Administrative
Appeals
Tribunal
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2003] AATA 1204
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) N2001/810
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION ) Re MARK ALBERT SHIBBLE Applicant
And
DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS AUTHORITY
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal P. J. Lindsay, Senior Member Date28 November 2003
PlaceSydney
Decision The decision under review is set aside. The tribunal determines that the applicant’s percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment on 14 June 2000 and since that date has been in excess of 60 per cent. He is reclassified as class A with effect from that date. (sgd) P.J. Lindsay, Senior Member
Where a member of the scheme, not being a member of the scheme to whom section 36 applies, is, or is about to become, entitled to invalidity benefit, the Authority shall determine his percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment and shall classify him according to the percentage of incapacity as follows:
Percentage of incapacity
Class
60% or more
A
30% or more but less than 60%
B
Less than 30%
C
…
s.34 Reclassification in respect of incapacity
(1) The Authority may, from time to time, if it is satisfied that the percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment of a recipient member in receipt of invalidity pay is such that the classification of the member should be altered, reclassify him in the appropriate classification set out in section 30 according to the percentage of his incapacity in relation to civil employment.
…
(1A) In determining:
(aa) what is the percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment of a recipient member; or
(aab) what was, immediately before his or her death, the percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment of a recipient member who has died;
the Authority shall have regard to the following matters only:
(a) the vocational, trade and professional skills, qualifications and experience of the recipient member;
(b) the kinds of civil employment which a person with skills, qualifications and experience referred to in paragraph (a) might reasonably undertake;
(c) the degree to which any physical or mental impairment of the recipient member, being a prescribed physical or mental impairment, has or had diminished the capacity of the recipient member to undertake the kinds of civil employment referred to in paragraph (b);
(d) such other matters (if any) as are prescribed for the purposes of this subsection.
(1B) In subsection (1A), prescribed physical or mental impairment, in relation to a recipient member or a deceased member who was immediately before his or her death a recipient member, means:
(a) a physical or mental impairment of the member that was the cause, or one of the causes, of the invalidity or physical or mental incapacity by reason of which the member was retired, whether or not that impairment changed, for better or worse, since that retirement; or
(b) any other physical or mental impairment of the member causally connected with a physical or mental impairment referred to in paragraph (a).
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Shibble and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Auth... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] AATA 1204
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue revolved around the interpretation and application of sections 30, 34, and 99 of the Act, specifically the criteria for assessing physical impairment and the threshold for reclassification of incapacity. The court was required to determine whether the Authority had correctly applied these statutory provisions and whether there were any errors in their assessment of the applicant's physical condition and its impact on his ability to work.
In its reasoning, the court highlighted that the Authority had not adequately considered the applicant's physical impairments and their effects on his ability to engage in civil employment. The Authority had made a determination that the applicant's incapacity was below the 60% threshold required for class A status, but the court found this assessment to be flawed. The tribunal had failed to properly weigh the evidence regarding the applicant's limitations and had overlooked significant aspects of his physical condition. Consequently, the court set aside the Authority's decision and determined that the applicant's incapacity exceeded the required threshold, warranting a reclassification to class A.
The court's decision resulted in the reclassification of the applicant as class A, effective from the date of the tribunal's original decision. The court ordered that the applicant's percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment be recognised as exceeding 60% as of 14 June 2000, and that he be reclassified accordingly. This reclassification would entitle the applicant to enhanced benefits under the Act, reflecting the severity of his physical impairments and their impact on his ability to work.
Orders
Orders of the court
The decision under review is set aside. The tribunal determines that the applicant’s percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment on 14 June 2000 and since that date has been in excess of 60 per cent. He is reclassified as class A with effect from that date.
Background
Background to the litigation
The tribunal had considered evidence from medical professionals, the applicant's submissions, and other relevant documentation. The tribunal concluded that the applicant's incapacity was less than 60 per cent, and hence, he was appropriately classified as class B. Dissatisfied with this determination, the applicant sought a review of the tribunal's decision, arguing that the tribunal had incorrectly assessed his capacity for civil employment and should have reclassified him as class A.
The applicant initially lodged an application with the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority, which assessed his incapacity and classified him as class B. Following the tribunal's decision upholding the authority's classification, the applicant sought judicial review of that decision. The matter came before the court for a review of the tribunal's decision, focusing on the correctness of the tribunal's assessment of the applicant's incapacity and its classification as class B. The court examined the evidence presented to the tribunal and the tribunal's reasoning in reaching its decision. No prior decisions or appeals from other courts or tribunals were directly cited in this instance, although relevant precedents and statutory provisions were considered in the judgment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the tribunal's assessment of the applicant's incapacity in relation to civil employment, finding it to be less than 60 per cent, correct?
2. Should the applicant have been classified as class A given his physical impairments arising from his service in the Defence Force?
3. Did the tribunal err in not reclassifying the applicant as class A based on the evidence presented regarding his inability to undertake any gainful employment?
Held
1. The court held that the tribunal's assessment of the applicant's incapacity in relation to civil employment, finding it to be less than 60 per cent, was incorrect. The court set aside the tribunal's decision on this matter.
2. The court held that the applicant should have been classified as class A given his physical impairments arising from his service in the Defence Force. The court ruled in favour of the applicant on this point.
3. The court held that the tribunal erred in not reclassifying the applicant as class A based on the evidence presented regarding his inability to undertake any gainful employment. The court set aside the tribunal's decision on this matter and ordered the tribunal to reclassify the applicant as class A.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the evidence presented to the tribunal and found that the tribunal had failed to correctly assess the applicant's incapacity in relation to civil employment. The court noted that the tribunal had placed too much weight on the applicant's ability to perform certain tasks in his job, without considering the impact of his physical impairments on his ability to perform other tasks. The court also found that the tribunal had not given sufficient weight to the applicant's medical evidence, which indicated that he was unable to undertake any gainful employment.
The court then turned to the question of the applicant's classification. The court noted that the tribunal had failed to consider the applicant's physical impairments arising from his service in the Defence Force, which had a significant impact on his ability to perform work. The court held that the applicant should have been classified as class A, which is reserved for those who are totally and permanently incapacitated for all work. The court also noted that the tribunal had not followed the relevant statutory provisions and prior authority in making its decision.
Finally, the court addressed the issue of the tribunal's failure to reclassify the applicant as class A. The court held that the tribunal had erred in not reclassifying the applicant based on the evidence presented regarding his inability to undertake any gainful employment. The court noted that the tribunal had not considered all of the evidence before it and had failed to apply the relevant statutory provisions and prior authority.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a person has physical impairments arising from their service in the Defence Force, and those impairments significantly impact their ability to perform work, they should be classified as class A under the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973. The court also held that tribunals must consider all relevant evidence and apply the relevant statutory provisions and prior authority in making their decisions.