GM v Department of Human Services (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

GM v DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES (No 2)

[2024] SASCA 103

Decision of the Honourable President Livesey  (ex tempore)

22 August 2024

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS - SOUTH AUSTRALIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GENERALLY

The appellant has urgently applied for an interlocutory injunction, restraining the respondent from continuing with a second ‘working with children check’, presently being conducted pursuant to s 30 of the Child Safety (Prohibited Persons) Act2016 (SA) (the Child Safety Act).

As part of affording the appellant procedural fairness, on 13 August 2024 the respondent gave the appellant a preliminary determination and sought the appellant’s response by 27 August 2024. The determination will address whether the applicant poses an unacceptable risk to children for the purposes of s 26(1) of the Child Safety Act and, accordingly, whether the appellant should be regarded as a prohibited person for the purposes of s 26(5) of that Act. 

The appellant has already sought leave to appeal an order made by a single judge, dismissing his appeal from the Tribunal, affirming a prohibition notice from the Central Assessment Unit pursuant to s 32 of the Child Safety Act following an earlier ‘working with children check’. As a result, he is presently prohibited from undertaking a broad range of activities involving working with children. The hearing of that appeal on 8 August 2024 was vacated because there was said to be new ‘assessable information’ requiring a second ‘working with children check’.

The appellant asked that his applications for an injunction, for judicial review and for discovery be listed “as a matter of urgency”.  He asked that the application for judicial review be heard and determined by the Court of Appeal, together with the appeal.  Ultimately he asked that four questions of law be referred for determination by the Court of Appeal.  Three of these are common to the appeal.  The respondent accepted that these questions could be considered by the Court of Appeal, but only after a second decision is made.

HELD refusing the application for an injunction, and remitting the balance of the applications for judicial review and for discovery to the General Division:

1.Whilst questions of convenience and degree may sometimes be involved, an injunction coupled with fresh applications for judicial review and discovery are the kinds of matters that should ordinarily be heard in the General Division of the Supreme Court, even though the Court of Appeal may exercise any jurisdiction or powers that the court has in its General Division.

2.Whilst the appellant’s argument about the illegality of a second notice has prima facie merit, it is not appropriate to express any concluded view about it for the purposes of this application. The appellant has available the statutory right of a ‘full merits review’ before the Tribunal, together with appeal rights in this Court.

3.Whether and to what extent the anticipated decision is flawed must await the making of the decision,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GM v Department of Human Services (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASCA 103
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Supreme Court of South Australia concerned an application by the appellant, GM, for an interlocutory injunction, judicial review, and discovery. GM was seeking to restrain the Central Assessment Unit from commencing or continuing a further "working with children check" and sought declarations regarding the threshold for finding an unacceptable risk to children and the Unit's authority to issue a second prohibition notice while an existing one remained in effect. These applications arose in the context of an existing appeal concerning a prohibition notice issued under the *Child Safety (Prohibited Persons) Act 2016* (SA), which prohibited GM from undertaking activities involving children.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether an interlocutory injunction should be granted to prevent a further assessment, and whether the Court of Appeal should hear the judicial review application. The appellant also sought declarations concerning the interpretation of "unacceptable risk" and the validity of issuing a further prohibition notice when one was already in force. The Court was required to consider the procedural implications of new information coming to light that led the respondent to vacate the appeal, and the potential for further assessments to undermine any success the appellant might have on appeal.

The Court refused the application for an interlocutory injunction, finding it appropriate to dismiss this aspect of the application. However, the Court indicated a willingness to consider referring questions of law to the Court of Appeal if a second prohibition notice were issued, without requiring further proceedings in the Tribunal. The Court directed that the applications for judicial review and discovery be heard and determined by the General Division of the Supreme Court. The Court reserved its decision on costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, I refuse the application for an injunction. I would be prepared to consider referring questions of law for determination by the Court of Appeal if a second prohibition notice issues. Background – an existing appeal The appellant has sought leave to appeal an order made by a single judge, dismissing his appeal from the Tribunal, affirming a prohibition notice from the Central Assessment Unit pursuant to s 32 of the Child Safety Act following an earlier ‘working with children check’.[3] As a result, the appellant is presently prohibited from undertaking a broad range of activities involving working with children.[3] GM v Department of Human Services [2024] SASC 23 (McIntyre J). On 29 July 2024, and over the appellant’s opposition, I vacated the appeal on the application of the respondent after it said it had become aware of new assessable information that was not before it when it made its earlier decision.[4] The appellant advanced a number of arguments as to why the appeal should proceed and why any further prohibition notice would be invalid. In the course of my brief reasons, I explained:[5]It is obviously not possible for me to resolve these arguments for the purposes of determining this application. Whichever view is correct, there will inevitably be a question about the basis upon which any assessment, and any review or appeal concerning that assessment, should be considered. Moreover, it is necessary to take into account the prospect that should the appellant succeed on this appeal, there may be a further assessment based on the new information undermining that success.[4] GM v Department of Human Services [2024] SASCA 93.[5] GM v Department of Human Services [2024] SASCA 93, [10]. Whether the appeal should be relisted, and any issue about costs thrown away, will be considered by me next week - on 28 August 2024.The application for judicial review – this Court? The appellant asked that his applications for an injunction, for judicial review and for discovery be listed before me “as a matter of urgency”. He asked that the originating application for judicial review be heard and determined by the Court of Appeal, together with the appeal. The appellant seeks the following orders by way of judicial review:1.An interlocutory injunction restraining the Central Assessment Unit, whether by its authorised person or otherwise, from commencing, continuing or completing a further working with children check pursuant to s 30, Child Safety (Prohibited Persons) Act 2016 until the final hearing and determination of this Judicial Review Application; 2.Declarations that: a) the Central Assessment Unit cannot find that the applicant poses an unacceptable risk to children (s 26 (1), Child Safety (Prohibited Persons) Act 2016) unless it is satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the applicant poses a risk that a reasonably informed and fair-minded member of the community would not be willing to tolerate and would not consider worth taking; b) the Central Assessment Unit is not authorised by the Act, or at all, to issue a Prohibition Notice to the applicant when he is already the subject of a Prohibition Notice which has not been revoked and is not the subject of an application to revoke it.3.An order in the nature of Prohibition, alternatively, Prohibition quoad hoc, preventing the Central Assessment Unit, whether by its authorised person or otherwise, from commencing, continuing or completing a further working with children check pursuant to s 30, Child Safety (Prohibited Persons) Act 2016; 4.A final injunction restraining the Central Assessment Unit, whether by its authorised person or otherwise, from commencing, continuing or completing a further working with children check pursuant to s 30, Child Safety (Prohibited Persons) Act 2016; 5.Such other order as to this Court seems fit; 6.costs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Nonetheless, I am receptive to the appellant’s concern about delay given that his appeal had been listed for hearing on 8 August 2024. I am prepared to facilitate the referral of questions of law once a decision has been made, without the need for proceedings to be commenced in the Tribunal.Conclusion The application for an interlocutory injunction is dismissed. I direct that the applications for judicial review and discovery otherwise be heard and determined by the General Division of the Supreme Court. I will make orders to that effect. Should a second prohibition notice be issued by the Central Assessment Unit I am prepared to consider referring questions of law, whether as proposed or in a form to be agreed, for determination by the Court of Appeal pursuant to s 49 of the Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) on reasonable written notice to my Chambers. I will hear from the parties on costs next week.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established