GM v Department of Human Services

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

GM v DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES

[2025] SASCA 68

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable President Livesey, the Honourable Justice S Doyle and the Honourable Justice Bleby)

18 June 2025

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - OTHER MATTERS - CASE STATED AND RESERVATION OF QUESTION OF LAW

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS - STATUTORY APPEALS FROM ADMINISTRATIVE AUTHORITIES TO COURTS

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - GENERAL APPROACHES TO INTERPRETATION - PURPOSIVE APPROACH

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - GENERAL APPROACHES TO INTERPRETATION - WHOLE ACT TO BE CONSIDERED

Appeal against decision of a single judge of this Court dismissing an application for permission to appeal under s 71 of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) (‘SACAT Act’). Questions of law reserved on Originating Application for judicial review.

On 6 February 2010, the Australian Federal Police executed a search warrant in respect of the appellant’s home. The appellant was subsequently charged with Commonwealth and State offences relating to the access and possession of child pornography. However, on 8 October 2021, all charges were withdrawn. On 16 July 2019, the appellant, who was previously a foster carer, applied for a working with children check (‘WWCC’). On 16 July 2019, the Central Assessment Unit (‘CAU’), having conducted a WWCC, determined to issue the appellant a prohibition notice under s 32 of the Child Safety (Prohibited Persons) Act 2016 (SA) (‘CSPP Act’), preventing him from working with children. A member of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘SACAT’) upheld this decision. A single judge of this court dismissed the appellant’s application for permission to appeal against the decision of the Tribunal. The appellant applied for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.

After the filing of a notice of appeal, the appellant was issued with a second Prohibition Notice. In response, the appellant filed an Originating Application for Review of the second Prohibition Notice. A judge of this court reserved questions of law for this court to determine in respect of the Originating Application for Review.

The issues arising on the Notice of Appeal and the questions of law reserved overlap to a degree. They include:

1.      whether ‘unacceptable risk’ is an objective legal standard (Appeal Ground 6, Question 1);

2.whether the determination of unacceptable risk is to be made on the balance of probabilities (Appeal Ground 7, Question 3);

3.whether the ‘unacceptable risk’ test in s 26(1) of the Act is a discretionary test (Appeal Ground 1, Question 2);

4.in circumstances where the appellant was already the subject of a prohibition notice under s 32(1) of the CSPP Act:

a. was the CAU authorised pursuant to s 30 of the CSPP Act to conduct a further working with children check (‘WWCC’) in relation to the appellant (Question 4a);

b.      upon determining that the appellant posed an unacceptable risk…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GM v Department of Human Services and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASCA 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *GM v Department of Human Services* involved an appeal to the Supreme Court of South Australia concerning a decision made by the Child and Family Safety and Support Services Unit (CAU) to issue a prohibition notice to the appellant. The dispute arose from the CAU's determination that the appellant posed an unacceptable risk to children, leading to the issuance of a second prohibition notice. The appeal was heard by Livesey P, S Doyle and Bleby JJ.

The court was required to determine several legal issues. These included whether the CAU correctly identified and applied the test for "unacceptable risk," and whether this determination should be made on the balance of probabilities. Further questions concerned whether the determination of unacceptable risk is a discretionary or non-discretionary decision, and in circumstances where the appellant was already subject to a prohibition notice, whether the CAU was authorised to conduct a further Working With Children Check (WWCC) and validly issue a second prohibition notice. The court also considered whether the CAU's actions were in excess of jurisdiction or contrary to law, and whether there had been a denial of natural justice.

The court's reasoning involved an examination of the relevant legislative scheme, particularly the *Child Sex Offender Prohibition and Registration Act* (CSPP Act) and the *South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act* (SACAT Act). The court considered the role of the Tribunal in reviewing decisions, noting that it must reach the correct or preferable decision while giving appropriate weight to the original decision-maker's findings. The court's approach involved a rehearing of the matter, considering evidence before the original decision-maker and any further admissible evidence. The court's ultimate determination on the reserved questions of law and the grounds of appeal would determine the outcome of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons are set out as follows:BackgroundThe First Prohibition OrderThe application to the Tribunal for reviewAppeal to a single judge of this CourtThe appeal to the Court of AppealInterlocutory ApplicationSecond Prohibition NoticeJudicial Review and questions of law ReservedApproach to the issuesThe legislative schemeDid the CAU correctly and properly identify and apply the test for ‘unacceptable risk’? (Question 1; Appeal Ground 6)Whether the determination of unacceptable risk is to be made on the balance of probabilities (Question 3; Appeal Ground 7)For the purpose of undertaking a WWCC pursuant to s 26 of the CSPP Act, is the determination whether or not a person poses an ‘unacceptable risk’ to children a discretionary or a non-discretionary decision? (Question 2; Appeal Ground 1)In circumstances where the appellant was already the subject of a prohibition notice under s 32(1) of the CSPP Act (Question 4):Was the CAU authorised pursuant to s 30 of the CSPP Act to conduct a further WWCC in relation to the appellant? (Question 4a)Upon determining that the appellant posed an unacceptable risk to children, did the CAU validly issue the appellant with a further prohibition notice? (Question 4b)Whether the CAU’s determination and issue of the second Prohibition Notice was in excess of jurisdiction or contrary to law (Question 5)The remaining appeal grounds and the question of leave to appealAppeal Grounds 4 and 5: denial of natural justiceConclusion on the questions of law reservedPreliminary conclusion on the appealBackground The appellant is currently 55 years old. He is married with two children. On 6 February 2010, the Australian Federal Police (‘AFP’) executed a search warrant over the appellant’s family home. At the time, the appellant was on holiday with his family. A neighbour notified the appellant of the AFP’s attendance at his home. The appellant and his wife returned home that day. The catalyst for the search was the arrest of a man who was in possession of a photograph of one of the appellant’s children. The child was depicted in the photograph partially naked. The arrested man told the AFP he had had discussions with the appellant about using their children to make child exploitation material. During the execution of the warrant, the AFP interviewed the appellant and searched his computers, hard drives and mobile phone. They discovered photographs and videos of naked and partially naked children on the appellant’s devices. They charged the appellant with using a carriage service to access child pornography material contrary to s 474.19 of the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) (‘the Criminal Code’) and possession of child pornography contrary to s 63A of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) (‘CLCA’). The Commonwealth charge concerned the downloading of a file containing 713 photographs and one video of both adults and children in a nudist setting, using a file sharing ‘torrent’ program called eMule. The photographs depicted naked adults and children. The children in the photos included prepubescent and pubescent males and females. The children in the video were shown engaging with adults in 10-pin bowling while naked. The breasts and sexual organs of the children were depicted in the video and photographs but were not a dominant characteristic of the material. There was not overtly sexual or sexualised posing.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant applied for a review of this reconsidered decision pursuant to s 34(1) of the SACAT Act. Section 34 provides:34—Decisions within review jurisdiction(1)If the matter that a relevant Act gives the Tribunal jurisdiction to deal with is a matter that expressly or necessarily involves a review of a decision (a reviewable decision), the matter comes within the Tribunal’s review jurisdiction.(2)For the purposes of subsection (1) (and the other sections of this Division), and subject to the provisions of a relevant Act, a reviewable decision is—(a) a decision made by the Crown or an agency or instrumentality of the Crown; or(b) a decision made by a prescribed person or body; or(c) a prescribed decision or class of decision,but does not include a decision made by a person or body or a decision, or class of decision, excluded by the regulations.(2a)For the purposes of this Act—(a) unless paragraph (b) applies—the decision‑maker for a reviewable decision is the person or body that made or is taken to have made the reviewable decision;(b) the rules may provide—(i)that the decision‑maker for a reviewable decision will, instead of being the person or body under paragraph (a), be a person or body that is assigned by the rules as being a suitable entity to act as the decision‑maker for the purposes of this Act (or specified provisions of this Act); or(ii)that a reference to the decision‑maker for a reviewable decision in this Act (or specified provisions of this Act) will be taken to include a reference to a person or body that is designated by the rules as being a suitable entity to act jointly with the person or body under paragraph (a) for the purposes of this Act (or specified provisions of this Act),and rules made under this paragraph will then have effect in accordance with their terms.(3)Subject to subsections (4), (5) and (6), the Tribunal will, in exercising its review jurisdiction, examine the decision of the decision‑maker by way of rehearing.(4)On a rehearing, the Tribunal must reach the correct or preferable decision but in doing so must have regard to, and give appropriate weight to, the decision of the original decision‑maker.(5)A procedure on a rehearing will include—(a) an examination of the evidence or material before the decision‑maker (unless any such evidence or material is to be excluded under another provision of this Act or under any other law); and(b) a consideration of any further evidence or material that the Tribunal decides, in the circumstances of the particular case, to admit for the purposes of rehearing the matter.(6)In exercising its review jurisdiction, the Tribunal is to deal with a matter in accordance with this Act and the relevant Act.(7)Furthermore, the relevant Act may modify the operation of this Act in relation to a matter that comes within the Tribunal’s review jurisdiction. The role of the Senior Member was to reach the correct and preferrable decision having regard to, and giving appropriate weight to, the Registrar’s decision. The Tribunal proceedings took place over four days. The parties tendered 11 exhibits. The Tribunal heard oral evidence from the appellant, his wife and the Registrar. The Tribunal delivered its Statement of Reasons for determining that the appellant posed an unacceptable risk to children in February 2023.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.