Energy Beverages LLC v Charlie Coglitore

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Energy Drinks LLC to registration of trade mark application 1710869 (5, 32) - MADUI Mother Against Driving Under the Influence - in the name of Charlie Coglitore.

Delegate: Aaron Walters
Representation: Opponent: Written submissions by Elizabeth Godfrey of Davies Collison Cave Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys
Applicant: No Submissions
Decision:

2018 ATMO 33
Opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995­ – grounds pursued under sections 42(b), 44, 59, 60, 62A of the Act – no grounds established – trade mark to proceed to registration.

Background

  1. On the 30 July 2015, Mr Charlie Coglitore (‘the Applicant’) filed an application for  the following trade mark:

Application number: 1710869

Trade Mark: MADUI Mothers Against Driving Under the Influence

(‘the Trade Mark’)

In respect of the following goods:

Class 5: Beverages adapted for medical purposes; Beverages adapted for medicinal purposes; Beverages containing added minerals (for medical purposes); Beverages containing added trace elements (for medical purposes); Beverages containing added vitamins (for medical purposes); Dietetic beverages adapted for medical purposes; Electrolyte replacement beverages for medical purposes; Herbal beverages for medicinal use; Ice beverages for medical use; Malted milk beverages for medical purposes; Medicated beverages; Medicinal beverages; Tisanes (medicated beverages); Tonic water (medicated beverages); Waters (beverages) for medical purposes; Nausea medications; Alcohol for pharmaceutical purposes; Chemicals for pharmaceutical use; Melissa water for pharmaceutical purposes; Milk of almonds for pharmaceutical purposes; Pain killers (pharmaceuticals); Pharmaceutical drugs; Pharmaceutical medicaments in unit dosage form; Pharmaceutical preparations; Pharmaceutical preparations being hormone preparations for human use; Pharmaceutical preparations containing hormones for humans; Pharmaceutical preparations containing royal jelly; Pharmaceutical preparations containing vitamins; Pharmaceutical preparations for alleviating disorders of the brain; Pharmaceutical preparations for health care; Pharmaceutical preparations for human use; Pharmaceutical preparations for oral use; Pharmaceutical preparations for personal use; Pharmaceutical preparations for the treatment of alcoholism; Pharmaceutical preparations for the treatment of cardiovascular diseases; Pharmaceutical preparations for the treatment of cardiovascular disorders; Pharmaceutical preparations for the treatment of depressive illness; Pharmaceutical preparations for the treatment of disorders of the central nervous system; Pharmaceutical preparations for the treatment of the eyes; Pharmaceutical preparations for use in discouraging the smoking habit; Pharmaceutical preparations for use in the treatment of hormonal disorders; Pharmaceutical preparations in the form of tablets; Pharmaceutical products; Pharmaceutical products derived from natural sources; Pharmaceutical products for combating heart diseases; Pharmaceutical products for the central nervous system; Pharmaceutical products for the treatment of cardiovascular disorders; Pharmaceutical products for use by humans; Psycho-pharmaceutical preparations; Stimulants for pharmaceutical purposes; Syrup of molasses for pharmaceutical purposes; Tablets (pharmaceuticals); Yeast for pharmaceutical purpose

Class 32: Aerated beverages (non-alcoholic); Alcohol free beverages; Beverages consisting of a blend of fruit and vegetable juices; Beverages containing not more than 1.15% (by volume) of alcohol; Beverages made from fruit concentrates; Coconut milk (beverages); Edible essences for making beverages; Electrolyte replacement beverages for general and sports purposes; Essences for making beverages; Extracts of vegetables (beverages); Fruit beverages; Fruit concentrates for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Energy Beverages LLC v Charlie Coglitore and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ATMO 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This decision concerned a trade mark opposition brought by Energy Beverages LLC against trade marks sought by Charlie Coglitore. The dispute centred on whether the proposed marks were deceptively similar to Energy Beverages LLC's existing registered trade marks. The matter was heard by a delegate.

The delegate was required to determine whether the trade marks sought by the applicant were deceptively similar to the opponent's registered trade marks, considering the opponent's asserted "family of trade marks" strategy. This involved assessing whether the proposed marks, when viewed in the context of the marketplace and the opponent's existing registrations, would lead consumers to believe they originated from the same trader.

The delegate's reasoning, drawing from a previous decision in *McDonald's v Macri Fruit*, emphasised that deceptive similarity arises not merely from a common element in trade marks, but from the contextual use of that element. In the *McDonald's* case, the delegate found deceptive similarity based on the prefix "Mc-" being conjoined with words describing goods or services that formed a normal part of the opponent's fast-food business. However, in the present matter, the delegate found that the existence of the opponent's "family of trade marks" did not lend significant weight to a finding of deceptive similarity, implying that the specific marks in question did not create the same contextual impression of origin as in the *McDonald's* example.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In McDonald’s v Macri Fruit the marks under opposition were McSALAD and McFRESH. The Delegate held:The type of confusion outlined here is founded on a perception that, within the context of the circumstances of the market-place, the applicant's marks are seen as being an extension of the opponent's registered trade marks due to a common element in the marks that leads to a conclusion that they identify the same trader. In the present circumstances the opponent has a family of 78 registered trade marks containing a word which has a prefix of Mc-. Of these 78 registered marks, 17 also have another common element. The second common element is that they consist of, or contain, words in which the prefix Mc- has been conjoined with a word which is either the name of the goods or services being sold, or a description of a quality or characteristic of the goods. [My emphasis added] After listing the 17 relevant marks, the Delegate went on to observe:Taken together, I believe that the family of 17 marks above, with one important proviso, supplies a sufficient expectation that any trade mark prefixed by Mc- which is conjoined to a word, which describes either the goods or services themselves or a quality or characteristic of the goods, would form part of the opponent's family of marks.The important proviso here is that the goods or services referred to, in the part word conjoined to the prefix Mc- in the trade mark, would also need to be seen to form a normal or usual part of the opponent's business. Any food, or quality or characteristic of that food, which would be expected to form part of the opponent's fast food operation would, therefore, qualify. In the present circumstances, McSALAD and McFRESH both meet these requirements. The opponent does use 'salad' ingredients and the word 'fresh' describes a laudatory characteristic or quality that would also be expected to be in use in relation to the opponent's goods. Forming an extremely close parallel to the present applications I note that, among others, the opponent has registrations for McVEGETABLE and McVALUE. Several other registrations of the opponent could also be used to demonstrate this parallel. Thus, I find that these two trade marks, McSALAD and McFRESH, are deceptively similar, in a contextual sense, to each of the 17 trade marks listed above, owned by the opponent.[16][16] Ibid. It is important to highlight the Delegate’s reasoning for finding those trade marks deceptively similar lay not in the mere presence of the ‘Mc’ prefix in the opposed marks, but through its use ‘in a contextual sense’, being the particular conjoining of ‘Mc’ to a word which describes goods “forming a normal part of the opponent’s business.” Such a conclusion requires consideration not just of key words or elements, but how these elements are used and their impact on the general impressions left by the respective marks. Therefore, while I accept the Opponent’s trade marks are united by the common and distinctive element MOTHER, a finding of deceptive similarity requires more than the mere presence of this element in the Trade Mark. In the current matter, I do not consider the existence of the Opponent’s ‘family of trade marks’ lends any significant weight to a finding of deceptive similarity.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.