Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v House

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v House [2009] FCA 302

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Appeal from Administrative Appeals Tribunal – Tribunal review of Decision of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority – Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth) – invalidity pension – invalidity classification – percentage incapacity for civil employment under s 34(1A)(a)– physical and mental impairment – alcoholism – personality disorder – whether error of law on part of Tribunal – whether Tribunal considered a serious submission regarding previous Tribunal decision – whether Tribunal failed to take into account relevant considerations – improvement of condition – range of civil employment available – whether reasons of Tribunal inadequate – relevance of previous related decision of Tribunal

Held: Tribunal erred in law in reaching its decision – failure to take into account serious submission regarding previous Tribunal decision – failure to take into account relevant considerations regarding improvement of condition and range of civil employment available – Tribunal erred in only considering two of the nine employment types available – reasons inadequate – appeal allowed – decision of the Tribunal set aside –matter remitted to Tribunal for determination according to law

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 43(2), 43(2B), 44(1)
Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth) ss 30, 34(1), 34(1)(c), 34(1A), 34(1B)(a), 37, 99(2), 99(6)

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184 followed
Australian Postal Corporation v Sellick [2008] FCA 236 cited
Casarotto v Australian Postal Corporation (1989) 86 ALR 399 at 403 followed
Cheung v AAT [2009] FCA 241 cited
Collector of Customs v Pozzolanic (1993) 43 FCR 280 cited
Comcare Australia v Grimes [1994] FCA 1054 cited
Dennis Willcox Pty Ltd v FCT (1988) 79 ALR 267 cited
Dixon v Commissioner of Taxation [2008] FCAFC 54 cited
Doman v Riordan (1990) 21 ALD 255 cited
House and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2004] AATA 667 cited
House and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2008] AATA 38 related
House v D.F.R.D.B. Authority [2004] FMCA 833 cited
McGovern and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (1988) 16 ALD 791 cited
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend (1986) 162 CLR 24 followed
Morales v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1998) 82 FCR 374 cited
Our Town FM Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (No 1) (1987) 77 ALR 577 cited
Re Quinn & Australian Postal Corporation (1992) 15 AAR 519 cited
Tobacco Institute of Australia Ltd v National Health and Medical Research Council (1996) 71 FCR 265 cited

DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS AUTHORITY v DAVID HOUSE

QUD 35 of 2008

COLLIER J
1 APRIL 2009
BRISBANE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD 35 of 2008

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED BY MR P MCDERMOTT RFD, SENIOR MEMBER
BETWEEN:

DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS AUTHORITY
Applicant

AND:

DAVID HOUSE
Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v Hous... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 302
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this appeal, the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority challenges a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal which had affirmed a decision of the Authority to maintain the invalidity classification of Mr House, a former member of the Australian Defence Force. The Authority sought to set aside the Tribunal’s decision and have the matter remitted for reconsideration, arguing that the Tribunal had erred in law in its assessment of Mr House's incapacity. The primary issue before the court was whether the Tribunal had erred in its consideration of Mr House's impairments and his capacity for civil employment.

The court examined the principles governing appeals from the Tribunal, emphasizing that wrong findings of fact alone are not sufficient to demonstrate error of law, and that the Tribunal's decision should not be lightly overturned. The Authority contended that the Tribunal had failed to properly consider certain aspects of Mr House's condition and its impact on his ability to work. However, the court found that the Tribunal had made its own findings based on the evidence before it and had provided adequate reasons for its decision. The Tribunal's findings differed from those of a previous decision, which had been upheld by the Federal Magistrates Court, indicating that the Tribunal had indeed considered the case afresh.

The court held that the Tribunal had not erred in law and that its decision should be affirmed. The Authority’s appeal was dismissed, and the matter was remitted to the Tribunal for further consideration in light of the Tribunal's own findings and reasons. The court emphasized that the assessment of incapacity was a value judgment, and that the Tribunal was best placed to make such assessments. Consequently, the decision of the Tribunal was upheld, and the Authority's appeal was dismissed with no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision of the Tribunal be set aside and the matter remitted to the Tribunal for determination according to law.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The orders sought by the Authority in this appeal are:1.That the determination of the Tribunal be set aside.2.That the reviewable decision before the Tribunal be affirmed.3.Such other orders as the Court sees fit.4.No order as to costs.Background The respondent to these proceedings, Mr House, is a “recipient member” for the purposes of the Act. So far as is relevant for the purposes of this case, “recipient member” is defined by s 3 of the Act to mean “a member of the scheme who is entitled to retirement or invalidity pay”. Mr House joined the armed forces on 1 October 1968 aged eighteen, and was retired on 29 May 1975 on the ground that “his retention in the Military Forces was not in the interests of those Forces”. In 1979 the Army Office informed the Authority that Mr House’s mode of discharge had been changed to “medically unfit for further service” because of the impairments “alcoholism and alcoholic liver disease”. On 30 August 1985 the Authority decided under s 37 of the Act to treat Mr House as if he had retired on the ground of invalidity. Since 1985 there have been numerous decisions in which Mr House’s level of incapacity in relation to civil employment and his classification under s 30 of the Act have been reconsidered. These decisions have been made by the Authority, on review by the Tribunal, and following appeals to the Federal Magistrates Court and this Court. During that time Mr House’s level of incapacity and classification under the Act has been assessed as follows:·From 30 May 1975 – 30% Class B·From 16 January 1987 – 35% Class B·From 4 May 1990 – 40% Class B·From 22 June 1999 – 30% Class B·From 10 August 2001 – 20% Class C. Of particular significance was the decision of the Tribunal immediately preceding the decision of the Tribunal the subject of this appeal. That decision – House and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2004] AATA 667 – was upheld on appeal to the Federal Magistrates Court (House v D.F.R.D.B. Authority [2004] FMCA 833). I shall return to this decision later in the judgment.The decision of the Authority The decision of the Authority which Mr House sought reviewed in the Tribunal stemmed from a request by Mr House in a letter dated 19 November 2004 seeking a review of his invalidity classification. At that time Mr House’s invalidity classification referred to “alcoholism and alcoholic liver disease”. Mr House requested that the invalidity classification extend to personality disorder and injuries he had sustained in a car accident. On 14 March 2005 the delegate of the Authority rejected the request for a review because, in summary, the additional conditions to which Mr House referred were not causally connected to his accepted impairment. However, the delegate said that if Mr House considered that his accepted impairment had deteriorated since his last review he could request the Authority to conduct a review of his classification. In letters to the Authority dated 18 March 2005 and 22 March 2005 Mr House requested reconsideration of the delegate’s decision to decline his request for a review. The Authority accepted these letters as a request for reconsideration of the delegate’s decision and for review of Mr House’s invalidity classification under s 34 of the Act.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

COLLIER J
Of particular significance was the decision of the Tribunal immediately preceding the decision of the Tribunal the subject of this appeal. That decision – House and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2004] AATA 667 – was upheld on appeal to the Federal Magistrates Court (House v D.F.R.D.B. Authority [2004] FMCA 833). I shall return to this decision later in the judgment.The decision of the Authority The decision of the Authority which Mr House sought reviewed in the Tribunal stemmed from a request by Mr House in a letter dated 19 November 2004 seeking a review of his invalidity classification. At that time Mr House’s invalidity classification referred to “alcoholism and alcoholic liver disease”. Mr House requested that the invalidity classification extend to personality disorder and injuries he had sustained in a car accident. On 14 March 2005 the delegate of the Authority rejected the request for a review because, in summary, the additional conditions to which Mr House referred were not causally connected to his accepted impairment. However, the delegate said that if Mr House considered that his accepted impairment had deteriorated since his last review he could request the Authority to conduct a review of his classification. In letters to the Authority dated 18 March 2005 and 22 March 2005 Mr House requested reconsideration of the delegate’s decision to decline his request for a review. The Authority accepted these letters as a request for reconsideration of the delegate’s decision and for review of Mr House’s invalidity classification under s 34 of the Act. The Authority found in summary as follows:·On 8 May 2001 the Tribunal reduced Mr House’s classification from 40% to 30% Class B. At a review conducted at Mr House’s request on 3 July 2001 the delegate, noting the Tribunal’s findings and other evidence, reclassified his level of invalidity as 20% Class C. This decision was confirmed by the Authority on reconsideration on 15 February 2002.·Mr House’s subsequent request for a review, dated 19 November 2004, was therefore made two years and nine months after the Authority last reconsidered his invalidity classification, and confirmed that it was 20% Class C, on 15 February 2002.·Mr House had not provided any evidence that his capacity to undertake relevant kinds of employment had significantly diminished during that period. In relation to Mr House’s submission that the Authority had not previously considered whether·a personality disorder should be recognised as part of the physical or mental impairment which was the cause of the incapacity by reason of which he had been retired from the Defence Force (that is, alcoholism and alcoholic liver disease); or·whether a personality disorder was an impairment connected with such that impairmentthe Authority noted that it had extensively canvassed the question of a possible relationship between a personality disorder and alcoholism in Mr House’s case in its decision dated 15 February 2002. In doing so, the Authority noted that it had considered and rejected the possibility that Mr House’s personality disorder was causally connected with his alcoholism – rather, the Authority had found that the better view was that Mr House’s alcoholism was best viewed as a manifestation of a personality disorder.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COLLIER J

Mr Harding, appearing on behalf of Mr House, submitted in summary:·Principles relevant to appeals to this Court from Tribunal decisions were explained in Collector of Customs v Pozzolanic (1993) 43 FCR 280 at 286-287. These principles include the following:oa wrong finding of fact is not sufficient to demonstrate error of law;oonly in exceptional circumstances should the decision of the Tribunal not be the final decision;othe Court will not be concerned with looseness in the language of the Tribunal nor with unhappy phrasing of the Tribunal’s thoughts;othe reasons for the decision under review are not to be construed minutely and finely with an eye attuned to the perception of error.·In relation to the Authority’s claim that the Tribunal erred by revisiting findings of fact already made by the Tribunal in House [2004] AATA 667 and by not taking that decision into account, in fact the Tribunal made key findings on critical issues which differed from those of the earlier Tribunal decision. Accordingly, the decision of the Tribunal in House [2004] AATA 667 was made redundant. Specifically:oin House [2004] AATA 667, the Tribunal had found that the incapacity by reason of which Mr House was retired was the effects of alcoholism and that Mr House’s prescribed physical and mental impairments were alcoholism and alcoholic liver disease, and not his personality disorder;oin the decision the subject of this appeal, the Tribunal found that alcoholism and the personality disorder of Mr House were the prescribed physical and mental impairments;othe Tribunal in the decision the subject of this appeal recognised it faced different evidence and different issues as to the kinds of civil employment which a person with the applicant’s skills, qualification and experience might reasonably undertake;othe fact that the 2004 decision of the Tribunal was upheld by the Federal Magistrates Court in House [2004] FMCA 833 is irrelevant – it simply means that, in the view of the Federal Magistrates Court, the earlier decision of the Tribunal was not infected by legal error.·In relation to the Authority’s submission that the Tribunal had failed to take into account a relevant consideration, namely that Mr House’s condition had improved, any comparison between Mr House’s level of functioning at the effective date of the Tribunal’s decision and earlier points in time must recognise that, until the Tribunal’s decision, Mr House’s personality disorder had not been considered to be one of his prescribed physical and mental impairments.·In relation to the Authority’s submission that the Tribunal failed to take into account relevant considerations as to the kind of employment Mr House could undertake in determining Mr House’s overall incapacity for civil employment, the Authority was inviting the Court to consider the Tribunal’s reasons “minutely and finely with an eye keenly attuned to the perception of error”.·In relation to the Authority’s submission as to misdirection, that submission does not take the Authority’s case any further than other grounds of appeal.·In relation to the Authority’s submission as to the alleged failure of the Tribunal to give adequate reasons, in relation to the issues which the Authority raised the Tribunal was not required to expressly give an explanation. The Tribunal made findings with reasons in respect of each of the issues under s 34 of the Act in compliance with s 43(2B) AAT Act. The Tribunal was required to make a global assessment, such an assessment is not a mathematical exercise, and a precise identification of how the Tribunal arrived at 30% incapacity is not necessary.·Because the decision as to Mr House’s degree of incapacity is a “value judgment”, not a mathematical exercise, if the Court upholds the Authority’s appeal the appropriate course is for the Court to remit the matter to the Tribunal as the arbiter of fact.ConsiderationFirst ground of appeal