FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Nelson v Northern Territory of Australia [2010] FCA 1343
Citation: Nelson v Northern Territory of Australia [2010] FCA 1343 Parties: HARRY JAKAMARRA NELSON, JACOB JUNGARRAYI SPENCER AND BOB JUPURRURLA DIXON v NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA and AUSTRALIAN WILDLIFE CONSERVANCY File number: NTD 6028 of 2000 Judge: REEVES J Date of judgment: 8 December 2010 Date of corrigendum: 8 April 2011 Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – application for determination of native title under s 87 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) – consideration of whether the parties have satisfied the criteria set out in s 87 such that the jurisdiction of the Court is enlivened – consideration of whether it is appropriate for the Court to make an order in terms of the agreement reached by the parties – the central focus is on the agreement and whether it was freely entered into on an informed basis – if the Court finds this to be the case it will infer the existence of the native title that is at the heart of that agreement – the Court must be satisfied that the State has taken a real interest in the proceedings in the interests of the community generally – however there must be a balance between the stringency of the processes followed by the State in assessing the applicant’s evidence and the need to take a flexible approach that is aimed at facilitating negotiation and achieving agreement – parties filed joint submissions in support of a minute of a proposed consent determination and a statement of agreed facts – Held that the agreement is free and informed and that the terms of the proposed orders are unambiguous and clear. Legislation: Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 55, 57(2), 57(3), 66, 87, 87(1), 87(1)(a), 87(1)(b), 87(1)(c), 87(1A), 94A Cases cited: Munn v Queensland (2001) 115 FCR 109; [2001] FCA 1229
Lovett v Victoria [2007] FCA 474
Nangkiriny v Western Australia (2002) 117 FCR 6; [2002] FCA 660
Jamesv Western Australia [2002] FCA 1208
Ward v Western Australia [2006] FCA 1848
Cox v Western Australia [2007] FCA 588
Brown v Western Australia [2007] FCA 1025
Hughes v Western Australia [2007] FCA 365
Kogolo v Western Australia [2007] FCA 1703
Eringa v South Australia [2008] FCA 1370
Nangkiriny v Western Australia [2004] FCA 1156Trevor Close on behalf of the Githabul People v Minister for Lands [2007] FCA 1847
Date of Joint Submissions in Support of the Minute of Proposed Consent Determination: 10 November 2010 Place: Newhaven Division: GENERAL DIVISION Category: Catchwords Number of paragraphs: 33 Solicitor for the Applicant: J Nugent of the Central Land Council Solicitor for the First Respondent: K Gatis of the Northern Territory Government Solicitor for the Second Respondent: J Siddins of the Australian Wildlife Conservancy FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Nelson v Northern Territory of Australia [2010] FCA 1343
CORRIGENDUM
1.In paragraph 3 of the Reasons for Judgment, in the third, sixth, ninth and eleventh lines, delete “criteria” and substitute “criterion” instead.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Nelson v Northern Territory of Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] FCA 1343
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court found that the agreement between the parties was free and informed, and the terms of the proposed orders were unambiguous and clear. The Court held that the primary consideration in these cases is whether there is an agreement and whether it was freely entered into and on an informed basis. If the Court is satisfied that the agreement is founded in fact, it will infer the existence of the native title that is at the heart of that agreement. The Court also noted that the State needs to strike a balance between protecting the community's interests and taking a flexible approach aimed at facilitating negotiation and achieving agreement.
In conclusion, the Court made orders giving effect to the substance of the orders sought by the parties. The Court determined the existence of native title according to the traditional laws and customs of the claimants' society, held by the five landholding groups mentioned in the case. The Court emphasised that the order does not grant native title to the claimants, but merely recognises the native title they have long held. The Court also ordered that within twelve months of the date of the order, the applicants must file and serve a notice nominating a prescribed body corporate for the purposes of the Act. If no nomination is made within the specified time, the matter is to be listed by the Registrar for further directions.
The final orders of the Court include the determination of native title in the terms set out in the judgment, the holding of native title by the common law holders, the nomination of a prescribed body corporate, and liberty for the parties to apply for the establishment of the precise location and boundaries of specified areas and to establish whether any pastoral improvements have been constructed unlawfully. The Court made no order as to costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. There be a determination of native title in the terms set out below (“the determination”), the determination to take effect:
(a) as to paragraph 3 of the determination – immediately upon the making of these orders; and
(b) as to the balance of the determination – immediately upon the making of a determination under s 57(2) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (“the Act”) in accordance with Orders 3 or 4.
2. Upon the determination taking effect, native title is not held in trust but is held by the common law holders of native title being the persons referred to in paragraph 3 of the determination.
3. Within twelve months of the date of this order, the applicants in NTD 6028 of 2000 file and serve a notice nominating a prescribed body corporate to:
(a) be the prescribed body corporate for the purposes of s 57(2) of the Act; and
(b) perform the functions mentioned in s 57(3) of the Act after becoming a registered native title body corporate.
4. In the event that there is no nomination within the time specified in accordance with Order 3 or such later time as this Court may order, the Registrar will arrange for the matter to be listed for further directions.
5. The parties have liberty to apply for the following purposes:
(a) to establish the precise location and boundaries of any public works and adjacent land and waters identified or otherwise referred to in Schedule C of the determination;
(b) to establish the precise location of the boundaries of land on which the pastoral improvements referred to in Schedule C of the determination have been constructed and any adjacent land or waters the exclusive use of which is necessary for the enjoyment of the improvements; and
(c) to establish whether any pastoral improvements referred to in Schedule C of the determination have been constructed unlawfully.
6. There be no order as to costs.
THE COURT DETERMINES THAT:
The determination area
1. The determination area is the area described in Schedule A.
The native title holders
2. The determination area comprises land and waters associated with the Jipalpa-Winitjaru, Pikilyi, Yarripilangu-Karrinyarra, Watakinpirri and Winparrku landholding groups respectively.
3. The persons who hold the common or group rights comprising the native title are the Aboriginal persons who are:
(a) members of one or more of the landholding groups referred to in paragraph 2 by virtue of descent (including adoption) through father and father’s father and mother and mother’s father;
(b) accepted as members of one or more of the landholding groups referred to in paragraph 2 by senior members of a landholding group, referred to in subparagraph (a), by virtue of conception or birthplace affiliation.
The native title rights and interests
4. The native title rights and interests of the native title holders are the rights possessed under and exercisable in accordance with their traditional laws and customs, including the right to conduct activities necessary to give effect to them, being:
(a) the right to access and travel over any part of the land and waters;
(b) the right to live on the land, and for that purpose, to camp, erect shelters and other structures;
(c) the right to hunt, gather and fish on the land and waters;
(d) the right to take and use the natural resources of the land and waters;
(e) the right to access, take and use natural water on or in the land;
(f) the right to light fires for domestic purposes, but not for the clearance of vegetation;
(g) the right to access and to maintain and protect sites and places on or in the land and waters that are important under traditional laws and customs;
(h) the right to conduct and participate in the following activities on the land and waters:
(i) cultural activities;
(ii) ceremonies;
(iii) meetings;
(iv) cultural practices relating to birth and death including burial rites;
(v) teaching the physical and spiritual attributes of sites and places on the land and waters that are important under traditional laws and customs,
including the power to regulate the presence of others at any of these activities on the land and waters, other than persons exercising a right conferred by or arising under a law of the Northern Territory of Australia or the Commonwealth of Australia in relation to the use of the land and waters;
(i) the right to make decisions about the use and enjoyment of the land and waters by Aboriginal people who recognise themselves to be governed by the traditional laws and customs acknowledged by the native title holders;
(j) the right to share or exchange natural resources obtained on or from the land and waters, including traditional items made from the natural resources;
(k) the right to be accompanied on the land and waters by persons who, though not native title holders, are:
(i) people required by traditional law and custom for the performance of ceremonies or cultural activities on the land and waters;
(ii) people who have rights in relation to the land and waters according to the traditional laws and customs acknowledged by the native title holders;
(iii) people required by the native title holders to assist in, observe, or record traditional activities on the areas.
5. The native title rights and interests referred to in paragraph 4 hereof do not confer on the native title holders possession, occupation, use and enjoyment of the determination area, to the exclusion of all others.
6. The native title rights and interests referred to in subparagraphs 4(c), (d), (e) and (j) hereof are for the personal or communal needs of the native title holders which are of a domestic or subsistence nature and not for any commercial or business purpose.
7. The native title rights and interests referred to in paragraph 4 hereof are subject to and exercisable in accordance with:
(a) the valid laws of the Northern Territory of Australia and the Commonwealth of Australia;
(b) the traditional laws acknowledged and traditional customs observed by the native title holders.
Other interests in the determination area
8. The nature and extent of other interests in relation to the determination area are the interests, created by the Crown or otherwise, as follows:
(a) the interest of Australian Wildlife Conservancy (ACN 068 572556) under Perpetual Pastoral Lease No. 1078;
(b) the rights of Aboriginal persons (whether or not native title holders) pursuant to the reservation in favour of Aboriginal people contained in pastoral leases set out in s 38(2) to (6) of the Pastoral Land Act 1992 (NT);
(c) the rights of Aboriginal persons (whether or not native title holders) by virtue of the Northern Territory Aboriginal Sacred Sites Act 1989 (NT);
(d) the rights of access by an employee, servant, agent or instrumentality of the Northern Territory or Commonwealth, or other statutory authority as required in the performance of statutory duties;
(e) the interests of persons to whom valid and validated rights and interests have been:
(i) granted by the Crown pursuant to statute otherwise in the exercise of executive power; or
(ii) conferred by statute.
Relationship between rights and interests
9. To the extent that the continued existence, enjoyment or exercise of the native title rights and interests described in paragraph 4 is inconsistent with the existence, enjoyment or exercise of the other rights and interests referred to in paragraph 8 the other rights and interests and the doing of any activity required or permitted to be done by or under the other interests prevail over, but do not extinguish, the native title rights and interests.
Other matters
10. There are no native title rights and interests in:
(a) minerals (as defined in s 2 of the Minerals (Acquisition) Act (NT));
(b) petroleum (as defined in s 5 of the Petroleum Act (NT));
(c) prescribed substances (as defined in s 3 of the Atomic Energy (Control of Materials) Act 1946 (Cth) and/or s 5(1) of the Atomic Energy Act 1953 (Cth));
(d) those parts of the determination area referred to in Schedule C, where native title has been wholly extinguished.
11. In this determination the term:
(a) “natural resources” means:
(i) any form of living or deceased organism, including but not limited to animals (vertebrates and invertebrates) plants and fungi, at any point in the life cycle, and any part thereof; and
(ii) surface soils, clays, stone, rocks and ochre,
but does not include minerals, petroleum and prescribed substances; and
(b) “natural waters” includes springs and rockholes, but does not include any water captured by the holders of Perpetual Pastoral Lease No. 1078.
Schedule A
Determination Area
1. The determination area consists of NT Portion 2406 (Lake Mackay) from Survey Plan S 831085 being an area of 2,610 square kilometres held under Perpetual Pastoral Lease No. 1078.
2. The determination area does not include the strip of land (100 metres wide) being a public road constructed between Newhaven Station Homestead and the eastern boundary of NT Portion 2406.
Schedule B
Map of Determination Area
Schedule C
Areas where native title does not exist
Native title rights and interests have been wholly extinguished in the following areas of land and waters:
Pastoral improvements
Those parts of the determination area being:
(a) the homestead, house, sheds and other buildings;
(b) the constructed airstrip;
(c) bores, turkey nests, squatters’ tanks, constructed dams and other constructed stock watering points;
(d) stockyards and trapyards.
The areas described in (a) to (d) comprise the land on which the improvements were constructed prior to the date of this determination and any adjacent land or waters the exclusive use of which is necessary for the enjoyment of the improvements.
Public works
Those parts of the determination area being the land or waters on which any public work as defined in s 253 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) is situated, including:
(a) public roads and bores (presently the responsibility of the Department of Lands and Planning);
(b) gravel and fill pits (presently the responsibility of the Department of Lands and Planning) that are on land or waters defined in s 251D of the Act;
(c) transmission water pipes, distribution water pipes, sewer pipes, bores, sewer pump stations, overhead power lines (presently the responsibility of Power and Water Corporation)
The areas described in (a) to (c) comprise the land on which the public works were constructed prior to the date of this determination.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
As North J said in Lovett:… when the Court is examining the appropriateness of an agreement, it is not required to examine whether the agreement is grounded on a factual basis which would satisfy the Court at a hearing of the application. The primary consideration of the Court is to determine whether there is an agreement and whether it was freely entered into on an informed basis ….(emphasis added) It follows that the critical issue is whether the existence of a free and informed agreement is founded in fact, not whether the matters dealt with in the agreement, specifically the existence of native title, are founded in fact. In Eringa, Lander J expressed it thus: … the Court adopts a different approach to the task of deciding whether it is appropriate to enter a determination reached by agreement than it brings to the task of deciding whether native title should be recognised in a contested matter. In each case the definition of native title is the same. The Act requires the Court to set out details of the matters mentioned in s 225 in all determinations whether reached by agreement or contest. Although there needs to be some foundation upon which the Court can exercise its jurisdiction, in matters in which the parties have reached agreement on the terms of a determination the Court will have particular interest in whether the agreement has been freely entered into and on an informed basis …. If that question is answered in the affirmative, the Court will consider the fact that an agreement has been reached as weighing in favour of the making of a determination of native title …(emphasis added). In other words, if the material filed by the parties in support of the consent determination establishes a free and informed agreement, the Court will infer the existence of the native title that is at the heart of that agreement. I have emphasised the word “informed” because the process the State respondent party follows to inform itself is critical to this issue. In Munn, Emmett J observed that the Court’s deliberations on an application under s 87:… would include a consideration of the extent to which the State is a party, on the basis that the State, or at least a Minister of the State, appears in the capacity of parens patriae to look after the interests of the community generally. The mere fact that the State was a party may not be sufficient. The Court may need to be satisfied that the State has in fact taken a real interest in the proceeding in the interests of the community generally. That may involve the Court being satisfied that the State has given appropriate consideration to the evidence that has been adduced, or intended to be adduced, in order to reach the compromise that is proposed. The Court, in my view, needs to be satisfied at least that the State, through competent legal representation, is satisfied as to the cogency of the evidence upon which the applicants rely.(emphasis added). It is appropriate to make some comments about the difficult balance a State party needs to strike between its role in protecting the community’s interests, including the stringency of the processes it follows in assessing the underlying evidence going to the existence of native title, and its role in the native title system as a whole, to ensure that it, like the Court and all other parties, takes a flexible approach that is aimed at facilitating negotiation and achieving agreement. In Lovett North J commented: … There is a question as to how far a State party is required to investigate in order to satisfy itself of a credible basis for an application. One reason for the often inordinate time taken to resolve some of these cases is the overly demanding nature of the investigation conducted by State parties. The scope of these investigations demanded by some States is reflected in the complex connection guidelines published by some States.The power conferred by the Act on the Court to approve agreements is given in order to avoid lengthy hearings before the Court. The Act does not intend to substitute a trial, in effect, conducted by State parties for a trial before the Court. Thus, something significantly less than the material necessary to justify a judicial determination is sufficient to satisfy a State party of a credible basis for an application. The Act contemplates a more flexible process than is often undertaken in some cases.