Stanbroke Pty Ltd v Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Stanbroke Pty Ltd v Queensland [2023] FCA 227

File number(s): QUD 22 of 2021
Judgment of: HALLEY J
Date of judgment: 16 March 2023
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – non-claimant application for determination of native title under s 61(1) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (NTA) – where respondent filed notice under s 86G of the NTA – whether within power and appropriate for Court to make orders sought – application granted
Legislation:

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 13, 61, 66, 81, 86G, 94A, 225, 253

Native Title (Notices) Determination 2011 (No 1) (Cth) s 6

Cases cited:

Aplin v Queensland (No 3) [2010] FCA 1515

Doyle v Queensland (No 3) [2011] FCA 1466

Mace v Queensland (2019) 274 FCR 41; [2019] FCAFC 233

Wagonga Local Aboriginal Land Council v Attorney General (NSW) [2020] FCA 1113

Worimi v Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council (2010) 181 FCR 320; [2010] FCAFC 3

Worimi Local Aboriginal Land Council v Minister for Lands for the State of New South Wales (No 2) (2008) 181 FCR 300; [2008] FCA 1929

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Native Title
Number of paragraphs: 89
Date of last submission/s: 30 January 2023
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Solicitor for the Applicant: Thynne + Macartney Lawyers
Solicitor for the Respondent: Crown Law

 

ORDERS

QUD 22 of 2021
BETWEEN:

STANDBROKE PTY LTD ACN 008 442 939

Applicant

AND:

STATE OF QUEENSLAND

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

HALLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 MARCH 2023

THE COURT DETERMINES THAT:

  1. Native title does not exist in relation to the land and waters described as Lot 5 on Survey Plan 287784 but excluding any land and waters subject to or within the external boundaries of:

    (a)the land the subject of the determination by this Court on 12 December 2011 in proceeding QUD 579 of 2005, William Doyle on behalf of the Kalkadoon People #4 v State of Queensland, as determined; and

    (b)the land accepted for registration by the National Native Title Tribunal on 15 September 1999 in proceeding QUD 6022 of 1999, Ada Walden & Ors on behalf of the Waanyi People v State of Queensland.

    Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


    REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

    HALLEY J:

  2. The applicant, Stanbroke Pty Ltd, seeks a determination that native title does not exist within an area of land located within Lot 5 on Survey Plan 287784 (Lot 5), but excluding any land and waters subject to or within the external boundaries of:

    (a)the land the subject of the determination by the Federal Court of Australia on 12 December 2011 in proceeding QUD 579 of 2005, William Doyle on behalf of the Kalkadoon People #4 v State of Queensland (Kalkadoon #4 claim); and

    (b)the land accepted for registration by the National Native Title Tribunal (Tribunal) on 15 September 1999 in proceeding QUD 6022 of 1999,

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stanbroke Pty Ltd v Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 227
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Stanbroke Pty Ltd, the registered lessee of Lot 5 on Survey Plan 287784, sought a determination from the Federal Court of Australia that native title does not exist within this area, excluding certain lands and waters subject to or within the external boundaries of previous determinations. The State of Queensland, the sole respondent, did not oppose the application and filed a notice under section 86G of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth). The applicant relied on an affidavit from Mark Stewart Boge, a solicitor representing the applicant, to support its application. The primary legal issue before the Court was whether it had the power and was appropriate to make the orders sought by the applicant. The Court considered the statutory framework and relevant legal principles, including the provisions of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), and the principles derived from previous cases such as Wagonga Local Aboriginal Land Council v Attorney General (NSW).

The Court assessed the application based on the evidence provided, focusing on whether the applicant had met the standard of proof on the balance of probabilities. Given the absence of any relevant entries on the Register of Native Title Claims after the notification period, and the lack of opposition from the State of Queensland, the Court found that the applicant had discharged its burden of proof. The Court also considered the gravity of a negative determination and its potential impact on native title rights and interests, as well as the principles derived from previous cases regarding non-claimant applications. The Court concluded that it was appropriate to make the orders sought by the applicant. Therefore, the Court granted the application and determined that native title does not exist in relation to the specified area, excluding certain lands and waters subject to previous determinations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant relied on an affidavit of Mark Stewart Boge affirmed on 24 November 2022 in support of its application. Mr Boge is a solicitor with the firm Thynne & McCartney who represent the applicant in these proceedings.FACTUAL BACKGROUND In the period up to May 2020, Lot 5 was part of the pastoral lease known as Augustus Downs, described as Lot 4 in SP120452. In October 1984, the applicant acquired Augustus Downs. At that time, Augustus Downs was subject to a 50 year lease commencing on 1 July 1975 and expiring on 30 June 2025. In 2020, Augustus Downs was subdivided into two lots, Lots 4 and 5 in SP287784. On 29 January 2021, the applicant made a non-claimant application for a determination of native title under s 61(1) of the NTA over the Land (Application). On 6 June 2021, the applicant filed an amended Application which removed any lands and waters subject to the Kalkadoon #4 claim. On 11 August 2021, public notification of the amended Application was made by the Tribunal. The notification period ended on 10 November 2021. Searches conducted after the end of the notification period recorded no relevant entries over the Land on the Register of Native Title Claims (Register). On 3 November 2021, Henry Morris Aplin filed a Form 5 application to become a party to the proceeding. On 8 November 2021, Carpentaria Land Council Aboriginal Corporation, the representative body for the area, filed a Form 5 application to become a party to the proceeding. On 28 February 2022, Carpentaria Land Council Aboriginal Corporation filed a Form 106 notifying the Court that they wished to cease to be a party to the proceeding. On 14 June 2022, the applicant filed a further amended Application which excluded any lands and waters subject to the Waanyi claim. On 11 July 2022, Mr Aplin filed a Form 106 notifying the Court that he wished to cease to be a party to the proceeding.STATUTORY FRAMEWORK AND RELEVANT LEGAL PRINCIPLES Section 13(1) of the NTA permits an application to be made to the Court for an "approved determination of native title" in relation to an area for which there is no other approved determination of native title. Section 81 of the NTA provides that the Court has jurisdiction to hear and determine applications that relate to native title. Section 61(1) of the NTA stipulates who may make such an application for an approved determination. Relevantly, this includes a person who holds a "non-native title interest in relation to the whole of the area in relation to which the determination is sought". Section 253 of the NTA provides that an "interest" in relation to land includes a legal or equitable interest in the land. Where a non-claimant application under s 61(1) of the NTA is unopposed, s 86G(1) of the NTA empowers this Court to make a determination of native title without holding a hearing provided that:(a)the determination occurs at the end of the period specified in the notice given under s 66 of the NTA;(b)this Court is satisfied that an order in, or consistent with, the terms sought by the applicant is within the power of the Court; and(c)it appears to this Court that it is appropriate to make such an order.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Native title does not exist in relation to the land and waters described as Lot 5 on Survey Plan 287784 but excluding any land and waters subject to or within the external boundaries of:(a)the land the subject of the determination by this Court on 12 December 2011 in proceeding QUD 579 of 2005, William Doyle on behalf of the Kalkadoon People #4 v State of Queensland, as determined; and(b)the land accepted for registration by the National Native Title Tribunal on 15 September 1999 in proceeding QUD 6022 of 1999, Ada Walden & Ors on behalf of the Waanyi People v State of Queensland.Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.REASONS FOR JUDGMENTHALLEY J: The applicant, Stanbroke Pty Ltd, seeks a determination that native title does not exist within an area of land located within Lot 5 on Survey Plan 287784 (Lot 5), but excluding any land and waters subject to or within the external boundaries of:(a)the land the subject of the determination by the Federal Court of Australia on 12 December 2011 in proceeding QUD 579 of 2005, William Doyle on behalf of the Kalkadoon People #4 v State of Queensland (Kalkadoon #4 claim); and(b)the land accepted for registration by the National Native Title Tribunal (Tribunal) on 15 September 1999 in proceeding QUD 6022 of 1999, Ada Walden & Ors on behalf of the Waanyi People v State of Queensland (Waanyi claim),in the Local Government Regions of Burke Shire Council and Carpentaria Shire Council in the State of Queensland (Land). The Land is located approximately 310 km northwest of Cloncurry in the State of Queensland. The applicant is the registered lessee of Lot 5. The only respondent, the State of Queensland, has filed a notice under s 86G of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (NTA) confirming that it does not oppose an order in, or consistent with, the terms sought by the applicant. The applicant relied on an affidavit of Mark Stewart Boge affirmed on 24 November 2022 in support of its application. Mr Boge is a solicitor with the firm Thynne & McCartney who represent the applicant in these proceedings.FACTUAL BACKGROUND In the period up to May 2020, Lot 5 was part of the pastoral lease known as Augustus Downs, described as Lot 4 in SP120452. In October 1984, the applicant acquired Augustus Downs. At that time, Augustus Downs was subject to a 50 year lease commencing on 1 July 1975 and expiring on 30 June 2025. In 2020, Augustus Downs was subdivided into two lots, Lots 4 and 5 in SP287784. On 29 January 2021, the applicant made a non-claimant application for a determination of native title under s 61(1) of the NTA over the Land (Application). On 6 June 2021, the applicant filed an amended Application which removed any lands and waters subject to the Kalkadoon #4 claim. On 11 August 2021, public notification of the amended Application was made by the Tribunal. The notification period ended on 10 November 2021. Searches conducted after the end of the notification period recorded no relevant entries over the Land on the Register of Native Title Claims (Register).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Wagonga Local Aboriginal Land Council v Attorney General (NSW) [2020] FCA 1113, Jagot J at [10] summarised the principles derived from Mace and Worimi in the following terms:(4)The overriding proposition is that each case must be assessed on its own particular facts: [47].(5)Relevant considerations will include the nature of the land and the tenure involved, the presence or absence of any present or previous native title claims and the nature and content of those claims, and any particular evidence adduced by the parties: [48].(6)The Court must act on evidence, direct or indirect, which can be weighed against the case brought by the non-claimant applicant: [52].(7)All issues are to be assessed on the usual standard of proof in civil litigation - proof on the balance of probabilities. A non-claimant applicant will either meet this standard or will not: [54].(8)A non-claimant application does not involve any general inquiry into what native title rights and interests may have existed at sovereignty or any general inquiry into how those rights or interests may or may not have continued: [55].(9)The provisions of the NTA are intended to facilitate all persons with a proper interest in an area of land taking steps to ensure that their interest is taken into account when the Court is making a native title determination with respect to that land. However, it is not necessary to employ evidentiary or adversarial presumptions to the task which may have been developed by the common law in different contexts from native title determinations: [56]. A better approach is to focus on what the evidence before the Court does establish, whether before or against the determination sought by the non-claimant applicant: [56]. Similarly common law maxims developed in different contexts are also of limited utility to the determination of a non-claimant application: [57]-[60].(10)In a non-claimant application the applicant seeks a negative determination in rem. In this context recourse to common law maxims developed in different contexts may not be useful: [61].(11)In a non-claimant application it is inappropriate to impose a specific evidential burden on a respondent such as the respondent need only make out a "prima facie" position. This would involve a gloss on the application of the usual burden and standard of proof which applies equally to claimant and non-claimant applications: [63].(12)The question whether native title does not exist (in a non-claimant application) or does exist (in a claimant application) is to be decided according to the balance of probabilities by reference to the circumstances of each case and on the evidence adduced without recourse to maxims or presumptions originating in different adversarial contexts: [64]. In this regard it may be noted that in Worimi at [74] the point was made that a respondent to a non-claimant application is not subject to any onus of proof. The onus remains at all times on the applicant for the non-claimant application, in this case, WLALC.(13)In a non-claimant application account needs to be taken of the gravity of a negative determination and its permanency in terms of its effect on native title rights and interests which are otherwise sought to be protected by the NTA: [66].(14)No hard and fast rules can be laid down about what evidence might be required or might suffice for a non-claimant applicant to meet the required standard of proof: [68]. Given what is at stake and the fact that any determination affects property rights as against the whole world no prescriptive approaches or glosses on the statute should be imposed. The Court has a wide discretion whether or not to make a negative determination and the potential combination of considerations which may arise in any particular application cannot be predicted or turned into any kind of checklist: [72].(15)If the burden of proof on a non-claimant application has been discharged it may be a rare case in which the discretion is exercised not to make a negative determination but in principle the discretion exists and the Court should not foreclose consideration of the question whether it is appropriate to make the order in all of the circumstances of the case: [73].(16)The Court's task is not to be more or less "stringent" depending on the kind of case before it but is to decide if the non-claimant applicant has discharged its burden of proof. In doing so the subject-matter of the non-claimant application and the consequences of a negative determination inform the requisite level of persuasion for a negative determination: [82].(17)The principal evidence likely to impede the grant of a negative determination is evidence of an assertion of native title in the land the subject of the non-claimant application which is objectively arguable, not evidence of the potential for the assertion of native title. A representative body is best placed to assist Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples to provide such evidence. The quality of such evidence, rather than its extent, will be determinative: [97].CONSIDERATIONFormal notification requirements