GM v Department of Human Services

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal to a Single Judge)

GM v DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES

[2024] SASC 23

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McIntyre  

16 February 2024

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – SOUTH AUSTRALIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – PROCEDURE – SOUTH AUSTRALIA – EXTENSION OF TIME FOR APPEAL

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – PROCEDURE – SOUTH AUSTRALIA – POWERS OF THE COURT – FURTHER EVIDENCE

This is an application for permission to appeal a decision by a Member of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Appeal Tribunal (‘SACAT’) to affirm a decision to issue a prohibition notice to the appellant under s 32 of the Child Safety (Prohibited Persons) Act 2016 (SA) (‘CSPP Act’). The effect of the prohibition notice is that the appellant cannot undertake any one of the broad range of activities that the CSPP Act regards as working with children.

The appellant seeks an extension of time as the appeal was not instituted within 21 days of the decision and further seeks leave to appeal.  The appellant appeals on 17 grounds ranging from errors of law, legally inadequate reasons, that the Tribunal’s findings contradicted the evidence and that the decision reached was not the correct and preferable decision.

The respondent does not assert any prejudice arising from the extension of time, however, does oppose the application for leave to appeal, contending that granting leave would undermine the legislative intent of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Appeal Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) and the CSPP Act insofar as that proceedings concerning working with children checks should be dealt with by SACAT as the specialist Tribunal.

Held:

1.      Extension of time to file the appeal granted.

2.      Leave to appeal granted.

3.      Appeal dismissed.

Child Safety (Prohibited Persons) Act 2016 (SA) ss 3, 4, 11, 21, 25, 26, 32, 43; South Australian Civil and Administrative Appeal Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) ss 34, 70, 71; Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) s 474.19; Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) s 63A; Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (South Australia) Act 2010 (SA) s 156, 196, referred to.
Varrichio v Wentzel (2016) 125 SASR 191; Jackson v Lepp Investments Pty Ltd (2016) 125 SASR 1; Pix v South Australian Housing Trust (2016) 125 SASR 10; Zollo v The Commisoner of Consumer Affairs [2023] SASC 72; City of Enfield v Development Assessment Commission & Ors [2000] HCA 5; Schinckel v Registrar of Firearms [2020] SASC 236; Aldridge v The Registrar of Firearms [2022] SASC 5; House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499; Lee v Lee [2019] HCA 28; Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZVFW [2018] HCA 30 at [30]; Re AKS [2016] SACAT 19 ; Maroulis v Psychology Board of Australia [2020] SASC 16; Shah (A pseudonym) v Medical Board of Australia [2022] SASC 140; Norbis v Norbis (1986) 65 ALR 12; Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118; Draoui v Le [2021]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GM v Department of Human Services and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was brought by the appellant, a foster carer, against the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT) decision to affirm the Department of Human Services' decision that the appellant posed an unacceptable risk to children. The case revolves around the appellant's downloading of a file containing child exploitation material (CEM), his creation of a list of usernames and logins for a photo storage website, and the possession of naked images of his child. The Department concluded that the appellant's actions indicated an unacceptable risk to children, a decision affirmed by SACAT. The appellant sought an appeal against the SACAT decision on several grounds, including the extension of time for appeal, the court's powers to admit further evidence, and the SACAT's interpretation of the evidence presented.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether SACAT erred in affirming the Department's decision that the appellant posed an unacceptable risk to children. This involved examining whether SACAT appropriately balanced the evidence presented, whether it correctly interpreted the appellant's actions, and whether it reasonably inferred an unacceptable risk based on those actions. Another significant issue was the admissibility and weight given to further evidence that the appellant sought to introduce after the initial SACAT hearing. The court also had to determine whether the appellant's appeal was within the permissible time frame and if there were valid reasons for any delay.

The court examined the evidence and SACAT's interpretation of it, noting that many facts were undisputed. The appellant admitted to downloading the eMule file, creating the IMGSRC list, and possessing naked images of his child. The court found that SACAT appropriately exercised its discretion in admitting and weighing the evidence. SACAT correctly concluded that the appellant's actions demonstrated an unacceptable risk to children. The court noted that SACAT had given the appellant's evidence a degree of caution due to the appellant's careful consideration of his testimony but did not find him to be a witness of unequivocal candour and credibility. The court affirmed SACAT's decision, finding no error in its reasoning or conclusions.

The court granted permission to appeal but dismissed the appeal on the merits. The court found that SACAT correctly affirmed the Department's decision and appropriately exercised its discretion in handling the evidence. The appeal was dismissed, and the original decision stood.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow I grant permission to appeal but dismiss the appeal.Background The appellant is currently 53 years old, married and the father of two children. On 6 February 2010, whilst the appellant and his family were on holiday, the Australian Federal Police (‘AFP’) executed a search warrant obtained for the appellant’s family home. The appellant was notified of the AFP’s attendance at his home by a neighbour. He and his wife returned home from their holiday that day. The basis for the search warrant arose out of an AFP operation in which the AFP had arrested a person who was in possession of a photograph of one of the appellant’s children. The child was partially naked. The person under arrest told the AFP that he had discussions with the appellant about using their children to make child exploitation material. During the course of the AFP’s execution of the search warrant, the appellant was interviewed, and his computers were searched and seized. The AFP found a number of photographs and videos of naked and semi naked children on the appellant’s devices. The appellant was taken to a police station and was charged with using a carriage service to access child pornography material contrary to s 474.19 of the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) (‘the Criminal Code’) and possession of child pornography contrary to s 63A of the Criminal Law ConsolidationAct1935 (SA) (‘CLCA’). I note in this context that the terminology for such offences has changed. The Criminal Code now refers to ‘child abuse material’ and the CLCA now refers to child exploitation material (‘CEM’). For consistency I will refer to the material as CEM. The Criminal Code charge alleged that the appellant, in 2009, downloaded 713 photographs and one video of adults and children (both prepubescent and pubescent) in nudist settings (‘the eMule file’). The CLCA charge related to the appellant’s possession of a number of videos and/or photographs taken by himself, his wife and other family members. The photographs were of his children naked or partially naked and other children. The appellant had uploaded these photographs and around 30,000 other family photographs to Flickr, a photograph storage and/or sharing website. On 6 October 2010 the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (‘CDPP’) concluded that:·the videos and photographs did not meet the legal tests for child pornography material under the Criminal Code or CEM under the CLCA;·there was no evidence that the appellant had searched for such material;·there was no evidence that the appellant had participated in discussions on internet platforms about CEM and related topics;·there was no evidence that the appellant had transmitted CEM to, or received CEM from, other individuals; and·there was no evidence that the appellant possessed unequivocal CEM material. Accordingly, on 8 October 2010, all charges against the appellant were withdrawn. The appellant and his wife were foster carers for children between 1996 and 2010. On 8 February 2012 the appellant was investigated by the Special Investigations Unit (subsequently known as Care Concern Investigations Unit (‘CCIU’)) of the Department for Education and Child Development. On 4 October 2012 the CCIU made a number of adverse findings against the appellant, finding that:·the appellant had uploaded to the internet photographs of two children under guardianship orders without authorisation and knowing that photographs of foster children are not to be made publicly available; and ·the appellant had a level of interest in young males of a sexual nature incompatible with standards for a foster carer.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ultimately Mr Lovegrove concluded that the appellant posed an unacceptable risk to children. This conclusion was based on the downloading of the eMule file and the list of passwords/logins on his personal mobile telephone which Mr Lovegrove concluded demonstrated that the appellant had accessed locations which contained CEM images and was indicative of a risk that he would do so again. Mr Lovegrove noted the factors favourable to the appellant but nonetheless affirmed the decision saying:I am reasonably satisfied, based on a holistic view of all the assessable information, that the appellant poses an unacceptable risk to children and should that risk eventuate the consequences of harm to children would be serious. The SACAT Decision The review proceedings took place under s 34(1) of the SACAT Act which relevantly provides as follows:34—Decisions within review jurisdiction(1) If the matter that a relevant Act gives the Tribunal jurisdiction to deal with is a matter that expressly or necessarily involves a review of a decision (a reviewable decision), the matter comes within the Tribunal's review jurisdiction.…………………..(3) Subject to subsections (4), (5) and (6), the Tribunal will, in exercising its review jurisdiction, examine the decision of the decision‑maker by way of rehearing.(4) On a rehearing, the Tribunal must reach the correct or preferable decision but in doing so must have regard to, and give appropriate weight to, the decision of the original decision‑maker.(5) A procedure on a rehearing will include—(a) an examination of the evidence or material before the decision‑maker (unless any such evidence or material is to be excluded under another provision of this Act or under any other law); and(b) a consideration of any further evidence or material that the Tribunal decides, in the circumstances of the particular case, to admit for the purposes of rehearing the matter. Accordingly, the role of the Senior Member was to reach the correct or preferable decision having regard to, and giving appropriate weight to, Mr Lovegrove’s decision. The SACAT review proceedings took place over four days. The parties tendered 11 exhibits, the Tribunal heard oral evidence from the appellant, his wife and Mr Lovegrove. On 2 February 2023 the Senior Member affirmed the decision under review and published her reasons. The Senior Member said that the appellant gave the impression of a witness who had “thought long and carefully about what he wished to say to the Tribunal and the matter in which he wished to say it” and ultimately found that “I should treat [the appellant’s] evidence with a degree of caution…I [do not] accept [the appellant] as a witness of unequivocal candour and credibility.” Many of the essential facts were not in dispute. The appellant conceded that he downloaded the eMule file, created a list of usernames/logons for a photo storage website called IMGSRC (the ‘IMGSRC list’), and possessed naked images of his child. The appellant did not concede that the IMGSRC list included passwords. The Senior Member did not consider it necessary to resolve that issue for the purpose of her decision given there was no evidence a password was required to access IMGSRC accounts and given the appellant’s evidence on that topic.[11] The key dispute related to the conclusions that the Senior Member should draw from the facts and, in particular, whether the Tribunal should draw inferences from the facts to conclude that the appellant had an interest in images of naked children. [11] FDN 7 at 23 [78] – [80].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering whether the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT) correctly applied the principles of judicial review, it is important to note that the SACAT Act mandates a rehearing process which includes an examination of the evidence before the original decision-maker and the consideration of any further evidence. In this case, the Senior Member of SACAT undertook a thorough review of the evidence presented by both the appellant and the original decision-maker, Mr Lovegrove. The Senior Member’s approach aligns with the statutory requirement to reach the correct or preferable decision while giving appropriate weight to the original decision. The tribunal's role was to determine whether the original decision was correct or preferable, a task that was carried out in a manner consistent with the statutory framework.

The appellant's evidence was treated with caution by the Senior Member, who found that the appellant was not entirely candid and credible. This treatment of the evidence is consistent with judicial practice, where the credibility and reliability of witnesses are assessed based on their overall demeanour and the consistency of their testimony. The Senior Member’s decision to approach the appellant's evidence with caution was reasonable given the nature of the allegations and the appellant's involvement in activities that could be perceived as questionable. The tribunal's handling of the appellant's evidence adhered to the principles of natural justice and procedural fairness.

In addressing the issue of whether the appellant's downloading of the eMule file and creation of the IMGSRC list was sufficient to infer an unacceptable risk to children, the tribunal found that these actions demonstrated a potential risk that the appellant would access child exploitation material again. The tribunal's inference was based on the established facts and the logical conclusion that repeated engagement with such material could indicate a persistent interest or risk. The tribunal's reasoning was grounded in the principle that actions speak louder than words, and the appellant's specific actions were indicative of a concerning pattern of behaviour.

The question of whether the appellant had a level of interest in young males of a sexual nature incompatible with the standards for a foster carer was central to the tribunal's decision. The tribunal concluded that the appellant's actions and the evidence presented supported this inference. The tribunal's conclusion was based on the appellant's behaviour and the logical deductions from his activities, such as the downloading of the eMule file. The tribunal relied on the principle that the safety and welfare of children in foster care are paramount, and any behaviour that could be interpreted as a risk to this safety must be rigorously examined.

The tribunal also considered whether the appellant's possession of naked images of his child was a relevant factor in determining if he posed an unacceptable risk to children. The tribunal found that while this possession was concerning, it was not the sole basis for their decision. Instead, it was one of several factors that contributed to the overall conclusion. The tribunal's approach was balanced, considering all relevant factors and not placing undue weight on any single piece of evidence.

In assessing whether adequate weight was given to the favourable factors presented by the appellant, the tribunal acknowledged these factors but ultimately found them insufficient to outweigh the concerns raised by the appellant's other actions and behaviours. The tribunal's decision to affirm the original decision indicates that, in their view, the negative factors were more compelling and relevant to the risk assessment.

The tribunal's decision to affirm the original decision was based on a holistic view of all the assessable information. This approach is consistent with the statutory requirement to examine the decision of the original decision-maker and to reach the correct or preferable decision. The tribunal's conclusion reflects a comprehensive assessment of all the evidence and a reasoned determination that the original decision was appropriate.

The SACAT's consideration of further evidence was in line with the provisions of the SACAT Act, which allows for the admission of additional evidence where it is relevant and necessary for the rehearing. The tribunal's consideration of further evidence, including the appellant's and his wife's testimonies, ensured that all relevant information was taken into account in reaching their decision.

The tribunal adequately addressed the dispute regarding the conclusions that should be drawn from the facts presented. The Senior Member carefully considered the arguments and evidence from both sides, providing detailed reasons for their conclusions. This thorough approach demonstrates that the tribunal engaged with the key issues and made reasoned decisions based on the evidence.

Finally, regarding whether the appellant’s interest in images of naked children was adequately substantiated by the evidence presented during the SACAT review, the tribunal found that the evidence supported this conclusion. The appellant's actions, such as downloading the eMule file and creating the IMGSRC list, provided a basis for inferring an unacceptable risk to children. The tribunal's decision was based on a logical and reasoned assessment of the evidence, ensuring that the conclusions drawn were supported by the facts.