Redenbach and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

Redenbach and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation [2019] AATA 4147 (4 October 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/2177

Re:Robert Redenbach

APPLICANT

AndCommonwealth Superannuation Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Theodore Tavoularis

Date:4 October 2019

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is affirmed.

.............................[SGD]...........................................

Senior Member Theodore Tavoularis

Catchwords

DEFENCE – Defence force retirement and death benefits – classification in respect of incapacity – percentage of incapacity – where Applicant classified as Class C – assessment as to the degree of physical or mental impairment causing invalidity in diminishing the capacity of the Applicant to undertake kinds of civil employment – whether Applicant should have been assessed as having a higher percentage of incapacity –  assessment of degree of impairment and percentage of incapacity at time of discharge – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth)

Cases

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority v House (1989) 22 FCR 138
Fury and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2005] AATA 382

Re Thompson and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (1987) 6 AAR 424

Contents

Reasons for decision

Introduction

Background

Consideration

Section 30(2)(a): Skills, qualifications and experience

Section 30(2)(b): the kinds of civil employment

Section 30(2)(c): the diminished capacity to undertake employment

Question One: What were the s 26 impairments?

Question Two: Ascertaining the degree the s 26 impairments have or had on the Applicant’s capacity to undertake employment

Dr McQueen – Orthopaedic Surgeon

Cross-examination of Dr McQueen

Dr Saxby – Orthopaedic Surgeon

Cross-examination of Dr Saxby

Dr Burke – Occupational Physician

Cross-examination of Dr Burke

Dr Ward – Sports Medicine Consultant

Findings about Section 30(2)(c): the diminished capacity to undertake employment

The Medical Evidence

The Applicant’s Employment History

Assessing the percentage of incapacity in the context of s 30

Findings

Decision

Annexure A………………………..……………………………………………………………..46

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Theodore Tavoularis

4 October 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 23 December 2014, a delegate of the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (“CSC”) made a decision[1] pursuant to s 30 of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (Cth) (“the DFRDB Act”) that the Applicant’s percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment with effect from 20 September 1987 was “small” (i.e.10%). Accordingly, the Applicant received a classification of “Class C” for the purposes of s 30 of the DFRDB Act. On 15 April 2016, the Defence Force Case Assessment Panel (“DFCAP”) affirmed[2] the earlier decision of the delegate of the CSC dated 23 December 2014. The Applicant now seeks review of the DFCAP decision of 15 April 2016.

    [1] Exhibit 3, s37 T Documents, T31, pages 186-192.

    [2] Ibid, T46, pages 249-259.

  2. Both parties were (with respect) very ably represented by Counsel in the hearing before me. In terms of documentary material received into evidence, 12 exhibits were tendered,[3] ranging from the parties’ respective Statements of Facts, Issues and Contentions, the mandatory Tribunal (or “T”) Documents, the Applicant’s army records of service and an array of medical opinions and reports.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Redenbach and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 4147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute between the Applicant and the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation concerning the Applicant's classification for an invalidity benefit under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits (DFRDB) Act. The Applicant, discharged from the Army in 1987 due to pes planus and left knee posttraumatic osteoarthritis, sought a review of the Corporation's decision classifying him as "Class C" with an incapacity percentage of less than 30%.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the Applicant's percentage of incapacity for civil employment as at 20 September 1987, the day after his discharge. This determination required the Tribunal to have regard to specific matters outlined in section 30(2) of the DFRDB Act, namely the member's vocational skills, qualifications, and experience; the kinds of civil employment reasonably available to a person with those attributes; and the degree to which the physical impairment diminished the capacity to undertake such employment.

The Tribunal acknowledged the difficulty in retrospectively assessing incapacity and emphasised that post-retirement employment history could only be considered to shed light on the applicant's condition at the time of discharge. Applying the factors in section 30(2), the Tribunal considered the Applicant's vocational skills, qualifications, and experience, including his Army service as an Infantry Rifleman, Section Commander, and Instructor, as well as his prior civilian employment. After a value judgment, taking into account the varying degrees of incapacity, the Tribunal determined the Applicant's overall incapacity for civil employment as at September 1987 to be 10 percent.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, which classified the Applicant as "Class C" with a 10 percent incapacity from 20 September 1987.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Both parties were (with respect) very ably represented by Counsel in the hearing before me. In terms of documentary material received into evidence, 12 exhibits were tendered,[3] ranging from the parties’ respective Statements of Facts, Issues and Contentions, the mandatory Tribunal (or “T”) Documents, the Applicant’s army records of service and an array of medical opinions and reports. The hearing received lay oral evidence from the Applicant himself and expert oral evidence from (1) Dr Andrew McQueen (orthopaedic surgeon); (2) Dr Terrence Saxby (orthopaedic surgeon); and (3) Dr Nicholas Burke (consultant occupational physician). [3] See exhibit list attached to these Reasons and marked “Annexure A”.BACKGROUND The Applicant is presently aged 55 years. His date of entry into the Australian Defence Force (“the Army”) was 17 June 1981. His date of discharge was 19 September 1987. The grounds of his discharge/retirement were determined to be:(i)Pes planus; and(ii)Left knee posttraumatic osteoarthritis.[4][4] Exhibit 3, s 37 T Documents, T46, page 254. Following his discharge, the Applicant sought to re-enlist with the Army. By letter dated 21 March 1991, the Applicant was advised that his application for re-enlistment had been unsuccessful. That letter said:“…for the reasons given by the Medical Officer, you do not meet the high medical standards required for entry to the Australian Regular Army.”[5][5] Ibid, T35.2, page 205. The Applicant appealed this decision but that appeal, as well, was unsuccessful. By letter dated 12 August 1991, the Applicant was told:“…The medical documentation from your day of testing at this centre, together with the medical certificates supplied by your doctor, was passed to our medical authority for a re-assessment of your medical suitability. I regret to inform you that the appeal has been dismissed based on all the available information that was presented. You are still considered below the acceptable medical standards for enlistment.…”[6][6] Ibid, T35.1, page 204. The material reveals (and it is common ground between the parties) that the Applicant made an application for an “invalidity benefit” on 5 November 2014. Pursuant to s 30 of the DFRDB Act, the Respondent determined the Applicant’s “percentage of incapacity” on 15 April 2016. Applying the table appearing in s 30(1) of the DFRDB Act, the Respondent determined (or classified) the Applicant as a “Class C” with an accompanying percentage of incapacity of less than 30%.[7][7] Ibid, T46, pages 249-259. On 26 April 2016, the Applicant filed the instant application seeking review of the Respondent’s classification decision of 15 April 2016. In order to determine the percentage of incapacity of a member for the purposes of s 30(1) of the DFRDB Act, s 30(2) of that Act stipulates that the Respondent:“…shall have regard to the following matters only:(a)the vocational, trade and professional skills, qualifications and experience of the member;(b)the kinds of civil employment which a person with the skills, qualifications and experience referred to in paragraph (a) might reasonably undertake;(c)the degree to which the physical or mental impairment of the member that caused the invalidity or physical or mental incapacity because of which he or she was retired has or had diminished the capacity of the member to undertake the kinds of civil employment referred to in paragraph (b); (d)such other matters (if any) as are prescribed for the purposes of this sub-section”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Therefore, having regard to the varying degrees of incapacity appearing in s 30(1) of the DFRDB Act, and bearing in mind that this is not a mathematical calculation, but is, rather, a value judgment, I consider that the Applicant’s overall incapacity as at September 1987 and in the years following for the three types of civil employment referred to above, taken together, was 10 percent. It follows that the Applicant’s classification for the purposes of s 30 of the DFDRB Act was “Class C”. DECISION Accordingly, the decision under review to determine the Applicant’s percentage of incapacity as 10 percent and to classify him “Class C” with effect from 20 September 1987 is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The outcome of conducting that exercise, contends the Applicant, should be as follows:“Overall, considering the width, quality and nature of the range of employment opportunities available…and making a value judgment, the applicant submits that, at a minimum, he was incapacitated to at least 30% for the kinds of civil employment which the applicant might reasonably have undertaken and that the Tribunal ought to decide accordingly. Further, considering the restrictions on the applicant in many kinds of civilian employment which he might reasonably have undertaken – and, particularly the prospect of failure at long-term, ongoing employment – the Tribunal ought to decide that the applicant’s incapacity was, in effect, at least 60%.”[8][8] Exhibit 12, Applicant’s Outline of Submissions, dated 9 March 2018, page 11, paragraph [65].CONSIDERATION The primary issue for determination in this application thus becomes the extent of the Applicant’s incapacity in relation to civil employment as at 20 September 1987, that being the day immediately following the Applicant’s retirement from the Army. As mentioned above, s 30(2) requires the Respondent, and now the Tribunal, to have regard only to the factors (a) – (d) of that subsection. As I recall the respective submissions, neither party contended for any application of factor (d) of s 30(2). The exercise of retrospectively determining an Applicant’s degree of incapacity for civil employment at the time of their retirement from the Army some 32 years after such retirement “…will inevitably be difficult.”[9] While a decision maker’s initial inclination will be to base such a determination on what this Applicant has been able to do by way of civil employment since his retirement from the Army in September 1987, such post-retirement employment history:“…can be taken into account, but only to the extent that such evidence can be related back to and throw light on the applicant’s state of health and any incapacity as at the earlier date: see Re X and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (1980) 3 ALN N58 [sic]. The Tribunal must, ultimately, “…address the same question as was before the primary decision maker” in the decision under review – namely, what was the percentage incapacity of the applicant for civil employment in [September 1987]…”[10][9] Fury and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2005] AATA 382 at paragraph [15] (“Fury”).[10] Ibid. SECTION 30(2)(A): SKILLS, QUALIFICATIONS AND EXPERIENCE The Applicant has provided a helpful summary[11] of the Applicant’s vocational, trade and professional skills, qualifications and experience as at the date of his retirement from the Army on 19 September 1987. The relevant skills, qualifications and experience comprise: [11] See Exhibit 4(a), Applicant’s Further Amended Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (‘SFIC’), dated 6 September 2017, paragraphs [73]-[82].·Completion of Year 10 secondary schooling;·Salesperson and kitchen hand;·Work at “Alpine Ash Building Supplies” from 11 December 1979 to May 1980 involving duties of loading and unloading building supplies from trucks and assisting in the distribution and sales of building supplies;·Work at “Willie Oldfield” from June 1980 to August 1980 as a fishing boat deck-hand involving duties of baiting hooks, emptying nets and cleaning fish;·Working as a builder’s labourer from September 1980 to December 1980 involving duties such as digging ditches, mixing cement and carrying timber;·Work at the “Glenora Hotel” from January 1981 to March 1981 involving duties such as cleaning dishes and emptying rubbish;·In-service employment with the Army from December 1981 until March 1986 involving duties such as: oInfantry Rifleman (from December 1981 to September 1984);oInfantry Section: second in command (from October 1984 to November 1985); andoInstructor (infantry minor tactics and small arms instructor) from December 1985 to March 1986;·Completion/obtaining of secondary school senior certificate in December 1986.