GM v Department of Human Services (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal to a Single Judge)

GM v DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES (No 2)

[2024] SASC 43

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McIntyre  

25 March 2024

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – SOUTH AUSTRALIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COSTS - GENERAL RULE: COSTS FOLLOW EVENT - GENERAL PRINCIPLES AND EXERCISE OF DISCRETION

These reasons address the issue of costs arising from an unsuccessful appeal by GM against a decision made by the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘SACAT’) affirming a decision of the Department of Human Services (‘DHS’) to issue a prohibition notice to the appellant under s 32 of the Child Safety (Prohibited Persons Act 2016 (SA) (‘CSPP Act’).

The respondent seeks an order that the appellant pay its costs of the appeal on the standard costs basis to be agreed or taxed.  The appellant contends that this appeal raised four key public interest features and submits that this should incline the Court to not award costs against the appellant, or to do so at a significantly reduced rate.

Held:

1.Whilst the appeal raised issues of general importance that there is not a proper basis to depart from the usual order as to costs.

2.The applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal on the standard costs basis, to be agreed or taxed.

Child Safety (Prohibited Persons) Act 2016 (SA) s 32; Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 40; South Australian Civil and Administrative Appeal Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) s 71; Uniform Civil Rules 2022 (SA) rr 194.5, 194.6, referred to.
GM v Department of Human Services [2024] SASC 23; Cretazzo v Lombardi (1975) 13 SASR 4; Holt v Bunney (No 2) [2020] SASCFC 120; Slater v Ecosol Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] SASC 29; Donald Campbell & Co v Pollak [1927] AC 732; Latoudis v Casey (1990) 170 CLR 534; Chaina v Alvaro Homes Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 353; Moloney v Hayward (No 2) [2023] SASC 36; JJK v Police (No 2) [2023] SASCA 84; Knight v The State of South Australia [2022] SASCA 34; GJC v Department of Human Services [2020] SACAT 38; Schinkel v Registrar of Firearms [2020] SASC 236; House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499; Shah (a Pseudonym) v Medical Board of Australia [2022] SASC 140; Minister for Primary Industries and Regional Development v Scali [2024] SASC 4, considered.

GM v DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES (No 2)

[2024] SASC 43

Single Judge Appeal: Civil

  1. McINTYRE J:   These reasons address the issue of costs arising from an unsuccessful appeal by GM against a decision made by the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘SACAT’) affirming a decision of the Department of Human Services (‘DHS’) to issue a prohibition notice to the appellant under s 32 of the Child Safety (Prohibited Persons Act 2016 (SA) (‘CSPP Act’).[1]

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GM v Department of Human Services (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 43
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In GM v Department of Human Services (No 2), the appellant, GM, challenged a decision of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT) that he posed an unacceptable risk to children, which prevented him from working with children. The appeal was heard by the South Australian Supreme Court. The central legal issue in this case was whether the decision made by SACAT was subject to the principles established in House v The King, which pertain to administrative decisions that are discretionary in nature. The court had to determine if the decision in question was discretionary and whether it was infected by a process error or an outcome error. This was an extension of previous cases like Shah and Scali, but the specific context of the Children, Young People and their Families Act 2020 (SA) added a new layer to the analysis. The court concluded that the decision was indeed discretionary and therefore subject to the principles from House v The King. Furthermore, the court considered whether the issues raised in the appeal were of sufficient public interest to warrant a departure from the usual rule that costs follow the event. The court referenced Knight v The State of South Australia & Another (No. 2) to assess the factors that might justify such a departure. Ultimately, the court decided that while the appeal raised issues of general importance, the primary motivation behind the appeal was GM's dissatisfaction with the outcome, rather than the broader public interest in the legal issues raised.

The court weighed the public interest in clarifying the legal issues against the appellant's personal motivation in bringing the appeal. It found that the clarification of the legal issues was important, but not sufficiently compelling to warrant a departure from the usual order regarding costs. The appellant's personal dissatisfaction with the decision did not constitute a reason to deviate from the general principle that costs follow the event. Therefore, the court upheld the usual order for costs, requiring GM to bear the costs of the appeal. This decision underscores the balance the court must strike between the importance of legal clarification and the personal motivations of the appellant in administrative law appeals.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The parties took opposing positions in relation to the question of whether the decision in House v The King[13] applied to this appeal. The Court had previously considered similar issues in the matters of Shah,[14] and Scali;[15] however this issue had not been considered in the context of the CSPP Act. Ultimately, I found that, in the context of a decision made under s 26(1) of the CCSP Act in relation to whether a person “poses an unacceptable risk to children”, this decision can properly be characterised as discretionary and therefore it is necessary to determine whether the decision was infected by a process error or an outcome error of the type identified in House v The King.[16] [13] House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499.[14] Shah (a Pseudonym) v Medical Board of Australia [2022] SASC 140.[15] Minister for Primary Industries and Regional Development v Scali [2024] SASC 4.[16] GM v Department for Human Services [2024] SASC 23 at [67].Conclusion The interpretation and specialist tribunal issues formed the basis of my decision to grant leave to appeal in that I considered that they were of sufficient substance to justify consideration by the Court.[17] Once leave was granted, there was then a significant contest between the parties concerning the manner in which the appeal ought to be approached, the House v The King issue. [17] GM v Department of Human Services [2024] SASC 23 at [37] – [50]. Can these matters either alone, or in combination, be characterised as matters of public interest that give good reason to depart from the general principle that costs follow the event? Useful guidance as to the factors impacting the decision can be gleaned from Knight v The State of South Australia & Another (No. 2)[18] where the Court of Appeal said:[19]Indeed, where a matter raises an issue of general importance of some difficulty, the appeal court may decline to make an order for costs against the unsuccessful party. The cases illustrate that where the clarification of an issue of law raised by an appeal is of particular importance to a respondent, by virtue of its position as an authority, the appeal court may decline to order costs in favour of the respondent and against the unsuccessful party. It has been held by the Full Court that, where it is important that the issue of law raised by an appeal be authoritatively determined, that will provide a reason for the Court to decline to make an order for costs against the unsuccessful party. However, it has also been recognised that merely because it may be beneficial to obtain appellate authority on a disputed issue of statutory construction, that may not be sufficient, standing alone, to justify departure from the usual order as to costs. (citations omitted)[18] [2022] SASCA 34.[19] Ibid at [5] – [6]. In this matter it is relevant that I found that it was appropriate to grant leave to appeal and that issues of general importance were raised. On the other hand, whilst the appeal raised issues of general importance, it is clear that the primary reason for the appeal was the appellant’s dissatisfaction with the decision under review and his wish to work with children. Absent any other consideration this does not suggest a reason to depart from the general order as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established