Minister for Primary Industries and Regional Development v Scali

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal to a Single Judge)

MINISTER FOR PRIMARY INDUSTRIES AND REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT v SCALI

[2024] SASC 4

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Kimber  

18 January 2024

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS - SOUTH AUSTRALIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS - STATUTORY APPEALS FROM ADMINISTRATIVE AUTHORITIES TO COURTS

This is an appeal against an order of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal pursuant to s 71 of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013. That order was in respect of an application by the respondent for a review of a decision of the appellant pursuant to s 112 of the Fisheries Management Act 2007 (the Act).

The respondent possesses a Marine Scalefish Fishery licence pursuant to the Act.  This licence was subject to a quota unit entitlement for the period of 1 July 2021 to 30 June 2022.  The appellant refused an application by the respondent for additional units to be added to his quota on the basis of exceptional circumstances.  

On review, the Tribunal found that the respondent did have exceptional circumstances and remitted the question as to any additional quota entitlement back to the appellant.  

On appeal, the appellant contended the Tribunal erred in finding the respondent has exceptional circumstances on two alternative bases.  If the decision was evaluative, the appellant submitted that the respondent’s circumstances could not be exceptional where they were circumstances which affected the industry as a whole.  If discretionary, the decision involved an outcome error where the conclusion of exceptional circumstances was unreasonable based on the facts as found.  

Held:

1.      The appeal is allowed.

2.      The decision of the Tribunal was not discretionary.

3.      The respondent did not have exceptional circumstances.

4.      The decision of the Tribunal is set aside.

Fisheries Management Act 2007 (SA) ss 3, 52, 54, 55, 111, 112, 128; South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) ss 34, 71, referred to.

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZVFW (2018) 264 CLR 541; Kent v Wilson [2000] VSC 98; Norbis v Norbis (1986) 161 CLR 513; Markarian v The Queen (2005) 228 CLR 357; Warren v Coombs (1979) 142 CLR 531; Nikac v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs [1988] FCA 670; Shah (a pseudonym) v Medical Board of Australia [2022] SASC 140; Pix v South Australian Housing Trust [2016] SASCFC 57; Khoo v Bartholomaeus [2020] SASCFC 122; Jackson v Lepp Investments Pty Ltd [2020] SASC 62, applied.

House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499; R v BCX [2015] QCA 188; Hili v The Queen (2010) 242 CLR 520; Banelis v Minister for Primary Industries and Regional Development [2022] SACAT 3, discussed.

MINISTER FOR PRIMARY INDUSTRIES AND REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT v SCALI

[2024] SASC 4

Civil: Single Judge Appeal

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal against an order of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the Tribunal)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Primary Industries and Regional Development v S... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Minister for Primary Industries and Regional Development v Scali involved the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT), where Mr Scali appealed the Minister’s decision regarding the allocation of quota units for commercial fishing licences in the Marine Scalefish Fishery (MSF). The central issue was whether the Tribunal erred in finding that Mr Scali had exceptional circumstances warranting an additional allocation of quota units. The legal issues before the court involved the interpretation of the Fisheries Management Act 2007 and the Fisheries Management (Marine Scalefish Fishery) Regulations 2017, specifically focusing on the criteria for determining exceptional circumstances and the authority of the Minister in allocating quota units.

The court examined the Tribunal’s reasoning and concluded that the Tribunal had erred in finding exceptional circumstances existed for Mr Scali. The court held that while the Tribunal considered the combination of circumstances presented by Mr Scali, including the impact of overfishing, low prices, and the decision to stop fishing, these circumstances did not constitute exceptional circumstances as defined by the relevant legislation. The court reasoned that the market conditions and the decisions of other licence holders were common factors affecting all participants in the fishery, and thus did not justify a departure from the standard allocation of quota units based on catch history.

Consequently, the court allowed the appeal, set aside the Tribunal’s decision to refer the matter back to the Minister, and substituted it with a finding that Mr Scali did not have exceptional circumstances. The court’s decision highlighted the importance of adhering to the statutory framework and the need for exceptional circumstances to be distinct and justifiable under the relevant legislative provisions. The final orders of the court reinstated the Minister’s decision that Mr Scali was not entitled to additional quota units on the basis of exceptional circumstances.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, the Tribunal erred in finding that exceptional circumstances existed. Permission to appeal is granted and the appeal is allowed. The decision of the Tribunal to refer the matter back to the Minister for reconsideration is set aside. The decision of the Tribunal is substituted with a finding that the respondent does not have exceptional circumstances. Background and legislative and regulatory framework This matter has had a protracted history. Mr Scali’s application to the Tribunal arose in the context of a broader reform of the MSF, which included the introduction of a quota system. This system allocated quota entitlements attaching to commercial fishery licences for the first time in respect of four priority species: snapper; King George whiting; southern calamari and southern garfish. The legislative and regulatory framework through which the quota system was introduced is set out below. Commercial fishing in the MSF is regulated by the Fisheries Management Act 2007 (the FM Act). The FM Act prohibits fishing activity of a class that constitutes a fishery for a commercial purpose unless the person holds a licence or permit (or acts as the agent of a person who holds a licence or permit) in respect of the fishery.[1][1] FM Act s 52. The Minister has power to grant or refuse applications for an authority (defined as a licence, permit, registration, authorisation or other authority under the FM Act); may place conditions on an authority; and may subsequently vary, revoke, or place further conditions on the authority.[2][2] Ibid ss 54 and 55. The FM Act also authorises the making of regulations for the management of a ‘fishery’, including to prescribe a quota system for a fishery and the allocation of quota entitlements to holders of licences or permits in the fishery.[3] A ‘quota entitlement’ is defined as the total quantity of aquatic resource of a particular class that may be taken under the licence or permit during a quota period.[4] [3] Ibid s 128.[4] Ibid s 3. The Fisheries Management (Marine Scalefish Fishery) Regulations 2017 (MSF Regulations) are regulations made under the FM Act. The respondent did not dispute the appellant’s submission they relevantly provide that: 1.The MSF is constituted as a fishery under the FM Act and consists of the taking of the aquatic resources specified in Schedule 1 of the regulations. The aquatic resources include the four priority species identified above. 2.Certain fishing zones are established, being the West Coast, Spencer Gulf, Gulf St Vincent and South East zones.3.In respect of each priority species, the Minister must, by notice in the Gazette on or before the 12 month quota period commencing on 1 July 2021 determine: the total allowable commercial catch (TACC) for each species and each fishing zone in that quota period; the number of kilograms of each species that is to be the value of a unit for that priority species for each fishing zone for that quota period; and the methodology or formula by which units of priority species fish are to be allocated to licences in respect of the relevant fishery.4.The fixing of the methodology or formula for fish units was expressly permitted, without limitation, to provide for or include a scheme for the allocation of additional priority species fish units on the basis of there being exceptional circumstances that apply to the holder of a licence, as determined by the Minister.5.The quota entitlement for each priority species was defined, in relation to a licence in respect of the MSF and fishing zone, to mean the maximum number of kilograms of each priority species that may be lawfully taken by the holder of the licence in that zone during a quota period, being the product of the unit entitlement under that licence in respect of that zone and the unit value for that zone and quota period, subject to any variation applying during that quota period.6.The Minister may impose or vary conditions on licences in respect of the MSF (and other fisheries), including that a condition may be imposed on a licence in respect of the MSF fixing a quota entitlement for each priority species.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The former Minister appointed Dr Cannon to assess each application for exceptional circumstances. The respondent met with Dr Cannon on 15 January 2021. Subsequently Dr Cannon recommended that the former Minister ‘consider a finding of exceptional circumstances’. Dr Cannon said that if exceptional circumstances were found by the Minister, it was recommended that the allocation of the respondent be calculated on his average catch history from 2010/2011 and 2011/2012 multiplied by five. Dr Cannon concluded: The loss of catch history here because they made the decision to stop fishing cannot be regarded as bad luck or bad decision making. On close consideration there is a good argument for exceptional circumstances. [They] made significant investment decisions before the 2017 investment warning that has adversely affected their catch history. Whereas most in this category were deprived of catch history by late entry, these recent entrants have been deprived of catch history by early exit. They made the decision to stop fishing as a response to the overfishing by others, and the consequent low price, rather than the notice of snapper closures. The Minister might see it as unfair that they lose quota as a result of their prescient decision to stop fishing when hindsight shows us that the overfishing at that time has led to the complete closure of the snapper industry. This case can be distinguished from others who changed their fishing approach after measures to limit the catch of snapper and garfish because the Scalis made their decision to leave the fishery early and based on their own assessment.[9][9] Andrew Cannon, Exceptional Circumstances Report (Antonio Scali) 2 (Appeal Book 20).The decision of the Ministers and delegates On 20 April 2021, Professor Begg wrote to Mr Scali providing an indicative outcome of his application for exceptional circumstances. That letter advised that the Minister had indicated that he was unlikely to find that Mr Scali had exceptional circumstances, but that he would be willing to offer Mr Scali an opportunity to voluntarily surrender his licence. On 14 May 2021, Mr Scali wrote to the Minister requesting that he reconsider his decision. On 17 May 2021, the Minister advised that he had ‘decided to accept Dr Cannon’s recommendation that a finding of exceptional circumstances applies’ and offered a remedy of voluntary surrender of the licence. On 29 June 2021, the Minister wrote to Mr Scali enclosing his final allocation of quota unit entitlements. The Minister advised Mr Scali in that letter that he was ‘satisfied you are not entitled to additional quota units on the basis of exceptional circumstances’. On 1 July 2021, the Minister imposed conditions on Mr Scali’s licence fixing his quota unit entitlements for each of the priority species. He was not allocated any additional units on the basis of exceptional circumstances. On 6 September 2021, the Minister provided reasons for his decision which stated:Pursuant to section 55 of the Act, I imposed a quota condition fixing a quota unit entitlement calculated in accordance with my determination. This included my finding that while I recognised exceptional circumstances may be found, I am not able to allocate additional quota units based on your application, your submission made to the independent adviser, Dr Andrew Cannon, … and the advice provided to me by the Independent Allocation Advisory Panel.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent submitted that the approach of the appellant was unduly narrow. The respondent submitted, consistent with the approach of the Tribunal, it was not the price of snapper which was an exceptional circumstance on its own. Rather, that was a circumstance which, in conjunction with others, amounted to exceptional circumstances. Those other circumstances being the response of the respondent to stop fishing at all in comparison to other license holders who continued to fish until prevented by Government regulation. The respondent also submitted that the diminished financial returns as a result of the price of snapper could be viewed as an exceptional circumstance as it was not something which could be assumed to have impacted all licence holders to the same extent. Consideration Before turning to the circumstances of the respondent which are said to be exceptional, it is important to identify the context in which that decision is to be formed. That context is what is said about ‘exceptional circumstances’ set out in the paragraphs of the Determination quoted at [10] above. The context is also how quota was calculated using catch history in a defined period. The exceptional circumstances must provide reason to depart from that catch history and to allocate additional fish units. I turn to consider the circumstances of the respondent which are said, in combination, to be exceptional circumstances. It was not disputed that they were identified by the Tribunal in the passage set out at [36] above. They may be described as: the impact of overfishing, consequent low prices and lack of commercial return (the first circumstance); the decision of the respondent to stop fishing in response, thereby diminishing catch history (the second circumstance); in contrast, the decision of others to keep fishing thereby increasing catch history (the third circumstance). In considering each circumstance, I do not overlook that they must be viewed in combination. They are also not independent of each other. Each is related to the commercial returns in the relevant fishery; that being a circumstance about which responses of participants in the relevant fishery differed which in turn, had a variable impact upon the catch history of those participants. As to the first circumstance, the Tribunal found that was not an exceptional circumstance. I agree. The price offered by buyers in a market will impact every seller into that market to some extent. It may be accepted, as the respondent submitted, that not every seller may be affected to the same extent. That will likely depend upon a variety of individual circumstances, but I am not satisfied that varying impacts makes this an exceptional circumstance. As to the second and third circumstances, I will discuss them together as they contrast the response of the respondent to that of others. The material available to me as to the response of others to the market is limited. That said, I do not understand it to be disputed other licence holders kept fishing and that by doing so, they were able to demonstrate a catch history over a longer period than the respondent.