Fulton v Chief of the Defence Force

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fulton v Chief of the Defence Force [2022] FCA 1582

File number(s): QUD 21 of 2021
Judgment of: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 22 December 2022
Catchwords: DEFENCE AND WAR – application for review of decision by delegate of Chief of the Defence Force –termination of service with Defence Force pursuant to reg 24(1)(c), Defence Regulation 2016 – whether termination decision vitiated by breach of procedural fairness because applicant given insufficient time to respond to termination notice – where failure to take into account applicant’s service, personal performance reports, and mental health alleged to constitute failure to have regard to relevant considerations – whether error in taking into account applicant’s traffic offence despite no conviction being recorded – whether delegate impermissibly limited the material to which he was obliged to consider – where no breach of procedural fairness or other error of law established – application dismissed
Legislation:

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 5, 16

Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) ss 85ZL, 85ZM, 85ZV, 85ZW, 85ZZH

Defence Force Discipline Act 1982 (Cth) s 153

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37M, 37N

Crimes Regulations 2019 (Cth) reg 21, Sch 2

Defence Regulation 2016 (Cth) regs 6, 24, 28, 30

Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) s 12

Cases cited:

Allesch v Maunz [2000] HCA 40; (2000) 203 CLR 172

Aon Risk Services Australia Pty Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27

Chief of Defence Force v Gaynor [2017] FCAFC 41; (2017) 246 FCR 298

Coutts v Close, Assistant Commissioner of Australian Federal Police [2014] FCA 19

Gaynor v Chief of the Defence Force (No 3) [2015] FCA 1370; (2015) 237 FCR 188

Graham v Deputy Chief of Air Force [2004] FCA 1377

Hartwig v Hack [2007] FCA 1039

Luck v Chief Executive Officer of Centrelink [2015] FCAFC 75

Martincevic v Commonwealth [2007] FCAFC 164; (2007) 164 FCR 45

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd [1986] HCA 40; (1986) 162 CLR 24

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZIAI [2009] HCA 39; (2009) 111 ALD 15

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Teoh [1995] HCA 20; (1995) 183 CLR 273

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf [2001] HCA 30; (2001) 206 CLR 323

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Huynh [2004] FCAFC 256; (2004) 139 FCR 505

Ozepulse Pty Ltd v Minister for Agriculture Fisheries and Forestry [2007] FCA 1601; (2007) 163 FCR 562

Plaintiff M1/2021 v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] HCA 17; (2022) 96 ALJR 497

Plaintiff M61/2010 v Commonwealth of Australia [2010] HCA 41; (2010) 243 CLR 319

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs; ex parte Lam [2003] HCA 6; (2003) 214 CLR 1

Shand v Chief of Army [1998] FCA 265

SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2006] HCA 63; (2006) 228 CLR 152

Tickner…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fulton v Chief of the Defence Force and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1582
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr Fulton, brought an application for judicial review of a decision by the Chief of the Defence Force (CDF) to terminate his service with the Australian Defence Force (ADF). The applicant argued that the decision was vitiated by breaches of procedural fairness and errors of law, including insufficient time to respond to the termination notice, failure to consider relevant factors such as his service record and mental health, and consideration of a traffic offence without a conviction. The CDF relied upon the statutory authority of the Defence Regulation 2016, which confers upon the CDF the power to terminate a member's service on various grounds, including that the member's retention is not in the interests of the Defence Force.

The court was required to decide whether the decision to terminate Mr Fulton's service was legally valid. This involved examining whether procedural fairness was observed, relevant considerations were taken into account, and irrelevant considerations were excluded. The court also considered whether the delegate had the authority to limit the material considered to that included in the termination notice and response, or whether he was obliged to undertake further inquiries.

The court found that no breach of procedural fairness or other error of law was established. The delegate had provided Mr Fulton with an extension of time to respond to the termination notice, allowing him to consider all relevant documents. The court held that there was no statutory obligation on the delegate to inquire further into matters not included in the termination notice or response. The delegate was also entitled to consider the traffic offence, despite there being no conviction, as it was relevant to the assessment of Mr Fulton's suitability for continued service. The court concluded that the decision to terminate Mr Fulton's service was legally valid and dismissed the application.

The court dismissed the application and reserved costs, directing the parties to attempt to agree on cost orders or, failing that, to prepare draft minutes of order setting a proposed timetable for the filing of short written submissions on the question of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. Costs are reserved.

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

3. The parties are to liaise in an endeavour to agree orders as to costs or, if not agreed, to prepare draft minutes of order setting a proposed timetable for the filing of short written submissions on the question of costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, I refused the applicant’s interlocutory application.3. EVIDENCE Mr Fulton relied upon his affidavits affirmed on 18 January 2021, 22 January 2022, 20 May 2021 (Fulton 20 May affidavit), 24 May 2021 and, in reply to the respondent’s evidence, 6 September 2022, save for those parts of the affidavits which were the subject of rulings are upheld by me and objections which were conceded by the applicant. Following the hearing, the applicant provided copies of these affidavits with the agreement of the respondent which applied these rulings by redacting those parts of the affidavits which were not admitted. The respondent relied upon the following affidavits in chief:(1)the affidavit of Julie Adams, Group Captain in the RAAF (now Air Commodore), affirmed on 19 November 2021 (Adams affidavit) which:(a)annexed a copy of Chapter 9 of the Air Force Personnel Standing Instructions providing details of the Air Force performance appraisal system; (b)explained that Mr Fulton’s “ADO Service Record”, providing detailed information about his service, was included as enclosure 18 to the Termination Notice and in the respondent’s bundle of material before the delegate filed in this proceeding on 14 April 2021 (RB); (c)explained that Mr Fulton’s posted position required him to have a NV2 (Top Secret) security clearance; and (d)gave evidence that, based on her knowledge of the Employment Process for Operations Officers (OPSO), every OPSO position for the ranks of Flying Officer to Wing Commander requires at least an NV1 (Secret) security clearance, and some OPSO positions require an a NV2 (Top Secret) security clearance or a PV (Positive Vetting) security clearance; and(2)the affidavit of Michael Small, RAAF Squadron Leader, affirmed on 16 August 2022 (Small affidavit) who, at the time of affirming his affidavit, was posted to the Personnel Branch of the RAAF where he held the position of Air Operations Officer 3. His evidence was directed to the question of whether the applicant had a waiver from complying with the Physical Fitness Test (PFT) component of the Individual Readiness (IR) requirements for members of the Air Force. These affidavits were admitted without objection and both deponents were cross-examined. The respondent also tendered his notice to admit filed on 1 November 2021 (NtoA) (Exhibit R‑1) and the bundle of materials before the delegate (filed in 3 parts) (Exhibit R-2).4. FACTUAL BACKGROUND4.1 The applicant’s service The applicant commenced his service with the RAAF as an Officer Cadet and was promoted in April 2011 to Flight Lieutenant. He served predominantly as an Operations Officer until termination of his service. He was posted in Darwin from 2011 to 2016 as part of Operation Resolute, during which time he was posted to Learmonth on multiple rotations. He was also deployed as part of the escort for the Governor-General to East Timor in 2008 and to the Pacific Islands Forum in August 2019. I accept the applicant’s evidence that he received a waiver for the PFT component of his IR assessment for both of these deployments. While Squadron Leader Small testified that he was only able to locate one waiver on the applicant’s file in the software filing system known as Objective which was for the Pacific Islands Forum, he accepted that particular units could have different places where the waivers are stored.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In these circumstances, there was no obligation on the delegate to consider the applicant’s mental health any further. Nor is any error apparent in the reasons given by the delegate for deciding that matters pertaining to the applicant’s mental health did not preclude him from deciding to terminate the applicant’s service if the delegate otherwise decided that the applicant’s retention was not in the interests of the Defence Force. To the contrary, given the breadth of the discretion conferred by reg 24(1)(c) of the Defence Regulation read with reg 6(2), that conclusion was plainly correct. 5.5 Did the decision-maker impermissibly limit the material which he was obliged to consider (ground 4)? Ground 4 of the second amended originating application alleges that the termination decision “was made in error of law as the Respondent misdirected itself as to the requirements of [reg] 24(1)(c) of the Defence Regulations 2016.” In support of the ground, the applicant submitted that:WGCDR [Nelson] was not limited in those considerations by what was put in the Termination Notice and the Response. The Respondent was obliged to take into account the matters set out in regulation 6(2). In making the Termination Decision, WGCDR Nelson considered that the only matters which could be considered were those raised in the Termination Notice and the response to the Termination Notice. However that impermissibly limited the material to which the Respondent was obliged to consider. This is particularly so given the time a member has to respond to a Termination Notice. In making the Termination Decision the Respondent was obliged to obtain the material, such as Personal Performance Reviews, and the views of supervising officers where those matters were not contained in the Termination Notice or Response.The failure to undertake those [inquiries] was a result of WGCDR Nelson considering that the role was confined to adjudicating between the competing submissions rather than making the determination based on the requirements of [reg] 6(2) of the [Defence] Regulation.Those inquiries may have required giving former FLTLT Fulton a further opportunity to respond but nonetheless should have been undertaken in circumstances where it was clear this information was missing from the Termination Notice.(AS at [48]-[50].) This ground has also not been established. First, I agree with the submissions of the respondent that there is nothing in the text or structure of the Defence Regulation imposing any duty to inquire on the CDF or his delegate in determining whether or not to terminate a member’s service pursuant to reg 24(1)(c) of the Defence Regulation. The only consideration identified by the applicant in support of the suggestion that such a duty exists is the shortness of the period of time within which a member must respond to a Termination Notice. However, reg 24 sets only a minimum time period within which a member must respond, thereby allowing a decision-maker to set a different time and/or extend the period of time within which the member must respond as in fact occurred in this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 4 September 2020, Squadron Leader Scarfe granted the applicant a further extension of 7 days to prepare his written response to the Termination Notice, that is, until 9 September 2020 (RB, Part C at tab 57). In his letter granting the extension, Squadron Leader Scarfe explained as follows:In your application to me to cease termination action, you raised four key points as justification. My response and rationale to these points are as follows:1.You received the response to your Unacceptable Behaviour [UB] complaint 11 days prior to the Termination Notice (TN) Response submission date: Given that you have been stood down from your duties to enable you to work exclusively on your TN Response, I deem you have more than sufficient time to and opportunity consider and address any relevant matters in the UB investigation outcome documentation without a further extension.2.As you are unsatisfied with the outcome of your UB complaint, you intend to submit a ROG[.] You wish to have the ROG resolved prior to responding to the TN: While you have every right to submit a ROG, there is no requirement to suspend the TN process to finalise the ROG. The UB Fact finding was not referenced in the TN and the termination process and any potential ROG are two entirely separate processes that can run in parallel. Importantly from a procedural fairness perspective, you are able to highlight any concerns you have with the UB investigation in your TN Response. These points can then be considered independently by myself and if necessary, the termination imposing authority.3.You plan to petition the outcome of the Summary Authority trial review. You wish to have this resolved prior to submitting your response to the TN: The TN is based on conduct and performance that span the length of your career. The conduct that resulted in DFDA action being taken against you is only one small consideration in the TN. Further, the TN does not reference the DFDA proceedings or outcome in anyway [sic] and the TN delegate would only become aware of the DFDA action if you choose to raise it in your response. Also, as you point out in your application, decisions made under the DFDA and for administrative sanctions are subject to different burdens of proof, with Admin Sanction decisions requiring the lower burden of proof. It is therefore appropriate that administrative sanction and DFDA decisions are made independently, noting a decision under one process is not a predictor or mitigation for the other. For these reasons, there is no requirement to delay the Termination action taken against you while you contest the DFDA outcome.4.You have requested documentation regarding your UB complaint (via Sentinel) and DFDA action. These had yet to be supplied to you: Documents relating to the DFDA petition are not applicable as explained above, however, I acknowledge the documentation related to the Sentential report (UB complaint) may be. I have confirmed with SQNLDR Wilson that you now have access to these additional documents. The extension to 09 Sep 20 will give you sufficient time to consider and incorporate them into your TN response if you deem it appropriate. Again I note you have been stood down to focus exclusively on this task. Given that you already have physical access to every document that is relied on in the TN and all the allegations made against you; you now have the opportunity to provide a full and comprehensive response to the TN.(Emphasis added.)4.4 The applicant’s response to the Termination Notice