Worimi v Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Worimi (aka Gary Dates) v Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council [2010] FCAFC 3

Citation: Worimi (aka Gary Dates) v Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council [2010] FCAFC 3
Appeal from: Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council v Minister for Lands for the State of New South Wales (No 2) [2008] FCA 1929
Parties: WORIMI (AKA GARY DATES) v WORIMI LOCAL ABORIGINAL LAND COUNCIL and MINISTER FOR LANDS FOR STATE OF NEW SOUTH WALES
File number(s): NSD 77 of 2009
Judges: MOORE, MANSFIELD & PERRAM JJ
Date of judgment: 2 February 2010
Catchwords:

NATIVE TITLE – appeal from non-claimant application under Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) for determination that no native title exists over land – where appellant asserted that he and others had native title rights and interests in land – no necessary requirement upon applicant to prove nature and content of pre-sovereignty native title rights and interests and to prove how those native title rights and interests ceased to exist – matter to be considered in circumstances of each particular application – discussion of type of evidence that may prove that no native title rights exist in relation to land at time of application – consideration of adequacy of evidence – determination of no native title of the land correct – appeal dismissed

EVIDENCE – non-claimant application under Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) – appellant (respondent to application) asserted that he and others had native title rights and interests in the land – discussion of circumstances to which it is desirable for appellant to give evidence although onus of proof of non-existence of native title rights lay on applicant

Legislation:

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 13, 36, 61 and 233

Aboriginal Land Rights Act 1983 (NSW) ss 40AA and 40D

Cases cited:

Peter Hillig as Administrator of Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council v Minister for Lands for the State of New South Wales [2006] FCA 61 cited
Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council v Minister for Lands for the State of New South Wales (2007) 164 FCR 181 cited
Hillig as Administrator of Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council v Minister for Lands for the State of New South Wales (No 2) [2006] FCA 1115 cited
Commonwealth v Clifton (2007) 164 FCR 355 cited
Apollo Shower Screens Pty Ltd v Building and Construction Industry Long Service Payments Corporation (1985) 1 NSWLR 561 applied
Jango v Northern Territory (2007) 159 FCR 531 applied
Members of the Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria (2002) 214 CLR 422 cited
State of Western Australia v Ward (2002) 213 CLR 1 cited
Commonwealth of Australia v Yarmirr (2001) 208 CLR 1 cited
Wilson v Anderson (2002) 213 CLR 401 cited
State of Western Australia v Commonwealth (1995) 183 CLR 373 cited
Wik Peoples v State of Queensland (1996) 187 CLR 1 cited
Fejo v Northern Territory of Australia (1998) 195 CLR 96 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia (2001) 205 CLR 507 cited
Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Worimi v Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCAFC 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Worimi v Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council involved an appeal against a determination made under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth). The appellant, Worimi, contested a decision by the primary judge that found no native title rights and interests existed over the specified land. The primary judge had dismissed Worimi's claims, and he subsequently appealed to the court.

The primary legal issues addressed by the court were whether the applicant in a non-claimant application must prove the nature and content of pre-sovereignty native title rights and interests, and how the contemporary state of affairs can be demonstrated to show the lack of continuity or reasons for the non-existence of native title. The court also examined whether the evidence presented was adequate to support the primary judge's conclusion.

The court reasoned that there was no requirement for the applicant to prove the nature and content of pre-sovereignty native title rights and interests and then demonstrate their cessation. This approach would involve an overly broad and potentially indefinite inquiry, which was not supported by legal precedent. The onus of proving the non-existence of native title lay with the applicant, but this could be achieved without needing to reconstruct the entire history of the native title rights and interests. The court held that the primary judge’s conclusion, reached after considering the entire body of evidence, was correct. The evidence presented was sufficient to support the finding that there were no native title rights and interests over the land at the time of the application.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the appellant pay the costs of the appeal. The court emphasized that each case must be considered on its particular facts, and the connection between native title rights and the land must be assessed within the context of the specific circumstances presented.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant to pay the costs of the appeal.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For those reasons, this ground of appeal must fail. The approach contended for by Worimi is not one which accords with commonsense. No circumstances were identified by counsel on his behalf (other than the matters put on the first ground of appeal) to show that the approach of the primary judge in this matter was incorrect. We now turn to that ground of appeal.Whether there was evidence upon which a conclusion was capable of being drawn that there is no native title in relation to the Land The submission on behalf of Worimi does not, it is asserted, involve any attack upon the weight given to the evidence by the primary judge. It is based upon the proposition that the evidence adduced by the Land Council could not support the conclusion of the primary judge. On an appeal such as the present, we do not consider that there is a relevant difference in those two positions. The appeal is by way of rehearing: Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia (2001) 205 CLR 507. That involves consideration not only of errors of law, but also of errors of fact. The Full Court is obliged to give the judgment which, in its opinion, ought to have been given in the first instance: Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531; CSR Ltd v Della Maddalena (2006) 224 ALR 1 per Kirby J at 7, [16]; Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424. In deciding whether the primary judge erred in reaching her conclusion, of course a misunderstanding about the nature of particular evidence or a misdirection about its significance might indicate error on her part. However, to preserve the distinction which Worimi asserted, the focus of his attack was upon the earlier part of the reasons of the primary judge, dealing with the preliminary matters. In our view, it is not appropriate to isolate the reasons of the primary judge in that way so as to support the contention that she fell into error in her ultimate conclusion. Her conclusion, and the means by which it was reached, must be assessed upon the whole of her reasons. The preliminary matters arose only in the particular context of the case. It is necessary to understand how that came about. Worimi, by the lateness of his application to be joined as a party to the proceeding, was required to justify the desirability of him being permitted to be joined as a party. He asserted that he had an interest in being joined because he claimed that he, and others, held and enjoyed native title rights and interests in relation to the Land. His earlier claims for a determination to that effect had been struck out. Even if he was unable to get authorisation of the community or group who (he said) strictly speaking enjoyed those rights and interests, he was able to use his asserted rights and interests defensively, to oppose the Land Council’s application: Kokatha People v State of South Australia [2007] FCA 1057 per Finn J at [48]. See also the primary judge’s reasons on the joinder application: Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council v Minister for Lands for the State of New South Wales (2007) 164 FCR 181 at 189, [30].

Decision

Reasons for decision

The third ground of appeal must fail.CONCLUSION It is desirable to make one further observation. The primary judge concluded, correctly as we have decided, that on the evidence there was, at the time of the application and the hearing, no ongoing connection between whatever native title rights and interests existed in relation to the Land at settlement. Each case must be decided on its particular facts. Bodney v Bennell (2008) 167 FCR 84 was not a case where there was a declaration that no native title existed in relation to the claim area. It found that the claim had not been made out. It provides an illustration of there being no evidence of contemporary connection in relation to that claim area (the Perth metropolitan area), even though the claim group in that case may have demonstrated ongoing connection with other more southerly parts of Western Australia. It is self-evident that a community or group of Aboriginal persons may have an ongoing connection with land, even though their access to, or use of, that land is restricted or spasmodic; that connection may be mainly spiritual rather than physical; it may have evolved over time to a less specific use of all or many parts of that land; it may not involve physical access to each and every part of the land: see for example De Rose v State of South Australia (2003) 133 FCR 325; De Rose v State of South Australia (No 2) (2005) 145 FCR 290; Northern Territory of Australia v Alyawarr, Kaytetye, Warumungu, Wakaya Native Title Claim Group (2005) 145 FCR 442. At least in each contested non-claimant application for the determination of native title, it is necessary to bear in mind that the particular area of land in question may be part only of a larger area of land over which there may be existing native title rights and interests. That is a matter to be determined on the facts of each case. For the reasons given, we consider that the appeal should be dismissed. Worimi should pay the costs of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Minister filed a Notice of Contention that the primary judgment should be affirmed on the ground that Worimi, having failed to adduce or to direct the Court’s attention to evidence of each of the elements necessary to establish the existence of native title over the Land did not, even if there was cogent evidence with respect to those elements that were addressed in the evidence, cast doubt on the assertion that native title did not exist. At the hearing of the appeal, counsel for the Minister indicated that that contention was no longer pressed as it was unnecessary to press it.CONSIDERATION It is convenient to first deal with the second of the grounds of appeal, as it asserts that the proof of the negative proposition – that there are no native title rights and interests in relation to the Land – must be effected in a certain manner.Whether the onus was on the Land Council to demonstrate the nature and content of the pre-sovereignty native title rights and interests in relation to the Land This ground of appeal addresses Worimi’s contention that an applicant in a non-claimant application for a determination of native title under s 61 of the NT Act is required to establish the nature and content of pre-sovereignty native title rights and interests in relation to the land that is the subject of the application, and then must “deconstruct” to show the contemporary state of affairs contrasted in order to demonstrate a lack of continuity or other reason by which native title no longer exists. The primary judge rejected that approach at [62] of the primary judgment. Her Honour said that the Land Council must establish, on the balance of probabilities, that native title under the NT Act does not exist over the Land, but did not accept that it must be proved in the way asserted by Worimi. Further, her Honour rejected that approach in her summary of the preliminary matters at [88] where her Honour said:· Accordingly, the onus is not on the Land Council to satisfy the Court as to the absence of each element required to prove the existence of native title. The Land Council is not required positively to establish the situation pre-sovereignty and from sovereignty to the present time with expert evidence of laws and customs. It is contrary to logic to say that a person who wishes to establish that there is no native title must first positively prove that there were laws and customs at any stage. The approach contended for by Worimi would involve a “roving inquiry” into whether any person, and if so who, held any, and if so what, native title rights and interests in the land and waters at settlement, and chronologically to the time of the application. Such approach is of the kind expressly rejected by the Full Court in Jango v Northern Territory (2007) 159 FCR 531 (Jango) at 558, [84]. There may be a number of reasons why, at or by a particular time, no native title rights or interests exist in relation to particular land. The term “native title rights and interests” is defined in s 223 of the NT Act. It has been authoritatively explained by the High Court in cases such as Members of theYorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria (2002) 214 CLR 422; Western Australia v Ward (2002) 213 CLR 1; Commonwealth v Yarmirr (2001) 208 CLR 1 and Wilson v Anderson (2002) 213 CLR 401. So, too, has the concept of extinguishment of native title rights and interests: State of Western Australia v Commonwealth (1995) 183 CLR 373; Wik Peoples v State of Queensland (1996) 187 CLR 1 and Fejo v Northern Territory of Australia (1998) 195 CLR 96. It is not necessary to repeat or summarise what those cases decided. They illustrate that native title rights and interests in relation to land or waters, accepting they existed at the time of settlement, may no longer exist because the Aboriginal peoples who enjoyed them at settlement may have ceased to exist as a community or group through the passage of history, or may have ceased to possess and enjoy those rights and interests, or by the intervention of Government over time that those rights and interests may have been extinguished.