Clarrie Smith v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Clarrie Smith v State of Western Australia [2000] FCA 1249

CLARRIE SMITH AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE NHARNUWANGGA, WAJARRI AND NGARLA PEOPLE v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & ORS

WAG 72, 73, 74 & 75 of 1998

MADGWICK J
3 OCTOBER 2000
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA

DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAG 72, 73, 74 and 75 of 1998

BETWEEN:

CLARRIE SMITH AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE NHARNUWANGGA, WAJARRI AND NGARLA PEOPLE
APPLICANT

AND:

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
FIRST RESPONDENT

SHIRE OF MEEKATHARRA
SECOND RESPONDENT

BG, LW & MDE BAIN, AG & EA BAIN, LW BAIN & DE MILES, DA O’DWYER & MDE, LE & BJ BAIN & CJ MACLEOD, DAWVILLE PTY LTD, JE & RE DAY, KH ELLIOT, ER & SV FORRESTER, J & D GARRITY & F DANIEL, CJ & SM GRAHAM, PG HALL, DR HAMMARQUIST, D, MA & RJ HEWETT, BM MAGUIRE & TUREE PASTORAL COMPANY PTY LTD, MT AUGUSTRUS STATION (1980) PTY LTD, BA & PM PANIZZA, PASTORALISTS & GRAZIERS ASSOCIATION OF WA INC, TM & GM PENS, DP STEVENS & ME ROACH, SUNBLADE HOLDINGS PTY LTD, JP TENNANT, GJ & HE WILLIAMS, CT WOODS, CF & CT WRIGHT
THIRD RESPONDENTS

ARCHAEAN GOLD NL, ARIMCO MINING PTY LTD, COLIN ROSS ATKINS, AUGUST VENTURES PTY LTD, BARRACK MINES LTD, CAMBRIAN RESOURCES NL, GRANGE RESOURCES NL, GRANTS PATCH MINING LTD, HORSHOE GOLD MINE PTY LTD, LACHLAN RESOURCES NL, LEGENDRE & CAMBRIAN RESOURCES, MIM EXPLORATION PTY LTD, MINES AND RESOURCES AUSTRALIA PTY LTD, NORMANDY INDUSTRIAL MINERALS LTD, RGC EXPLORATION PTY LTD, PEKO EXPLORATION LTD, PERILYA MINES NL, PLUTONIC (BAXTER) PTY LTD, PLUTONIC OPERATIONS LTD, RENISON LTD, ST BARBARA MINES LTD, SWAN GOLD NL, TROY RESOURCES NL, WHIM CREEK CONSOLIDATED NL, ZYGOT LTD
FOURTH RESPONDENTS

TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED
FIFTH RESPONDENT
VAGETA PTY LTD
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

CMS GAS TRANSMISSION OF AUSTRALIA
EIGHTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 AUGUST 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

CORRIGENDUM

His Honours Reasons for Decision dated 29 August 2000, are to be amended as follows:

On page 10, paragraph 28, line 2, after the words “…I am bound by the rulings of the Full Court of this Court in” the following needs to be inserted “Western Australia v Ward”.

Associate:
Date: 3 October 2000


FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Clarrie Smith v State of Western Australia [2000] FCA 1249

NATIVE TITLE – innovative settlement – nature of court’s discretion to make orders in settlement of native title cases.

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 87(1), 87(2)

Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) 152 CLR 83 referred to
Western Australia v Ward & Ors (2000) 170 ALR 159 cited
The State of Western Australia v Ward [2000] FCA 611 cited

CLARRIE SMITH AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE NHARNUWANGGA, WAJARRI AND NGARLA PEOPLE v THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA & ORS

WAG 72, 73, 74 & 75 of 1998

MADGWICK J
29 AUGUST 2000
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA

DISTRICT REGISTRY

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clarrie Smith v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1249
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Clarrie Smith v State of Western Australia, the primary dispute involved the recognition and protection of native title over a significant area of land, primarily for future mining activities. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The central legal issues revolved around the existence of native title, its extinguishment by past acts, and the appropriate framework for future dealings affecting native title, particularly concerning mining activities and pastoral leases.

The court examined whether it had the authority to approve the settlement terms agreed upon by the parties, which included a non-exclusive native title declaration, an Indigenous Land Use Agreement, and provisions for compensation for future mining activities. The court concluded that the settlement was consistent with the objectives of the Native Title Act 1993 and was in the best interest of all parties involved. The settlement provided a clear framework for economic activities to proceed while protecting Aboriginal heritage sites and ensuring the recognition of native title holders.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the parties' agreement and the evidence presented, which demonstrated the survival of traditional laws and practices among the claimant group. The settlement's terms were deemed fair and just, offering a resolution to the long-standing battle for native title recognition. The court found it appropriate to approve the settlement, as it facilitated a practical and equitable interaction between native title holders and other stakeholders, such as pastoralists and mining interests.

The final orders included the approval of the amended application, the declaration of native title rights and interests, and the extinguishment of native title in certain areas. The orders also mandated the registration of the Indigenous Land Use Agreement and provided for the payment of costs by the respective parties. The court granted general liberty to apply, ensuring flexibility in future proceedings related to the settlement.

Orders

Orders of the court

By consent:

1. The Applicants have leave to amend the application in the terms of the Minute of Proposed Amended Application (Attachment D) and that the minute stand as the amended application in these proceedings.

2. 2.1 Native title exists in the "determination area" save, subject to paragraph 2.4, for the areas of land or waters described in the Second Schedule. The determination area is that part of the land or waters within the area depicted by blue outline on the map in the First Schedule as does not include land or waters in respect of which no application for determination of native title was made by the applicants in the application lodged with the National Native Title Tribunal referred to the Court by the Tribunal, as that application has been amended from time to time.

2.2 Native title existing in the determination area is held by the community of Nharnuwangga, Wajarri and Ngarlawangga people, hereafter described as the common law holders of native title.

2.3 Subject to paragraphs 2.4, 2.5, 2.6 and 2.7 hereof the nature and extent of the native title rights and interests existing in the balance of the determination area are as follows:

(a) the right as against any other Aboriginal group or individual to be acknowledged as the traditional Aboriginal owners of the land;

(b) the right to hunt, fish and gather (including to gather ochre) for the purpose of satisfying their personal, domestic or non-commercial communal needs, including observing traditional laws and customs; and

(c) the right to have access to and camp on the balance of the determination area in order to:

(i) exercise the rights set out in (b) above;

(ii) travel through; and

(iii) visit and care for places which are of cultural or spiritual importance.

2.4 The native title rights and interests described in paragraph 2.3 above subsist in the land comprising Yulga Jinna Aboriginal Community being that land of 25.0007 hectares in extent as illustrated in diagram number LAWA 1210 dated 14 February 1997 in Western Australia Department of Land Administration file number 634/993, and in Reserve Number 22309 known as Peak Hill Reserve, and in Pastoral Lease Number 3114/1018, North West Division, Teano District, Teano Location 22, known as Mulgul Station.

2.5 The nature and extent of other interests in relation to the determination area are the interests created by the Crown or created otherwise, as set out in the Third Schedule.

2.6 There is no native title right or interest in minerals and petroleum in the State as defined in the Mining Act 1904 (WA), the Mining Act 1978 (WA), and the Petroleum Act 1936 (WA). In all nature reserves or wildlife sanctuaries created in Western Australia in the determination area before the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) came into operation, native title to take fauna has been wholly extinguished.

2.7 To the extent that any inconsistency exists between the native title rights and interests referred to in paragraphs 2.3 and 2.4 and the rights conferred by any other interests referred to in paragraph 2.5 hereof the native title rights and interests must yield to such other rights.

2.8 The native title rights and interests described in paragraphs 2.3 and 2.4 are subject to regulation, control, curtailment or restriction by State laws of general application including the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 and by valid laws of Australia.

2.9 The native title rights and interests referred to in paragraph 2.3 and 2.4 are not exclusive of the rights and interests of others.

2.10 Within one month of the date of this determination coming into effect, a representative of the common law native title holders may indicate whether they intend to have the native title held in trust by:

(a) nominating, in writing given to the Federal Court, a prescribed body corporate to be trustee of the native title; and

(b) including with the nomination the written consent of the body corporate.

2.11 If a prescribed body corporate is nominated in accordance with paragraph 2.10, it will hold the native title rights and interests described in paragraph 2.3 in trust for the common law holders.

2.12 If a prescribed body corporate is not nominated in accordance with paragraph 2.10, the native title rights and interests described in paragraph 2.3 will be held by the common law holders.

FIRST SCHEDULE

SECOND SCHEDULE

Native title has been extinguished in the following areas and/or by the following acts:

1.

(a) those parts of pastoral leases leases granted in the determination area under the Land Regulations 1882 (WA), the Land Regulations (1887) (WA) and the Land Act 1898 (WA) which were, prior to 1994, "enclosed and improved" within the meaning of the reservations in favour of Aboriginal people contained in the said pastoral leases, and

(b) those parts of pastoral leases granted in the determination area under the Land Act 1933 (WA) which were, prior to 1994, enclosed or improved within the meaning of s 106 of the Land Act 1933.

2. mining or general purpose leases granted under the Mining Act 1978 prior to 1994 and gold mining leases, mineral leases and coal mining leases granted under the Mining Act 1904;

3. any interests set out in the Titles (Validation) Act and Native Title (Effect of Past Acts) Act 1995 as extinguishing native title; and

4. any interests that are wholly inconsistent with native title rights and interests.

5. Lot 195 Peak Hill, formerly the subject of Certificate of Title Volume 1293 Folio 841 (Peak Hill telephone exchange).

6. The whole of the following Reserves for the purpose of 'repeater' or 'repeater station':

(a) Reserve 40710 (Touhey DRCS)

(b) Reserve 40869 (Facey DRCS))

(c) Reserve 41016 (Dunns Range DRCS))

(d) Reserve 41151 (BaTthewmurnarna DRCS))

(e) Reserve 42690 (Bundabunda DRCS))

(f) Reserve 44235 (Robinson DRS)

(g) Reserve 44454 (Fremanga DCRS);

7. Part of Lot 111 Peak Hill, being an area of 5666.7 square metres, the boundaries of which, commencing from the northernmost corner of Lot 195 Peak Hill, are 36 metres bearing 42 degrees 56 minutes and then a boundary of 86.67 metres bearing 132 degrees 56 minutes and then a boundary of 77.68 metres bearing 222 degrees 56 minutes and then a boundary of 61.09 metres bearing 312 degrees 56 minutes and then a boundary of 41.68 metres bearing 42 degrees 56 minutes and then a boundary of 25.59 metres bearing 313 degrees 59 minutes and 24 seconds back to the point of commencement (Peak Hill DRCS);

8. Part of Reserve 35104 (Collier Range National Park) being a aquare-shaped area of 10,000 square metres (100 metres by 100 metres), the corner points of which are located 70.71 metres from a central station mark located at AMG 84 Zone 50 North 7272469, East 683010, on the following bearings 45 degrees, 135 degrees, 225 degrees and 315 degrees (Begg Hill DRCS);

9. Part of Teano Location 23 (Mingah Springs Station) being an area of 966 square metres in the shape of an equilateral triangle with sides 47.22 metres, the southernmost point of which is located 26.99 metres from station mark AMG 84 Zone 50 North 7239381 East 672940 on a bearing of 180 degrees 57 minutes 6 seconds, the further two corner-points being located 47.22 metres from the southernmost corner-point on a bearing of 331 degrees 0 minutes 38 seconds and 31 degrees 0 minutes 38 seconds (Mingah Springs DRCS).

THIRD SCHEDULE

Other interests in the determination area are of the following kind:

(a) an Indigenous Land Use Agreement entered into by or on behalf of the Nharnuwangga Wajarri and Ngarlawangga People of the one part and the State of Western Australia of the other part relating to the determination area and dated [date]

(b) pastoral access agreements entered into by or on behalf of the Nharnuwangga Wajarri and Ngarlawangga People of the first part and the State of Western Australia of the second part and certain pastoral lessees of the third part in each case relating to access to certain pastoral leases situated within or partly within the determination area

(c) Interests of persons in whom Crown reserves are vested under the Land Act 1898 (WA) or Land Act 1933 (WA) or under a lease of the reserve.

(d) the interests of the National Parks and Nature Conservation Authority under the Conservation and Land Management Act 1984 (WA) in Reserve no. 35104, being land vested in the Authority.

(e) Interests of persons entitled to use reserves according to a purpose for which Crown land is reserved, or under a lease made for the purpose of the reserve.

(f) Interests of lessees under:

(i) Leases granted under the Land Act 1933 (WA);

(ii) Leases granted under the Mining Act 1978 (WA);

(iii) Leases granted under the Aboriginal Affairs Planning Authority Act 1972 (Cth).

(g) Interests of licensees under:

(i) Licences issued under the Land Act 1933 (WA);

(ii) Licences issued under the Mining Act 1978 (WA);

(iii) Licences issued under the Wildlife Conservation Act 1950 (WA);

(iv) Licences issued under the Rights in Water and Irrigation Act 1914 (WA);

(v) Licences issued under the Transport Co‑ordination Act 1966 (WA);

(vi) Licences issued under the Petroleum Pipelines Act 1969 (WA)

(h) Interests of holders of permits issued under:the Land Act 1933 (WA);

(i) Interests of holders of tenements under the Mining Act 1904 (WA).

(j) Interests of holders of tenements under the Petroleum Act 1936 (WA) and the Petroleum Act 1967 (WA).

(k) Interests of holders of rights or licences under the Goldfields Gas Pipeline Agreement Act 1994 (WA)

(l) Other interests obtained by reason of provisions of legislation of the State, Territory or Commonwealth.

(m) Other interests held by members of the public arising under the common law.

(n) The interests of Telstra Corporation Limited with respect to telecommunications facilities installed within the determination area which were created pursuant to the Post and Telegraph Act 1901 (Cth), the Telecommunications Act 1975 (Cth), the Australian Telecommunications Corporation Act 1989 (Cth), the Telecommunications Act 1991 (Cth) and the Telecommunication Act 1997 (Cth).

THE COURT FURTHER ORDERS THAT:

By consent:

3. Each party will pay its own costs of the proceedings.

4. Paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of this order will not come into operation and effect unless and until:

(a) the indigenous land use agreement (Attachment A) is registered by the Native Title Registrar as an indigenous land use agreement under section 24CG(1) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth); and

(b) registration is effected within a period of twelve months from the date of this order.

5. There be general liberty to apply.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Indigenous Land Use Agreement which is to be executed by the State and by the applicants is principally directed towards providing a framework under which future mining activities can proceed, but in a way which will recognise and protect significant Aboriginal sites. In particular, the Indigenous Land Use Agreement provides that the native title holders will forego their right to negotiate, under the Act in respect of the grant of future mining tenements. However, they will replace that right with agreed rights of consultation and compensation under a State-based regime, once a proposed mining venture reaches the stage of productive mining. Aboriginal sites will be protected under an agreed form of Heritage Agreement between the miner and the native title holders.Background Representatives of the claimant group, led by an indomitable man, Mr Clarrie Smith and other determined people, including Mrs Linda Riley and Mrs Gladys Leake and her late husband, some years ago walked onto and have since lived on, and established and secured legal title to land in the claim area on which there is now a community and village called Yulga Jinna. The Yulga Jinna people and others who, according to what survives of traditional Aboriginal laws and practices, may speak for their communities authoritatively in respect of the land concerned, came together to present a unified claim on behalf of the Nharnuwangga, Wajarri and Ngarlawangga people over the much larger area now claimed. Evidence was heard by the Court at various places on the land concerned. There was evidence of the survival, despite the decimation of Aboriginal populations and their dispossession of their lands since the coming of white people, of a community observing so far as is possible, in modern circumstances, traditionally based laws and customs. Other evidence included rigorously criticised anthropological evidence and studies by two professional historians. The evidence also showed, again so far as is possible in modern circumstances and in the actual circumstances of the surviving members of the claimant groups, a continuing connection with the land in question. There were, however, live issues about all these matters. The evidence could support a conclusion that native title was, at least over considerable areas, non-exclusive. On the material before me, the extent of extinguishment of native title by past acts was uncertain. By agreement, the parties had deferred extinguishment issues for later consideration in the case. However, they have now dealt with these issues in their settlement. On the other hand, commencing before the turn of the last century, there has been significant mining activity at various points within, and increasing pastoral activity over much of the area claimed. Over the great bulk of the land there are now twenty functioning cattle stations operating under pastoral leases. In addition, the Western Australian State Government has, over many years, asserted its right to many parts of the land for roads, other infrastructure and various other public purposes. Much of the land is in the Shire of Meekatharra, the Council of which became a party to the proceedings but has taken no active part in them. The parties who have taken an active part in the proceedings have been the claimants, the State Government, the pastoralists and to a lesser extent, the mining interests and Telstra.Settlement achieved

Decision

Reasons for decision

MADGWICK J
According to the main objects of the Act as set out in s 3, the Act aims to provide for the recognition and protection of native title and to establish ways in which future dealings affecting native title may proceed and to set standards for these dealings. There is also a number of provisions in the Act, which provide for mediation and means to assist in resolving issues without the necessity for judicial determination: see s 86B, s 86F(2) and (3) and s 88(1).Conclusions It is for the Court to determine whether it is within the Court's power, and if it is, whether it is appropriate, to make orders consistent with the terms of the parties' settlement. Where the orders sought can reasonably be related to the evidentiary materials before the Court and the parties have had legal representation, it is not for the Court to exercise any paternalistic role as to the merits or demerits of the proposed settlement. However, it is to be borne in mind that, although it is the parties to this case who have arrived at the agreement, determinations of native title have effect as against all the world, and that there can be only one native title determination in relation to any particular area of land or waters (s 68). The settlement would appear to have the following effects, among others:·subject to protection of aboriginal heritage in relation to sites of spiritual and cultural significance, present economic activities and future economic development will be able to proceed on a sure footing;·the long battle of Mr Clarrie Smith and the other applicants, for recognition of their native title will be concluded on terms that are satisfactory to them;·the native title declared will be on a non-exclusive basis;·the principal rules have been worked out as to practical interaction between the native title holders and those such as the pastoralists who have other rights to be on and to use the land. It is an important consideration in my mind, that it would probably not be possible for this Court to settle such a working out of on-the-ground practicalities without the agreement of the parties;·if new active mining is undertaken, compensation will be payable to the claimant group. The settlement proposed seems to me to be justified by the evidence. I bear in mind also that I am bound by the rulings of the Full Court of this Court in, which appear not to be helpful to the applicants in relation to extinguishment issues. The parties have, however, properly had regard to what may be a degree of uncertainty about the extent to which that decision has finally resolved legal questions as to how far the grant of Western Australian pastoral leases has extinguished native title. The High Court of Australia has granted leave to appeal in relation to important aspects of that decision but the appeal has not yet been determined. The terms of the settlement appear to me to be consistent with the objectives and purposes of the Act. I therefore now indicate that in my view, the Court does have power to make the orders sought, that it is appropriate to do so and that I will make the orders proposed.Those responsible

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MADGWICK J

The Court found that the settlement achieved was consistent with the objectives and purposes of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (the Act). It considered that the settlement provided a framework for future mining activities to proceed while recognising and protecting significant Aboriginal sites, and provided satisfactory terms to the native title holders for the recognition of their native title rights. The Court also noted that the settlement provided for the protection of Aboriginal heritage in relation to sites of spiritual and cultural significance, and allowed for present economic activities and future economic development to proceed on a sure footing. The Court further considered that it would probably not be possible for the Court to settle such a working out of on-the-ground practicalities without the agreement of the parties. The Court was also mindful that determinations of native title have effect as against all the world, and that there can be only one native title determination in relation to any particular area of land or waters (s 68). The Court held that it was within its power, and appropriate, to make orders consistent with the terms of the parties' settlement, and that it would make the orders proposed. The Court applied the principles of the Act, including the provisions for mediation and means to assist in resolving issues without the necessity for judicial determination, and considered the evidence presented by the parties. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Court has the power and it is appropriate to make orders consistent with the terms of the parties' settlement, provided that the settlement is consistent with the objectives and purposes of the Act, and the parties have had legal representation.