Gardiner v Taungurung Land and Waters Council

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Gardiner v Taungurung Land and Waters Council [2021] FCA 80

File number(s): VID 384 of 2020
Judgment of: MORTIMER J
Date of judgment: 9 February 2021
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – application for judicial review of decision of delegate of the Native Title Registrar – decision to accept Indigenous Land Use Agreement for registration – task of Registrar under s 24CK(2) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) – s 203BE(5)(a) of the Native Title Act – meaning of “all reasonable efforts” to identify people who hold or may hold native title – application upheld.
Legislation:

Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 (Cth)

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 24CJ, 24CK, 203BE(5), 223, 251A

Traditional Owner Settlement Act 2010 (Vic)

Cases cited:

AQV15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 133; 266 FCR 83

BFH16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2020] FCAFC 54

Bright v Northern Land Council [2018] FCA 752

Carrascalao v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 107; 252 FCR 352

Corunna v South West Aboriginal Land and Sea Council [2015] FCA 491; 235 FCR 40

DAO16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 2; 258 FCR 175

DCU18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2020] FCA 1817

De Rose v State of South Australia (No 2) [2005] FCAFC 110; 145 FCR 290

Drill on behalf of the Purnululu Native Title Claim Group v State of Western Australia [2020] FCA 1510

Drury on behalf of the Nanda People v State of Western Australia [2020] FCAFC 69

Gardiner v Attorney-General (No 3) [2020] VSC 516

Gardiner v Attorney-General [2020] VSC 224

Kemppi v Adani Mining Pty Ltd (No 2) [2019] FCAFC 117

Mabo v State of Queensland (No 2) [1992] HCA 23; 175 CLR 1

McGlade v Native Title Registrar [2017] FCAFC 10; 251 FCR 172

McGlade v South West Aboriginal Land & Sea Corporation (No 2) [2019] FCAFC 238; 374 ALR 329

Members of the Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria [2002] HCA 58; 214 CLR 422

Minister for Home Affairs v Omar [2019] FCAFC 188; 272 FCR 589

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSSJ [2016] HCA 29; 259 CLR 180

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZRKT [2013] FCA 317; 212 FCR 99

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang [1996] HCA 6; 185 CLR 259

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Bhardwarj [2002] HCA 11; 209 CLR 597

Moses v State of Western Australia [2007] FCAFC 78; 160 FCR 148

Neowarra v State of Western Australia [2003] FCA 1402

Northern Land Council v Quall [2019] FCAFC 77

Northern Land Council v Quall [2020] HCA 33

Northern Territory v Alyawarr, Kaytetye, Warymungu, Wakaya Native Title Claim Group [2005] FCAFC 135; 145 FCR 442

NWWJ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gardiner v Taungurung Land and Waters Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, Gardiner sought judicial review of a decision by a delegate of the Registrar of the Federal Court to register an Indigenous Land Use Agreement (ILUA) as an area agreement under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth). The ILUA was the product of negotiations between the Taungurung Land and Waters Council (the first respondent) and the State of Victoria. The second respondent, First Nations Legal and Research Services, is the Native Title Representative Body for Victoria and had certified the application for registration of the ILUA. The applicants argued that the delegate’s decision to register the ILUA was invalid because the statutory conditions in s 24CK(2) of the Act were not satisfied. The applicants also argued that the decision was otherwise invalid for reasons including lack of procedural fairness. The applicants sought the Court to set aside the decision of the delegate and make a declaration that the decision was invalid. The Court held that the decision of the delegate was invalid because the statutory conditions in s 24CK(2) were not satisfied. The Court held that the decision of the delegate did not accord with s 24CK(2)(c) because, while all reasonable efforts had been made to identify all persons who held or may hold native title in relation to land or waters in the area covered by the agreement, it was not the case that none of the persons objecting to the registration of the ILUA had satisfied the Registrar that the requirements of s 203BE(5)(a) and (b) had not been satisfied in relation to the certification of the application by First Nations Legal. The Court further held that the decision was invalid for reasons of procedural fairness. The Court held that the delegate had failed to provide the objectors with a fair opportunity to comment on the Full Court’s decision in Northern Land Council v Quall [2019] FCAFC 77, which was a material consideration in the decision to register the ILUA. The Court held that the delegate had also failed to provide the objectors with a fair opportunity to comment on the decision of the Court in McGlade No 2 [2020] FCA 102, which was a material consideration in the decision. The Court held that the application for judicial review would be upheld on the basis of the errors identified above. The Court held that the parties should be given an opportunity to address the question of relief in the event that the decision was set aside.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, the judicial review application will be upheld on some grounds, but not all of them. The parties will have an opportunity to be heard on the question of appropriate relief after they have considered the Court’s reasons.BACKGROUND The ILUA in dispute is the product of negotiations between the first respondent and the State that occurred for some years prior to its registration on 30 April 2020. It is part of a package of agreements between the Taungurung People and the State of Victoria forming part of a recognition and settlement agreement, entered into under s 4 of the TOS Act. As noted by Richards J in a decision in a related proceeding, Gardiner v Attorney-General [2020] VSC 224 (at [3]):The settlement package is yet to be fully implemented. If and when that occurs, it will confer significant benefits on the Taungurung and its members. In particular, if the ILUA is registered, it will bind all persons holding native title in relation to any of the land or waters in the agreement area, who are not already parties to the agreement. Its effect will be to settle all native title claims in respect of the agreement area. The first respondent, The Taungurung Land and Waters Council, is represented by First Nations Legal and Research Services. First Nations Legal is the Native Title Representative Body for Victoria, and receives Commonwealth funding to undertake this role pursuant to s 203FE of the Native Title Act. First Nations Legal is, accordingly, also a body which can certify the authorisation of an ILUA under s 203BE of the Act. The ILUA was entered into on 26 October 2018. On 30 November 2018, First Nations Legal certified that the requirements in s 203BE(5)(a) and (b) had been met by the process leading to the agreement of the ILUA. The application for registration of the ILUA was made on 17 December 2018. On 20 March 2019, the National Native Title Tribunal gave notification of the application to register the ILUA, in accordance with s 24CH of the Native Title Act. On 6 June 2019, the solicitors for the applicants and certain other people, whom I will refer to as the objectors, wrote to First Nations Legal, stating that they intended to object to the registration on the bases that:(a)the certification of the ILUA was “indistinguishable from the one held in Quall not to be a certification for the purposes of ss 24CG(3) and 203BE of the NT Act”, referring to the decision of the Full Court in Northern Land Council v Quall [2019] FCAFC 77; and(b)the ILUA had not been authorised as required by s 251A of the Native Title Act, and so could not meet the conditions for proper certification under s 203BE of the Act.The applicants requested that the application for registration be withdrawn. On 20 June 2019, the applicants provided a letter of objection to the registration of the ILUA to the Native Title Registrar, noting in detail the objections they had previously provided to First Nations Legal. First Nations Legal and the State each provided submissions to the Registrar in response to the objectors. These submissions are before the Court and are summarised below in the context of the summary of the delegate’s decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The meaning of the condition in s 24CK(2)(c), and its application to the facts, is central to the applicants’ arguments on judicial review.THE DELEGATE’S DECISION The decision of the delegate of the Registrar set out the chronology prior to the registration decision as follows (at [2]-[9]):On 20 October 2018, a meeting was held at Camp Jungai in Rubicon, Victoria to authorise the Taungurung Settlement ILUA (authorisation meeting).On 17 December 2018, an application was made to the Registrar, pursuant to s 24CG(1) of the Act, for the registration of the Taungurung Settlement ILUA as an area agreement ILUA (see ss 24CA to 24CE). The area covers about 20,210 square kilometres and comprises land and waters south of the Murray River from Rochester to Wangaratta to the Great Dividing Range.On 25 February 2019, I decided that the Registrar was required to give notice of the agreement, pursuant to s 24CH, because the procedural requirements for notification of the agreement had been met. It is not disputed that the application complied with the procedural requirements for notification and that the Registrar was thus obliged to notify the agreement.The notice period commenced on 20 March 2019, and between 24 April to 20 June 2019, objections against the registration of the agreement were received from persons claiming to hold native title in the agreement area.On 20 May 2019, the objectors and the parties were advised that the Registrar was considering the impact of the Full Federal Court’s decision in Northern Land Council v Quall [2019] FCAFC 77 (Quall) and that while undertaking such consideration, the delegate would stay the procedural fairness process in relation to each objection received. The parties were advised that the delegate was of the view that she was required to continue to assess the validity of any further objections that were made and that the procedural fairness for any prima facie valid objection would also be stayed. The parties were also requested to advise the delegate of their proposed course of action if they considered the Full Court’s decision would adversely affect the ability of the agreement being registered as an ILUA.On 20 June 2019, the notice period for the agreement ended.In the period from 2 August 2019 to 28 February 2020, the procedural fairness steps outlined in Attachment A were taken.In November 2019, December 2019 and February 2020, the objectors and the parties were advised that, in my view, a fair opportunity had been provided for all relevant persons to comment on the objections and the responses received in relation to them, and that I would proceed to make a decision.(Footnotes omitted.) Some of the objections referred to in paragraph [5] of the delegate’s decision were objections raised on behalf of the applicants in this proceeding. The “procedural fairness steps” taken by the delegate were described in Attachment A to the delegate’s decision:•On 24 April 2019, the Registrar received an objection against registration of the agreement from Mr Freddie Dowling.•On 25 April 2019, the Registrar received an objection from Dr Judith Crispin.•On 9 May 2019, the Registrar received an objection from Ms Michelle Carlon.•On 20 May 2019, the objection by Dr Crispin was provided to First Nations as the native title service provider and the representative of the Taungurung Signatories and the Taungurung Clans Aboriginal Corporation, and the Victorian Government Solicitor’s Office as the representative of the State of Victoria. First Nations and the State of Victoria were also informed, by a separate letter of the objection by Mr Dowling but were advised that he had been given an opportunity to provide additional information to support his objection and that his legal representative, Mr Matthew Pudovskis had requested a copy of the application for registration to progress the objection.•On 22 May 2019, the Victorian Government Solicitor’s Office confirmed that the parties agreed to only a copy of the certification of the application to be provided to Mr Dowling’s representative. The Victorian Government Solicitor’s Office also queried whether there would be a change to the registration process being undertaken in relation to the application following the decision of the Full Federal Court in Quall handed down on 20 May 2019.•On 24 May 2019, the objectors and the parties to the agreement were informed that the application for registration may be affected by the Full Court’s decision in Quall and that the procedural fairness process had been stayed in relation to each objection until the Registrar had considered the implications of the decision. The parties were also informed that the delegate would continue to assess the validity of any further objections received and objections that were prima facie valid would also be stayed. The parties were requested to advise their proposed course of action if they considered the Full Court’s decision would adversely affect the ability of the agreement being registered as an ILUA.•On 11 June 2019, the Registrar received an objection from Mr Darren Atkinson.•On 17 June 2019, the Registrar received an objection from Mr Alan Dowling.•On 19 June 2019, objections were received from Ms Nicole Atkinson, Ms Porsha Atkinson and Mr Kevin Atkinson.•On 20 June 2019, objections were received from Mr Robert Nicholls and Professor Henry Atkinson.•On 2 August 2019, the objections and supporting material, including letters of support of some of the objections, were provided to First Nations and the Victorian Government Solicitor’s Office.•On 30 August 2019, in response to the objections, three submissions were received from First Nations responding to the objection of Mr Freddie Dowling, the objectors represented by Holding Redlich and other objectors (collectively the Bangerang and Wollithiga objectors).On 10 September 2019, the State responded to the objections, also providing three submissions. A copy of the responses by First Nations and the State were provided to the objectors on 3 and 10 September 2019. The objectors were also provided with a copy of First Nations’ certificate pursuant to s 203BE of the Act which accompanies the application for registration.•On 23 September 2019, Mr Alan Dowling provided a response to the submissions by First Nations, the State’s Comments and Attachment B to the State’s Comments (A Dowling’s Response).•On 23 September 2019, Mr Kevin Atkinson, Mr Darren Atkinson, Ms Nicole Atkinson, and Ms Porsha Atkinson provided a document titled ‘Response to State of Victoria’s Comments on the Bangerang and Wollithica Objections’ (Atkinson’s response to State’s Comments) and a Parliament of Victoria First Session response by the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs.•On 24 September 2019, Mr Kevin Atkinson, Mr Darren Atkinson, Ms Nicole Atkinson, and Ms Porsha Atkinson provided a document titled ‘Our Objectors Responses\To the FNLRS Response’ (Atkinson’s response to First Nations).•The material received on 23 and 24 September 2019 was not provided to First Nations and the State for further comment as in my view the objectors did not raise new matters that required comment and a fair opportunity had been provided for all relevant persons to comment on these objections.•On 7 October 2019, Mr Matthew Pudovskis provided a submission on behalf Mr Freddie Dowling, responding to the matters raised by First Nations and the State in their responses.•On 7 November 2019, Holding Redlich provided a submission on behalf of its clients responding to submissions from the First Nations and the State.•The objectors and the parties were advised that in my view the objectors represented by Holding Redlich did not raise new matters within the additional material provided that required further comment and that a fair opportunity had been provided for all relevant persons to comment on the objections. There was further correspondence in relation to this, and on 28 November 2019, Holding Redlich provided a letter enclosing four affidavits filed and served in the Supreme Court of Victoria proceeding.•On 22 November 2019, the State provided comments in response to the submissions made on behalf of Mr Freddie Dowling.•On 6 December 2019, First Nations provided a response to the submissions made on behalf of Mr Freddie Dowling.•In response to these submissions, further submissions was provided by Mr Pudovskis on behalf of Mr Dowling on 21 January 2020.•The parties were asked whether they wished to comment on the recent decision in McGlade No 2 and any other matter. The State and First Nations provided responses on 10 and 18 February 2020 respectively.•On 28 February 2020, Mr Pudovskis provided submissions on behalf of Mr Dowling in response to the parties’ submissions.•This material received in support of Mr Freddie Dowling’s objection was not provided to First Nations and the State for further comment as in my view the objectors did not raise new matters within the additional material provided requiring comment and because a fair opportunity had been provided for all relevant persons to comment on the objection.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For an ILUA to be registered, a decision such as that under review in this proceeding is required by ss 24CJ and 24CK of the Native Title Act, which provide:24CJ Decision about registrationThe Registrar must, after the end of the notice period, decide whether or not to register an agreement covered by an application under this Subdivision on the Register of Indigenous Land Use Agreements. However, in a case where section 24CL is to be applied, the Registrar must not do so until all persons covered by paragraph (2)(b) of that section are known.24CK Registration of area agreements certified by representative bodiesRegistration only if conditions satisfied(1)If the application for registration of the agreement was certified by representative Aboriginal/Torres Strait Islander bodies for the area (see paragraph 24CG(3)(a)) and the conditions in this section are satisfied, the Registrar must register the agreement. If the conditions are not satisfied, the Registrar must not register the agreement.First condition(2) The first condition is that:(a)no objection under section 24CI against registration of the agreement was made within the notice period; or(b)one or more objections under section 24CI against registration of the agreement were made within the notice period, but they have all been withdrawn; or(c)one or more objections under section 24CI against registration of the agreement were made within the notice period, all of them have not been withdrawn, but none of the persons making them has satisfied the Registrar that the requirements of paragraphs 203BE(5)(a) and (b) were not satisfied in relation to the certification of the application by any of the representative Aboriginal/Torres Strait Islander bodies concerned.Second condition(3)The second condition is that if, when the Registrar proposes to register the agreement, there is a registered native title body corporate in relation to any land or waters in the area covered by the agreement, that body corporate is a party to the agreement.Matters to be taken into account(4)In deciding whether he or she is satisfied as mentioned in paragraph (2)(c), the Registrar must take into account any information given to the Registrar in relation to the matter by:(a)the persons making the objections mentioned in that paragraph; and(b)the representative Aboriginal/Torres Strait Islander bodies that certified the application;and may, but need not, take into account any other matter or thing. Thus, the Registrar or her delegate has a binary choice under s 24CK. If the statutory conditions are met, she must register the ILUA. If they are not, she must not register the ILUA. The certification function to which s 24CK(1) refers is, relevantly, the following part of s 203BE:Certification of applications for registration of indigenous land use agreements(5)A representative body must not certify under paragraph (1)(b) an application for registration of an indigenous land use agreement unless it is of the opinion that:(a)all reasonable efforts have been made to ensure that all persons who hold or may hold native title in relation to land or waters in the area covered by the agreement have been identified; and(b)all the persons so identified have authorised the making of the agreement.