Metcalfe and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

Administrative

Appeals

Tribunal

 

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2004] AATA 1241

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No W2003/315

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION )
Re ANTHONY METCALFE

Applicant

And

DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS AUTHORITY

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Mr M J Allen, Member

Date25 November 2004

PlacePerth

Decision

The decision made on 12 November 2002 to reclassify the applicant from class B to class C with effect from 13 December 2002 is set aside. The matter is remitted to the respondent with a direction that the applicant is entitled to receive invalidity benefits from 13 December 2002 as a class B recipient.

.............(sgd M J Allen)....................

Member

7. Section 34(1B) relevantly provides that “prescribed physical or mental impairment” means:

“(a)a physical or mental impairment of the member that was the cause, or one of the causes, of the invalidity or physical or mental incapacity by reason of which the member was retired, whether or not that impairment changed, for better or worse, since that retirement; or

(b)any other physical or mental impairment of the member causally connected with a physical or mental impairment referred to in paragraph (a).”

8. On 8 May 1986 the respondent made an initial classification of the applicant under s 30 (T56) based upon information provided by the Army (T55). The kinds of civil employment that were identified by the respondent as applicable to the applicant were “cook, cake decorator, clerical office assistant” and the physical impairment that was the cause of the applicant’s incapacity was described as “recurrent achilles tendonitis of right ankle”.  The applicant was assessed as having a 20% incapacity and was classified C. 

9.      The applicant sought a reconsideration of that decision (T58) on the basis that the condition that caused his retirement was in respect of both his left and right ankles.  In July 1986 the Directorate of Army Health Services (“the Directorate”) advised the respondent that it recommended that the description of the impairment that caused the retirement be unaltered but that it would agree to amend the applicant’s percentage incapacity assessment from 20% to 40%, taking him from a class C to a class B classification (T61 and T62).  In October 1986 the respondent, relying on advise from the Directorate and from Dr W N Gilmour, retained the description of the impairment that caused retirement, amended the types of civil employment that were applicable to the applicant to “cook and kitchen manager”, and varied the percentage incapacity and classification of the applicant to 30% class B with effect from 27 March 1986 (T67).

10.     The applicant’s classification was reconsidered on a number of occasions thereafter by the respondent.  In September 1993 the relevant civil employment was described as “cook, kitchen manager and croupier” and the percentage incapacity was retained at 30% (T80).  That position was maintained in review decisions made in August 1996 (T83), August 1998 (T86), and April 1999.

11.     In November 2002 the applicant’s classification was again reviewed.  The description of his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Metcalfe and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Aut... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] AATA 1241
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case before the court, the applicant, Metcalfe, was challenging a decision by the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (the Authority) to reclassify his retirement benefits from class B to class C. Metcalfe had been discharged from the Army on medical grounds, and the Authority had determined that an impairment in his right leg was the primary cause of his incapacity. Metcalfe argued that an impairment in his left leg was also a significant contributing factor to his incapacity and sought to be classified as a class B recipient, which would entitle him to a higher level of benefits.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the impairment in Metcalfe's left leg was part of the impairment that caused his incapacity and, if so, what categories of civil employment were applicable to him. The court had to determine if Metcalfe's incapacity remained within the 30% to 60% range, which would classify him as a class B recipient. The Authority had found that Metcalfe's incapacity fell within the 60% to 80% range, justifying a class C classification.

The court found that the condition in Metcalfe's left leg was indeed a contributing factor to his incapacity. It was determined that Metcalfe's incapacity remained within the 30% to 60% range, thus justifying his classification as a class B recipient. The court set aside the Authority's decision to reclassify Metcalfe from class B to class C and directed that Metcalfe was entitled to receive invalidity benefits from 13 December 2002 as a class B recipient.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision made on 12 November 2002 to reclassify the applicant from class B to class C with effect from 13 December 2002 is set aside. The matter is remitted to the respondent with a direction that the applicant is entitled to receive invalidity benefits from 13 December 2002 as a class B recipient.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established