Bennell v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bennell v State of Western Australia [2021] FCA 1508   

File numbers: WAD 6085 of 1998
WAD 6134 of 1998
WAD 6181 of 1998
WAD 6192 of 1998
WAD 6274 of 1998
WAD 6286 of 1998
WAD 6006 of 2003
WAD 6012 of 2003
WAD 253 of 2006
WAD 33 of 2007
WAD 242 of 2011
Judgment of: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 1 December 2021
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – consent determination that native title does not exist over determination area – agreement of parties – South West Settlement – whether s 87 and s 87A of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) satisfied
Legislation:

Native Title Amendment Act 1998 (Cth) s 61, Sch 5, Pt 3, item 6

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 13(1)(a), 24CK, 24EA(1), 61, 61(1), 62A, 66, 66(8), 66(10)(c), 67(1), 68, 87, 87(1), 87(1)(a), 87(1)(b), 87(1)(c), 87(1A), 87(2), 87A, 87A(1)(b), 87A(1)(c), 87A(1)(d), 87A(2), 87A(3), 87A(4), 87A(4)(a), 87A(4)(b), 87A(8), 94A, 199A, 225, 225(a)-(e), 251B

Noongar (Koorah, Nitja, Boordahwan) (Past, Present, Future) Recognition Act 2016 (WA)

Cases cited:

AC (deceased) v State of Western Australia [2021] FCA 735

Bennell v Western Australia [2006] FCA 1243; (2006) 153 FCR 120

Bodney v Bennell [2008] FCAFC 63; (2008) 167 FCR 84

Bolton v State of Western Australia [2004] FCA 760

CG (Deceased) on behalf of the Badimia People v State of  Western Australia (No 2) [2015] FCA 507

CG v Western Australia [2016] FCAFC 67; (2016) 240 FCR 466

Corunna v South West Aboriginal Land and Sea Council [2015] FCA 491; (2015) 235 FCR 40

Gardiner v Taungurung Land and Waters Council [2021] FCA 80

Hill on behalf of the Yirendali People v State of Queensland [2017] FCA 273

Kelly on behalf of the Byron Bay Bundjalung People v NSW Aboriginal Land Council [2001] FCA 1479

Leyland v State of Western Australia [2020] FCA 512

Mace v Queensland [2019] FCAFC 233; (2019) 274 FCR 41

McGlade v Native Title Registrar [2017] FCAFC 10; (2017) 251 FCR 172

McGlade v South West Aboriginal Land & Sea Aboriginal Corporation (No 2) [2019] FCAFC 238; (2019) 374 ALR 329

Munn v Queensland [2001] FCA 1229; (2001) 115 FCR 109

Nelson v Northern Territory [2010] FCA 1343; (2010) 190 FCR 344

Prior v South West Aboriginal Land and Sea Council Aboriginal Corporation [2020] FCA 808

Yarran v South West Aboriginal Land & Sea Council Aboriginal Corporation [2020] HCATrans 202

Division: General Division
Registry: Western Australia
National Practice Area: Native Title
Number of paragraphs: 64
Date of last submissions: 18 October 2021 (joint submissions)
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers

Solicitor for the Applicants in WAD 6085 of 1998, WAD 6134 of 1998, WAD 6181 of 1998, WAD 6192 of 1998, WAD 6274 of 1998, WAD 6286 of 1998, WAD 6006 of 2003, WAD 6012 of 2003, WAD 253 of 2006,
WAD 33 of 2007

(the First to Tenth Applicants):

Mr M Geritz of Clayton Utz
Solicitor for the Applicant in…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bennell v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 1508
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bennell v State of Western Australia, the applicants sought a consent determination that native title does not exist over the determination area. This matter was before the Federal Court of Australia and involved various applicants and the State of Western Australia. The dispute centred on the interpretation and application of sections 87 and 87A of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), which pertain to the making of consent determinations regarding native title. The applicants argued that the proposed determination was appropriate and should be made under these sections, while the State of Western Australia supported the application.

The court was required to decide whether the criteria set out in sections 87 and 87A of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) had been satisfied, and if so, whether it was appropriate to make the consent determination that native title does not exist over the determination area. The applicants provided evidence in support of their argument, including affidavits and documents related to the South West Native Title Settlement. The State of Western Australia also submitted relevant evidence, including affidavits and the Minute signed by all parties. The court needed to assess the evidence and determine whether the orders sought by the parties were appropriate and within the power of the court.

The court found that the criteria in sections 87 and 87A of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) had been satisfied, and the proposed determination was appropriate. The lengthy and complex history of native title determination applications in the determination area, including previous litigation and settlements, supported the appropriateness of the orders sought. The court concluded that making the orders would bring about widespread advancement and benefit to all whom the settlement is intended to recognise. The court granted the orders sought by the parties, concluding the main role of the court in reaching this historic settlement.

The court ordered that native title does not exist over the determination area, as proposed by the parties. This decision marked the culmination of extensive efforts by the applicants and the State of Western Australia to reach a settlement and resolve the native title issues in the area. The court hoped that the settlement would bring about significant benefits to the community in the years to come.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In submissions filed by the First to Eleventh Applicants and the State in support of a determination that native title does not exist in relation to the Determination Area, they specifically address the criteria in s 87A of the NTA (in respect of the Single Noongar #1 Application and the Yued Application) and s 87 of the NTA (in respect of the other Underlying Noongar Applications and the Single Noongar #2 Application) by which the Court should be satisfied that an order in the terms proposed by the parties should be made. EVIDENCE The State has filed an affidavit of Mr Daniel Gorman (Gorman Affidavit) attaching extracts from the Register established and kept by the Native Title Registrar under s 199A of the NTA. Complete copies of the six Settlement ILUAs which comprise the South West Native Title Settlement are published on the website of the State. Also filed is a Minute signed by each of the parties required by s 87A(1)(c) of the NTA (in respect of the Single Noongar #1 Application and the Yued Application) and s 87(1)(a) of the NTA (in respect of the other Underlying Noongar Applications and the Single Noongar #2 Application). The First to Tenth Applicants have filed an affidavit of Mr Mark Geritz addressing the authorisation of the Minute (Geritz Affidavit). The Eleventh Applicant has filed an affidavit of Mr Paul Sheiner addressing the authorisation of the Minute (Sheiner Affidavit).OVERVIEWProcedural history of the ApplicationsSingle Noongar #1 Application The Single Noongar #1 Application was lodged with the National Native Title Tribunal (NNTT) on 6 October 2003 pursuant to s 61 of the NTA. This proceeding has been referred to as the ‘Single Noongar Claim’ on account of the fact that it was brought by a large number of named applicants ‘on behalf of all Noongar people’. It was given NNTT File No. WC2003/006. The Single Noongar #1 Application is a combined native title determination application comprised of the following constituent claims:(a)WAD 6006 of 2003 (Anthony Bennell & Ors v State of Western Australia (SNC)); and(b)WAD 142 of 1998 (Richard Wilkes & Ors v State of Western Australia (Combined Metro Working Group)), which is itself a combined claim comprising the following six previously lodged constituent claims:(i)WAD 142 of 1998 (Richard Wilkes & Ors v State of Western Australia (Combined Metro Working Group)), filed with the NNTT on 8 December 1995;(ii)WAD 6159 of 1998 (Bropho v State of Western Australia (Swan Valley Nyungah #5)), filed with the NNTT on 9 April 1997;(iii)WAD 6239 of 1998 (Bropho v State of Western Australia (Robert Charles Bropho)), filed with the NNTT on 15 May 1998;(iv)WAD 143 of 1998 (Warrell v Premier and State of Western Australia (William Warrell)), filed with the NNTT on 16 May 1996;(v)WAD 6128 of 1998 (Garlett v State of Western Australia (Garlett)), filed with the NNTT on 18 October 1996; and(vi)WAD 6283 of 1998 (Wilkes v State of Western Australia (R. Wilkes & A. Corunna)), filed with the NNTT on 29 September 1998.

Decision

Reasons for decision

None of the discretionary considerations identified in Badimia serve to negate the appropriateness of the Court granting the orders sought. The long and complex history of native title determination applications in the Determination Area, including Bennell v Western Australia [2006] FCA 1243; (2006) 153 FCR 120 per Wilcox J and Bodney, is relevant to the criterion of whether it is appropriate to make an order: Hill per Reeves J (at [15]) and Gardiner v Taungurung Land and Waters Council [2021] FCA 80 per Mortimer J (at [157]). These matters have been litigated exhaustively at a considerable cost to the community at large and the participants.CONCLUSION There is no doubt that the proposed determination is appropriate. An order under s 87 and s 87A of the NTA is both within power and appropriate to be made. These orders now conclude the main part of the role to be played by the court in reaching this historic settlement. The parties have seen a number of challenges and setbacks prior to achieving this significant result. As the Court has been involved in resolving those challenges, it is inappropriate to comment on them. But it is important and appropriate to record that it is to be firmly hoped that the settlement reached will bring about, in the years to come, widespread advancement and benefit to all whom it is intended to recognise.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established