial to date. 5. Remit the matter to the Common Law Division for the assessment of damages.
CATCHWORDS: EVIDENCE – admission – statements made in the course of interrogation in Pakistan and Guantanamo Bay – whether inadmissible by virtue of s 84(1) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) - EVIDENCE – statements made in the course of interrogation in Pakistan and Guantanamo Bay – whether issue under s 84 raised as required under s 84(2) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) - EVIDENCE – statements made in the course of interrogation in Pakistan and Guantanamo Bay – whether primary judge reversed onus of proof under s 84(1) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) - EVIDENCE – statements made in the course of interrogation in Pakistan and Guantanamo Bay – whether respondent discharged burden of demonstrating appellant’s admissions not influenced by s 84(1) conduct - DEFAMATION – whether defence of substantial truth established - DEFAMATION – characterisation of imputation - DEFAMATION – whether imputation general charge against the character of the plaintiff - DEFAMATION – whether interview given after publication of matter complained of sufficiently proximate in time to be relied upon as evidence of substantial truth of imputation - PROCEDURE – abuse of process – whether s 56 Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) obliged appellant to make a strike out application in regard to aspects of the respondent’s defence - WORDS AND PHRASES – “raised in the proceeding an issue about whether the admission or its making were so influenced” – s84(2) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW)
LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Civil Wrongs Act 2002 (ACT)
Crimes Act 1914 (Cth)
Criminal Code Act Compilation Act 1913 (WA)
Criminal Procedure Code of the Laws of Brunei (Cap 7)
Defamation Act 1889 (Qld)
Defamation Act 1957 (Tas)
Defamation Act 1974 (NSW)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW)
Evidence Bill 1991 (NSW)
Evidence Bill 1991 (Cth)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)
Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (UK)
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
CATEGORY: Principal judgment
CASES CITED: Ajodha v The State; Chandree v The State [1982] AC 204
Anderson v Mirror Newspapers Ltd (No 2) (1986) 5 NSWLR 735
Assaf v Skalkos (Supreme Court of New South Wales, Levine J, 15 December 1997, unreported)
Attorney-General (NSW) v TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd (1990) A Def R 50-080
Australian Securities Commission v Marlborough Gold Mines Limited (1993) 177 CLR 485
Barca v The Queen [1975] HCA 42; (1975) 133 CLR 82
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Habib v Nationwide News Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWCA 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a defamation proceeding brought by the appellant, Mr. Habib, against the respondent, Nationwide News Pty Ltd. The dispute centred on statements made by Mr. Habib during interrogations in Pakistan and Guantanamo Bay, and whether these statements, admitted as evidence by the primary judge, were admissible under section 84(1) of the *Evidence Act 1995* (NSW). The respondent also sought to rely on a defence of substantial truth to the defamatory imputations.

The court was required to determine several legal issues. Firstly, whether the primary judge erred in admitting Mr. Habib's admissions, given the circumstances of their making in Pakistan and Guantanamo Bay, and whether the onus of proof under section 84(1) had been discharged by the respondent. Secondly, the court considered whether the issue under section 84(1) had been properly raised in the proceedings as required by section 84(2) of the *Evidence Act*. Thirdly, the court examined whether the defence of substantial truth was established, including the characterisation of the imputations and whether an interview given by Mr. Habib after the publication of the defamatory material was sufficiently proximate in time to support the defence. Finally, the court considered whether the appellant's failure to make a strike-out application constituted an abuse of process.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, finding that the primary judge had erred in admitting the statements made by Mr. Habib during his interrogations. The court held that the respondent had failed to discharge the burden of demonstrating that these admissions were not influenced by the circumstances of their making, as required by section 84(1) of the *Evidence Act*. Consequently, the judgment of the primary judge was set aside, and judgment was entered for the appellant. The matter was remitted to the Common Law Division for the assessment of damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs. 2. Set aside the judgment and orders of McClellan CJ at CL made on 7 March 2008. 3. In lieu thereof, judgment for the appellant. 4. Respondent to pay the appellant’s costs of the trial to date. 5. Remit the matter to the Common Law Division for the assessment of damages.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Habib v Nationwide News Pty Ltd involves a defamation suit brought by David Habib against the respondent, Nationwide News Pty Ltd, regarding statements published in The Daily Telegraph newspaper. David Habib, an Australian citizen, was detained in Pakistan in 2005 and subsequently transferred to Guantanamo Bay. Following his release, he gave an interview to the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC), where he discussed his treatment and experiences during detention. The newspaper published articles based on this interview, which Habib claims were defamatory.

The respondent defended the defamation claim by arguing that the published statements were substantially true. They sought to rely on admissions made by Habib during interrogation in Pakistan and Guantanamo Bay. Habib objected to the use of these statements on the grounds that they were obtained in circumstances that breached his rights under the Australian Constitution and were therefore inadmissible under section 84(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). The respondent countered that the issue of admissibility under section 84 had not been properly raised in accordance with section 84(2) of the Act and, in any event, they had discharged the burden of proving that Habib's admissions were not influenced by any contravention of his constitutional rights.

The primary judge initially ruled that the issue of admissibility had not been properly raised and that the respondent had discharged their burden under section 84(1). Habib appealed this decision, arguing that the primary judge had erred in both respects. The appeal also contested the respondent's defence of substantial truth, including the characterisation of the imputations as a general charge against Habib's character, and whether the interview given after his release was sufficiently proximate to the publication to serve as evidence of the substantial truth of the imputations. Additionally, the appeal questioned whether the court had correctly applied section 56 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) in obligating Habib to make a strike-out application regarding aspects of the respondent’s defence.

The matter before the court is an appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the appellant, Mr Habib, had previously sought damages for defamation against the respondent, Nationwide News Pty Ltd. The proceedings originated from an article published by the respondent which Mr Habib contended defamed him. The primary judge had ruled in favour of the respondent, finding that the defence of substantial truth was established and that the defamatory imputations were not general charges against Mr Habib’s character. The appeal centred on the admissibility of statements made by Mr Habib during interrogations in Pakistan and Guantanamo Bay, with the appellant arguing that these statements should not have been admitted under s 84(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). Mr Habib further contended that the primary judge had misapplied the onus of proof in admitting these statements and that the imputations were not substantially true. The appeal was heard on the basis of the procedural and evidentiary rulings made by the primary judge, with no substantive issues being re-litigated at this stage.

Prior to the appeal, Mr Habib filed a motion to strike out parts of the respondent’s defence, which was dismissed by the Supreme Court. This decision is also subject to review as part of the appeal. The primary judge had considered the statements in question, ruling that they were not influenced by the alleged coercive conduct as required by s 84(2) of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). Additionally, the primary judge found that the respondent discharged the burden of demonstrating that Mr Habib’s admissions were not influenced by the impugned conduct. The appeal thus focuses on the correctness of these evidentiary rulings and procedural decisions, with the substantive issues of defamation being secondary to the admissibility and impact of the contested statements.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether statements made in the course of interrogation in Pakistan and Guantanamo Bay are inadmissible by virtue of s 84(1) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW).
2. Whether the issue under s 84 was raised as required under s 84(2) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW).
3. Whether the primary judge reversed the onus of proof under s 84(1) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW).
4. Whether the respondent discharged the burden of demonstrating the appellant’s admissions were not influenced by conduct contrary to s 84(1) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW).
5. Whether the defence of substantial truth was established in the defamation claim.
6. What is the characterisation of the imputation in the defamation claim.
7. Whether the imputation is a general charge against the character of the plaintiff.
8. Whether the interview given after publication of the matter complained of is sufficiently proximate in time to be relied upon as evidence of the substantial truth of the imputation.
9. Whether s 56 Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) obliged the appellant to make a strike out application in regard to aspects of the respondent’s defence.
10. What is the meaning of “raised in the proceeding an issue about whether the admission or its making were so influenced” under s 84(2) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW).

Held
1. Statements made in the course of interrogation in Pakistan and Guantanamo Bay are inadmissible by virtue of s 84(1) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). The court concluded that such statements are inadmissible, resulting in the exclusion of these statements from the evidence.
2. The issue under s 84 was not raised as required under s 84(2) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). The court concluded that the issue was not properly raised, impacting the admissibility of the statements.
3. The primary judge did not reverse the onus of proof under s 84(1) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). The court found that the primary judge correctly applied the onus of proof, maintaining the burden on the respondent.
4. The respondent did not discharge the burden of demonstrating the appellant’s admissions were not influenced by conduct contrary to s 84(1) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). The court concluded that the respondent failed to meet the burden, affecting the admissibility of the statements.
5. The defence of substantial truth was not established in the defamation claim. The court found that the respondent did not successfully prove the defence of substantial truth.
6. The characterisation of the imputation in the defamation claim was not fully determined by the court. The court did not provide a definitive characterisation of the imputation.
7. The imputation was not considered a general charge against the character of the plaintiff. The court found that the imputation was not a general charge, which impacts the defamation claim.
8. The interview given after the publication of the matter complained of was not sufficiently proximate in time to be relied upon as evidence of the substantial truth of the imputation. The court concluded that the timing of the interview was not close enough to the publication to be admissible.
9. Section 56 Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) did not oblige the appellant to make a strike out application in regard to aspects of the respondent’s defence. The court found that the appellant was not obligated to make such an application.
10. The meaning of “raised in the proceeding an issue about whether the admission or its making were so influenced” under s 84(2) Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) was not fully explored by the court. The court did not provide a definitive interpretation of this phrase.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal in Habib v Nationwide News Pty Ltd provided detailed reasoning on several complex legal issues, beginning with the admissibility of statements made during interrogation in Pakistan and Guantanamo Bay. The Court examined whether these statements were inadmissible under s 84(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), which prohibits the use of admissions obtained through oppression or unfair conduct. The Court determined that the statements were indeed inadmissible, finding that the conditions for exclusion under s 84(1) were met due to the oppressive nature of the interrogations.

Further, the Court scrutinized whether the issue under s 84 was properly raised in the proceedings as required by s 84(2) of the Act. The Court concluded that the issue was sufficiently raised, as the appellant had brought the matter to the attention of the primary judge. This interpretation was pivotal, as it aligned with the legislative intent to ensure that objections to the admissibility of evidence on the grounds of oppression or unfairness are not overlooked.

The Court also assessed whether the primary judge had reversed the onus of proof under s 84(1). The Court found no reversal of onus, as the respondent bore the burden of demonstrating that the appellant's admissions were not influenced by oppressive or unfair conduct. This finding was critical in upholding the integrity of the evidentiary process, ensuring that the respondent met the required standard to justify the use of the contested statements.

In determining whether the respondent had discharged the burden of demonstrating that the appellant's admissions were not influenced by conduct contrary to s 84(1), the Court found that the respondent had not met this burden. The evidence presented did not sufficiently rebut the inference that the admissions were influenced by oppressive conditions, thus affirming the exclusion of the statements.

Turning to the defamation claim, the Court addressed whether the defence of substantial truth was established. The Court found that the respondent had not demonstrated that the defamatory imputations were substantially true, thus failing to uphold this defence. The characterisation of the imputation, which involved allegations of criminal activities, was examined in detail, with the Court concluding that these imputations were not substantially true based on the evidence presented.

The Court also considered whether the imputation was a general charge against the character of the plaintiff. It was determined that the imputation went beyond mere opinion and made serious allegations that impacted the plaintiff's reputation, thus qualifying as a general charge against character. Additionally, the Court evaluated the proximity in time of an interview given after the publication of the matter complained of, finding it sufficiently proximate to be relied upon as evidence of the substantial truth of the imputation.

Addressing procedural matters, the Court examined whether s 56 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) obliged the appellant to make a strike-out application regarding aspects of the respondent's defence. The Court concluded that there was no such obligation, thereby rejecting the respondent's procedural argument.

Lastly, the Court clarified the meaning of “raised in the proceeding an issue about whether the admission or its making were so influenced” under s 84(2) of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). The Court interpreted this phrase to mean that the party objecting to the admission must have sufficiently brought the issue of oppressive or unfair conduct to the attention of the court, which was found to have been achieved in this case. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that statements obtained through oppressive conduct are inadmissible, and the burden to demonstrate otherwise lies with the party seeking to introduce such evidence.