Stuart v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Stuart v State of South Australia [2023] FCAFC 131  

Appeal from: Stuart v State of South Australia (Oodnadatta Common Overlap Proceeding) (No 4) [2021] FCA 1620
File numbers: SAD 16 of 2022
SAD 17 of 2022
Judgment of: RANGIAH, CHARLESWORTH AND O'BRYAN JJ
Date of judgment: 14 August 2023
Catchwords: APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – NATIVE TITLE – appeal from orders made on overlapping native title determination applications – claims brought on behalf of the Arabana people and the Walka Wani people – trial judge finding the ancestors of the Arabana people occupied the overlap area at sovereignty – trial judge concluding the Arabana claim group did not presently possess native title rights and interests in the overlap area – trial judge concluding the Arabana people did not, by their traditional laws and customs, have a connection with the overlap area – whether the trial judge misconstrued or misapplied the definition of native title in s 223 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) – whether the orders or conclusions of the primary judge are inconsistent with a determination of native title in favour of the same claimants in an adjacent area – trial judge making a determination of native title in favour of the Walka Wani people – trial judge finding there to be a consensus among expert witnesses as to the existence and nature of native title rights and interests in a report of a joint conference of experts – whether the finding of a consensus was open on the material before the primary judge – whether there was a sufficient evidentiary basis for a determination describing the nature of the rights and interests possessed by all members of the Walka Wani claim group – where error affecting that finding justifies the setting aside of the native title determination – whether there is a proper basis to order a new trial
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 27, 28

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 13, 51, 61, 67, 87, 87A, 94A, 223, 225

Aboriginal Lands Trust Act 1966 (SA)

Cases cited:

AB (dec’d) (on behalf of the Ngarla People) v Western Australia (No 4) [2012] FCA 1268; 300 ALR 193

Akiba v Queensland (No 3) (2010) 204 FCR 1

Akiba v The Commonwealth (2013) 250 CLR 209

Attorney-General (NT) v Ward (2003) 134 FCR 16

Banjima People v Western Australia (2015) 231 FCR 456

Bodney v Bennell (2008) 167 FCR 84

CG v Western Australia (2016) 240 FCR 466

Commonwealth v Akiba (2012) 204 FCR 260

Dale v Western Australia (2011) 191 FCR 521

De Rose v South Australia (No 2) (2005) 145 FCR 290

De Rose v State of South Australia (2003) 133 FCR 325

Dodd v State of South Australia [2012] FCA 519

Drury v Western Australia (2020) 267 FCR 203

Fortescue Metals Group v Warrie (2019) 273 FCR 350

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118

Harvey v The King [1901] AC 601

Hill v Clifford

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stuart v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCAFC 131
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Stuart v State of South Australia involved an appeal against the orders made on overlapping native title determination applications brought on behalf of the Arabana people and the Walka Wani people. The central issue in this case was whether the trial judge had misconstrued or misapplied the definition of native title as set out in section 223 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth). Additionally, the court examined if the trial judge's findings and orders were inconsistent with the determination of native title in favour of the same claimants in an adjacent area. Another key issue was whether there was a sufficient evidentiary basis for the determination of the nature of the rights and interests possessed by all members of the Walka Wani claim group.

The court examined the evidence presented, including the historical migration of the Arabana people away from the overlap area, and the testimonies of expert witnesses. The primary judge concluded that the Arabana apical ancestors had native title rights and interests in the overlap area at sovereignty. However, the judge also concluded that the Arabana people did not presently possess native title rights and interests in the overlap area and did not have a connection with the overlap area by their traditional laws and customs. The court found that the trial judge's conclusions were consistent with the determination of native title in favour of the Walka Wani people and that the finding of a consensus was open on the material before the primary judge. However, the court found that there was not a sufficient evidentiary basis for a determination describing the nature of the rights and interests possessed by all members of the Walka Wani claim group. Consequently, the court held that the appeal should be allowed, and the orders and determination made in the primary judge's decision should be set aside.

The court ordered that the originating application in SAD78/2013 is dismissed, and the originating application in SAD220/2018 is dismissed. These orders reflect the court's findings that the primary judge's determination was flawed due to insufficient evidentiary basis for the determination of the nature of the rights and interests possessed by all members of the Walka Wani claim group. The court's decision highlights the importance of a robust evidentiary basis for determinations of native title rights and interests, and the need for careful consideration of the connection between a claimant group and the area in question.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The following orders are set aside:

(a) paragraphs 2 and 3 of the orders made on 21 December 2021 in SAD 38/2013; and

(b) the orders and determination made on 23 December 2021 in SAD78/2013 and SAD220/2018.

3. In lieu thereof there be the following orders:

(a) the originating application in SAD78/2013 is dismissed.

(b) the originating application in SAD220/2018 is dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The State admitted that the Arabana people continued to acknowledge and observe a system of laws and customs under which they possessed NTRI in the area subject to the 2012 Arabana Determination. However, it put the Arabana people to proof in respect of whether, by those traditional laws and customs the Arabana people held NTRI in the Overlap Area, and particularly on the matters pleaded at [36] and [37] in respect of connection. The State admitted the matters pleaded at [38] – [40], but only insofar as those paragraphs related to the area subject to the 2012 Arabana Determination.The conclusions of the primary judge The primary judge concluded that the Arabana apical ancestors had NTRI in the Overlap Area at effective sovereignty (at [410], [537], [842]). In their closing submissions at trial, all parties accepted that conclusion to have been an “inevitable” conclusion on the ethnographic, anthropological and linguistic evidence (at [842]). There is no challenge by any party to that finding on either appeal. As to the significance of the surrounding determinations, the primary judge said:54It was common ground that each of the 2006 Yankunytjatjara/Antakarinja Determination and the 2012 Arabana Determination had ‘determined as a fundamental matter, once and for all’ that NTRI existed in the areas to which those determinations related and that the NTRI were held by the Yankunytjatjara/Antakarinja People and the Arabana People respectively. This means that each has been recognised as a society or communal group of people holding rights and interests possessed under traditional law acknowledged and the traditional customs observed by them having a connection with the respective determination areas. These determinations and these recognitions cannot be called into question in the present proceedings – see Lake Torrens Full Court at [198]-[202], [401].55The same may be said with respect to the Eringa No 1 and Eringa No 2 Determinations. As the State submitted, each of these four determinations is to be taken to have established conclusively that the identified Aboriginal peoples held NTRI, as described in the determinations, with respect to each determination area ‘at sovereignty and [have] at all times since then’, so that the Court should not attach any weight to evidence which is directly inconsistent with those determined facts: Lake Torrens Full Court at [198]-[201]. The primary judge had regard to a considerable body of historical evidence to the effect that there had been a progressive southward migration of the Arabana away from the Overlap Area (at [538] – [580]). His Honour also had regard to the evidence of expert witnesses called by each party. Relevantly for these appeals, they were anthropologists Dr Scott Cane, Dr Belinda Liebelt and Mr Robert Graham (called by the Walka Wani), Dr Rodney Lucas (called by the Arabana), Dr Lee Sackett (called by the State), and an historian Mr Tom Gara (called by the State). The Arabana called six lay witnesses. We will consider the relevant aspects of their evidence in the disposition of each argument on the appeal. The primary judge made the following observations by way of summary:658By way of brief summary of the evidence of the six Arabana witnesses, it can be said that none is presently a resident of Oodnadatta; two (Aaron Stuart and Leonie Warren) have lived there as permanent residents in the past, but the periods during which they did so were relatively short. For reasons which will become apparent, I think it probable that Aaron Stuart had had only one period of residence in Oodnadatta and that was attributable to him being stationed there as a Community Police Officer. With the exception of his involvement in a site clearance in 2004, Aaron Stuart does not seem otherwise to have been involved in the care of Arabana interests in the Overlap Area. The physical connections of the other witnesses to the Overlap Area have often occurred when they were passing through Oodnadatta (Sydney Strangways), when visiting relatives or friends, or when attending functions such as races and gymkhanas. There is, however, evidence of contemporary camping, hunting and gathering by Joanne and Leonie Warren, and to a lesser extent by Dr Arbon.659There is some, but by no means extensive, familiarity with Arabana law and culture, and some, but again not extensive, evidence of the passing on of that knowledge. There is relatively little evidence of actual protection of sites, of the teaching of law and culture in relation to particular sites or locations, of an intimate knowledge of the Overlap Area, and of attending to cultural responsibilities.660Aaron Stuart did know of the Arabana Ularaka and myths associated with Oodnadatta and I accept that he has been taught them by Laurie Stuart in particular. However, Aaron Stuart’s evidence did not convey a sense of being actually connected to the country through those Ularaka. Mr Strangways does know the Ularaka, but the knowledge by the other Arabana witnesses of them was limited.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.