Dodd v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dodd v State of South Australia [2012] FCA 519

Citation: Dodd v State of South Australia [2012] FCA 519
Parties: REGINALD DODD, LAURIE STUART (DECEASED) and MILLIE WARREN v THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA, COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA, SOUTH AUSTRALIAN NATIVE TITLE SERVICES INC, KUYANI PEOPLE, DIERI PEOPLE, AUSTRALIAN WILDLIFE CONSERVANCY, TONY BOYD, ANDREW TREVOR CLARKE, MACUMBA PASTORAL COMPANY PTY LTD, MULOORINA STATION, STRANGWAYS SPRINGS PTY LTD, BLANUSA OPALS PTY LTD, LAURA HOLDINGS PTY LTD, ALFONZ NAGYSZOLLOSI, MARY M NAGYSZOLLOSI, OZ MINERALS PROMINENT HILL OPERATIONS PTY LTD, SCORPION EXPLORATION PTY LTD, TASMAN RESOURCES LTD, BHP BILLITON OLYMPIC DAM CORPORATION PTY LTD, TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED, TERMITE RESOURCES N.L. and SOUTH AUSTRALIAN APIARISTS ASSOCIATION INC
File number: SAD 6025 of 1998
Judge: FINN J
Date of judgment: 22 May 2012
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE - Consent Determination - requirements under s 87 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)
Legislation: Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) s 47A, s 47B, s 87, s 223, s 225, Part 2, Division 3
Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA)
Cases cited: King v South Australia (2011) 285 ALR 454 cited
Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria (2002) 214 CLR 422 cited
Risk v Northern Territory [2006] FCA 404 cited
De Rose v State of South Australia (No 2) (2005) 145 FCR 290 cited
Date of hearing: 22 May 2012
Place: Finniss Springs Station, South Australia
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 77
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr S Kenny
Solicitor for the Applicants: Camatta Lempens
Counsel for the First Respondent: Ms G Reid
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Crown Solicitor's Office
Counsel for the Pastoralists: Mr T Mellor
Solicitor for the Pastoralists: Mellor Olsson
Counsel for the South Australian Native Title Services: Ms B Lena
Solicitor for the South Australian Native Title Services: South Australian Native Title Services Ltd
Counsel for Oz Minerals Prominent Hill Operations Pty Ltd: Ms J Dnistrianski
Solicitor for Oz Minerals Prominent Hill Operations Pty Ltd: Finlaysons

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

SAD 6025 of 1998

BETWEEN:

REGINALD DODD, LAURIE STUART (DECEASED), MILLIE WARREN
Applicants

AND:

THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA, COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA, SOUTH AUSTRALIAN NATIVE TITLE SERVICES INC, KUYANI PEOPLE, DIERI PEOPLE, AUSTRALIAN WILDLIFE CONSERVANCY, TONY BOYD, ANDREW TREVOR CLARKE, MACUMBA PASTORAL COMPANY PTY LTD, MULOORINA STATION, STRANGWAYS SPRINGS PTY LTD, BLANUSA OPALS PTY LTD, LAURA HOLDINGS PTY LTD, ALFONZ NAGYSZOLLOSI, MARY M NAGYSZOLLOSI, OZ MINERALS PROMINENT HILL OPERATIONS PTY LTD, SCORPION EXPLORATION PTY LTD, TASMAN RESOURCES LTD, BHP BILLITON OLYMPIC DAM CORPORATION PTY LTD, TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED, TERMITE RESOURCES N.L., SOUTH AUSTRALIAN APIARISTS ASSOCIATION INC
Respondents

JUDGE:

FINN J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 MAY 2012

WHERE MADE:

FINNISS SPRINGS STATION, SOUTH AUSTRALIA

Preamble

AThe Applicant first lodged Native Title Determination Application No. SAD 6025 of 1998 (the Application) with the National Native Title Tribunal on 16 January 1998 in relation to lands and waters in northern South Australia which are now the subject of a proposed determination of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dodd v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 519
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Dodd v State of South Australia was heard in the Federal Court of Australia and involved a dispute regarding a proposed Consent Determination for a native title claim. The Arabana native title claim group sought to amend the eastern boundary of their claim to exclude the area east of Lake Eyre, based on evidence that this area was not traditionally Arabana land. The State of South Australia agreed to the amendment, but other parties, including Laura Holdings Pty Ltd and Raelene Warren, did not consent to the proposed changes.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the steps taken by the State to satisfy itself of the matters stipulated in section 223 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) were rigorous enough to form a credible basis for the Arabana's application. The court also needed to determine whether the terms of the proposed Consent Determination met the requirements of section 225 of the Act. This involved assessing the particularity with which the Consent Determination defined the areas in which native title exists, excluded areas where native title had been extinguished, identified the group of native title holders, and described the nature and extent of the native title rights and interests.

The court found that the State's approach to verifying the Arabana's application was comprehensive and rigorous. This included engaging expert anthropologists, conducting a thorough review of ethno-historical literature, and participating in a fieldtrip with the experts and members of the claim group. The court was satisfied that the steps taken by the State provided a credible basis for the Arabana's application. The court also found that the proposed Consent Determination met all the requirements of section 225 of the Act, detailing the determination area, excluded areas, group membership criteria, and the nature and extent of the native title rights and interests.

The court concluded that the proposed Consent Determination was appropriate and ordered that it be made. This determination recognised the Arabana people's native title rights and interests in the specified areas, with non-exclusive rights recognised in the determination area.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

An Application has been brought to amend the Arabana claim to withdraw the eastern boundary of the claim to the eastern shoreline of Lake Eyre. This reflects the evidence that the area to the east of Lake Eyre was not traditionally Arabana country.The Evidence The experts engaged on behalf of the Applicants, Drs Deane Fergie and Rod Lucas, prepared an expert report which addressed a series of propositions directed at s 223 of the Act the provisions of which are referred to below. These propositions were formulated through consultation between the experts and the State (“Table of Expert Opinions”). Prior to considering the propositions the State, through its in-house anthropologist Mr Kim McCaul, conducted a thorough review of the publically available ethno-historical literature for the claim area. As a result, the State was able to agree several propositions at the outset without requiring they be further substantiated. Except where the State agreed that no further evidence was required, the expert material consists of the opinions reached by the experts in relation to the propositions, and the evidence or other material relied on by them to form their opinions. Drs Deane Fergie and Rod Lucas are consultant anthropologists with considerable professional and academic experience, both generally and with regard to native title. Dr Fergie holds a Senior Lectureship in Anthropology at the University of Adelaide and is the founder of LocuSAR, an interdisciplinary social analysis and research team at the University of Adelaide. Dr Fergie has prepared native title reports for claims in both South Australia and Victoria. Dr Lucas also holds a Lectureship in Anthropology at the University of Adelaide. He has been a consultant on a large number of cultural heritage surveys and several native title matters and in these contexts he has worked with a number of Aboriginal groups across South Australia. The above material was also supplemented by historical and genealogical research undertaken by the State’s in-house historian, Mr Tom Gara. Mr Gara is a professional Historian who has specialised in native title matters since 1995. As a Consultant Historian, he has carried out historical research for a number of native title claims, both in South Australia and interstate. With the agreement of the Applicants, State officers participated in a fieldtrip, during which a legal officer and Mr McCaul accompanied the experts and members of the claim group through the southern half of the claim area, between Marree and Coober Pedy, over a period of four days. This approach has not previously been adopted by either the State or any applicant group in South Australia. Overall, the State found this process helpful in providing a fuller understanding of the claim group, the claim area, and the nature of the claimants’ contemporary connection to country. The State officers found the claimants who participated in the fieldtrip to be credible and knowledgeable and to have demonstrated that there continues to be a strong contemporary connection to the determination area.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Evidence was given of the importance to Arabana people of protecting their country, in particular, the preservation of their mound springs and other water sources, which are both critical natural resources and the loci of many Ularaka. Arabana people have sought over a number of years to have areas and places of significance entered on the heritage register under the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1988 (SA) and there are a large number of recorded sites across the claim area.Conclusion on s 223 I conclude for present purposes that the steps taken by the State to satisfy itself of the matters stipulated in s 223 as they relate to the Arabana claim were rigorous and, as described in the Submissions could properly satisfy it that there was a credible basis for the Arabana’s application.Section 225 of the Act The terms of the proposed Consent Determination satisfy the requirements of s 225 of the Act. The Consent Determination sets out with particularity the area in which native title exists (the Determination Area). Paragraphs 10, 12, 13 and 15 (Schedule 3) set out all areas excluded from the determination area because native title has been extinguished. For the purposes of s 225(a), paragraph 5 of the Consent Determination defines the group of native title holders and the criteria by which they have group membership. For the purposes of s 225(b), paragraph 6 of the Consent Determination sets out the nature and extent of the native title rights and interests in the determination area. The rights so recognised are non-exclusive rights. For the purposes of s 225(c), paragraph 16 of the Consent Determination sets out the nature and extent of other interests in the determination area. The State’s comprehensive tenure searches have not identified any other relevant interest holders in the determination area. For the purposes of s 225(d), paragraph 17 of the Consent Determination describes the relationship between the native title rights in paragraph 6 and those other rights in paragraph 16. For the purposes of s 225(e), the majority of the Determination Area is covered by non-exclusive pastoral leases. There are no exclusive native title rights in the determination area. Other Matters I would note that all but two of the respondent parties have signed the Minute of Consent. One of these, Laura Holdings Pty Ltd, is no longer at its address for service. An ASIC gazette of 26 March 2010 listed it as being deregistered. The other listed respondent, Raelene Warren, was served with the draft consent orders on several occasions and was contacted by phone by a solicitor for the State on several occasions. Mrs Warren refused to indicate whether she would or would not sign the minute. She has had every opportunity to make her views known to the parties and to the court but has not done so. I would also note that most of the parties to this determination (which include the Commonwealth, very substantial mining interests and pastoralists) have had independent legal advice in the proceeding. Extinguishment

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.